7 ms·
Why the US is one of only a few countries with no paid time off
- frfl 3y ago> The chambers of commerce of all five city boroughs released a survey that found four out of five small businesses fear they’d have to lay off workers should the bill pass. How are 4/5 (80%) small businesses operating with such low margins in one of the largest and prosperous cities that they would have to lay off people just to give them 10 days pto? Every other country major country has businesses offering more pto (see Europe for eg) and they seem to make it work is less prosperous economies
- photonbeam 3y agoI think its a bit like interest rates, if you raise the floor rate then some investments become unviable
- rgmerk 3y agoYeah, but the vast majority of the jobs we’re talking about are in the non-tradable sector. New York City isn’t exactly the place to locate labour intensive manufacturing industries for goods exported to the rest of the US, or internationally.
- lastitude 3y agoMostly, rent costs and regulatory and licensing fees. Inflation sure isn't helping since this article was written in 2019.
- struant 3y agoThat is simple. They aren't in dire financial straits. They are just lying.
- SantalBlush 3y agoYep. My own understanding of American politics became so much more clear once I realized that many people are lying about their reasons for supporting/opposing certain issues. A lot of people take issue when someone points out lying as a likely explanation, because they think that assumes malice, but here's the thing: it's not about malice, it's about self-interest. Some folks will lie to benefit themselves. As you say, it's very simple.
- genocidicbunny 3y agoPart of the problem is that commercial rents in places like NY are untenable unless you're somehow managing to squeeze every last dollar out of your employees and customers. But with surveys like this, I also have a hard time believing the responses if they're not backed up with hard data. So unless business owners want to open up their books for all to inspect, I take statements like 'fear they'd have to lay off workers' with multiple cups of salt. I still have little sympathy though -- if your business cannot survive without exploiting people, it shouldn't survive, no matter what the cause of your business needing to exploit people.
- rgmerk 3y agoCommercial rents aren’t fixed in stone, either.
- fasthands9 3y agoIn fairness the unemployment rate in Europe is now twice what it is in the US. I think realistically, though, if you asked any business in any country "Would increasing the cost of employees make you more likely to have trouble paying employees" every business would answer yes in a survey.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y ago3.5% to 5.9%. Neither is high. How much of that 2.4% is jobs with liveable wages?
- andsoitis 3y ago> 3.5% to 5.9%. Neither is high. How much of that 2.4% is jobs with liveable wages? While the EU's unemployment rate is 5.9%, the unemployment rate of the countries who use the euro currency is 6.4% https://www.euronews.com/my-europe/2023/08/01/eu-eurozone-unemployment-rates-remain-at-historic-low-in-june#:~:text=The%20unemployment%20rate%20for%20the,were%20unemployed%20in%20June%202023 https://www.euronews.com/my-europe/2023/08/01/eu-eurozone-un....
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoSo if China had a 2% unemployment rate that would be worse unemployment because of the total people effected? And Greece's 12 percent unemployment is fine because it's only 1.2m people? Edit: did you change your argument after I replied? I swear you were taking about total numbers before.
- andsoitis 3y ago> So if China had a 2% unemployment rate that would be worse unemployment because of the total people effected? And Greece's 12 percent unemployment is fine because it's only 1.2m people? 1.412B (China population) x 2% = 28.2m people in China unemployed 1.2m people in Greece unemployed Yes, % is statistics. The absolute number of people is the real impact.
- kashunstva 3y ago> one of the largest and prosperous cities because that prosperity does not follow a Gaussian distribution. The United States has a uniquely skewed distribution of national income; and Thomas Pikkety’s analysis of that data shows that the skew is growing progressively larger.
- hibikir 3y agoIt's not unlike how more than 80% of workers would love a raise. It's all posturing until it's actually done. Realistically though, PTO comes out of salary, just like healthcare. For the businessman, it's a matter of total costs vs labor they get. Whether it's needing to hire someone to cover for 280 days of pto of everyone else, or paying more. What raises wages and benefits is that the employer has to pay more to have enough people that want the job and are qualified. Total wage expenses go up only when there's no other choice.
- CaptainZapp 3y ago> Realistically though, PTO comes out of salary, just like healthcare. The US seems to be one of very few countries where this is the case. It doesn't seem to be a very good model overall. To be more precise: In some countries healthcare may be deducted from a salary. But that's usually an universal healthcare model, which is certainly not comparable.
- jimmydddd 3y agoWhen OP says "PTO comes out of salary," I think they mean that the company has more money to pay a person if the person takes less PTO. For example, if a company needs a janitor role filled, and a janitor gets (for sake of simplicity) 6 months/yr PTO, then the company has to hire two people to fill the janitor role. So, if the company wants to dedicate $100k to the janitor role, each person would get $50k. With 0 PTO, one person could do the role for $100k.
