11 ms·
E-bike industry blames consumers for fires to undermine right to repair laws
- josefresco 3y agoWas curious about the organization behind this. It's called "People for Bikes" and the board* is made up of big bike co execs. https://www.peopleforbikes.org/board https://www.peopleforbikes.org/board
- Macha 3y agoI think this is more a case of "regulatory capture" (or in this case "lobbyist capture", I guess). When your goal is the promotion of cycling infrastructure, the goals of cyclist and bike companies are aligned, so you might not think too much of your lobby group being run by the corporate interests you agree with. Right up until you get to an issue like this where suddenly those formerly aligned interests are no longer aligned. Except now you've given these group the legitimacy to claim to represent the interests of cyclists, even when it's now going against them.
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoTo be honest I think this is more an issue of an org that can be constructed nearly whole cloth by one or more corporate entities and be basically designed from the word go to misinform the public, somehow. Be it the more Machiavellian end of the spectrum where you want to convince people a bad thing is good actually (a lot of climate stuff fits this, looking at you Koch) all the way to this kind of thing. The scale of the lie is an interesting data point, but nevertheless, we as a society have apparently decided we're okay being lied to at scale. That's... weird, right? Like even if you say companies should have the right to lobby (which frankly I'd disagree with but I digress), why are they allowed to do it like this? Where they astroturf a "citizens" group to trick people into parroting their propaganda?
- InSteady 3y agoFreedom of $peech is a broad umbrella. And at least in America, we are incredibly business friendly while being rather cavalier regarding consumer protections. At the same time we are an incredibly litigious society, so you end up with a perverse situation where laws, regulations, and bureaucratic inefficiencies choke up the efforts of businesses and nonprofit organizations (and even local governments), but individual consumers still regularly get fucked with absolutely no recourse. Other than shelling out for a lawyer and taking someone to civil court themselves. Lobbying is it's own can of worms as a system with perverse incentives and ethical quagmires. But good luck getting any traction trying to change the way that works.. anyone in a position to make changes to it stands to benefit from this way of doing things (and has probably been indoctrinated into believing it is an effective and equitable system in any case). At least our brand of political corruption is (mostly) out in the open and "on the books." Businesses and NGOs get tax write-offs for their lobbying expenses, so there is plenty of documentation.
- afavour 3y agoThat stuff always infuriates me. I have no problem with an industry forming a group to advocate for their interests but when they deliberate misname themselves it makes it clear day one that they have no intention of honesty.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoSo you like the power structure, but wish for at most a change of heart to overcome the incentives - keep wishing
- mysterydip 3y agosimilar: OpenAI
- pessimizer 3y agoIf they were as advanced as pharmaceutical or medical device companies, they'd just pour money into a "consumer/patient's group" that they'd completely control the administration and priorities of, and make sure that no one is allowed to be a candidate for the board without their opinion vetting. This is better.
- local_person 3y ago[dead]
- Pingk 3y agoThe FTC already debunked this claim years ago (which the article states). Calling out manufacturer propaganda shouldn't even need to be a thing we have to do... https://www.ftc.gov/reports/nixing-fix-ftc-report-congress-repair-restrictions https://www.ftc.gov/reports/nixing-fix-ftc-report-congress-r...
- jeffbee 3y agoWhich part particularly debunks? It appears ambivalent to me. For example, pages 20-21 seem to conclude that "The use of 18650 cells with the same form factor but different internal chemistries creates the risk that a replacement 18650 will have a different internal chemistry from the original 18650, placing individuals and independent repair shops at risk of inadvertently causing thermal runaway events." As a person who already had to flee one structure fire caused by a DIY hoverboard battery, I am sympathetic to this line of argument.
- jacquesm 3y agoLithium Ion should be replaced ASAP by safer chemistries so we can sidestep this issue completely. As far as I'm concerned this should have never gotten as far as it did and manufacturers that produce crap batteries (of which there are plenty!) should be held responsible. Apropos: not rare at all to open AAA brand battery packs to find burned out wiring, burned out circuit boards, signs of combustion that somehow didn't go outside of the case. Take no risk with these things, even with the good ones: in case of doubt place in fireproof container and deliver to a recycling station that knows how to handle them safely. If you have no experience with these then do not try to repair a pack because the risks are nothing to be trifled with. Finally: cheap stuff containing 18650's should be avoided like the plague, if the device is cheap then that means the components are even cheaper. Only use devices that use quality cells, that haven't been recycled and that have only been used within spec. Your fire insurance policy protects you from monetary loss, but it won't revive you or your companions...
