5 ms·
Imagine in 5-10 years where, just like people make video games all by themselves or with a small group of people, people can make their own movies that rival Ho
by satvikpendem 3y ago
Imagine in 5-10 years where, just like people make video games all by themselves or with a small group of people, people can make their own movies that rival Hollywood productions, for a fraction of the cost as there's no need to hire anyone. When the output is just pixels on a screen and you can manipulate the placement of every pixel, it's really no different to Hollywood making them with real actors and crew members or someone drawing them, as is the case with current animation methods. Now, we can do the same process as drawing each frame but then make it look photorealistic.
- ChatGTP 3y agoWatching you own movie sounds quite boring ? Spoiler alert ?
- dylan604 3y agoEven in animation, there are teams of people involved. Each team specializing in different aspects. This single person hollywood replacement dream is something to be really afraid of, at least as far as the quality of the content. I couldn't imagine watching something that only one person has ever worked on with no input from other people with suggestions/tweaks/edits to improve the product. We've already seen things like True Detective Season 2 that was produced and it had people involved that did not push back.
- satvikpendem 3y agoI played Stardew Valley, a game made entirely by one person, and by all accounts it is one of the highest rated games of all time. Can anyone make shit? Sure, that is true in any medium. But individuals or even small groups of people can do amazing things, if they have the tools. It is not "something to be really afraid of," which I find to be an extremely hyperbolic view.
- dylan604 3y agoHave you seen The Room? Anytime I see the same person's name in the credits for all the roles, I immediately start to get nervous. Also, small teams is not a single person
- satvikpendem 3y ago> * Have you seen The Room? Anytime I see the same person's name in the credits for all the roles, I immediately start to get nervous.* Sounds like that's more of a personal problem than one about this sort of video generation in general. > Also, small teams is not a single person Yes, which is why I likened this to what was in my original comment: "just like people make video games all by themselves or with a small group of people"
- dylan604 3y ago>Yes, which is why I likened this to what was in my original comment: "just like people make video games all by themselves or with a small group of people" You're reading that out of context. I intentionally separated that comment. The original post I replied discussed all of the work being done by a single person. That what this is about. You introduced a small team. A small team is not one person. A small team still has the potential of having discussion on edits, creative, etc vs just the ideas of one person.
- satvikpendem 3y agoYou replied to my original post, did you not [0]? The post where I, as stated above, also included the words, "all by themselves or with a small group of people," no? The post where I explicitly did not "[discuss] all of the work being done by a single person" that denies work also being done by groups. You were the one who omitted the "with a small group of people" part and started talking only about a "single person hollywood replacement dream." I think you're just arguing semantics at this point, as to me, it doesn't really matter if it's a single person or a small team making stuff, my greater point was that it will be a lot cheaper than a full-blown Hollywood production and will usher in a new sort of industry like YouTubers today, as ubiquitous phone cameras have, only now these creators will also make photorealistic productions rather than just filming themselves doing things. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37310759 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37310759
- NBJack 3y agoStardew Valley is great. But note that the author took a classic approach to solo assets and devlopment: pixel art on a 2d canvas. This is a great game in a well established medium, and the concept itself is part homage to Harvest Moon, originally a 2d title released in 1996. Contrast this with the fact that Steam is now averaging about 1000 new games per month. [1] There are undoubtedly some excellent games in there that haven't survived the onslaught of choices. Sadly, finding them without either significant marketing by the dev or the right conditions makes it nearly impossible to sift out the gems from the asset flips. [1] https://steamdb.info/stats/releases/ https://steamdb.info/stats/releases/
- brucethemoose2 3y agoAnd yet Steam is a shining example of curation compared to, say, the App Store or Google Play. Excellent curation will be critical to gen AI. The window for such curation to be established feels extremely small, otherwise "app stores" will take hold and we will end up with a sea of unnavigable spam.
- NBJack 3y agoHard to argue against that. There's clearly a higher bar in Steam. Hopefully that will continue.
- lmm 3y agoThere are 1000 new games per month and 90% of them are crud, sure. But the end result is that we have more original and innovative games than ever before (and cheaper, too). I certainly wouldn't want to go back to the days of big publisher gatekeeping. Would you?
- NBJack 3y agoMy original point was meant to nod towards survivorship bias. I won't argue that choices are great now, with tons of niche offerings that are a delight for many. But using Stardew Valley as an example doesn't hold up well for creator success; many (if not the majority) fail in the Steam store despite their efforts and quality. I think this is generally true for much of the gaming industry in general. There are indeed so many titles that several very big releases years in the making can drop off the scene shockingly quick, if only because new ones show up so often now.
- throwaway287391 3y agoEven assuming it's impossible for a single person to produce something as good as a large team, why would this be "something to be really afraid of"? There will still be demand for high-quality films -- why wouldn't that demand continue to be met? It's been the status quo for at least a decade that one "normal person" can make and publish a "movie" (e.g. filming something on their phone and posting it on YouTube), and yet Hollywood somehow hasn't been upended.
- Vicinity9635 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rebuilder 3y agoI think we’ll find, among other things, that making tons of minute decisions is exhausting. Iterating your way to an end result is a way of getting something, but so far, the rule of thumb seems to be that the more control you have over a creative process, the harder it is to not end up with a stiff end product.
