9 ms·
The Heart of W. Edwards Deming
- User23 3y agoAnd even fewer people have heard of Homer Sarasohn[1], who was perhaps even more seminal to the Japanese economic recovery and kickstarted their electronics industry. An entertaining introduction is here[2]. [1] https://honoringhomer.net/ https://honoringhomer.net/ [2] https://honoringhomer.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/cringely.pdf https://honoringhomer.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/cringel...
- prla 3y agoI had indeed not known of Sarasohn. Thanks for sharing, will dive into his history!
- linksnapzz 3y agoThe story of Homer giving Akio Morita one more chance, and that chance becoming Sony Inc. is a wonderful tale…
- User23 3y agoIndeed. And it generalizes. Good managers generally believe in second chances, because if they saw enough to give a first chance it’s worth the risk. Third chances on the other hand not so much.
- Aloha 3y agoOne of the books linked within is interesting https://www.amazon.com/Reckoning-David-Halberstam-ebook/dp/B00AG8FZ4C/ https://www.amazon.com/Reckoning-David-Halberstam-ebook/dp/B... I read it some years ago, and its very very interesting.
- fuzzfactor 3y agoI followed Dr. Deming since the 1960's when I was a boy. Spent a lifetime since then building on his ideas and how to apply them to scientific laboratory work of various kinds, not just quality control, and it has been quite helpful. Especially when it comes to the elements of experimentation and discovery. Not everybody is aware of the way in his later years Dr. Deming was involved with Jim McIngvale "Matress Mac" of Gallery Furniture in Houston, and made a major difference in their operation. As a very promotional local personality it was easy to witness the transformation as it occurred over the years. I would say this influence was what allowed their ultimate growth beyond what would have been possible before. https://deming.org/customer-satisfaction-and-the-deming-way/ https://deming.org/customer-satisfaction-and-the-deming-way/ For some quick reading I'll quote a few quotes from the 11-page quote page: "A bad system will beat a good person every time." "All that we have has come from people that are responsible only to themselves, only themselves to satisfy." "Defects are not free. Somebody makes them, and gets paid for making them." "In my mind, if you run your company on visible figures alone, you will have neither company nor figures, given a little time. The most important figures are unknown and unknowable. That opinion comes from my good friend, Dr. Lloyd Nelson." "Information, no matter how complete and speedy, is not knowledge." "It is wrong to suppose that if you can’t measure it, you can’t manage it – a costly myth." "Joy in work comes from understanding why your work is important. Not from the work, but from knowledge of who’s going to use it." "The supposition is prevalent the world over that there would be no problems in production or service if only our production workers would do their jobs in the way that they were taught. Pleasant dreams. The workers are handicapped by the system, and the system belongs to the management." "To manage one must lead. To lead, one must understand the work that he and his people are responsible for." https://deming.org/quotes https://deming.org/quotes
- kqr 3y agoAh I don't remember the exact words but one of my favourite images he painted was something along the lines of "Managing an organisation by quarterly reports is like driving a car by looking at the centre line in the rear view mirror."
- bookaway 3y ago>"It is wrong to suppose that if you can’t measure it, you can’t manage it – a costly myth." Ironically, this may have been a reaction to an early software management book in the 80s by Tom DeMarco of Peopleware fame and similar books that were popular at the time. It's kinda annoying that the people that are maintaining a website in Deming's name don't reference the first edition book dates for the quote attributions. The original book seems to have been published in 1993 (when Deming was 93...), whereas the quote is attributed to a 2018 third edition on the website. The reason I find it ironic is that Deming seems to have been critiquing the young (relatively) influential upstarts at the time like DeMarco for over-emphasizing the importance of management metrics, And as it turns out, the nuances in his approach turned out to be more compatible with the approach that came to dominate the post-millennial software landscape (led by Google/Facebook at the time)--ie rigid process-averse lower case agile. It turns out the out of touch senile old guy was more prescient than the new suits. Although DeMarco started deviating from his early utopian management approach when he published Peopleware, it wasn't until the late 2000s when he did a a complete 180 and wrote a mea culpa, disavowing his earlier management books and the "You can't control what you can't measure" quote attributed to him [0]. [0] https://www.cs.uni.edu/~wallingf/teaching/172/resources/demarco-on-se.pdf https://www.cs.uni.edu/~wallingf/teaching/172/resources/dema...
- marcosdumay 3y ago> It turns out the out of touch senile old guy was more prescient than the new suits. Well, it was Deming. He is still more prescient than the state of the art in management. Managers read his books, make an effort to internalize them, and immediately go and do the complete opposite thing.
- 3y ago
- j7ake 3y agoNice quote here “If we focus on never making others feel inferior, there’s no limit to what can be achieved”. In light of how snarky people can be during interviews and evaluating others, it’s good to remember we are not better than one another in any meaningful way.
