9 ms·
Feds probing roughly 5k pilots suspected of withholding major health issues
- mattw2121 3y ago"The pilots who have had their records examined are military veterans who informed the Federal Aviation Administration that they were suitable to fly, but didn't disclose that they were also receiving veterans benefits for various disabilities that could prevent them from effectively sitting in a pilot's seat." This is just my anecdotal observations, but I've seen that military veterans are extremely adept at gaming the system to their benefit. They are able to maximize disability benefits as well as GI Bill benefits. I've known and worked with multiple veterans and each one of them gamed these systems to maximum benefit. It also appeared that they coached each other on how to obtain maximum benefit. With that said, I wouldn't be surprised if the health issues in this article were largely exaggerated specifically for the purpose of maximizing benefits.
- nickpeterson 3y agoI’m not a vet, but I wonder if it comes from working in an environment that is so massive, at times wasteful, and your contributions feel insignificant. I think a lot of people could convince themselves that if they don’t take advantage of something, someone else will.
- Geisterde 3y agoThe moment you realize debt is devalued over time and begin taking on debt to acquire hard assets, like anybody who is smart with their money, you are gaming the system. Its not to say people aren't legitimately creating value or building good businesses, but those businesses necessarily must pay the minimum required taxes to be competitive in the market against someone else who will. Politicians invest in stocks that their forthcoming policies will predictably pump. The whole of it all is gaming the system in one way or another. I'm a vet and I need to get back to spamming the VA to increase my disability benefits even though I feel the best I ever have now.
- dh2022 3y agoDebt is devalued in time when interest rates raise. The last couple of years aside, debt value has been increasing since interest rates peaked in late 1970s.
- Geisterde 3y agoDebt is devalued because the money is getting cheaper, I know in 20 years my debt will be easier to manage even though the payments in the nominal denomination of currency has not changed. Inflation is programmatic in a monetary system where currency can only be created through debt, if there werent inflation then every existing dollar would eventually disappear to pay interest to the fed, and there would still be outstanding debt. The practical implications of this are that even if there is a touch of inflation then it can cause a contagion even that shuts down the banks.
- goodbyesf 3y ago> I’m not a vet, but I wonder if it comes from working in an environment that is so massive, at times wasteful, and your contributions feel insignificant Simple formula ( greed + opportunity ). Everyone from politicians to doctors to lowly grunts game the system if they can. Just because you are elected, are educated or wear a uniform doesn't change your innate human nature. You just hide it better. If you can get disability and work too, why wouldn't you. It's like eating your cake and having it too. > I think a lot of people could convince themselves that if they don’t take advantage of something, someone else will. Not themselves. Others. They will try to convince you with that rationalization.
- justrealist 3y agoThe negative PR from wrongfully denying a vet benefits is so bad, and the system is completely un-incentivized to be cost-effective, that there are basically 0 real eligibility tests. Any politician (or bureaucrat) who says "you know, maybe we should be denying disability to 20% of these veterans" is going to be strung up and quartered. So, nobody tries.
- 23B1 3y agoI'd wager that a big part of the PR hazard is that American taxpayers supported the war(s) – and therefore there is a sense of obligation amongst them that vets should get whatever support they think they need. Not saying grift is excusable, but there's a lot of checks and balances on this system – not the least of which if a veteran is caught lying, he loses his benefits and may even have to pay them back.
- justrealist 3y ago> not the least of which if a veteran is caught lying, he loses his benefits and may even have to pay them back If you claim PTSD, trauma, or back/knee/joint pain without fabricating the material circumstances of your injury (lying about where you were stationed or what you were doing), there is a 0% chance you will be accused, much less convicted, of lying. Look for a single vet disability fraud case (and there aren't many, period) where the conviction was for anything other than outright fabrication of service record.
