11 ms·
NFTs were supposed to be an end-run around the Howey Test. ICOs were clearly securities offerings, and the SEC shut down most of those. NFTs were specifically d
by Animats 3y ago
NFTs were supposed to be an end-run around the Howey Test. ICOs were clearly securities offerings, and the SEC shut down most of those. NFTs were specifically designed to evade that test, by claiming they were really "digital artworks". This one, though, was clearly marketed as Make Money Fast. The Securities Act of 1934 has a "duck test" definition of security - if it is marketed, bought, sold, and held as a money-making thing, it's a security. The contract terms don't matter. This is because creative financial scams long predate 1934.
- wpietri 3y agoI really appreciate the way the Howey Test matches the regulatory purpose, its operationalist approach to the question. That it's stood up to nearly a century of scammer "innovation" is admirable. It does have the drawback of requiring some interpretation, some thought. But I think that's necessary. Rather than requiring regulators to keep creating ever-broader definitions of "security", patching every scammer hole, it throws the burden back on those wanting to innovate. They're supposed to stop and say, "Well what are we really up to here?" And I think that's where the burden should be. My only real grumble is that the SEC gave the cryptowhatever world too much rope. I wish they had been faster off the mark, so there was less nonsense. But even there I can't complain too much. Generally I want regulators to be cautious squashing new things.
- dcow 3y agoNot trying to kill the vibe of your comment, I just want to point out that the burden of proof historically has fallen on the accuser, the regulator, the plaintiff, (point is: not the defendant,) to prove that some behavior is illegal and problematic. So I’m not sure I agree that it’s good to foster a regulatory regime where everyone trying to innovate is questioning whether the political winds will change in the future and some new hotshot regulator is going to make their career by being tough on whatever they’re currently doing when last year nobody cared. Post facto regulation doesn't really do any good as you’ve realized in your comment—the damage is already done. So at least I think we need to protect innovators by holding regulators to a statute of limitation on enforcing policy (like no bringing cases against activity that predates some signaling by the regulator that the interpretation is changing), and ideally require regulators to publish guidelines before they’re allowed to take legal action. Or maybe regulators should have to inform an innovator that they’re no longer in compliance with an updated perspective and provide them actionable steps that if taken would make them compliant, etc. prior to taking legal action. I’m not saying there’s no room for interpretation practically, but this deal where the SEC sits silent on whether “crypto assets” are securities or not and the only way we’ll know is if they sue one of the innovators doesn’t seem particularly healthy either. It’s exactly why you can’t be held criminally accountable for something you did before it became a crime, and we should hold regulators to the same expectations.
- wpietri 3y agoThe burden of proof to prove a crime still falls on the accuser. Nothing has changed there. I also don't think the interpretation has changed at all. We're still using the Howey test. The SEC took no immediate position on the cryptoetcetera community's various inventions, but they certainly didn't give anything their approval that they have since withdrawn. I'll note how much the more socially legitimate end of that community have been asking for "regulatory clarity". The problem is that they now have clarity and don't like it. And I'm sure they don't. They were hoping to sweep aside the regulatory regime set up in 1934, which was in response to the crash of 1929. But I don't think we need any particular safe harbor for people who tried to dodge regulators and lost.
- dcow 3y agoI have very little skin in the game and certainly haven't dabbled in the NFT world. And I “don’t like” the idea that a regulator can essentially leverage ambiguous language to prosecute after the fact just to leave innovators on their toes. This is required to achieve your goal of innovators asking “should I be doing this”, because otherwise there are clear guidelines and nobody is left wondering. Nothing has changed about the legal system, you’re right, but you expressed a desire to live in a more ambiguous regulatory regime where people are unsure whether they’re committing crimes or not because we’re okay with a changing interpretation of how regulations apply. That rubs me the wrong way and frankly feels pretty dystopian. Yeah I agree that practically it’s good to not have a bunch of buffoons running around doing quasi-legal securities offerings by a different name. But would it really have hurt to have the SEC say “we’ll be applying the Howey Test to NFTs, if you plan to sell one we’d recommend consulting a lawyer versed in securities law before proceeding”. Were consumers really damaged when their founders keys weren’t worth anything? Who in their right mind even treats a founders key as an honest security? Seems like there’s some blame on both sides here. It’s conversely not great to have consumers not using their brains, applying zero scrutiny, and buying into whatever the new street fad is then wailing for the Uncle SEC when their little crypto tokens became worthless. In short, I don’t think you need an ambiguous regulatory regime to achieve a climate of healthy innovation. You just need the SEC to not drag its feet on action and a little up front “hey don’t be idiots we consider this stuff a security <insert reminder of penalties for violation of securities law> so do your homework”.
