5 ms·
The problem with carbon offsets is worse than that. First, there is no real way to tell if someone was going to do something anyway. You have an existing opera
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
The problem with carbon offsets is worse than that.
First, there is no real way to tell if someone was going to do something anyway. You have an existing operation which is already cost effective to modernize because the fuel savings exceed the cost, so you were going to do it anyway, but now you get to sell credits even though the modernization would have happened regardless. So you have a significant amount of preexisting supply without motivating any real emissions reduction.
Second, not everyone is required to buy them, so the demand side is artificially low.
The result is that credits are available for less than $2/ton, or to put it another way, less than $0.02 per gallon of gasoline. This is obviously not going to provide any meaningful incentive to reduce emissions.
- quixoticelixer- 3y ago> First, there is no real way to tell if someone was going to do something anyway. There sort of is though, and both carbon off-setters and this study claim that they can Also there is plenty of demand in this market, even dodgy credits are worth much more than $2
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> There sort of is though, and both carbon off-setters and this study claim that they can What they're talking about is determining if you've paid someone to not burn down a forest and then they do it even after taking the money. Which you could conceivably verify. The problem is when someone already intends not to burn down a forest, or do whichever other thing counts for credits. Then they can sell credits in exchange for proceeding with their existing intentions. Everyone already intending to do any of those things can profit from selling the credits, so they do and the market contains tons of credits that are not actually making any difference. > Also there is plenty of demand in this market, even dodgy credits are worth much more than $2 https://carboncredits.com/carbon-prices-today/ https://carboncredits.com/carbon-prices-today/ Offset are worth less than $2. "Credits" in the EU are worth significantly more, because they use "cap and trade", which results in significant carbon pricing but is manifestly unjust because it directly rewards companies for having been the largest polluters.
- tito 3y agoI work in the industry [0]. The decarbonization game is extremely tricky. This whole notion of "were they going to do it anyway", how the heck do you build that in. And how the heck does demand happen, who wants to pay for invisible, mostly useless gas? The key question at the root of this is this: do we need to win the decarbonization game? Or can we just set down the game and walk away? To me it looks like we need to win the decarbonization game to maintain a stable climate. So then all these attempts, failures, and mind bending problems all become challenges to overcome. Not "if", but "how". The prize is a stable climate, a thriving civilization, and the specific players that beat the game probably get trillions of dollars of prize money. [0] https://airminers.org https://airminers.org
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Not "if", but "how". Sure, but "how" could be to abandon the concept of credits whatsoever and institute a carbon tax.
- tito 3y agoFirst off, yes, agree, fixed problem, open on solution, "how" could be anything, including doing a funny dance that inspires every person on the planet to just stop emitting so much. Hmm, say more about this. I said this to another commenter, I'm pretty sure all a carbon tax does is solve for the "demand" side of the equation. Fundamentally you would still need an accounting system for carbon, thus carbon credits of different sorts. Or am I missing something?
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoWith a carbon tax there is nothing to exchange with other people. If you buy gasoline or coal, you pay a tax and the money is evenly distributed to everyone. People who have existing coal-fired power plants don't get free credits to allow them to sustain their operations, they just pay the tax and then become uncompetitive with non-carbon generation methods. So they go out of business as fast as alternative generation methods can be constructed. In the meantime ordinary people have the refund to compensate for the temporarily higher price of electricity.