- bitwalker 3y agoThis is said so confidently, but clearly with little to no experience with the military or the VA to back it up. No vet is receiving benefits without something to back up their disability rating, even if that rating is higher than it seemingly "should" be. Some disabilities are easier to establish than others, because the issue causing the disability is so prevalent in the service that the military has little basis to deny them. Hearing loss is a common one. That said, I'm a vet, with significant hearing loss due to my time in (I was an F-16 maintainer on the flightline, an extremely intense noise environment). I'm not eligible for _any_ disability rating at all, because I did not report issues while I was still in the service; but hearing loss issues often take time to become apparent, and it's not like we were being tested for it. It was not uncommon for someone to forget their earplugs (the second layer of hearing protection we had, under our headset), and be essentially forced to go out on the flightline anyway to handle some task around running engines. These events would be downplayed, but just one instance of that can cause irreversible hearing loss. But that's just a specific issue relevant to my time in the service. The bottom line is that unless you report every little thing that _might_ cause an issue later, you're going to be up shit creek when you get out and find out that something you were exposed to during your service is causing an expensive medical issue that you have to deal with. There are all kinds of fucked up things people had to do while they were in, that they struggle to get compensation for now that the consequences are catching up, because the issues aren't straightforwardly attributable to some event during your service, like with combat injuries. Burn pits are the most notorious one - you have advocates like Jon Stewart fighting in Congress to pass laws to support vets who were forced to work those pits and are now battling all kinds of complications. If anyone should be an obvious beneficiary of the disability system, beyond those with combat injuries, it should be those folks - but they are largely left hanging in the wind. In the case of burn pits especially, the military _knew_ there were consequences to having soldiers work them, but chalked it up as the cost of war. Frankly, from what I've observed, once vets are out of the service, our country largely gives them the middle finger when they struggle with mental or physical health issues. I say "them" here, because I'm not a combat veteran, and I'm lucky that I had it pretty easy during my tenure (2009-2015), but for many, that is very much not the case. Yeah, nobody in Congress is going to stand up in front of everyone and say "let's make disability benefits harder to obtain" - but I have no doubt they'd have few, if any, qualms about doing it behind closed doors.
- 23B1 3y agoAm a military veteran. While I know there's plenty of grift on this front, I'd like to point out that you have to become extremely adept at gaming the system even if you have a legitimate injury/disability. The games the VA plays to deny benefits are just as cynical and brazen as many other things the government writ large has done to conceal dangers to veterans – dangers that can have far, far-reaching health consequences. I welcome you to look up the development and deployment of Agent Orange for an example that is still killing people today. Edit: https://www.publichealth.va.gov/exposures/publications/agent-orange/agent-orange-summer-2015/diabetes.asp https://www.publichealth.va.gov/exposures/publications/agent...
- mattw2121 3y agoI am well aware of Agent Orange and am also aware that anyone that was anywhere close to Agent Orange figures out a way to correlate every single health issue they experience to Agent Orange. I'm not saying that Agent Orange wasn't a problem and, of course, it caused health issues for many people. What I am saying is that a 80 year old man, that is 100 pounds overweight, who develops diabetes didn't necessarily get diabetes from Agent Orange exposure.
- 23B1 3y agoYes, that is exactly the same logic the VA uses to deny claims to people who did in fact get diabetes from Agent Orange exposure. Looks like you have a bright future in claims adjustment! ;-) Edit: There's plenty of evidence connecting Agent Orange exposure to a whole host of illnesses that only manifest later in life – including Diabetes. It's even on the VA's own site: https://www.publichealth.va.gov/exposures/publications/agent-orange/agent-orange-summer-2015/diabetes.asp https://www.publichealth.va.gov/exposures/publications/agent...
- brianwawok 3y agoHow do you conclusively attribute diabetes to agent orange 40 years after the fact? What test do you run, and what scientific methodology do you employ? We are real bad at connecting dots that take more than a few years to happen. So many other things happen to us every day. Even if some bad action doubles your odds of a certain outcome.. that means it is still 50/50 if the original thing "caused" your bad outcome.
- tiahura 3y agoAs someone who practices law in a disability-adjacent field, I can assure you that gaming ssdi isn’t restricted to former military.