- Filligree 3y ago> Lithium Ion should be replaces ASAP by safer chemistries so we can sidestep this issue completely. As far as I'm concerned this should have never gotten as far as it did and manufacturers that produce crap batteries (of which there are plenty!) should be held responsible. What should they be replaced with? I'm curious to know what alternate chemistry you're proposing for my e-bike battery.
- jeffbee 3y agoFor the particular case of e-bikes, if they have a right to repair, do I also have a right to not live in the same apartment building as some guy who exercised his "right to repair" his e-bike battery? It really seems like factory refurbished battery packs are sufficient accommodation for consumers and the external risk to the public from YOLO DIY bozos is high enough to blunt this "right".
- notarget137 3y agoLet's keep them away from kitchens and matches then.
- jeffbee 3y agoDoes your kitchen burst into flames unprovoked while you aren't home? Lithium-ion batteries are unstable. In this analogy they are self-striking matches.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoHave you heard of gas stoves? Or grid electricity? Either occasionally sets something ablaze unprovoked. (As much as I hate this as a city dweller, the compromise solution may be simply to ban work on certain types of batteries in multi-tenant buildings and dense residential areas - making it so you effectively need to own a home outside of the city, with a plot of land, to do this. Or perhaps just enforce existing rules better, because I bet that the potentially dangerous activities are already not legal to perform in a regular flat.)
- jacquesm 3y agoObviously they have, so please don't degrade the discussion like this. Lithium Ion packs are far more dangerous than gas stoves or general use of electricity. If you don't recognize that fact then maybe I should send you my safety notes regarding lithium ion battery packs? This stuff is so unstable that I'm kind of on the edge of believing that we probably should have never used this tech to the degree that we do, and as these systems get older you can expect more and more of them to develop issues.
- taylodl 3y agoHere's my take: you don't really own something if you can't repair it. Manufacturers prefer you don't really own their products: they own it, they service it, you use it, and they charge you for the "experience." It's created a throwaway culture that's an environmental disaster. We need to figure out how to right this course.
- sparrowInHand 3y agoState controlled subscriptions, with cost-free repairs.
- sydbarrett74 3y agoThis should be a threatened backstop if the market fails to meet this need. The latter is preferable, of course, and should be incented.
- georgeplusplus 3y agoThis is just about the laziest unimaginative solution. What drove you to this solution? Do you have such low interest or investment in the problem so you would prefer some larger entity like the government just hand wave away this problem? With how many examples exist of the government getting involved at levels of industry they clearly don’t have the expertise for and how everything gets batshit expensive when they get involved or how many examples you can draw from communist countries, a normal person would get the hint that this kind of blanket regulation is toxic and evil and would stop being proposed as solutions.
- isanjay 3y agoAnd they are very efficient
- mitchdoogle 3y agoWhat are you talking about? This whole thread is discussing how private enterprise is failing consumers. Meanwhile, countless examples exist of government-run entities and non-profits that are well-liked and less expensive for consumers. I don't think a large-scale repair entity created by the government is the answer to this problem, but it's clear you have a bias towards business, and in the repair industry, business is the problem and we need a government solution. I don't understand why anyone ever has your attitude. Any organization can be run poorly and its leaders susceptible to corruption, whether that be a government one or a private entity. You have to understand the problem to offer solutions and in many cases, a profit motive simply does not provide the best outcome for consumers.
- tinus_hn 3y ago[flagged]
- pcdoodle 3y agoThey have a spot where you can leave a review on google if you feel so inclined. I don't trust that these groups will reduce waist or risks. I hope someday there's a standard 36/48/52V battery that has a cost of $0.25 per wh. If you slightly oversize your battery AH requirements, 5-6 life years is typical with even heavy use. Better yet, merge the electric lawn care batteries with bicycles (easy and safe if you're into DIY and match the load to the C rate the battery can provide). There's already DRM on my lawn care tools but luckily i can still power a bike off the batteries because the DRM is on the tool side (it has an extra 4th pin looking for a specific PWM pulse). Most of the fires are coming from bottom of the barrel factories that recycle cells into questionable packs with questionable BMS systems.
