10 ms·
Hundreds of thousands trafficked to work as online scammers in SE Asia, says UN
- lost_tourist 3y agoThe people doing this and anyone supporting it should be put away forever. Still a person's liberty and making them a slave is one of the worst possible lives for anyone and should be relegated only to the worst of criminals like murderers, rapists, and enslavers. I have zero tolerance for those types of people and think the international community shouldn't either.
- charlysl 3y agoJFK files: How a Soviet lie that the CIA shot the US president became the original 'fake news' story https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/jfk-files-how-soviet-lie-that-cia-shot-us-president-became-original-fake-news-story-1644848 https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/jfk-files-how-soviet-lie-that-cia-...
- skilled 3y agoRelated (as in a similar story but focusing specifically on Cambodia), They’re Forced to Run Online Scams. Their Captors Are Untouchable (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37304188 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37304188) (no comments)
- shiftpgdn 3y agoThis isn’t new, but it’s good to continue to report on it. I remember even back in 2005 it was generally well known that the gold farmers in World of Warcraft were likely Chinese prison labor. There were even a few articles about it: https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/chinese-prison-inmates-forced-to-moonlight-as-world-of-warcraft-gold-farmers-for-guards/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/chinese-pr...
- logicchains 3y agoThere's a big difference between prisoners (who at least in theory are locked up as punishment for committing a crime) and people who've been trafficked into slavery. Even the US uses prison labour, but it's people who committed crimes. What's happening in SEA is kidnappping innocent people, locking them in guarded compounds and forcing them to scam people, and they get raped or beaten if they refuse.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat's true in principle but the laws and legal system are set up in such a way that a very large percentage of particular demographics will end up in this situation and from an outsiders perspective it doesn't look all that different.
- logicchains 3y agoEven if you see it as China enslaving its own citizens under false pretences of criminality, that's still quite different from private entities in one country luring people from another country under the false pretences of high-paying jobs and then enslaving them.
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, there are differences. But there are also some pretty worrisome similarities. And the numbers in the US are far higher than those mentioned in TFA, especially when taken over the decades that this has been happening.
- logicchains 3y agoThe difference is that the US is a democracy and people voted for the politicians who created those laws (and the attorney generals who enforce them), so by democratic logic the people convicted by the system "deserve" to be imprisoned to some degree.
- 3y ago
- mistrial9 3y agoLabor historically in a lot of places, was built on peasant-serfs, indentured servitude with a duration, or in many cases slaves. I believe that many educated people in the West are not aware of the extent to which this is true throughout history.
- whimsicalism 3y agoI agree that this is true, however I also think that when we imagine slavery in the West we think of chattel slavery and the reality is that what we call slavery in these peasant-serf contexts was not the same thing, did not have the same mortality rates, etc.
- whimsicalism 3y agoSorry, but that is insufficient evidence to me for something to be "generally well known." It is well known that there are flawed incentives to testify in Western contexts to things that did not happen in East Asia, this is known among South Korean defectors (not denying that NK is objectively terrible, one of the worst countries in the world - but defectors to SK have been known to say outright false things because this is how they get paid and get media attention and many of these publications will pay for stories). Something that is "generally well known" by contrast is that China almost certainly harvested organs from prisoners in the 90s and early 2000s.
- jedmeyers 3y agoMy friend in Eastern Europe ran a bot farm in WoW. He ran bots on his computers that farmed resources, then sold resources for gold and then sold the gold to Chinese for end-user resale. The only labor involved was hiring some college students and paying them for each top-level character they progress that can be used for farming. He even bought my character for $50 when I stopped playing.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kazanz 3y ago> The scam centres generate revenue amounting to billions of US dollars each year. Revenue in 2021 from scamming globally amounted to USD 7.8 billion worth of stolen cryptocurrency. Crypto has made scamming easier than ever. Ironically, it probably is making it easier to track how impactful it is too.
- delusional 3y agoIt's a nice honeypot. All the scammers are busy scamming each other.
- throwaway67743 3y agoThis is not new at all, there are US companies facilitating this (see: Tinder e.g) with zero regard for the lives of the people forced into doing this. They actively ignore these things and profit off it, absolutely disgusting.
- naillo 3y agoWhat is tinder doing to facilitate this? I assumed bots on there were just financial scam bots not of the trafficking kind
- Nextgrid 3y ago"bots" don't run on their own. While the initial message might be from a bot, leads need to then be coached into falling for the scam which involves human labor and can very well be such enslaved victims trapped in third-world countries.