- kotaKat 3y agoIt's the FAA's normal mental health brigade horseshit, except this time it's the FAA snooping around in VA records just because they can. It looks like the veterans being targeted have various concerns like PTSD, which the FAA finds that as soon as you even think you're depressed, they want to revoke your pilots license because they think you'll immediately pull Some Shit in the air. The average person has no clue how bad mental health is in the aviation sector and how hard it has to be hidden so they can actually keep doing what they love -- to fly. See also: https://www.cbsnews.com/colorado/news/pilots-crying-out-help-pilots-criticize-faa-outdated-prohibitive-mental-health-policies/ https://www.cbsnews.com/colorado/news/pilots-crying-out-help... > the FAA has subjected him to costly frequent drug tests, and doctor's visits with FAA-approved experts who don't accept insurance > the FAA wouldn't accept other doctor's notes saying that he was perfectly fine to fly a plane The FAA throws up some massive gates as soon as you get flagged like this and forces you to go to a battery of doctors and psychs that only they can apparently decide your fate.
- briffle 3y agoRight, its not like hundreds of people's lives are in these pilot's hands. I can't imagine what a depressed pilot might do.. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Germanwings_Flight_9525 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Germanwings_Flight_9525
- tycho-newman 3y agoPerfectly competent pilots have killed more people than depressed ones since the beginning of flight. Empirically, non-depressed pilots are more of a risk to the public. But they don't get this kind of stigma.
- kkielhofner 3y agoIt’s also one of the more glaring issues still present in regard to mental health stigmatization - that people with mental health issues are a danger to others. The overwhelming majority of people experiencing mental health issues are only a danger to themselves (worst case). The differences in suicide rates compared to murder-suicide rates back this up but per usual extremely rare cases or murder-suicide grab headlines while the 125 suicides per day on average in the US are completely unknown to anyone other than the people personally impacted by them. Not only are murder-suicides sensational, the “murder” component bypasses the otherwise standard media practice of not reporting on suicides because of the data on upticks in additional suicides due to reporting.
- dghughes 3y ago> I've seen that military veterans are extremely adept at gaming the system to their benefit. They are able to maximize disability benefits as well as GI Bill benefits. I'm not in the USA but really to me that's just seems like they are getting what they should. Any citizen of any country should get medical care free of charge. Military veterans whether their issue is from combat or not I think should get all the care they can. If the system is working against you and you can find ways to fight back and help others that is OK with me.
- mattw2121 3y agoThese benefits (and the gaming of them) are not about receiving medical care. These veterans already get free medical care from the VA. It's about monetary payments. They game the VA disability system to get paid.
- docandrew 3y agoI’m not sure how “gaming” it is possible when the VA either performs (or contracts out) medical exams for a veteran’s specific claim and determines whether the veteran is eligible or not. It’s not like they just take a veteran’s word for it.
- sedivy94 3y agoI work on a military base and can attest to this. Many prior enlisted (veterans) feel that they get shafted (screwed or taken advantage of) by the contract between themselves and USG during their service. Their pay is low and transitioning back to a civilian lifestyle is incredibly difficult, despite their compulsory, Congress-mandated transition assistance training. Maximizing their disability claims is one way of getting what they deserve. The VA has a disability rating system that goes from 0% to 100%. Obtaining a 100% disability rating guarantees a certain amount of monthly income for life. The step increase in pay from 80% disability to 100% disability is large. There’s also a logarithmic function that makes it increasingly difficult to raise your disability rating after each disability claim. Hypothetically, losing your left leg might qualify for 50% disability, losing a second leg might qualify for 75%, and then losing an arm might qualify for 87.5%. Pretty horrendous. That being said, many service members aim to hack the system by making disability claims for everything under the sun. Service members often collect disabilities such as arthritis, lumbar disc degradation, knee injuries, sleep apnea, and depression. Like Pokémon - gotta catch ‘em all.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y ago> I've known and worked with multiple veterans and each one of them gamed these systems to maximum benefit. So exactly like private employees & companies? I'm not sure we should be expecting humans not to game systems to their own benefit. Isn't that basic human nature?