- michael1999 3y agoWe also have rules about welding car gas tanks, and for similar reasons. One of the virtues of bikes is how easy they are to service or modify at home. It's great to tinker with motors, wiring, switching, transmission, and brakes. Unfortunately, LiON battery packs have invisible failure modes that involve burning down the building.
- jacquesm 3y agoAnd most car gas tanks are no longer made of metal.
- pnpnp 3y agoThe problem here is that there's not good alternative to Lithium for now. LiFePO4 (commonly seen as LFP) chemistry is a little safer, but also less energy dense & heavier. It's unclear to me whether or not these downsides rule out that chemistry's use for bikes as space and weight can often be at a premium.
- jacquesm 3y agoAgreed, and yes, this is a problem. I'm hoping for Lithium Titanate to become more affordable, I think it is one of the most promising candidates.
- firebat45 3y ago
- mpsprd 3y agoCompanies fighting against right to repair is an ecological disaster. I take pride in repairing everything at home, and god I hate how hard they try to stop me. The hypocrisy of our societies that want us to consume "ecology products" and associated marketing infuriates me. Just stop buying things!
- katbyte 3y agoI am always annoyed by how hard I have to work to buy things that last/won’t need replacing because they break
- LanceH 3y agoI'm going to hop in here and add that it's hard to find things that work, as well. Like right now I'm looking for a carpet cleaner that works as well as a professional model (or the professional model). Consumer models just seem flawed. In particular, even when they are meant to vacuum wet things, they internal that end up wet aren't cleanable. So I end up with internal mold and the suggestion that I clean it out with a wire. Disassembly instructions are multiple pages long, and still present the problem of cleaning curved plastic pipes. I just to buy the same thing I can hire someone to use that will clean up after 3 dogs, and can itself be cleaned.
- bo1024 3y agoGreat point, and I feel the same thing happens with software. Consumer products are stuffed with hostile attention-stealing software, telemetry, overcomplicated, ads, etc. Professional stuff is actually designed to work. (e.g. TVs, printers)
- getarofilter 3y ago[dead]
- LarryDarrell 3y ago"Reduce, Reuse, Recycle" was never going to be compatible with our economic system. Thus, our new slogan. "Buy Green!"
- jacquesm 3y agoSo, here is my take. I've built my own battery pack, a pretty big one (170 cells of the largest capacity available), and it has served me well. But: I'm not your average DIYer and have spent a ton of time reading up on the do's and don'ts of pack construction, made a smaller one first to experiment with and have researched pack safety until my eyes hurt. My short take is that if you are someone who wants to revive their e-bike battery pack after it fails and who does not have extensive experience yet that it is going to be much cheaper and safer to just go out and buy a replacement pack from the same brand. I've seen multiple packs that had burned out wiring (usually: balancing wires, but also the main current carrying conductor), burned out BMS boards. Rarely did I open a pack that had been in service after developing a fault where the fault could not have potentially propagated. That it did not was in most cases sheer luck. Even for brand name gear! It is super easy to mess up with these. Drop a pack, drop a sliver of wire or interconnect ribbon, misplace a tool and you have a thermal runaway on your hands which you will not be able to stop. Doing this in a facility that is not set up for it (say, your kitchen or living room, especially if it is in shared accommodation such as an apartment building) is super dangerous. If you're going to do this anyway, prepare to spend a grand or so on tools and a good month or so on creating a safe setup. After that you might as well go into business. I'm all for DIY stuff, but this isn't one of those. Finally: manufacturers could help with this: they could design their packs to be more reliable and easier to repair. They also could stop price-gouging the consumers on the packs, which is one of the reasons people want to repair them to begin with. But the packs are so chock full of DRM and other nonsense that repairing them properly is specialist work and they are so expensive that there will be a number of people that will try to repair a pack themselves anyway. Just disassembling a pack is not without risk. If you go down this route feel free to drop me an email and I'll send you a document that I have been working on for a long time to make working on these safer. Some ground rules: - replace all cells at once - weld your connections (NEVER solder them) - use only the same cells - use only cells that have all been charged to the same voltage - make a thermal scan of the pack after the initial build during high speed charging and discharging to make sure you don't have a cell in there that somehow stands out (it will surely fail) - if you drop a pack or a cell consider it lost, even if it seems to still work - only use A brand cells from a reputable vendor - do not use recycled cells - only use the original BMS - Make sure none of your sense wires are crossed or loose enough that they can cross - spend as much time on the mechanical part of your build as on the electrical part hth
- elicash 3y agoI'm sympathetic to the argument that you shouldn't be allowed to do something so dangerous it not only threatens to set your own house on fire, but also your neighbors. But it seems to me the solution to that is forcing manufacturers to make it easier to repair. Less chance of things going wrong. Which, I assume, means more standardization, even if maybe that also means less innovation. I've never repaired a bike, or a battery, so am open to having my mind changed.
