4 ms·
Even a literal Nazi should have access to utilities. Though I would say cloudflare isn't quite up to that level. Edit: Seeing this downvoted is disappointing.
by Dylan16807 3y ago
Even a literal Nazi should have access to utilities.
Though I would say cloudflare isn't quite up to that level.
Edit: Seeing this downvoted is disappointing. Access to utilities needs to be treated as a right. Only the courts should be able to take it away.
- michaelmrose 3y agoThe Germans who died in the 30s and 40s would be alive if the Nazis had been denied access to oxygen. As some of their heirs openly talk about murdering us I don't think in the long run we'll still be mutually protecting each others rights. It in fact might be kinder to deny them rights now than life later. People who openly advocate for mass violence even if vague and theoretical belong in prison.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> People who openly advocate for mass violence even if vague and theoretical belong in prison. Okay, so put them in prison! But if they're not in prison they should have electricity, mail, communications. Hell, even if they are in prison they get those things.
- chonkerz 3y agoYou think the companies they do business with should be forced against their will to carry their hateful communications?
- Dylan16807 3y agoIf they choose to enter a utility market, yes. They can leave the market at any time, but ISPs should not be making these choices.
- vdqtp3 3y ago> if the Nazis had been denied access to oxygen >As some of their heirs openly talk about murdering us > People who openly advocate for mass violence even if vague and theoretical belong in prison. Wait.......didn't you just openly advocate for mass violence (denying them oxygen) against the philosophical heirs of Nazis, even if only in a vague and theoretical fashion?
- michaelmrose 3y agoI did not. I said specifically that Germans in hindsight ought to have bled the Nazis rather than descend into the hellscape that followed and we with the gift of their terrible example should shut down the monsters now when this can be done non-violently. Please attend more carefully to my words. > It in fact might be kinder to deny them rights now than life later. Lock up the bad guys now so we aren't in a position where our only options are fascism or murder.
- hotdogscout 3y ago>People who openly advocate for mass violence even if vague and theoretical belong in prison I very much agree but this is so one-sided. Would you support arresting Muslims who support Shariah? Would you support arresting Stalinists? There are sadly so many groups that advocate for mass violence I think it's pointless how people only seem to care about the single one that's most vilified and defeated.
- michaelmrose 3y agoI don't think this is complicated at all. If the are merely organizing and trying to use proper legal procedures to implement their designs they should be defeated at the ballot box if they plot to implement by force they belong in prison.
- bb88 3y agoI have a hard time with this. The constitution doesn't say you have a right to water, electricity, internet service, sewer service, etc. Meanwhile the conservatives in the US are saying that corporations have a right to choose who they serve based upon their religious beliefs. See the SCOTUS Masterpiece Cakeshop ruling on whether they must serve a gay couple. I'm pretty sure I could argue that Nazism is against someone's religious beliefs....
- gruez 3y ago>Meanwhile the conservatives in the US are saying that corporations have a right to choose who they serve based upon their religious beliefs. This gotcha only works when your opponent is pro business and you want them oppressed by businesses. However republicans are starting to turn anti-business. Take for instance the kerfuffle Ron DeSantis had with Disney.
- bb88 3y agoSure, conservatives have been pushing rights for conservative businesses. But once those religious rights have been granted, it's possible for that pendulum to swing the other way. Must a power company, say, give power to the NY State NAMBLA headquarters? That's the easy one. The more complex one is arguing that the insurrection was against your religious beliefs (because your religion espouses non-violence), and then the power company could say cut off power to offices held by congress people that supported the J6 criminals?
- ImJamal 3y ago>Meanwhile the conservatives in the US are saying that corporations have a right to choose who they serve based upon their religious beliefs. See the SCOTUS Masterpiece Cakeshop ruling on whether they must serve a gay couple. Unfortunately you are misinformed. The baker was quite willing to serve a gay couple. The Supreme Court never said the baker can not serve gays if he doesn't want to. What the Supreme Court said is a baker cannot be forced to engage in an activity (gay wedding) that he disagrees with even if it is as remote as a baking the cake. The baker made it clear if they wanted a plain cake he would have sold it to them.
- chonkerz 3y agoYou think hosting a website is a right?
- CogitoCogito 3y agoWhether it is or is not certainly depends on the laws in the jurisdiction in question, but personally I'd say it should be.
- chonkerz 3y agoRussian malware authors agree with you.
- Dylan16807 3y agoWebsite host is not a utility. ISP is a utility. Having an ISP, much like having mail service, should always be possible for everyone. I think website hosts should be able to drop people for most reasons, but that's not what's happening here
- chonkerz 3y agoThis is literally what's happening here. No one is cutting off the admin's personal Internet connection to get on the Internet. They're taking his website down because it's full of abuse.
- Dylan16807 3y agoThey're cutting off the company's internet connection, which isn't significantly better than a personal connection. The entity doing this is not the web host, it's the ISP. I would be fine with a web host refusing service, but that is not what is happening.