- latency-guy2 3y agoBusinesses tend to actually survive their first year in the US. The same cannot be said for the EU. You seem misinformed.
- shadowgovt 3y agoAmong other reasons: because we foisted a big chunk of the social safety net onto companies instead of making it an everyone-pays public responsibility. Social security, healthcare, various insurances... In other countries, everyone pays for those and the government provides them. Here, the cost is foisted disproportionately on employers and their employees (with those between jobs excluded from those services).
- adolph 3y ago> Here, the cost is foisted disproportionately on employers and their employees There is no such thing as a free lunch. Employers and employees still pay when the money is run thru a government payor instead of a non-government heath plan. There is no magic money that appears by changing who cuts the checks to providers.
- shadowgovt 3y agoThis assumes a zero-sum economy, which is not how the healthcare economy works at a national scale. Hypothetically, competing insurance companies would push prices down. In practice, the market isn't a fair market (even before you get into issues like "People need medicine to live, so a market is a bad tool to parcel out medicine because price the patient is willing to pay is unbounded"), so insurance companies tend to add cost through paperwork, managerial overhead, accounting overhead, and cases becoming more expensive to treat as delays in preventative and early-intervention care cause issues to become chronic and urgent-care issues. When the payer is the government, the government can say "The price of insulin is 2% above cost of materials" ... and it is. And when the money is flowing from taxes to government to healthcare, instead of employees to employers to insurance to healthcare, a company isn't asking itself "Can we afford to take on more employees right now if it's going to cause our healthcare insurance costs and employment taxes to go up," because the decision of how many people to employ is decoupled from the question of how much in taxes the company will pay.
- adolph 3y agoThat’s a rosy hypothetical in which people get lower costs and better service through a change in payors. That doesn’t change the fact that the costs of healthcare will still be “foisted disproportionately on employers and their employees” because those are the revenue generating population. Government is already the largest payor in healthcare through Medicare and Medicaid [0] (funded by taxes “disproportionately on employers and their employees”). You’d think that they would already have the market power to do whatever they’d like with prices. 0. https://www.cms.gov/research-statistics-data-and-systems/statistics-trends-and-reports/nationalhealthexpenddata/nhe-fact-sheet https://www.cms.gov/research-statistics-data-and-systems/sta...
- acters 3y agoAlongside what everyone else mentioned, I believe a part of it is that the margins are being spent on frivolous; Instead of putting the money back into the business it is hoarded or spent on personal goods and services by those that control the company/business/corporation. There is is inflationary reasons but we don't want to accept this fact or think about it at all. And yes giving employees proper wages and time off is an expense a business should pay and this is where a lot of wealth is being taken out of from the middle class.
- arwineap 3y agoCapitalism breeds competition, and the simplest way to compete is on price. I suspect that each of these owners is likely speaking in good faith, and at their current margins they probably would have to lay-off other people. But what I think they are failing to account for is that this will effect their competitors as well, so they may be able to compete across the board after a price increase. It's probably a naive thought
- cool_dude85 3y agoBusinesses don't usually compete on price. They're price setters in general and people are price takers.
- ghastmaster 3y agoIn this case, the potential employee would be setting the price of their labor and trying to sell that to the employer. While typically the employer does make the offer, it is akin to going to a market and advertising that I(employer) would like to buy tomatoes(labor) for $.50/lb. The seller of tomatoes is still setting the price if they decide to sell.
- pixelatedindex 3y ago> Capitalism breeds competition, and the simplest way to compete is on price. Only if there is proper regulation, which there is less and less of. Otherwise you end up with price fixing and oligopoly.
- simonhorlick 3y agoCapitalism naturally tends towards monopoly. The idea that it breeds competition is a nice fairy tale, but doesn’t reflect reality.
- dantheman 3y agoWhy would you say that? It seems that the majority of monopolies ever created have had substantial government intervention. Assuming you mean a business that is monopoly for say a decade and not a few years.
- wmidwestranger 3y agoThose business owners are also being exploited by larger businesses. They're also accustomed to a certain slice of pie and hate accepting it diminish. As a self-employed developer, I've had the same discussion with people that hire me and want to change my rate, "My rate is set by the market and I'm not willing to undercut the people behind me. If I were to set my rate, it would be greater and not less. Hire someone that takes less and best of luck to you, I might not be the right fit." I'm all for growing the pie instead of changing the slices but that's a concern of things many orders of magnitude beyond myself. I thought rising interest rates might be good for the industry but it turns out the industry is pretty clueless and they don't actually seem to know what they're keeping and what they've dropped, accordingly some people that seem like dead weight technologically are basically untouchable to the people that make the budgets and decisions. Things have been divorced from economic realism for so long, I'm not sure we can even reach the bottom before we run out of breath.