- mattw2121 3y agoYes, I think we should expect people to act with integrity. When they don't we should call them out. I'm all for social programs to help people in need, but I end up opposing most of the proposed social programs. Why is this? Because people game them. If people acted with integrity, and only people that truly needed assistance utilized social programs, then I think you'd find far less people oppose them.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoWhy is it not integrity to use the system to maximize the benefit to myself? Insurance carriers and the medical-industrial complex are notoriously byzantine, and so if anyone can navigate those waters and improve their outcomes, and extract the maximum value of care for themselves, then I think that is exactly what one should be expected to do within the bounds of the system they are given. There is nothing dishonest or "gaming" about it.
- mattw2121 3y agoWhen you lie about medical conditions, that is not acting with integrity. If you believe that lying to achieve maximum personal outcomes is, in fact, acting with integrity, then our definition of integrity is vastly different.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoIt was termed "gaming" and not "lying". Where are you seeing lies?
- 3y ago
- lp0_on_fire 3y ago> This is just my anecdotal observations, but I've seen that military veterans are extremely adept at gaming the system to their benefit. They are able to maximize disability benefits as well as GI Bill benefits. I've known and worked with multiple veterans and each one of them gamed these systems to maximum benefit. "gamed" is a very loaded term that suggests something untoward is happening as opposed to people just trying to get the benefits they're entitled to as Veterans. Do you have any evidence that the people you've observed are doing something shady or do you just think they're getting more than they deserve? > It also appeared that they coached each other on how to obtain maximum benefit. Is it "gaming" the system when I offer my friend advice on how to navigate the byzantine health insurance system in the US?
- mattw2121 3y agoYes, I have anecdotal evidence that people are gaming the system to get more than they deserve. I have directly observed multiple Vietnam Vets gaming the Agent Orange system to get 90-100% disability. The would visit multiple doctors to get the wording they needed to supply evidence that some health issue was related to Agent Orange. Their goal was to get a doctor to write down that a particular health issue "might" be related to Agent Orange. Once they achieved that, they would add that health issue on the list of other health issues. Each one would get them 5-20% disability.
- lp0_on_fire 3y agoTo be be clear, you are not a physician who has examined these Vietnam Vets and have determined that their issues are 100% unrelated to Agent Orange?
- mattw2121 3y ago(responding to to sibling comment) No, I'm not a doctor that has examined them. I have been told by these people that they want to maximize their disability payments and they can do that by claiming things are caused by agent orange. I've been told by them that they will shop around the diagnosis until they get something in writing they can use. I have been told by these people that they don't care if it is related to agent orange or not, as long as they can get a doctor to write it down.
- hedora 3y agoWhat happened to medical record confidentiality? Presumably this is a slow normalization of deviance play, and using people’s medical records against them will be commonplace soon. Starting with vets is particularly cynical, but sadly unsurprising. Anyway, since these records can be used to screw vets over, can vets also access the statistics they’d need to prove safety violations and other forms of negligence in the chain of command?
- tycho-newman 3y agoIt is routine for government agencies to audit medical claims records for waste, fraud,and abuse. These uses are well-defined in existing American medical privacy laws.
- millzlane 3y agoI wouldn't call it harassment. It's clear it's just easier to catch the vets because they also lied to the VA. I admit they VA has it short comings. But there more vets in need then there are not,embellishing your condition to get more benefits is dishonorable. What's not surprising is pilots who lie about their health to keep making money. Especially in this economy.
- Geisterde 3y agoDishonorable? Lying us into wars is dishonorable. Stop putting government bureaucrats in charge of so much money, its obvious they can't spend it appropriately, I could get a hell of a lot more bang for my buck out of spending my own money.