- prla 3y agoOne of my favorite quotes comes to mind and is #3 of the Ten Commandments of Egoless Programming: 'No matter how much "karate" you know, someone else will always know more.' :) https://blog.codinghorror.com/the-ten-commandments-of-egoless-programming/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/the-ten-commandments-of-egoles...
- prla 3y agoPaulo here, author of the post. Thanks everyone for engaging with it and for the lovely insights in the comments here. I hope more people get to know Deming because he showed us — multiple times — that it's people AND profit, not people OR profit. Superior intellect with what I know now was an enormous heart. Thanks again!
- akolbe 3y agoDeming's philosophy was a big part of my professional life in the 1990s. It's good to learn more about the man. Thanks for your article!
- speak_plainly 3y agoI think the conflation of software testing and Quality Assurance is a major shame of the tech industry. It's warped the understanding of the field of QA and pays little respect to Deming's ideas and goals.
- mikey_p 3y agoCheck out the episode of Gene Kim's podcast with Elisabeth Hendrickson, it does such a great job exploring the myths and realities around software testing. https://itrevolution.com/podcast/the-idealcast-episode-3/ https://itrevolution.com/podcast/the-idealcast-episode-3/
- fuzzfactor 3y agoThanks for this, also there is a reference to her excellent paper from 2000 "Better Testing - Worse Quality?" where she emphasizes the need for engineers to do their own testing for the most part. Still posted in a few places which was worth reading. Inherent quality depends completely on the factory floor. But I would say with code development bugs all you can expect the engineers to catch are the ones that can be found during their combined development/testing progress as it goes along. So they should honestly think it's perfect before turning it over to dedicated testers who will put their full effort into trying to find defects that were possible to be overlooked up until that point. Kind of like having a machinist making motor shafts who can easily see when they are coming out bent and fix it so that doesn't happen, plus manually gage his parts as he goes along to make sure the diameter is holding steady. He's doing all he can to produce what then look like perfect parts. Next the QC guy comes along and using automated measurements, tests the whole shaft along its entire length, and finds a few below-spec items that slipped through the cracks. Feedback to engineering can be used to make sure it doesn't happen again. The engineer is building value as intended performance is being accomplished, the tester is not building value from scratch or doing invoiceable work but they are essential to make the most of the value that is created.
- projektfu 3y agoIt reflects a similar problem in industry. If you look at the trade magazines during the Renaissance in quality management, many paid lip service to the ideas of statistical quality control while trying to sell gadgets and data processing systems to enable 100% inspection. That's because leadership change can't be bought and requires work from leadership. QA, I've always felt, is the wrong approach, in that I don't think quality is something you can assure, especially if it's not designed into the product. Whether you're talking about software testing, ISO 9000, GMP, or whatever, these approaches are good at providing a lot of activity and reports and not necessarily coordinated with quality product. They may be an essential part of achieving quality, but they don't cause it. The US government, for a long time, was killing itself with QA that allowed purchasing from anywhere that could supply an "acceptable quality level", meaning on average 3% of any item was defective and an assembly could have a high likelihood of not working. Similarly to software process, quality management gets fetishized and cargo-culted, so you end up with six sigma, "zero defects", total quality management, etc. I read that Deming once saw a TQM placard and said something like, "I hope I'm not guilty by association."
- ericalexander0 3y agoI highly recommend Beyond The Phoenix Project. It's less of a book and more of a podcast with John Willis and Gene Kim exploring Deming, Goldratt, and related theory.
- sharas- 3y agoDeming was the man. But being a systems thinker, and seeing the corporate idiocy (just watch his talks on management), I suspect he knew that a system cannot be transformed, it can be destroyed and rebuilt. Japan was a great opportunity fro him to rebuild a system the right way.
- FooBarBizBazz 3y agoI was ready to come down hard on this -- "just what we need, a hagiography of some Taylorist" -- but then I saw that this is not at all what Deming was about. This quote really resonated with me, particularly the part about intrinsic motivation: > Our prevailing system of management has destroyed our people. People are born with intrinsic motivation, self-respect, dignity, curiosity to learn, joy in learning. The forces of destruction begin with toddlers—a prize for the best Halloween costume, grades in school, gold stars—and on up through the university. On the job, people, teams, and divisions are ranked, reward for the top, punishment for the bottom. Management by objectives, quotas, incentive pay, business plans, put together separately, division by division, cause further loss, unknown and unknowable. And that first sentence is a hell of a sentence(!) --"has destroyed our people". Fantastic. When I consider the mess that has been made of the American landscape, of the pollution dumped into waterways by hedge-fund-operated manufacturing plants, I think similarly about "has destroyed our environment".
- DanielHB 3y agoI wonder how responsible Deming was for the decline in births in Japan. He somehow managed to convert work culture into life purpose for employees and I imagine a lot of that bled into replacing children as one's life purpose as there is only so much a single person can yearn.
- fuzzfactor 3y agoTo recover from devastation you need to convert life purpose to include work culture more than ever. Deming just showed them the way to get more done in less calendar time.