- asu_thomas 3y ago> Those business owners are also being exploited by larger businesses They aren't being "exploited." If they need so desperately to exploit workers, they can and should just go out of business instead. It's that simple. It's called a market and this is how it works. Business owners love to describe themselves as risk-takers but they whine like babies when they have to pay the price. They are dishonest and generally pathetic people in my experience.
- boredpeter 3y agoDon’t forget what happens when they do fail. They get bailed out by the government thanks to all the lobbying they do. The 2008 bank bailouts, PPP loans to business owners. The government will bend over backwards for business owners but god forbid it helps regular people. Socialism for the rich, rugged individualism for everyone else. And they’ll still brag about how they’re “self made” and call themselves fiscally conservative.
- HWR_14 3y ago80% of them fear they would have to lay workers off in a survey. Do we know if they are telling the truth or trying to using the survey results manipulate people?
- Spooky23 3y agoThe answer is always that Americans fall for the myth of the sole proprietor. In NYC, the enemy is the landlord.
- spiralpolitik 3y agoIt's the same everywhere. Right now everyone in the chain is squeezing the level below them for as much as possible. The coffee shop near where I work is a small business and their landlord increases the rent regardless of market conditions. At some point they either close up, putting 2-3 people out of work, or end up charging $10 per cup of coffee. Right now there is no market counter force against the rent increases. There are many empty units but the landlords keep the rent high to keep the value of the building high. There is no penalty for keeping the unit empty even if there is demand for the unit at a lower price point.
- Spooky23 3y agoOh yeah, at the national level politics has weaponized tax policy to be a transfer payment to real estate interests. For small time shitty owners, they run off the books and write down “losses” while letting property crumble. In the legit economy, it’s like a variant of the Great Eskimo Tax Scam. It’s going to get crazier too - hundreds billions of dollars of real estate is underwater in NYC alone, and banks hold 60-70% of the paper.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- uglygoblin 3y agoThis is article is from 2019.
- monero-xmr 3y agoIt’s not that we don’t offer no paid time off. It’s that it’s not mandated federally (although some cities and states do). A recent article in the NYT pointed out how the minimum wage is irrelevant now given the difficulty of hiring: https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/23/business/economy/minimum-wage.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/23/business/economy/minimum-... This is the argument the anti-minimum wagers have been saying forever. The going rate for workers will rise well above the minimum wage, and by having a high minimum wage you prevent people from getting on the economic ladder at all. The lack of mandated paid time off means it is a benefit companies can provide. This attracts workers. I want most benefits to be negotiated this way, as well as the minimum wage eliminated.
- lastitude 3y agoEveryone should be paid the federal minimum wage. No government employees should be allowed additional income from stocks, dividends, additional businesses, trusts, etc. That'll be the day minimum wage becomes a living wage.
- Izkata 3y agoI gotta ask, was that phrasing intentional? Because I don't think it's usually used as part of a sentence, just standalone. Idiom for anyone uncertain what I'm referring to: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/that%27ll_be_the_day https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/that%27ll_be_the_day
- ghastmaster 3y agoAs a native english speaker, I interpret it literally, "On the day no government employees... ...minimum wage becomes a living wage".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- memefrog 3y ago>The United States is one of just a handful of countries — others include India, Pakistan, Suriname, and Papua New Guinea — that have no national policy guaranteeing workers paid annual leave. (It’s also among the few with no federal laws guaranteeing paid parental leave or paid sick days.) Any benefit offered to workers, like paid time off, is entirely up to the discretion of private employers. It's not "up to the discretion of private employers". It is up to the contractual arrangement between an employee and his employer. The USA is a huge place. It isn't obvious to me that there should be national laws for things like this. This is exactly the sort of thing you'd expect to be set on a state-by-state basis.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoIt seems that there could be at least a minimum, something like 5 days. If not, what demographic factors in a state would you consider valid to deny any paid time off?
- asu_thomas 3y agoThere is no moral rationale for either side, only a conflict between classes.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y ago> This is exactly the sort of thing you'd expect to be set on a state-by-state basis. There was no mention of "moral rationale" in the original discussion.
- memefrog 3y agoIf they don't have paid time off then clearly they don't value it. Any state legislature could pass legislation creating that rule. Maybe let people democratically choose their own rules
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoWhy is a federal rule undemocratic but a state rule democratic? If the federal government ran with that as part of their platform that would be democratic, no?
