3 ms·
> Yes it’s true, by default in Plasma 6, you’ll single-click to select files and folders, and double-click to open them. What was it before? I haven't used KDE
by IshKebab 3y ago
> Yes it’s true, by default in Plasma 6, you’ll single-click to select files and folders, and double-click to open them.
What was it before? I haven't used KDE since the Plasma debacle but I don't remember it getting something this basic wrong...
- shakow 3y ago> getting something this basic wrong... Despite the obvious vitriol of your message, I'd precise for the posterity that when KDE was created, this was not such a surprising thing to do as e.g. old Apple OS did so, and it was a commonly used option on other OSs.
- howinteresting 3y agoI'm just happy KDE is changing old behaviors that are counterintuitive in the modern age. Now as for the macOS cmd-tab behavior...
- msiyer 3y agothere is nothing "basic" about this. something that seems pretty obvious to you may not be natural to someone else. i think the single-click navigation or opening of files was done to mimic how hyperlinks on the internet work. some people are wired that way. on the other hand, some people have a completely different brain configuration: they think that a single-click should select whereas a double-click should open a file. there are people who do not agree with both these options. maybe, they want everything to work via audio commands. how do we decide what the default behavior should be? the answer is: leave it to the user.
- IshKebab 3y ago> there is nothing "basic" about this It's how both major desktop OSes have worked for literally decades. It works very well. Why be different? Mimicking hyperlinks doesn't make sense because you never want to move hyperlinks around or rename them. There's rarely a reason to select a hyperlink.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoSo I don't think my mother has ever grokked the difference between single- and double-click. I watched her double-click web links all day long while sitting at the desktop Windows Vista computer. I couldn't do anything to educate her on when to use single and when to use double, because that distinction is just lost on some people, you know? So I would often send her YouTube links in email, and she always reported back "I couldn't watch this; the sound was horrible! Unlistenable!" And years, yes years, later, she reported to me that she'd figured out what was messed up about her YouTube experience, because she had been consistently double-clicking every link in her email, and opening two browser tabs to the same content, and it didn't bother her unless it was autoplay video, which would offset the sound by several milliseconds and totally mess it up.
- firen777 3y ago> the Plasma debacle I'm not familiar with it. Can you elaborate? > ... but I don't remember it getting something this basic wrong 1. It's only "wrong" because windows has been doing the double click way. In terms of accessibility, I'd argue double click is actually kinda bad, consider how people with joint issue may have trouble double clicking quick enough to register it. (Yes, you can adjust the speed, but this setting wouldn't even be needed if it's single click in the first place.) Imagine how annoying it would be if mobile device and <button/> all require double click/double tap, or even double-enter just to open a file. 2. Most of the Linux distro configured it into double click, anyway. Probably the reason why you don't remember it being a thing. 3. Steam Deck, on the other hand, only need single tap if you use touch screen.
- Agingcoder 3y agoYes, I’ve been using single click for years including on windows because of rsi issues.
- magicalhippo 3y agoAnd I hate single click because I have a tendency to accidentally click, and for me double click is, for now, a trivial extra step. Great thing about KDE (and others) is it's configurable. I don't particularly care which is default though, but being used to Windows it's of course nice for me to have one less step to tweak. However given it's easier for me to change than someone with disabilities, I wouldn't mind single click staying default.
- noisem4ker 3y ago>> the Plasma debacle > I'm not familiar with it. Can you elaborate? Plasma was introduced as the name for KDE's actual DE component (distinct from apps and frameworks) with KDE 4, a major version which was released too early in development and alienated many users due to bugs and missing features compared to KDE 3, hence the "debacle".
- bachmeier 3y ago
- bmacho 3y agoProbably: one click to select a file/folder, and one click on an already selected file/folder to open them? As opposed to windows, which doesn't open a file/folder if you single click on a selected icon.