- gumballindie 3y agoAs soon as sam altman hears about this he will make a proposal about replacing scam humans with ai. Which in itself is better than trafficking humans i suppose.
- throwaway67743 3y agoAI can't feel suffering, after all.
- gumballindie 3y agoIndeed. It's usually those around it that feel it.
- throwaway67743 3y agoai is literally the human equivalent of a sociopath and/or narcissist, it's devoid of human emotion
- 1-6 3y agoUnsure if it's related to the same region but in general, scammers are getting sophisticated with their attacks finding local churches and email phishing with unusually detailed information about church members. Posting videos asking prayers for specific individuals online is a bad practice since it exposes not only that individual but everyone around them to scam.
- ConfusedDog 3y agoJust saw a documentary interviewing escaped trafficked labors – just men, women ain't even capable of escape. They are falsely promised for "entrepreneurial opportunities," promptly got locked up and financially deprived to do scamming, prostitution, etc. One guy escaped, bystanders took him to the police and the police was part of the traffiking ring and sold him back. He finally paid off somebody with promise of ransom payment from his relatives, and upon entering Chinese border, he was fined by Chinese border control for violations. These local traffik orgs are armed with AKs and well connected politically. What a crazy, crazy world.
- andrethegiant 3y agoLink to documentary?
- ConfusedDog 3y agoI couldn't find the exact video I saw on YouTube. It's funny if you search "escape Cambodia," a lot of Gordon Ramsey's food videos pops up, but if you search "逃出柬埔寨" in Chinese, you find all these terrible trafficking cases.
- larkaa 3y agoI'm guessing it's this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n-EtdC4zQso https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n-EtdC4zQso
- aaron695 3y agoThis is the best for Cambodia - "Forced to Scam: Cambodia’s Cyber Slaves" by Al Jazeera - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n-EtdC4zQso https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n-EtdC4zQso > local traffik orgs are armed with AKs > police was part of the traffiking ring These statements are not representative of Cambodia, local/Chinese gangsters don't run around with AKs, and the documentary is a little exaggerated like all documentaries but I don't doubt there were suicides and beatings. Some Facebook ads were very clear what you were doing. There were not 100,000 working in Cambodia and most were not trafficked. This UN statement is garbage, liars bore me. It's why this is progressing to organ harvesting and other rubbish because the UN is bringing it to fantasy. Watch the doco and they mention the amounts they were making, then times that by 100,000 trafficked then all the ones who answered the Facebook ads and it doesn't add up. It's the Chinese doing this, which the UN page doesn't mention. Maybe the report does. But it's a main point for a summary... if the truth mattered. Video of 40 people escaping a Chinese run Cambodian casino https://e.vnexpress.net/news/news/40-people-swim-back-to-vietnam-after-escape-from-cambodian-casino-4501407.html https://e.vnexpress.net/news/news/40-people-swim-back-to-vie...
- gumballindie 3y agoNot even scam bosses allow for remote work i see. Cant they just like hire willing scam workers instead of trafficking people?
- bboygravity 3y agoThe scams with willing people are just called multi-level marketing.
- differentView 3y agoIt's harder to beat the workers into working harder remotely. Remote workers can also more easily work with law enforcement, quit, and start competing scams.
- gumballindie 3y agoA bit like legitimiate workers minus the beating part. That's replaced by hazing, harrasment, gaslighting and bullying at the work place. Same end goal, worker control, for both types of businesses, legitimate or scam.
- brap 3y agoI wonder if low quality scams (made by humans) are still going to be a thing given advances in AI. I bet a human sounding bot can already make a phone call and scam most of our grandparents far better than the average human scammer. Add the ability to mimic the voice of a relative and you can get pretty high success rates, even with more tech-savvy victims I bet.
- 1-6 3y agoEventually, it's going there but at the moment, people are mostly using low-tech methods to scam others. Oftentimes we'll overestimate/underestimate the abilities of scammers. It's important to realize that access to cloud services and sophisticated AI requires money for that infrastructure and these paltry scammers won't do that unless it's a part of a bigger org.
- brap 3y agoI'm guessing that most of these scams are coming from large orgs as described in the OP/comments, this seems like a fairly expensive operation. I'm also guessing that for about the same cost they could use AI to cast a much wider net, making it more profitable even if the quality is lower. The paltry individual scammers will probably go out of business soon.
- slig 3y agoLow quality and obvious scams are a feature, they filter only the most gullible.
- brap 3y agoI think you only need to filter when your scale is very limited due to the effort involved. A human can only make so many calls per day. AI makes these attempts much cheaper.