- ghastmaster 3y agoThe article does not answer the question(implied) it poses in the title. There is barely an attempt to answer the question. It is a bait and switch. > Lonnie Golden, a labor economist at Penn State, said in survey after survey, American workers tend to say that making more money is a higher priority than having access to more paid time off This is close to answering the question, however, it does not address why there is no national PTO law. It explains why workers do not take time off. > Beyond that, Golden said, there’s always been an American discomfort with leisure and time off, and a cultural bias to display our commitment to work as a sign of status. This is closer. As with the first example, this is just explaining why individuals choose not to take time off. The answer is the USA is reluctant to put mandates on employers that would interfere with free association of entities due to our founding being largely influenced by the idea that individuals should be free to make contracts between others. The federal government is also limited in the constitution to only regulating interstate commerce. There are of course many examples where the federal government has ignored this thanks mostly to Wickard v. Filburn (1948). Ref: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- theoldlove 3y agoNot sure your proposed answer is right, but I agree I was hoping for more of an explanation in the article for the US’ unusual position on vacation time.
- echelon 3y agoMeta: Why is your comment sorted below the above downvoted (currently appearing in grey) comment?
- andsoitis 3y ago> The answer is the USA is reluctant to put mandates on employers that would interfere with free association of entities due to our founding being largely influenced by the idea that individuals should be free to make contracts between others. Mandating PTO wouldn't be forcing people to make contracts; it would only say that IF you make a particular kind of contract, you need to include the following terms.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- njharman 3y agoI lived and worked US my whole life. I've had lots of paid time off. Probably less than French worker over 30 years. But still infinitely more than "no paid time off".
- tamimio 3y agoThe answer is simply because USA is run by corporations, so mostly it will never be on the side of the average employee.
- ghastmaster 3y agoI agree with your sentiment, however, there are many cases where the federal government has intervened to regulate employer/employee relationships at great expense to corporations. Why this one particular issue has not seen intervention is still up for debate and not answered in this article.
- boredpeter 3y agoDon’t expect the corporate owned media to ever do any actual investigative work on why workers in the US have been getting shafted for the past 50+ years. It’s just a mouthpiece for corporate interests and government propaganda.
- MontagFTB 3y agoMy company doesn’t have official PTO. They used to, but had to track the untaken time off as unpaid debt to Wall Street. They since changed to a more fluid arrangement between manager and employee that is not officially tracked. The old system was decisively pro-employee, now it is pro-company, and I don’t see them ever going back.
- CSMastermind 3y ago> Close to one in four workers in the United States have no time off at all. Okay, let's check the source on that... https://cepr.net/images/stories/reports/no-vacation-nation-2019-05.pdf https://cepr.net/images/stories/reports/no-vacation-nation-2... ...and it's not in the pdf as far as I can tell. They just assert it without citation. In sources they do list the BLS: https://www.bls.gov/charts/employee-benefits/percent-access-paid-leave-by-wage.htm https://www.bls.gov/charts/employee-benefits/percent-access-... Though assuming I'm reading that chart correctly that only says that 21% of Americans have no formal vacation days. Which I guess they could be rounding up to 1 in 4 while ignoring other types of paid time off like holidays, sick days, companies with "unlimited" PTO, etc. The BLS numbers seem to indicate the actual figure is closer to 13% of Americans who have no paid time off all.
- lumb63 3y agoAs a lifelong US citizen, the idea that for some reason, other citizens, via the government, should pay for me, or anyone, to not show up to work, doesn’t make any sense to me. How do other countries rationalize this idea?
- 4lb0 3y agoI've seen plenty of job posts in the US with PTO. It works the same as having a minimum wage and other workers' rights.
- dantheman 3y agoMinimum wage hurts the least skilled the most and makes them unemployable. There is no empirical need for the minimum wage as almost no one earns it.
- SahAssar 3y agoIf the minimum wage is low enough that nobody gets paid it how can it still hurt the least skilled workers? Aren't your two statements contradictory?
- dantheman 3y agoIt removes the bottom rung of the ladder, it's a temporary stage.
- zlg_codes 3y agoWhat are you smoking? A minimum wage puts a floor on what is needed to have an employee. Paying less than that is even worse than we have it now. Where do you live that doesn't have fast food, restaurants, retail, and so on? Most of these 'skilless' jobs are minumum wage. You are advocating for entire sectors of people to be paid less (i.e. exploited further) based on the false notion that few people are paid minimum.
