11 ms·
SpaceX CEO claims he can send you on a round-trip to Mars for $500K
- warpspeed 15y agoWhile I'm sure it's a technical hurdle in itself, I didn't think that fuel or weight were the big problems with a manned mission to Mars. I'm curious as to what Mr. Musk's plan is for shielding passengers from intersteller radiation that one would experience outside of our magnetosphere. The Apollo astronauts were exposed to approximately 1140 millirem over a 9 day mission, while the average here on earth is 350 millirem per year. Nuclear workers are limited to about 2000 millirem per year... so the approximately 52,000 millirem per year the astronauts would receive on a Mars mission is a problem.
- mrsebastian 15y agoObligatory XKCD link: http://xkcd.com/radiation/ http://xkcd.com/radiation/ (100 rem = 1 sievert)
- api 15y agoAgreed. Maybe long distance manned space flight will finally kill radiophobia.
- Groxx 15y agoFollowing that math, the 9 day Apollo trip got 0.0114 sieverts. We'll round that to 11 mSv. So in 9 days, they got 11x more than the EPA's yearly limit to the public, or 1/5th of the EPA's yearly limit to radiation workers. The 520mSv warpspeed listed as a trip's radiation exposure comes out to 5x the lowest yearly radiation exposure 'clearly linked' to increased cancer risk. So yeah. A problem, barring adequate shielding, if that number is correct.
- albertzeyer 15y agoWhere do you have that 52,000 millirem (i.e. 520 mSv) number from? Doesn't that completely depend on the thickness and material of the walls of the spacecraft? I.e., isn't it just a question of making the walls thick enough?
- Daviator 15y agoThat's what I was thinking. Not to mention, I would imagine that anti-radiation technology has surely grown in capability since the Apollo missions.
- warpspeed 15y agoPractically it really hasn't. Polyethylene is being tested in NASA's Radiation Shielding Program but I don't believe it's been put into service for a manned mission. There are also tests being conducted with adjustable "magnetic bubbles" that can in theory shield a spacecraft from radiation, but the last I heard they were done on a much smaller scale and would require a huge amount of power. NASA has been making progress in making astronauts less susceptible to radiation damage through diet and vitamins. There's also this paper which talks about a vaccine that's being tested to counteract some of the body's responses to radiation exposure (PDF): http://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20070021485_2007019108.pdf http://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/2007002...
- warpspeed 15y agoI occasionally get to work with the Astronomical Society and have gotten into a few conversations about manned Mars missions with people from NASA, JPL and various educational institutions. The numbers are from a study NASA conducted at Brookhaven National Laboratory. The problem with shielding is the weight involved to achieve any level of protection.. wrapping the ship in enough lead to make a difference would be hard to get it off the ground. Also while this type of shielding may be effective against normal solar radiation, high energy galactic cosmic rays are far more dangerous and are almost unaffected by conventional shielding. If you're interested, I recommend this paper. It goes a bit deeper into exactly why radiation is such a problem for any proposed Mars missions (warning, PDF): http://spaceradiation.usra.edu/references/Ch4RadCarcinogen.pdf http://spaceradiation.usra.edu/references/Ch4RadCarcinogen.p...
- Daviator 15y agoThis is a pretty relevant and interesting read about magnetic shielding. http://www.thespacereview.com/article/308/1 http://www.thespacereview.com/article/308/1 I hope this technology is thoroughly investigated before moving forward with the standard absorption method of radiation protection.
- samstave 15y agoHe said "round trip" - he did not claim what state you would be in upon return :)
- architb 15y agoThis might sound like a stupid question, but here it goes. What if you lined the astronauts in a room with a control unit and really thick lead walls for most of the journey? Could this theoretically stop radiation, and protect them? Lead blocks most radiation, specifically gamma.
- ceejayoz 15y agoSure, but getting lead to orbit is hugely expensive. A better solution is water. You need to carry it anyways.
- elithrar 15y ago> A better solution is water. You need to carry it anyways. You certainly won't be drinking that water after a while, though. Some might be used for cooling systems, but you would have a lot of extraneous water.