- snapcaster 3y agoI'm very personally against the war state and general US imperialism but I don't think the "bang for your buck" argument is necessarily true. I couldn't personally secure alliances with or occupations of oil rich nations that allow for me to have access to extremely cheap energy. I think I benefit from it, but that doesn't make it just
- Geisterde 3y agoWhy can't a business like exxon secure contracts for your oil? You benefit from the government doing it on a first order where the worlds oil is priced in your native currency, secondary effects may include the world hating you, the destruction of domestic production, your cultural traditions fading into obscurity, corruption, the joining of political and corporate interests. Ask your doctor before taking.
- pc86 3y agoWhat do you mean by "secure contracts" in this context?
- 3y ago
- bettercallsalad 3y agoI expect a major pilot shortage in recent years. Not too long ago many of them were on strike [1] [2], due to apparently bad pay and high burnout. It really is a thankless profession. [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2023/06/29/southwest-pilots-union-lays-groundwork-for-potential-strike.html https://www.cnbc.com/2023/06/29/southwest-pilots-union-lays-... [2] https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/united-airlines-pilots-union-votes-authorize-strike-vote-2023-06-03/ https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/united-ai...
- api 3y agoIt's a high skill profession in an industry that largely competes on cost. One will find similarly thankless jobs in manufacturing, agriculture, and any other industry where the push is to squeeze margins as much as possible. Everything about flying has become substantially worse except safety. The only way the industry is able to maintain its safety record is by being heavily regulated and never changing anything.
- no_wizard 3y agoThe difference of course, is that pilots can squeeze airlines almost infinitely if they want to, because without pilots, the whole operation stops. They're the difference between flights happening and not happening, and they aren't easy to replace, and certainly not easy to replace quickly Honestly, I'm surprised they haven't flexed this more.
- Analemma_ 3y agoThey probably have less power than you think. If they actually shut down all aviation and didn’t have a very convincing PR strategy, they’d find an infuriated public (you can’t go to your daughter’s wedding, your grandpa’s funeral, etc.), which the airlines (and the government, which has a serious interest in seeing air commerce working smoothly) would absolutely use to their advantage. Don’t forget that when ATCs actually followed your logic, Reagan responded by firing them all, and even though in more recent years this has been cast as the horrible beginning-of-the-end for American unions, at the time he had broad public support, because people were incensed that one profession could shut down air travel. All this is to say that I think pilots’ unions do have a good sense of how hard to push and not push. They don’t have infinite leverage.
- tiahura 3y agoThis seems to be based on a misunderstanding. SSDI really doesn’t have anything to do with actual disability.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- CobaltFire 3y agoI had a lifelong dream of becoming a pilot, but after my discharge physical and VA rating I realized I’d likely never be able to due to the diagnosed issues. This whole saga frustrates me (it’s been going on for a while) because if you actually have the problems you’ve gotten the VA to acknowledge, and the FAA says they are an issue… Well you are lying and gaming the system on one side or another. I’m not a fan of that at all, and as someone who got rated without gaming the system I get to deal with the fallout of being painted with the same brush. So for those who have that view of vets, please do remember that there are some with less visible disabilities that are honest and doing their best to adapt and not game the system.
- linuxftw 3y agoI sustained a back injury while on active duty. I have a rating for my back. 90% of the time, I'm able to function normally. Every once in a while, I re aggravate the injury and I'm laid up for a week or 2. The disability rating ensures I'm able to get treatment from the VA for my service connected condition. I still pay for my own health insurance and see private doctors as the care the VA provides is garbage, but I have it as a back stop if I ever fall on hard times. Having a disability rating doesn't strictly mean you're disabled, that would be a 100% disability rating.
- CobaltFire 3y agoMy back injury is similar; most days I’m ok but there are some (today being one) where it makes life much harder than it needs to be. The other issues I’ve sustained (I talk about them in other comments elsewhere on here) also present challenges.
- motohagiography 3y agoBenefits fraud is a serious issue, but using personal health information to fish for and detect it is a disincentive to people seeking medical help. The whole point of privacy legislation was to protect PHI from being abused like this so that people would actually trust the systems enough to use them.
