5 ms·
It's support from companies who make money from Terraform being free, and at least one looked like a direct Terraform Cloud competitor that probably hurt Hashic
by robertlagrant 3y ago
It's support from companies who make money from Terraform being free, and at least one looked like a direct Terraform Cloud competitor that probably hurt Hashicorp's chances of making Terraform profitable.
It makes sense they'd do this, but we need to stop loving people who appear to give us things. They're just making reasonable business decisions.
- prepend 3y agoI prefer reasonable business decisions that support open source software over companies baiting and switching. If Hashicorp didn’t have a business plan that made money off terraform being OSS then the time for that was years ago. If you release as OSS then your competitors will use it to. This is predictable and all plans should account for it. This competition didn’t hurt Hashicorps chances of profitability, they were factored in from the beginning.
- louzell 3y agoI mean, businesses change? The founders didn't have a crystal ball to see how every decision would play out. Reading through these comments, I'm reminded of a pop psychology book that I read that essentially said "never try to take someone away, no matter how small, it is perceived as a much larger loss than it is". If Hashicorp had started with this new license in the first place, do we really think they wouldn't have had the business success that they've had? We'll never know, but my guess is that a license that says "competitors can't copy us" would seem totally reasonable to folks contributing, and irrelevant to customers that have a problem to solve. Someone correct me if I'm wrong here, I want to understand this obviously passionate response. (Since I've commented a couple times on this let me also say I'm not a hashicorp employee nor know anyone there)
- dablya 3y agoI don't know that it's at all clear how successful Terraform would be if it started with a more restrictive license. I mean there is a reason why a lot of projects start out with a different license and only change to BSL once a certain level of popularity is achieved, right?
- rbanffy 3y agoAs a possible contributor, and with all things being equal (which, really, never happens), I'd prefer a GPL-based product to have my time over a BSD/MIT license, because I really want my work to remain free. A BSL-based product would have to be very important to me to make it worth for me to dedicate time to it. In reality, the usefulness of the product and friendliness towards developers is much more important.
- prepend 3y agoDo you think crack dealers change their mind and suddenly discover they can’t make money off free crack? Or they give it away knowing that’s how you develop a customer base.
- robertlagrant 3y agoPretty sure crack dealers don't set things up so their work can be forked into a foundation.
- cto_of_antifa 3y ago[dead]
- prepend 3y agoBait and switch isn’t about the literal means of production. It’s about corporation and organizational dishonesty. It’s lame that hashicorp (and others) are fair weather open sources who start as open source to gain critical mass and then jettison their purported ideals when it benefits them. Dishonest because they trick contributors into working toward something that they may not, I think probably wouldn’t have, chosen to work on had hashicorp been honest since the beginning.
- robertlagrant 3y agoI don't know what "literal means of production" is referring to here. Crack dealers don't generally control anything one might refer to as a "means of production"; they are more like resellers. Marxist terminology is a bit too much of a Duplo-brick description of reality to apply usefully here, or indeed in most places. All the work done in this case can be forked into a different product, as is being done here. The reason crack dealers do what they do is they control the supply, not a "means of production". Hashicorp explicitly licenced away their control of the supply ten years ago.
- hodgesrm 3y ago> I'm reminded of a pop psychology book that I read that essentially said "never try to take someone away, no matter how small, it is perceived as a much larger loss than it is". That's not just pop psychology. That's straight from "The Prince" by Machiavelli. “Injuries, therefore, should be inflicted all at once, that their ill savour being less lasting may the less offend; whereas, benefits should be conferred little by little, that so they may be more fully relished.” https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/6858171-injuries-therefore-should-be-inflicted-all-at-once-that-their https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/6858171-injuries-therefore-...
- louzell 3y agoNice find!
- robertlagrant 3y ago"Make sure your enemies read pop psychology"
- supriyo-biswas 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_aversion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_aversion
- pxc 3y ago> This competition didn’t hurt Hashicorps chances of profitability, they were factored in from the beginning. They weren't, actually. From a Hashicorp FAQ article (which is a transcript of a video interview which has since been delisted from YouTube) titled 'Why is HashiCorp committed to open source?': > Mitchell: [I]t's always sort of been a default for me. [...] When we were starting the first projects, we both didn't intend to ever start a company around them. There was no monetization goal at all, and so I think open source was an obvious default then. https://www.hashicorp.com/resources/why-is-hashicorp-committed-to-open-source https://www.hashicorp.com/resources/why-is-hashicorp-committ...
- prepend 3y agoThey should have been. Them being irresponsible early on is negative for the community. Cynically, I believe they intentionally were stupid knowing that their tool would only become widely used if open source (who wants infrastructure as code locked into some proprietary thing).
