5 ms·
Why doesn't the word "rent" appear in here anywhere? If the landlord becomes aware that the restaurant pays way above industry norms, it will raise the rents at
by jeffbee 3y ago
Why doesn't the word "rent" appear in here anywhere? If the landlord becomes aware that the restaurant pays way above industry norms, it will raise the rents at the earliest opportunity to squeeze that money back out of the business. Either they own the building or have an existing long-term lease.
- scotty79 3y agoThat's the exactly the same reason why basic income can't work if it's introduced on its own. This money will immediately land in the hands of landlords who'll just increase rent.
- tech_ken 3y agoDoesn't any landlord who defects from colluding stand to gain though? Like how Georgists argue that their land tax won't get passed directly on to renters because if it's applied to the whole market at once then absent perfect and universal collusion on behalf of the landlords renters will arb out those with the highest rent spikes.
- tracker1 3y agoConsidering a handful of companies already control most rental pricing, and already extract "maximum value" from those properties, I'm not sure it would be any different in any direction. I don't get why there isn't some level of Trust Busting going on regarding the rental property pricing management at all.
- astrange 3y agoBecause it's not true. People only think this because of an innumerate article from ProPublica. Almost all landlords are small time, only own one or two buildings, and can't organize a cartel. Except there's one way they can - by changing the law to favor them by banning new construction.
- mordae 3y agoThey don't need to collude explicitly. They just watch posted prices in their region and match that. Since the posted prices are always above average (you start higher than the old rent and keep lowering it until somebody takes it), rent keeps going up for everyone.
- astrange 3y agoRents don't always go up even nominally; you've just listed the upward pressures without the downwards ones. I believe they're still down in SF compared to last year. Posted prices can be misleading because they prefer to give discounts (X months free) rather than lower the sticker price, so it also depends how you count.
- CJefferson 3y agoIf a landlord becomes aware a company pays it's managers above industry norms, do they raise rent? How does any company make a profit in such a world?
- astrange 3y agoCommercial leases tend to be much longer to prevent the landlords from raising the rent. Which of course, also makes commercial landlords picky about who they rent to. Land value tax would solve this. (We have property taxes, but they're not as good, and in California they're capped.)
- datavirtue 3y agoI worked at Perkins in another lifetime. They had 99 year leases on land where they built stores.
- ralfd 3y agoAn company can more easily switch offices. But for a restaurant the location is very important.
- werewrsdf 3y agoThat is generally not how things work. Your same argument could be made if they realized the restaurant was very popular/profitable (with low empoloyee wages). Rents have to be somewhat in line with market. They can't just increase rents ignoring the rest of the market. If you are arguing that switch costs are high, so they can. That may be somewhat true, but I know of multiple restaurants in my area that have moved. It's not that high and commercial real estate is not in the best place, so landlords aren't looking forward to vacant property
- tristor 3y ago> That is generally not how things work. Your same argument could be made if they realized the restaurant was very popular/profitable (with low empoloyee wages). Rents have to be somewhat in line with market. They can't just increase rents ignoring the rest of the market. No, that is actually pretty much exactly how things work. Successful restaurants get higher rents on lease renewal which is why they're incentivized to sign longer lease terms. The restaurant is usually paying for all the necessary renovations to kit a property out with their equipment, decor, and branding, so the switching costs are very high, and the landlord is heavily incentivized to squeeze them. It's one of the largest, most common, and most existential issues for restaurants as a business, and a major reason why the largest and most successful chains usually operate on a franchise lease-back model where the corporate entity owns the free-standing building, preventing mis-aligned landlords from making the business unsustainable and eating into their profit-margins. Have you ever wondered why an Applebee's or similar is a free-standing building even on a mall property, even though it doesn't need a drive-through? Because Darden Restaurant Group, just like McDonald's, is as much a real-estate investment company as it is a restaurant company, and it understands that both the franchisee/operator and their primary corporate entity benefit from cutting out landlords that are incentivized to be a rent-seeking as possible. Your comment is deeply misinformed and it's clear you've never been involved in running a restaurant as a business. Rent is often the #1 factor that can drive a restaurant out of business, because it's the thing you have the least control over. You can often structure your menu to help manage food/ingredient and staffing cost, but you cannot do the same about rent. Restaurants are somewhat unique in that for single-location entities, too /much/ success can actually kill you because of asshole landlords.
- ARandumGuy 3y agoWhy would that be different in a worker-owned business compared to any other business? Wouldn't a landlord be equally likely to jack up the rent on a company that posts high profits? I'm not an expert on commercial leasing, but I suspect a landlord who tried to do that would quickly find themselves with no tenants.
- burkaman 3y agoThe landlord could also just not do that.
- FredPret 3y agoThose evil landlords and their infinite pricing power. If only there was competition among landlords (ie, build more). In all seriousness, businesses can move (easier said than done for a restaurant) and commercial leases are very long, 5-10 years.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoCurious how the average lifespan of a restaurant just happens to be 8 to 10 years. Couldn't be a coincidence, just couldn't. /S
- BeetleB 3y agoOver the last 3-4 years, I've spent a lot of time around RE folks. I can't speak for places like malls, but I have encountered quite a few that own your typical plaza/strip mall, and this is not at all how they think. Most are relatively simple folks, who make less than your typical SV SW engineer. Their goal is not to maximize profit, but rather to not work. That's why they really like triple net lease[1] - so they don't even have to think about it. Once they've covered all their expenses so they can "retire" from their regular job, they put all the extra income into other RE efforts (namely buying other such strip malls). For lease renewals, they'll usually charge just the market rates. They are very unlikely to hyperfocus on one particular business they rent out to - they have better uses of their time, and don't want volatile income. They want something steady and reliable. They know restaurants have thin margins and may fail. There's an Indian restaurant in one of the top food streets in my city that people love - a lot of folks consider it amongst the best in the city. I once jokingly told the owner "What will it take for you to open in my suburb?" She said that before she opened where she did, she tried to open at a plaza close to my house, but the rent was too high. I was shocked - that plaza is a graveyard of restaurants and businesses, and is not at all a happening location. Yet a top food street in the city charges less? It's not a crazy story. It happens often. [1] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/triple-net-lease-nnn.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/triple-net-lease-nnn.as...