- lafar6503 3y agoYep working with big li-ion batteries is dangerous and should be done with proper equipment and safety measures, but claiming that nobody can do that but the producer is BS. They just make sure nothing else is compatible so you have no alternatives. Same with electric tools - is every lawn mower so unique that it can't be powered with another brand's battery? It could, but to prevent that producers add proprietary authentication and such. They even make new generation of tools incompatible with previous gen batteries, just to be sure you're not accidentally reusing anything.
- gonzo41 3y agoI have an E-bike, I'd repair everything but the battery. The battery I have is expensive at about $1K. So I can see why the 'working person' may want to have a crack at repairs on their own, but it's risky. With bikes, there's a tradeoff with weight. If the batteries were repairable. I could see them getting heavier to make them more friendly with clip in joints and lots of inbuilt safety. Rather than the sealed for life style that they currently exist in. Anyway, I'm happy to send my bike to a mechanic. It;s money in the local economy. Though I did get a car service that was cheaper than my last bike service. Which was kinda wild in retrospect.
- sleepybrett 3y agoIMO batteries need to be standardized, documented, training and parts available and certification programs for repair. I should be able to take my battery to a certified technician/shop and have it serviced (bad cells replaced, battery management board replaced) without having to worry about it.
- roboror 3y agoThe solution here (and for most things) is education. These big bike companies (and any company selling large LiPo batteries) should fund battery safety programs for kids as part of the general fire safety lessons they already learn, as well as publish repair and safety guidelines for consumers. They should also offer low cost battery refurbishment and swaps.
- lafar6503 3y agoMany producers put a great effort into making sure you can only use their battery for replacement, even if it's obvious that any battery with correct voltage would do. Batteries should be interchangeable just like in cars- nobody sane would claim that using different brand of battery increases risk of car fire. Just set some standards on voltage and power limits and agree on common connector type, this should be done many years ago.
- jacquesm 3y agoMostly, but not quite: there are a ton of crap battery manufacturers that produce cells with the right form factor and nameplate ratings but that are complete junk.
- TheLoafOfBread 3y agoIf your product can randomly catch on fire, your product is dangerous and should not have been sold at a first place.
- throwaway9870 3y agoDepending on how you define "randomly", you might have just decided no more phones, laptops, etc. Bad batteries can sneak into even the best supply chains and cause fires.
- JumpinJack_Cash 3y agoThe e-bike industry is a scam! The bike is a 200 year old invention, these people really are fooling consumers into thinking they have re-invented the wheel. Some e-bikes go for 20,000$, that's the same price of a new Ducati Panigale which has 400 lbs of material in it, including a 220hp motor which rotates at 17000rpm. It's either a scam or poor engineering, some people claim that the pricy e-bikes have 'a lot of carbon fiber on them' , but centuries of work showed that if you are struggling to propel yourself forward the low hanging fruit is a more powerful motor which is way more helpful than lowering the weight by half an ounce at the price of hundreds of dollars of carbon fiber.
- Joel_Mckay 3y agoLithium batteries are only stable in a narrow range of conditions. Most chemistries self-heat during use, BMS often lack a charge stabilization cool-down timer, and true cell impedance monitoring is rare in fast chargers. To be blunt, if you are running LiIon/LiPol outside the 4'C to 54'C range, than you can be sure the bathtub-curve* will not flatten. i.e. given enough users a fire event becomes a certitude. * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bathtub_curve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bathtub_curve One mitigation is a metal cabinet on a concrete floor. You may think this is unnecessary for large lithium battery banks, but as cells degrade they become more problematic. Have fun, =)
- ooterness 3y agoWhat I don't get: If they're really worried about battery fires, why do the lobbyists always ask for category exceptions for "bikes" or "cars" and not "batteries"?