- pxc 3y agoOne of the things that comes through for me in that FAQ, Mitchell's story about learning to code by reading and playing with open-source projects, and Armon's assertion that this license change is continuous with the company's original 'open-source ethos' is that this has always really been more about 'source availability' for them— I think they're credible, in way. I still think of open-source in a traditional, historically informed way: 'open-source' is about software freedom at bottom, even though its name and common arguments in its favor are more practical and self-interested. I get the impression that Mitchell Hashimoto never saw it that way, and certainly didn't buy into the actual 'open-source ethos' in the sense of the values of the people who decided the term and founded OSI, etc. A source-available license like BUSL probably would have been a better fit for HashiCorp from the start, or as near the start as possible. But I don't know that 'source-available' as a label could have driven adoption the same way in the early days, and it seems plausible to me that the founders might've realized that too.
- 3y ago
- rapnie 3y ago> It makes sense they'd do this, but we need to stop loving people who appear to give us things. They're just making reasonable business decisions. I don't see OP talking about 'loving people'. Just stating that a very good approach was taken. Wrt 'give us things', it is not about giving either (that's like free beer), but about freedom. If OpenTF indeed ends up under Linux Foundation / CNCF it doesn't matter how many competitors are involved, but that freedoms are assured.
- robertlagrant 3y agoWell, OpenTF hasn't given anyone anything there - the original open source licence Hashicorp put in place is why CNCF/LF can adopt the project. OpenTF is just an administrative middleman in that process. My comment was about a previous commenter thinking it was amazing that other companies put FTEs in place for a few years to work on OpenTF. It's not amazing; their businesses were built on Hashicorp licencing Terraform as OSS. They've been given far, far more than a few FTEs' worth of effort, and their continued existence depends on OpenTF being actively developed. It's not a noble thing (unlike the original open sourcing); it's just business as usual.
- ohad1282 3y agoenv0 founder here, direct competition of Terraform Cloud, and core member in the OpenTF initiative. Thank you for your note. I wanted to mention that indeed env0 enjoyed Terraform being free, but also contributed back to the Terraform ecosystem, with github.com/env0/terratag OSS and TheIaCPodcast.com for education. Also important to mention another and probably a more important key member in the OpenTF initiative - Gruntwork, creators of Terragrunt and Terratest. I believe we all contributed nicely to the community. Just my 2 cents, in order to add a bit more context to "companies who make money from Terraform being free".
- robertlagrant 3y agoUnderstood - but that was completely for your own gain. There's nothing wrong with that, but I don't like the mischaracterisation of HashiCorp as the baddies and this new entity as the goodies. Hashicorp just were too open and giving, and didn't have a way to profit from all the money they invested, the way you and others have profited from their investment.
- ohad1282 3y agoI could not agree more. Hashicorp are not the baddies. They did what they chose is right for them. They have any right to do so. Also, what Hashi did for OSS in the last decade is amazing, made OSS better and built many communities. Now it is time for something/somebody else to keep Terraform OSS. env0 is proud to take a significant part in this initiative (together with our friends in other companies and the support we got from the community so far), forking Terraform into opentf and donating opentf to CNCF/LF.
- tonyhb 3y agoYeah. I don’t really love that companies exploited something hashicorp gave away for free, then play good when they finally have to commit to the ecosystem when hashicorp takes it away. Where was this support when they built a business on this free work?
- sausagefeet 3y agoHello! I think your comment is missing some facts that might change your opinion: 1. Open-source software is a gift to the world. You make it, release it, and people can do whatever they want with it, including not contribute back. There is no exploitation here. You can build a trillion dollar business on top of Linux, without paying Linux anything. This is how open source is meant to work. This is the known contract when you release something as open source. To imply that by following the spirit of open source, somehow HashiCorp, a 5 or 6 billion dollar company is being exploited doesn't quite jive, IMO. 2. HCP has been clear that they will not put forth resources to review pull requests. They let many good pull requests languish until they die. If HCP were better stewards of the Terraform community and prioritized contributions, would things be different? I don't know. But I think if one is going to say the competitors should have contributed to Terraform, one also has to acknowledge that HCP has explicitly stated they are not going to prioritize reviewing your contribution. If you're looking for the best way to spend your engineering time, the best business decision for you is probably not to spend a lot of time on a piece of work that may die in the vine. 3. But it's not even just to say none of these folks have contributed back. They may not have many commits in the repository, but Gruntwork has created Terragrunt, which is free and open source. This has impacted the community considerably. The founders have written a book on Terraform. 4. Where is HCPs acknowledgment of all of the people that saw Terraform as stable open source foundation to build providers for, to build tooling for, to contribute pull requests to? Terraform itself is pretty simple, the hard work is in the providers. HCP makes some of the important providers, yes, but so many providers are made because Terraform is popular. HCP wants to make this all about them. They want you to think they put all the work into making Terraform what it is today. They did put a lot of work in, but the community did too!
- pm90 3y ago
- skunix 3y agoIs it a reasonable business decision to compete with a large and enthusiastic open source community though?