- ars 15y agoWhy won't you drink it? Just because it's used for shielding doesn't make it radioactive. Also water basically can't become radioactive. The isotope of oxygen with the longest half life, and more neutrons than the stable ones, has a half life of 26 seconds, so it doesn't stay radioactive. If you manage to bind a proton (it's virtually impossible for oxygen, but lets say) and make fluorine, the result has a half life of less than an attosecond. Deuterium is not radioactive, and tritium is hard to make (you need deuterium first, and there barely is any in your water). The radiation could theoretically fission oxygen into other elements, but that's very unlikely, and the results have extremely short half lives. In short: Water can't become radioactive, which is why it's so good as shielding. (However water can obviously be contaminated by something else that is radioactive - so don't go drinking the water in a nuclear reactor :)
- marze 15y agoWater works better. Heavy elements like lead splatter when hit by high energy particles and generate secondary radiation. The idea is good, most mars plans include a shelter with a water or rocket fuel shield.
- rsynnott 15y ago> Nuclear workers are limited to about 2000 millirem per year... so the approximately 52,000 millirem per year the astronauts would receive on a Mars mission is a problem. The limits for nuclear workers are extraordinarily conservative, so it may not be as much of a problem as you'd think. Given the safety track record of manned spaceflight, the radiation is probably the least of your worries.
- mkn 15y agoWe could be saved by the square-cube law, or, The Power of Being Big. In essence, let's assume you've made your own fully-shielded space capsule for one, and that you need, for example, a pound of material for every square inch of its surface, and that you've made it into a sphere to economize on material. Wise choices, all of them. A 2m diameter capsule would come in at 19,500 lbs, or so, for that many square inches. Congratulations. You've just found out why we don't shield small spacecraft. Now, however, let's get an estimate of what it would cost to shield 200 people, providing them each with a volume-equivalent of your capsule, or 4.2ish cubic meters per person. Really packing them in. This is a 11.6-meter diameter sphere, with roughly 3,300 pounds of shielding per person. At 2000 people, packed in like sardines, we're at 25.2 meters in diameter and 1550 lbs of shielding per person. A 54-meter sphere packs 20,000 sardines, and requires a mere 717 lbs of shielding per person. A factor of 10-20 better. Obviously, we want to relax the space constraints a bit. However, the form factor of shielding in the larger craft is going to be much better suited to the reutilization of supplies as shielding. In the limiting case, of course, there is effectively no required shielding per occupant. Long before that, magnetic shielding schemes become a viable option, too. A more practical limit would be to consider a transport module made up of re-entry craft seating 1-10 persons, with the ablative heat-shields and supplies facing outward. In this case, assume we can get down to 5 times your cross-sectional area in shielding, and guess that that's about 2.5 square meters. That's 4000/lbs per person. So, still a factor of 5 better than the solo case. Additionally, this is a lot of arithmetic to ask of google and http://www.calculatorsoup.com/calculators/geometry-solids/sphere.php http://www.calculatorsoup.com/calculators/geometry-solids/sp..., so the numbers may be off. Also, the Dragon capsule checks in at 5.8 m^2 of heat shield per astronaut, which may be a practical limit. And I just made up the 1lb/in^2 shielding requirement.
- bstpierre 15y agoIn other news, a one-way trip to Mars only costs $50k. If you don't make it, you can sue for a refund, but you have to sue in Martian courts, which won't be set up for a few more decades.
- xspence 15y agoIs mars established as a credible planet/nation zone, or does it count as space (international)? Its an interesting perspective that the "zone" of mars could be a place of legal jurisdiction. But it seems that space is a free for all "zone", so maybe your lawsuit would be void?
- warpspeed 15y agoAccording to the 1967 U.N. Outer Space Treaty, "outer space, including the Moon and other celestial bodies, is not subject to national appropriation by claim of sovereignty, by means of use or occupation, or by any other means. However, the State that launches a space object retains jurisdiction and control over that object. The State is also liable for damages caused by their space object and must avoid contaminating space and celestial bodies." (from Wikipedia) So any crimes on Mars would probably fall under the jurisdiction of the country who launched the mission. Enforcement on the other hand might be tricky.
- xspence 15y agoInteresting. I would imagine because of the vast majority of things that can come into contact with the vessel (ranging from a toothpick to an asteroid) could cause any amount of damage and there would be no way to retrieve the vessel for evidence. Thanks for the clarification on the subject.
