5 ms·
The last thing we need right now is people living longer.
by SoftTalker 3y ago
The last thing we need right now is people living longer.
- tjlingham 3y agoThat's very easy to say until it's your partner, mother/father, or child on the other side of that assertion. If you're curious and have time, I'd suggest the following excellent exploration of the idea of extinguishing natural death by CGP Grey. He uses an interesting analogy to help challenge the ingrained belief that natural death is just https://youtu.be/cZYNADOHhVY?si=oCqVGD5RX9Q0Cnrk https://youtu.be/cZYNADOHhVY?si=oCqVGD5RX9Q0Cnrk
- SoftTalker 3y agoWe only need to look at nature to see that everything dies. It is natural, and necessary. I am not in any way saying that people should be euthanized or disease not treated or that people not live out their natural lives. But artificial extension of life will only result in those who can afford it staying in power forever.
- tchaffee 3y agoWe only need to look to nature to find the immortal jellyfish. Much of medical science is "artificial" extension of life. Natural would be you dying of Smallpox at a young age. Instead you've artificially extended your life with a vaccine. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turritopsis_dohrnii https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turritopsis_dohrnii
- jdhendrickson 3y agohttps://effectiviology.com/appeal-to-nature-fallacy/#:~:text=The%20appeal%20to%20nature%20is,because%20it's%20perceived%20as%20unnatural https://effectiviology.com/appeal-to-nature-fallacy/#:~:text....
- dekhn 3y agoThat's a logical fallacy. The argument you are responding to is not logical, but rhetorical (argument by analogy, based on the premise that analogous systems behave in similar ways). Logical fallacies don't apply to rhetorical arguments in a logical way. We can all do better than pedantically pointing out logical fallacies, as no argument outside of mathematics is completely logical.
- xereeto 3y agoTo hell with nature! I have never understood this argument even a little bit.
- chrisan 3y ago> That's very easy to say until it's your partner, mother/father, or child on the other side of that assertion. There is a difference between living longer/forever and giving a child with terminal cancer a normal full life
- Teever 3y agoWhat is that difference?
- lelandbatey 3y agoLiving forever and living longer shouldn't be grouped together; living forever means unbounded existence and unbounded consumption over time. That's a fundamental paradigm shift for our entire system of being human. Saving extending the lives of more children is unfortunately, a statistics change for our current world. Unlimited life means all models of economics, morality generally, class, etc will be affected.
- Teever 3y agoBut no one is truely going to live forever. They'll die from disease or accident or murder. Everyone dies man.
- mjan22640 3y agoOur cells live forever, despite the support "clumps" they create in the process eventually die off.
- ben_w 3y ago> Unlimited life means all models of economics, morality generally, class, etc will be affected. That's also going to happen with automation — and I don't just mean AI, as it has been happening continuously since the power loom led to Karl Marx inventing Communism, or possibly even earlier with the social and technological changes of Adam Smith's era and the end of feudalism.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ftxbro 3y ago> That's very easy to say until it's your partner, mother/father, or child on the other side of that assertion. The idea isn't that poor people will get life extension, it's that families of billionaires will get it. And no it won't "trickle down" life expectancy is actually decreasing in USA despite tech gains. EDIT: downvote me if you want, you know it's true
- ajmurmann 3y agoDidn't most of the additional deaths come from COVID, drug overdoses and suicides? While those are terrible and need to be addressed, those don't seem to be related to availability of medical treatment.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoDeaths of despair are linked to economic system configuration, pushed by the wealthy to remain static. Similar story with US healthcare. https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2023/03/25/1164819944/live-free-and-die-the-sad-state-of-u-s-life-expectancy https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2023/03/25/1164819... https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/whats-behind-shocking-u-s-life-expectancy-decline-and-what-to-do-about-it/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/whats-beh...
- ajmurmann 3y ago>Deaths of despair are linked to economic system configuration,[..] Sure there is a correlation between deaths of despair and poverty. However, the argument here was that healthcare advances won't tickle down with the evidence being declining life expectancy. That's a totally different claim. As of 2021 over 90% of Americans had health insurance coverage and AFAIK the vast majority of proven, legitimate treatments are available to those insured people. (sauce: https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2022/demo/p60-278.html https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2022/demo/p60-27...). >pushed by the wealthy to remain static What class war, conspiracy nonsense is this? Do you think "the rich" get together once a year, smoke cigars and discuss what policies to convince everyone of in order to keep the poors down because they are idiots who believe the world is a zero-sum-game?