- IanCal 3y ago> The Securities Act of 1934 has a "duck test" definition of security - if it is marketed, bought, sold, and held as a money-making thing, it's a security That doesn't seem right. You're missing a really fundamental part of what makes a security a security. Let's steal the cut phrase from investopedia > an investment contract, for the purposes of the Securities Act means a contract, transaction or scheme whereby a person invests his money in a common enterprise and is led to expect profits solely from the efforts of the promoter or a third part Investing in a common enterprise is a really key part. A random beeple NFT wouldn't meet that definition, even if marketed as "this hot new thing that's only going up in value". The SEC isn't stopping people buying daft things. > The order finds that Impact Theory encouraged potential investors to view the purchase of a Founder’s Key as an investment into the business, stating that investors would profit from their purchases if Impact Theory was successful in its efforts This is where it differed from many other NFTs that aren't securities.
- kranke155 3y agoPeople either self organised or were organised around discord chats with the purpose of pumping the price
- pclmulqdq 3y agoThe good news is that judges can read the law and interpret it without having a myopic focus on specific wordings. They also don't use investopedia as a legally-binding source. Whether an NFT (or any other crypto token) is a security is still very much up in the air, and I am assuming is not able to be uniformly defined. People making noises like "you are investing in a project" and "there will be airdrops to NFT holders" sure seem like they are trying to run an unregistered securities offering. On the other hand, tokens like LINK (which you spend to do call APIs) and NFTs that are sold purely for the art don't really seem like securities. Even tokens like ETH or BTC could be considered currencies/commodities rather than securities despite all of the "project" language.
- IanCal 3y ago> The good news is that judges can read the law and interpret it without having a myopic focus on specific wordings Hmm, sort of but the specific set of requirements here are important. That's the point of a test like this. > They also don't use investopedia as a legally-binding source. Sure, but it's literally a quote from the supreme court case, I was pointing out that I got that from investopedia. https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/328/293/ https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/328/293/ > Whether an NFT (or any other crypto token) is a security is still very much up in the air, and I am assuming is not able to be uniformly defined. Correct. NTFs are very simple data structures, it depends on the token and how it's sold as to whether it counts as a security or not.
- dumbfounder 3y agoCare to offer some evidence of that? I haven't heard that and I am in the vertical. I agree that Impact Theory was selling securities, and I think it's pretty clear. But bored apes a security? I don't think many share that opinion. How is it any different than art or pokemon cards? People buy both all the time with the expectation they go up in price.
- sroussey 3y agoDo the Pokémon card makers make money continuously as the cards change hands?
- _trampeltier 3y agoSpecial edition sneaker for sure. How can a sneaker cost 10'000$, 100'000$, 1'000'000$? https://luxe.digital/lifestyle/style/most-expensive-sneakers/ https://luxe.digital/lifestyle/style/most-expensive-sneakers...
- TimJRobinson 3y agoNo and bored apes don't either. Royalties on NFT sales have mostly gone away now when big marketplaces like Blur started ignoring them.
- Dylan16807 3y agoIf the buyer's expectation of profit from the common enterprise pushes something closer to being a security, wouldn't that kind of money extraction move it further from being a security?
- psychlops 3y ago> if it is marketed, bought, sold, and held as a money-making thing, it's a security. At face value that definition would, of course, include commodities and futures, which it doesn't. There must be more to the definition.