- lewisgodowski 15y agoI believe warpspeed meant damages caused to the celestial body BY the vessel, not vice versa. Basically they don't want you littering and damaging whatever planet/moon/etc. you decide to visit.
- sgt101 15y agoHow is he going to do the landing? Human manned craft are going to be too big for bags, and the atmosphere is too thin for parachutes to work. Landing on thrusters is somewhat fuel heavy (so to speak).
- blueprint 15y agoGlider?
- samstave 15y agoThis is why I said we first need to conquer the moon. Send robotic building machines to the Moon, let them build habitable structures there first. Then send these to Mars, have them remotely operated and autonomous and build a habitable setup there first without humans. Then ship fuel pods to orbit mars which would allow you to go there with an empty lander - fill it up in orbit then land. I think we need to take logical steps before we shove humans in a pringles can and launch them to mars.
- warpspeed 15y agoLike this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BudlaGh1A0o http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BudlaGh1A0o edit- Parachutes are probably more practical. They work if you make them big enough.
- ballooney 15y agoYour mass scales with the cube of linear dimension. Parachute drag scales as a square of linear dimension. What this means is that the chute gets bigger much more quickly than the payload as you increase lander mass, to the point that you quickly get outlandishly large and impractical chutes for manned landers. Hence the research into alternatives.
- lewisgodowski 15y agoI haven't gotten a chance to read the article yet, but is he planning on landing at all? I would imagine it would be much easier to just go there and back, without landing...? Much more fuel efficient and technically still "round trip."
- ef4 15y agoRobert Zubrin published a detailed plan for generating rocket fuel on Mars several years ago. His book "The Case for Mars" is a good read. Such a technology really is a game changer for the economics of the mission. And you can send your robotic fuel factory and make sure it's working before you commit to launching people.
- inchcombec 15y agoI've actually got that book in my collection and you're right, it is a good read. The idea of producing rocket fuel on Mars is not only a good one, but quite likely the only way such a mission would even be viable. The idea of hauling all that extra rocket fuel for the return trip to Mars and back simply doesn't work.
- benl 15y agoThe full-length interview this story is based on is on this page: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-17439490 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-17439490 Just skip the stories and listen to the audio, it's much more informative.
- vannevar 15y agoHe's relying on generating fuel on Mars, which considering that we've barely scraped the Martian surface with robots is highly speculative. Mars travel is still beyond business planning and into the realm of futures studies. I love SpaceX, but they haven't yet demonstrated they can reliably deliver payloads to Earth orbit on a regular basis. They're a long, long way from Mars.
- mkramlich 15y agoI've heard some experts in the field say that the hardest parts about space travel are the launching and the landing. The middle parts, like the long boring flight and keeping the crew alive and not crazy, are massively easier and less risky in comparison, engineering-wise. They've shown they can put something into orbit. Landing on Mars with humans will be tricky, but the technology seems to exist to allow it, and that general kind of thing has been done before. Parachutes and thrusters, etc.
- vannevar 15y agoI don't doubt that SpaceX can get to Mars eventually, maybe even within 10 years. I really hope they do, I'm rooting for them. But I seriously doubt they will be ferrying space tourists out there for $500K apiece in any timeframe that would fit in a business plan, even a very long-term one. We're decades away from that kind of capability.
- adaml_623 15y agoI'd rather go to the moon. The view is better.
- pjscott 15y agoIf you're interested in spectacular views, it's hard to compete with a mountain three times the height of Mount Everest: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olympus_Mons http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olympus_Mons Mars also has an atmosphere suitable for flying around in with helium or hydrogen balloons. You could mount a camera on a bunch of balloons and get some amazing pictures. If you don't mind my saying so, "The view is better" doesn't sound like your real reason for preferring the moon.
- pyrotechnick 15y agoHe means the view of Earth from the moon vs from Mars.
- za 15y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earthrise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earthrise
- joeyh 15y agoThe problem with Olympus Mons, when it comes to views, is that when you're on it, it's too big, and too gradual a slope to see off it. Also, when standing at the base of it, the summit is off over the horizon. Give me Valles Marineris any day.
- michaelkscott 15y agoI'd choose Pluto for some stunning views: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:ESO-L._Cal%C3%A7ada_-_Pluto_(by).jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:ESO-L._Cal%C3%A7ada_-_Plut...