- lacrimacida 3y agoI think AI chatbots will lift these scams to a new level never seen before without any telltale signs that we can spot.
- boeingUH60 3y agoI’ve had a random person contact me out of the blue on Telegram and try to build a friendship that obviously ends in a pig butchering scam. Fortunately, I have a rule to never make online friends. If I’ve not met someone in a personal or professional setting before, I assume they’re a robot unless proven otherwise. Some pig butchers have also tried to contact my parents, but my parents are careful, and I immediately block any such number. Pretty sad to see that these operations could easily be stopped, but the perpetrators live in extremely corrupt places/semi-failed states where they just pay bribes to the local authorities to leave them alone.
- apetresc 3y agoSorry, is "pig butchering" a euphemism for something, or am I missing out on some new scamming trend?
- boeingUH60 3y agoIt’s the name of the scam where they trick people into investing in fake platforms and steal their money. The scammer starts first by building a romantic relationship with the target (this part can last weeks or months). Along the way, they start suggesting cryptocurrency investments on trading platforms that look legit at a glance but are fake underneath. They instruct the target to deposit money into a wallet, like any exchange, but the perpetrators just steal the tokens and show the mark fake figures. It’s a long term thing that takes a ton of work…I have no idea how the scammers even pull it off at scale. This site goes into more detail; https://www.techtarget.com/whatis/feature/Pig-butchering-scam-explained-Everything-you-need-to-know https://www.techtarget.com/whatis/feature/Pig-butchering-sca...
- mschuster91 3y ago> It’s a long term thing that takes a ton of work…I have no idea how the scammers even pull it off at scale. When cost of living is a few hundred dollars a month at best, looting 10k from a single mark is going to last quite the time.
- 3y ago
- fortran77 3y agoAre they scamming Westerners? (TFA wasn't clear). They'd have to be pretty fluent in idomatic English to do that. Do the 5-10 messages I get each week "Hi! This is Irene. Are you going to the party?" come from trafficed people?
- tropicaljacket 3y ago"Many of the victims are well-educated, sometimes coming from professional jobs or with graduate or even post-graduate degrees, computer-literate and multi-lingual." (from the report)
- Avicebron 3y agoIf it's not automated, it could easily be some sort of pre-defined script. I don't get many anymore, but I've definitely had mysterious text messages from different numbers supposedly across the country that were nearly identical. Usually it was "hey is this [random name], where were you last night?" I assume this was meant to draw me into some sort of dialogue. It happened enough that I can't really believe it was just a misdial.
- knodi123 3y agoFrom what I understand, initial messages don't come from the slaves; instead, you get connected to one if you reply. So the english skills might shift drastically between the first and second message.
- alephnerd 3y agoThey started off targeting Chinese speakers (Mainland China, Taiwan, HK, Malaysia, Singapore) but expanded into English and Thai over the past few years.
- em500 3y agoI'm guessing that they're mostly targeting the richer Asian countries, including China (which is on average is poorer than the West, but in the aggregate has comparable spending power as North America).
- magic123_ 3y ago
- aphroz 3y agoA good thing that soon AI will be able to scam us as good as humans so they won't need to traffick people anymore.
- lacrimacida 3y agoAnd would that make life better for traffick victims in any way? They’ll brutally be repurposed for some other dirty work
- logicchains 3y agoThere's a recent Chinese blockbuster about this called No More Bets, inspired by a true story. But in the movie the victim is saved; in real life he's still enslaved
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- em500 3y agoAnother one is Lost In The Stars. https://www.straitstimes.com/asia/haven-for-scams-hit-movies-further-sour-chinese-view-of-south-east-asia https://www.straitstimes.com/asia/haven-for-scams-hit-movies...
- elric 3y agoHundreds of thousands? That's a mind boggling scale. That's at least the size of a decent city. How do you even cope with the logistics of dealing with 100k+ scammers?
- yalogin 3y agoThey torture people to do online scams? What a bizarre world this has become. Never thought we would see trafficked and online scams in the same sentence. Effectively, I guess, they don’t want to pay the employees and so force them at gun point.
- csomar 3y agoI don't know about Myanmar but I am a little bit skeptical about "hundreds of thousands" in the rest (Thailand, Laos, Cambodia). I've traveled the region extensively and am in a remote place in Laos now. I think the UN is using the word "trafficked" way too liberally. While I heard stories from fellow travelers and citizens (only in Cambodia, be careful in Phnom Penh and don't go to Sinahouk); my guess is that the majority of these are in some kind of situation (like owing money to the boss) or maybe justifying what they are doing (it's not a crime if you are forced!). For some reason, I find this "hundreds of thousands" quite sinister. It devalues the whole issue as it normalizes it; while there are some people now in real need of help and in real danger.