- rubinelli 3y agoCGP Grey doesn't explore what happens after death is defeated. I can't imagine how it can lead to anything but a stagnated society, with prejudices and inequalities enshrined forever.
- seer 3y agoWouldn’t it be the other way around? Now, since the effects of our prejudice, inequality etc, are usually borne way after we die, we don’t get to see the effects of our decisions. If we get to live a lot longer, we’ll be wiser in making better, more balanced decisions. As for stagnation, sure earth itself is quite overpopulated, but there is nothing technologically stopping humanity from colonizing the solar system. If humanity gets it shit together and becomes slightly more organized, those experiments in society will just happen in geographically different places. The “red mars, blue mars, green mars” trilogy explores this quite well, even if the science is a bit dated, the politics aspects of the books are quite interesting, tackling future colonization and longevity’s political pressures and opportunities.
- rubinelli 3y agoThat's a very rosy view of humans. The average person gets older, not wiser; they see the consequences of their actions and find someone else to blame. Real social and cultural change comes from new generations.
- rco8786 3y agoThis is not backed by evidence or statistics. The earth is not overpopulated nor in danger of being so.
- notjoemama 3y agoI’ve read a bit on the topic too and I think I agree? One of the other obvious occurrences we’re living through is some form of population collapse. Although it’s termed “collapse” I think it’s better conveyed as “global population shrink”. As far as sustainability, I think we can all wait for generational turn over and see what shakes out. But that brings with it other problems like not having enough younger people to care for the elderly or meaningfully contribute to a tax revenue. Anyway, glad you pointed that out. In a cacophony of doom from main stream media (news, social, political, celebrities) maybe this isn’t one of the very big problems that needs global attention right now.
- throwuwu 3y agoNot just tax and elder care. If you have fewer young people than old then when those young people take the place of their older colleagues in their various professions you wind up losing a lot of tacit knowledge. If there are 1.5 olds for every young then that young one needs to learn 150% of the skills and knowledge that they did before. In such cases the extra information often gets lost. This is how population collapse leads to civilizational collapse.
- asah 3y agoClimate impact is roughly O(N) for the number of humans. Sure, some have more impact than others but reduce humans and reduce impact.
- rco8786 3y agoThis is kind of defeats the point of environmentalism. The point is for humans to live on a sustainable planet, not for us to accept artificial death.
- ben_w 3y ago
- arcticbull 3y agoThe more a society develops the lower its birth rate. Most of the developed world is well below replacement rate, and the rest of the world will be there soon too.
- seer 3y agoTo be fair I personally believe this is not a case of “rich/educated people have fewer children”, more the case that the way society is structured in those rich/educated places, having children is a bad deal. It used to be if you had some kids, it was a huuge investment, but you got a lot out of the deal after about 13 years. But right now, children are still a huge investment, but the parents hardly get any economic incentive for it, the country has “captured” that for its own end. If governments took this into account and “repaid” this back to the parents, I’m sure people will have way more children. If societies were structured in such a way that children made economic sense to their parents, I’m sure shrinking population would not be a thing. Now if something like this has moral problems in and off itself is a different question. I just want to point out that “developed countries are have fewer children” shouldn’t be taken as an absolute truth. It just developed countries as currently structured do not incentivize parents enough. Just look at Israel for example.
- arcticbull 3y agoIt is indeed literally a case of rich/educated people have fewer children. It’s called the demographic-economic paradox. [1] There’s been a lot of research on this because the effect is so pronounced. > In decreasing order of strength, fertility (TFR) correlates negatively with education, [contraceptive prevalence], and GDP per capita, and positively with religiosity. [2] If you’re educated, rich, non-religious and can bone with impunity you have somewhere between 1 and 2 kids on average, well below the replacement rate of 2.1 It is absolutely a fantastic deal to have kids in Finland where you get months and months of mat and pat leave, etc, and their birth rate is 1.37 Israel is only high because they’re a religious ethnostate and religiosity as the studies show is positively correlated with fertility. Respectfully I do think the data shows we should take this for granted. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_and_fertility https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_and_fertility [2] https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12889-020-8331-7 https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s...
- mensetmanusman 3y agoI thought we wanted billionaires to be immortal!
- Tommstein 3y agoSomehow, the people who always bitch about there being too many people never volunteer themselves to help reduce the problem.