- DangitBobby 3y ago
- JSavageOne 3y agoNPR Planet Money just did a podcast on this a week ago https://www.npr.org/2023/08/17/1194467863/europe-vacation-holiday-paid-time-off https://www.npr.org/2023/08/17/1194467863/europe-vacation-ho... They interview MIT professor Tom Kochan who says that in the 1930s U.S unions like the AFL actually pushed against federally guaranteed worker benefits like paid vacation because then there'd be less need for unions. Other benefits Americans never got were federally guaranteed health insurance and pensions. To quote the podcast transcript [1] "The big three - pensions, health insurance, time off through vacations - were left off the table. Instead, we got collective bargaining rights, which basically say we can bargain and negotiate with our individual employers for pension, health care and vacation. Now, we should say that the U.S. is also known for not passing these work benefits because of racism. A bunch of people in the U.S. back then didn't want Black people, for example, to get these benefits, so no one got them. But in Europe, everyone gets the big three - vacation, pension, health care - as a right. Vacation started spreading in Europe in the 1920s and '30s, and health care came in waves in the 1940s, '70s and '80s. And maybe this is why European countries started cutting their hours after 1979, but not the U.S. Like, maybe Europeans were, like, OK, we're getting all these benefits, plus we're just generally getting richer. Maybe work is not so important anymore. But when you do have to pay for these things, like we do in the U.S. - maybe that's why work is so important here." [1] https://www.npr.org/transcripts/1194467863 https://www.npr.org/transcripts/1194467863
- hnbear 3y ago[2019]
- foogazi 3y agoWould you take a 10% paycut to get 4 weeks PTO
- xtracto 3y agoNot in my 20s, maybe in my 30s . Now in my 40s, hell yes. I'd take a higher pay cut for even more weeks.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CaptainZapp 3y agoWhen working for a software vendor I negotiated a 10% pay cut for an additional 4 weeks vacation. That added up to 9 weeks a year and turned out to be some of the happiest time of my life.
- _nalply 3y agoBecause paid time off is not a thing in the US I can imagine that people have difficulties imaging how this could be organized in the company, especially for small ones. This is what I experienced in Switzerland. - Sometimes the company just closes for two weeks the summer (Betriebsferien). You see this for restaurants, bakeries, and so on. They post a sign at the door with the dates and when they open again. - If the company can't close, colleagues aren't allowed to take paid time off at the same time. Colleagues tell each other what they do such that substitution is possible. - Sometimes the company partially closes and has only a minimal service running. - It is accepted that during the holiday seasons everything runs a lot slower. - Sometimes it just does not matter, especially for large companies or for very fluid working situations like health care. There will be always some people picking up what needs to be done. - Sometimes the employee takes the work into holidays but this is somewhat frowned upon because the expectation is that you really take time off. And when the company reopens or the colleagues return from their holidays they bring a lot of fresh energy. And because all companies do this there is no loss of competitive activity. Companies tend to focus how to manage paid time off well instead of blocking it.
- alanfranz 3y agoOne detail: -paid- time off is accrued in most eu countries. What happens more or less is that instead of getting your “full” pay for a working day, you stash a certain amount of money away, and you pick up money from that bucket when taking time off. The important part of PTO in EU is that’s guaranteed that you can take it, or even that you MUST take it. If the total amount of money per year is the same, it doesn’t make a lot of difference whether it’s paid or unpaid.
- nunez 3y agoOn one hand, federally-mandated paid time off outside of FMLA sounds nice. On the other hand, Europe's median annual salary is €33.5k compared to $59.5k, while the average home sale price per square foot in the US is significantly lower than Europe [0] [1]. So I don't know what to think about this. Given that I've only worked at places with generous time-off policies, I don't think I can have a say on the matter. [0] https://www.statista.com/statistics/722905/average-residential-square-meter-prices-in-eu-28-per-country/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/722905/average-residenti... [1] https://finance.yahoo.com/news/study-reveals-average-cost-per-195736142.html?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAACYHFdYVkmiyOdQiTtYZouGgqOrzKLyCNyfIJPMpgqfbUf8MlC-JHiOp2b9o4bAiFmER4jSmWYrBXoajNhIkQQumeYR0cdmnWyUrtAg_d2esS-sKBapycsYRewO0HHUW0Bipk8KHhntZLUvnCe7aXItvzJvFTn35vMak-V_2KmF9 https://finance.yahoo.com/news/study-reveals-average-cost-pe...
- naveen99 3y agoHow do you do double entry accounting of paid time off ? In the end the employee is paying themselves out of payments they got for working some other time. Paid time off makes as much sense as making energy from not doing work instead of spending energy to do work.