- cheeze 3y agoI mean, these aren't people locked up on slave ships and hauled to a new world or something, but they are absolutely trafficked in that they are forced to do the work against their will without a way out - literally modern slavery. This comment feels mega weird to me, like you're trying to downplay the plight of these hundreds of thousands of modern-day slaves because it doesn't meet your definition of trafficking. I'm certainly going to trust official figures coming from the UN over someone on HN who happens to be traveling in SEA
- Eridrus 3y agoMany advocacy groups (particularly those making claims about human trafficking) fudge their numbers to make their cause seem more important, and you can see why, we would probably not be discussing this article without such an eye catching statistic in it. If you try to see how they got this number in their report it is "credible estimates/sources" that are "on file at OHCR". So there's no way to independently verify this, you have to just trust them, which doesn't breed confidence in their estimates.
- hungryforcodes 3y agoAnecdotally I met an NGO worker once in Phenom Phen who was drunk and admitted exactly this -- because he had to justify his 200K Euro job in that city. With that salary you're like a king, you'd probably do alot to keep it.
- mithras 3y agoMy wife's niece is from Laos and works for one of these chinese scam shops in the golden triangle. She is there voluntarily because it makes 5 times more money than her best alternative. Morally repugnant of course.
- vishnugupta 3y agoRelated; 130 trafficked Indian workers were rescued last year. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/10/8/indian-workers-rescued-from-digital-job-scams-in-southeast-asia https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/10/8/indian-workers-resc...
- freedude 3y agoSlavery is an old, detestable practice. There are more slaves worldwide today than in any other time in history. Welcome to modern civilization. Contemplate that the next time you use something made in China or another third world country. This is a common practice. https://www.un.org/en/delegate/50-million-people-modern-slavery-un-report https://www.un.org/en/delegate/50-million-people-modern-slav...
- dangus 3y agoThis is why I discourage people from playing games with scammers to “waste their time.” I always assumed that they were not really doing this job by choice, whether it’s modern slavery or not. You’re not saving someone else from getting scammed, you’re messing up a quota for someone who might be physically punished for missing it.
- lacrimacida 3y agoIf everyones quota goes to zero perhaps the master behind these scams go down with it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dangus 3y agoIf I don’t pay the prostitute it’s definitely not the pimp who is going to get bruises.
- mcpackieh 3y agoIt's sad that these scammers are victims themselves, but measures that reduce the extent to which these victims can victimize other people are a clear net good for society. You won't save a trafficked scammer by hanging up early so he can move on to easier marks, but you can prevent him from using the next hour to make a new victim out of somebody else. Or to put this in other terms; you're a Ukrainian machine gunner. In the distance you see Russian soldiers. You know that many of them are from the Russian gulags, unjustly imprisoned in an oppressive autocracy, quite likely for a crime they didn't commit, and now forced to invade a foreign country. You pull the trigger and mow those victims down, because if you don't those victims will make victims out of your friends, family, and fellow countrymen.
- jstarfish 3y ago> You’re not saving someone else from getting scammed, you’re messing up a quota for someone who might be physically punished for missing it. At some level, starving the beast is the only way to stop it. The more crimes they commit, the more likely it is they get caught. You can't account for the disposition of victims in the hands of thugs, and there's no guarantee victims won't get fed to pigs even if they were consistently Employee of the Month. If you already have a viable way to dispose of bodies, why let anybody leave? The better reason not to play games with scammers is that you're antagonizing someone who does not respect rule of law. Consider what someone overconfident in their ability to commit crimes unchecked might do to you in retribution.
- blurbleblurble 3y agoThis is an extreme and poignant caricature of the labor market in general as vast numbers of people experience it. Not to minimize what's happening here: extreme financial pressure with very high stakes is not rare. It's disturbing to see the extremes because there's no hard line between normal labor and this, it's really a continuum. Aside from enforcement and regulation, what really prevents these exploitative forms of labor from spreading?
- sproketboy 3y ago[dead]
- momirlan 3y agoi remember an article about people from Moldova trafficked to Turkey, where they promptly had one or two organs harvested and then sent back home. the horror...
- kirillzubovsky 3y agoHi, this is UPS. Your packages was the wherehouse due to an error in the shipping address. Please contact our customer service immediately at http://scams4you.xyz http://scams4you.xyz