- ivalm 3y agoOP is missing “common enterprise” part of definition, which covers commodities. Security futures are securities (jointly managed by SEC and CFTC), commodity futures are not (as they are a derivative on a non-security). The main inconsistency is that bank loans are not securities.
- freeone3000 3y agoBank loan derivatives and packaged loan products are, however. It is simple debt sales that are not, which is reasonable.
- ivalm 3y agoIs a business loan syndicated to 50 institutional investors that different from a bond offering?
- echelon 3y ago> This one, though, was clearly marketed as Make Money Fast. How about BAYC? All the a16z investments in crypto? Will the hammer fall for these, too?
- candiddevmike 3y agoThe wheels of justice turn slowly but grind exceedingly fine
- chrisco255 3y ago> if it is marketed, bought, sold, and held as a money-making thing, it's a security No, sorry, no such legal language exists and how absurd of a law would that be. Anything which goes up and down in value could be bought or sold as "a money making thing" including collectible video games, books, Pokemon cards, .com domain names, pork bellies, houses, bar codes, imported goods, rare sneakers, wholesale products, golf club memberships, Picasso paintings, etc. There is a Supreme Court precedent called the Howey test which specifies 4 criteria for which all 4 must be true in order for something to be a security. You cannot have 3 of 4 and be considered to be a security: 1. An investment of money 2. In a common enterprise 3. With the expectation of profit 4. To be derived from the efforts of others Notably, speculative flipping of owned assets is not considered to profit derived from a common enterprise. Speculative flipping happens everywhere in all supply chains you participate in on a daily basis. Everyone is attempting to buy low in an attempt to sell high. Everyone loves to compare crypto to the tulip mania in the Netherlands from the 17th century. While that is true in some cases, you certainly can't make the case that tulips should be regulated by the SEC.
- ajross 3y agoThat seems to reinforce the grandparents characterization of this as an evasion of the Howey test, not refute it. You really think the technical distinction of a unique number defeats the idea of "common enterprise"? Doesn't the fact that all the initial profit goes to one enterprise clearly make it "common"? Conversely, aren't traded shares of common stocks on NYSE merely "speculative flipping" unless they're specifically paying dividends? Meh. I mean, fine, you can make that argument but I don't think this is nearly as clear as you think it is. From my perspective: I mean, duh. Of course these are securities. "Give us money for this thing and you'll get more money later" isn't a hard idea to understand as the spirit behind securities regulation.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> Doesn't the fact that all the initial profit goes to one enterprise clearly make it "common"? Maybe, but you're not tied to the enterprise after the initial purchase. > Conversely, aren't traded shares of common stocks on NYSE merely "speculative flipping" unless they're specifically paying dividends? The value is tied to the company and can be extracted in a multitude of ways, and the company has a duty to the shareholders. The expectation of profit in a stock goes well beyond just dividends. > I mean, duh. Of course these are securities. "Give us money for this thing and you'll get more money later" That depends on where the money comes from. The people selling gold say the exact same thing, and gold is not a security.
- mike_d 3y ago> NFTs were specifically designed No, NFTs were to capitalize on the new tax reporting and valuation requirements for physical art that closed the money laundering loophole.
- kemitchell 3y agoInterested. Source to read? Thank you.
- mike_d 3y agohttps://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20210213-will-money-laundering-laws-end-art-world-s-culture-of-secrecy https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20210213-will-money-la... https://www.artnews.com/art-news/market/new-u-s-anti-money-laundering-laws-and-sanctions-art-market-impact-1234588194/ https://www.artnews.com/art-news/market/new-u-s-anti-money-l... https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/29/business/art-money-laundering-sanctions-senate/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/29/business/art-money-laundering...
- stainablesteel 3y agoyeah you can only launder with real art not this digital bullshit
- bboygravity 3y agoYeah, well the SEC also has rules from the 1930's stating that brokers who sell shares to clients and fail to deliver them should have their license suspended. Guess how often that rule was applied since the 30's? Zero. And that's not because fails to deliver don't exist. So yeah, there's a massive regulatory crisis going on and SEC rules are applied however the future employers of the SEC decisionmakers want.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]