- StevePerkins 3y agoThings will certainly change. However, I don't think professional studio productions will go away. In the age of MP3's and streaming services, "anyone" can put their music out there. And while many do, the most popular and successful music still comes from major labels. With Amazon's distribution platform and tooling for self-published authors, "anyone" can write a book. And while many do put out some great stuff, the overwhelming majority of books that don't come from major publishers are shovelware. As shitty of a curator as Hollywood might be, for most people there is value-add in curation.
- novok 3y agoI think it will create a new middle class artist category, much like youtube, commodity video editing software and good 4k cameras have done today. Certain kinds of niche content will become more viable.
- extr 3y agoIt's identical to the current state of the publishing world. They've already gone through this transition: the marginal cost to "publish" a book is zero. However to "publish a book that will people will read" is a different question altogether and is still very much gatekept by the major publishing houses.
- echelon 3y ago> It's identical to the current state of the publishing world. They've already gone through this transition: the marginal cost to "publish" a book is zero. However to "publish a book that will people will read" is a different question altogether and is still very much gatekept by the major publishing houses. Not at all identical. Writing and selling a book only requires a text editor (or typewriter), maybe a copy editor, and maybe a publicist. It's been that way for the better part of a century. Present-day films require enormous capital, equipment, logistics, personnel, pre-production, post-production, and marketing. Film is about to be wholly transformed by several orders of magnitude of cost, talent, personnel, and logistics reductions. All at the same time. Kids at home will have access to this tech and grow up on it.
- duped 3y agoimho the thing that makes film the pinnacle of art is that it is the amalgamation of many artists' vision and interpretation. And what makes great film great is when those differences form a cohesive story. And at the end of the day, art is a reflection of the human condition. Removing humans from the process is not a feature, it's a bug because it reduces the scope at which the art can address.
- throwuwu 3y agoSince when is film the pinnacle of art? If collaboration makes it so then both music and architecture also have that trait. Theatre as well.
- duped 3y agoimho: in my humble opinion. And you're right, but you also need to make all those art forms to make great film.
- satvikpendem 3y agoI don't agree that film is the "pinnacle of art," but even discounting that, there are many works made by individuals throughout history that are great, books and paintings for example. I don't see anyone saying that these should have more than one person making such works but for movies and shows, it seems that we are used to the status quo and cannot see how in the future that great works can similarly arise from individuals via the advances of technology. I'm sure in 2100 when this tech is commonplace that people will think about how archaic it was to have thousands of people work to produce a film.
- tomjen3 3y agoIts an interesting concept, which will further fragment the amount of attention that each individual piece can get. If the actors are AI generated, then we are also past the point there sex and nudity can't be part of the experience. It will likely be more attractive than anything else for that reason alone.
- satvikpendem 3y agoIt'll be like YouTube, anyone can put out anything they want there, the vast majority of which will be bad, but there are still good content creators making high quality videos.
- tomjen3 3y agoI don't think so. There is a qualitative difference between youtube and what can be made for streaming, but there are also entire groups of things that are not on youtube: there are lots of video essays, but basically no TV shows over multiple episodes, in any genre. This is currently a limitation, but it doesn't have to be and with the new system it won't be.
- satvikpendem 3y agoHuh? Many content creators on YouTube have made TV shows over many episodes on YouTube, Wong Fu for one.
- rossjudson 3y agoI think you'll see that high production quality becomes more accessible, while content quality remains as elusive as it has ever been... Unless you can successfully train the population to equate content quality with production values.
- Art9681 3y agoYou are forgetting that as the tooling gets better and the capability of individuals increases, so too does the capability of a group of individuals working together, using the same tools you would be. You are still not going to match the level of quality as a talented team pooling their experience, time and cognitive abilities to create something. This team can also afford more compute capacity, to the same thing in half the time, or the same time at twice the quality, so to speak. I am excited at being able to do exactly the things you mentioned, and I definitely plan to. But I dont live under any illusion that the capability of one man will supercede the capabilities of a group that uses the same "equipment" per se.
- satvikpendem 3y agoMaybe, maybe not, not all groups are created equally. I cite in another comment about Stardew Valley being made by one person while, say, EA games are made by teams. I consider the former much more well made than the latter. So too can there be such examples in this sort of AI media generation tool usage.
- actuallyalys 3y agoYeah, I'm skeptical that generative AI is really that different from other new filmmaking technologies (or new technologies in other creative fields), although it may be premature to say. Will individuals create good films that it wasn't feasible for them to do alone before? Probably. Will that mean large teams are obsolete? Probably not.
- magic_hamster 3y agoIn the last 20 years virtually all professional capabilities have been accessible to the public, especially in software, which has become very affordable and sometimes free. This definitely helped creative people get a leg up and create some amazing things. However, the majority of people still don't really use this stuff. You still need a creative vision and coherent direction, both are major weakpoints in current state of generative AI (and for humans). I for one totally embrace the latest AI tools and managed to leverage Stable Diffusion in several places. But I don't see it replace genuine creativity soon.
- satvikpendem 3y ago> But I don't see it replace genuine creativity soon. I never said it will either. I also see it as a tool for creatives, just one that democratizes film making at the level of Hollywood productions.
- croes 3y agoImagine the amount of fake videos to spread misinformation.
- satvikpendem 3y agoPeople have been saying that since the Photoshop days, if not earlier. Stable Diffusion has been out for over a year, I don't see any fake images being put out that are taken seriously by anyone notable, such as news organizations.
- croes 3y ago>anyone notable, such as news organizations The problem is the less notable people. It is not the people from news organisations who storm the Capitol. They alread believe the fake pictures of Trump