- jacquesm 3y agoBecause it's just a figleaf for their commercial interests. They could easily solve this but they like their $.
- sleepybrett 3y agoThey aren't 100% wrong, sketchy battery repairs can end in fire, it's just the nature of lithium based batteries. They need to be charged and discharged appropriately. The solution here is not locking out anyone but the manufacturers, the solution is standardization and training. If there was one standardized battery management board, or a series of standards, and one standardized way of putting together these batteries (which there mainly is) then there could be a training program w/ certification. Take your battery to get serviced by someone without certification that's on you, take it to a certified technician and it goes up in smoke that's on them and/or the certification board.
- jacquesm 3y agoIndeed, it is ridiculous that there are so many different battery makes and models out there when the cells themselves are highly standardized already. This is something the EU is addressing as we speak though.
- rekttrader 3y agoOnly a matter of months before vamoof goes vamoose.
- ndsipa_pomu 3y agoVanMoof goes VanPoof
- kluikens 3y agoIn California, Senator Eggman et al. have introduced SB-244 Right to Repair Act [1]. It's currently sitting in the suspense file in the Assembly's Appropriations Committee [2], where it could die unless the committee decides to pull it out so that it can be put to a vote. It currently only has a few exemptions for video game consoles, alarms, and select other equipment. If you live in California, I recommend calling the Assembly Appropriations Committee at (916) 319-2081 and asking them to pull SB-244 from the suspense file and pass it so it can go to the floor for a vote. [1] https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billCompareClient.xhtml?bill_id=202320240SB244&showamends=false https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billCompareClient.x... [2] https://apro.assembly.ca.gov https://apro.assembly.ca.gov
- ak217 3y agoThis is an incredibly cynical move by the e-bike industry, and I'm really sad to see an industry org claiming to represent REI, Santa Cruz, etc. peddling this crap. What they're asking consumers to do is send them a battery that they paid anywhere between $300 and $1000 new, which 99% of the time has had one BMS pod (10% of the battery) fail because one cell failed and took the pod with it. So they'll recycle this 90% good battery (95+% if you count the enclosure and BMS) - which means basically ship it hundreds of miles, melt it down, throw away the enclosure, and extract the raw materials. This is devastating for the environment. Meanwhile the consumer will buy a new one. Quality batteries are produced in Korea and Malaysia, while the hardware for the enclosures and BMSs is produced mostly in Taiwan and China. Preventing the proper reuse of these components is not just environmentally devastating, it's bad for the American economy. Now, it's true that consumers should not try to fix these batteries without extensive training. They are hazardous to disassemble and require specialized equipment to work on. If you mix cells and don't understand how BMSs work, you can easily start a fire. But it's not rocket science, and all the manufacturers are using pretty much off-the-shelf components. Repair is generally safe as long as you replace all cells in a parallel pod using healthy cells that are otherwise compatible and have matching charge/discharge curves with each other and with other pods in the battery - and use a quality BMS. This is not something that a typical consumer should do, and it does require monitoring equipment to confirm the health of the battery. But this is currently a huge unmet need that should be filled by local shops that train techs and create local jobs, not by melting down batteries en masse. Conversely, by trying to prevent safe routes to economical and environmentally friendly repair, the industry is encouraging people to dangerously hack their batteries to save hundreds of dollars.
- efields 3y agoI've been putting off electrifying my priority bike because I figured I would just buy one eventually, but I don't need two bikes, and now I feel like modding my existing is the morally right move forward.
- ericfrazier 3y agoRight to repair and a phone's ip67 rating can't coexist
- BenjiWiebe 3y agoYes they can. Right to repair wouldn't mean that gaskets, o-rings, and silicone must cease to exist.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aziaziazi 3y ago> Minnesota recently passed its own right to repair law, and while also watered down to exclude cars, medical equipment, and game consoles, it did at least manage to include e-bikes. This part makes me wonder how the industry will deal with Minnesota and others countries that have a right to repair. Will the manufacturers avoid selling their bikes there ? Will they produce “special reparable bikes” there ? Will they just sell the same sh*t illegally regarding that law ?