- duxup 15y agoCan't get that much time off of work. What can you do for me over a couple weeks?
- damoncali 15y agoWhat is it about this guy that allows him to make such claims and not be laughed out of the room? It's an amazing an useful talent that, oddly, I first witnessed as a young engineer on NASA's Hubble Space Telescope project. The head of the servicing missions was a boisterous, outrageous, personality (some told me it was what held him from higher positions within NASA). He was the kind of guy who brought in a sales guy for a rapid prototyping machine (a 3D printer starting at $1 million), walked in half way through the presentation, and then promptly kicked the salesman out for not having a $200k offering. He was also the kind of guy who demanded composite structures yielding 10X the mechanical properties of the current state of the art materials. But with no research projects, development, or anything even close to it. Just "get it done". Of course, we didn't get it done (because it was impossible), but what we did get done was a major leap forward. We used materials without, gasp, flight heritage. We used the absolute state of the art in some cases. We got it done, it's just that it wasn't what was asked for, at least not directly. This smells of the same thing. But don't underestimate the shear force of personality it takes to make such outrageous claims, and still have people follow you to something remarkable, yet more realistic.
- spoiledtechie 15y agoThis reminds me of Atlas Shrugged, when the entire community is against the stars for the book building the Rail Road. They don't believe it possible. I would actually say, don't underestimate perseverance. Might sound like he is an optimist, but I think you have to be with anything to do with spaceflight. At least at this day an age. I would also consider him an expert in the subject, and what are you?
- Daviator 15y agoI think it's pretty cool that not only is he the obvious owner of the entire enterprise, but he is the chief technology officer because he is a self taught aeronautical engineer for lack of a better descriptor in this case. One of his degrees is in physics, sure, but one of his real ambitions in this instance is reading everything and talking to every expert he could in this field. The point of the matter is that this kid did his homework and deserves everything he will earn in this endeavor.
- linuxhansl 15y agoMaybe fly to the moon first before you tackle mars?
- Androsynth 15y agoThis is great and I fully applaud him for this. But when I go, I won't be coming back http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_to_Stay http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_to_Stay
- rwhitman 15y agoSo you can drop a half million dollars and spend 2 years of your life in a tiny compartment millions of miles from home to visit a dead, cold, rusty rock without a breathable atmosphere? Does that sound unappealing to anyone else?
- Zaak 15y agoI expect there are many people who would find that very unappealing. I also expect that there are people who would put down the money right now if you would let them.
- repsilat 15y agoThere are people who would put down the money for a one-way trip.
- mmahoney 15y agoIt sounds awesome personally
- mkramlich 15y agoI don't find the idea of jumping out of a plane with only a parachute (that will probably open OK. maybe) to be appealing, yet thousands of people do it every year, willingly, and repeatedly. And that's downright mundane compared to the obvious exoticness and thrill those kinds of folks would get from setting foot on the planet Mars.
- pygorex 15y ago> Of course, there are many skeptical experts out there that have pointed out the fact that SpaceX has only attempted a rocket launch seven times. Of those seven, three were total failures. Ouch. I hope that $500,000 is refundable in case of death or accident. > Any human that makes the trip will be stuck inside the vehicle for the 214 days it would take to actually travel to the Red Planet. I once made a road trip from Seattle to Tennessee in 3 days. In the middle of a frigid winter. During blizzard conditions. Of course we took breaks to get out of the car, stretch our legs, have a piss and get some fresh air. At the end of the trip I was ready to hang myself. The boredom and rigor of endless driving became unbearable. The prospect of taking a similar trip, over a much longer timespan, in much more hostile conditions and paying for the privilege is not appealing, at all.
- pjscott 15y agoTo be more specific about their flight record: the first three test flights were failures, back when they were still working out the kinks on the Falcon 1. The flights since then -- including both Falcon 9 launches -- have been successful.
- nl 15y agoThe boredom and rigor of endless driving became unbearable. Well the good thing is that you won't have to do the driving part..
- kamaal 15y agoThere is huge difference between traveling to places on earth and space and the motivation to do so. On earth you might be traveling for whatever boring reason. Imagine if some one told you Shangri La actually exists and you have to bear some pain for an year to get there. What would you do? Will you take some pain to get there and live at Shangri La for some days? I definitely would. And I'm sure many would.