- curiousObject 3y agoIs Germanwings Flight 9525[0] the worst case of how this can go terribly badly if these pilots are not treated with kindness and assured of a dignified retirement? [0] https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Germanwings_Flight_9525 https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Germanwings_Flight_9525
- rhplus 3y agoBy 2017, Lufthansa had paid €75,000 to the family of every victim, as well as €10,000 in pain and suffering compensation to every close relative of a victim. Wow. These compensation amounts seem… incredibly low. Is this some upper limit under German law? I’d have assumed compensation would be in the order of €1m. [*] https://www.keystonelaw.com/keynotes/how-is-compensation-calculated-after-an-aviation-accident https://www.keystonelaw.com/keynotes/how-is-compensation-cal...
- pc86 3y agoThere are probably a handful of incidences like this, and statistically several where this was the truth but we have no way of ever knowing (e.g. MH370). I'm not sure how it could get any worse than this? At the end of the day you will never have a system that will protect you against a homicidal pilot. The closest you can get is requiring two pilots in the cockpit at all times, but if the bigger and stronger of the two wants to kill everyone anyway, there's little stopping them from just trying to kill the other pilot first while the door is locked.
- sklargh 3y agoAlways struck by contrast - aviation regulators who’ve embraced and benefited immensely from no-fault safety reporting can’t seem to rationalize that the entire medical qualification system for pilots is killing people (literally in the case of German Wings). System as designed encourages concealment by ending careers and destroying livelihoods. One obviously can’t fly commercial airliners impaired or with a material medical condition, but one can’t manage that risk without data. We need a no-fault early retirement fund or some similar mechanism needs to be out there to help get psychologically distressed pilots out of the cockpit and into treatment…with a possible path back too. Just a terrible and inhumane situation all around.
- nutate 3y agoThe mental health limitations around flight are how you get malaysian air flight 370. Don't say anything, treat anything, work through anything involving mental health because you'll lose your license immediately. Therefore the folks with milder mental illnesses will never solo pilot a plane, and folks with serious psychopathic mental illness, especially if it appears after they begin working, will kill everyone on board.
- bjornsing 3y agoIs there any confirmed connection between MA370 and mental health, or are you speculating?
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoThe German Crash. They instituted a preventative measure in 2015, already gone by 2017. Low Cost is always the most important thing. Lives are cheap. Unless there are like 2-3 crashes in a year, directly attributable to mental health, then the decision will be to let pilots suffer, it is cheaper. From Wiki: Aviation authorities swiftly implemented new recommendations from the European Union Aviation Safety Agency that required two authorized personnel in the cockpit at all times but, by 2017, Germanwings and other German airlines had dropped the rule.
- Simulacra 3y agoThis sadly reminds me of Germanwings Flight 9525. Detecting mental illness can be very, very difficult. Pilots will not seek therapy or medical care for mental health issues if they think they could lose their job because of it. Authorities should know when there is a pilot with serious mental concerns. Short of breaking a wall of privacy I don't see how we can bridge this divide. https://admiralcloudberg.medium.com/the-madness-in-our-methods-the-crash-of-germanwings-flight-9525-and-our-broken-aeromedical-system-5b95abd4fe6d https://admiralcloudberg.medium.com/the-madness-in-our-metho...
- MilStdJunkie 3y agoYou think this is bad? You should see the lengths people with security clearances will go to in order to hide the fact they need mental healthcare. By the time they finally get it, they're already beaming mental radio commands from Venus.
- archo 3y agohttps://archive.is/OO0MG https://archive.is/OO0MG
- thomastjeffery 3y agoWhen it comes to the subject of mental health, the FAA is absolutely full of shit, and everyone involved knows it. The same goes for the VA, though that situation seems to be improving gradually, at least on a case-by-case basis. This story is yet another instance of an unelected federal agency using bullshit from another unelected federal agency to drum up FUD; all in order to make themselves appear to be useful. We can all see the perverse incentives that are driving this situation. We can all see the outcome of this system. It's well past time for a change.
- more_corn 3y agoNext up, catastrophic lack of pilots leads to cancellation of many flights. Not making a value judgment, just a prediction.