5 ms·
Curious about someone in the industry's opinion, but the problem sounds like carbon offsets should actually be treated as carbon offset futures. I.e. the value
by ethbr1 3y ago
Curious about someone in the industry's opinion, but the problem sounds like carbon offsets should actually be treated as carbon offset futures.
I.e. the value is determined at the time of delivered carbon offsets, and the instrument's price floats on the market before that time, including relative to how likely / valuable the delivery is
If company A buys a carbon offset from entity X, and it becomes increasingly apparent that entity X isn't going to be able to deliver the face value in terms of carbon, the instrument bought by company A should decrease in value.
Consequently, next time around, company A would not purchase from entity X.
Which is exactly what you'd want to happen!
Corollary: Verification by third party should be required, with less measurable schemes less valued.
Multiple satellites confirming forests intact? Proof. Direct air capture or weathering? Proof.
Some nebulous walk through how this might have influenced this other thing? Eh...
- wmf 3y agoThat doesn't really match the way people are using offsets. If you buy offsets for a flight and ten years later you learn that that they were ineffective... what? The least effective offsets having the lowest price isn't a good incentive either.
- ethbr1 3y agoI don't believe the majority of VCM offsets are being purchased by end users. Are they? I thought they're typically purchased by corporate entities to support "net zero carbon by X year" pledges. Apparently this stuff has matured a lot in the last 10 years, and I haven't been keeping pace with it. There's already a concept of "vintage" (i.e. year carbon reduction realized in), but I still don't think they're being traded in a floating price futures model. It sounds like the international community is leaning on certification-first, then sale of only certified offsets. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_offsets_and_credits#Other_international_programs https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_offsets_and_credits#O... ... which, doesn't feel like it fully harnesses the power of market investment in new technologies. If a corporate buyer finds a new technology that has promise, they should be able to plow money into it! (At a cheaper per-offset-CO2-ton price than alternatives) If that new tech delivers, the company just saved money. (For the same amount of CO2 offset purchase) If the new tech fails to deliver, the offset buying company should be forced to realize financial losses. Ergo, companies will be incentivized to invest in the most effective tools for future CO2 offsetting.
- asu_thomas 3y ago> Apparently this stuff has matured a lot in the last 10 years Matured is not the word I would choose.
- ethbr1 3y agoLast time I checked on the international side of this, it was mostly an imaginary future. Now, it looks like there's non-trivial implementation work being done: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_offsets_and_credits#Programs_and_markets https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_offsets_and_credits#P...
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThe problem with carbon offsets is worse than that. First, there is no real way to tell if someone was going to do something anyway. You have an existing operation which is already cost effective to modernize because the fuel savings exceed the cost, so you were going to do it anyway, but now you get to sell credits even though the modernization would have happened regardless. So you have a significant amount of preexisting supply without motivating any real emissions reduction. Second, not everyone is required to buy them, so the demand side is artificially low. The result is that credits are available for less than $2/ton, or to put it another way, less than $0.02 per gallon of gasoline. This is obviously not going to provide any meaningful incentive to reduce emissions.
- quixoticelixer- 3y ago> First, there is no real way to tell if someone was going to do something anyway. There sort of is though, and both carbon off-setters and this study claim that they can Also there is plenty of demand in this market, even dodgy credits are worth much more than $2
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> There sort of is though, and both carbon off-setters and this study claim that they can What they're talking about is determining if you've paid someone to not burn down a forest and then they do it even after taking the money. Which you could conceivably verify. The problem is when someone already intends not to burn down a forest, or do whichever other thing counts for credits. Then they can sell credits in exchange for proceeding with their existing intentions. Everyone already intending to do any of those things can profit from selling the credits, so they do and the market contains tons of credits that are not actually making any difference. > Also there is plenty of demand in this market, even dodgy credits are worth much more than $2 https://carboncredits.com/carbon-prices-today/ https://carboncredits.com/carbon-prices-today/ Offset are worth less than $2. "Credits" in the EU are worth significantly more, because they use "cap and trade", which results in significant carbon pricing but is manifestly unjust because it directly rewards companies for having been the largest polluters.
- 3y ago