5 ms·
This is a wonderful start. Here's hoping it catches on outside of the EU as well!
by JohnFen 3y ago
This is a wonderful start. Here's hoping it catches on outside of the EU as well!
- jklinger410 3y agoWhat about this free market that everyone talks about? I don't think there are any protections around the reasonable expectation of privacy from a private industry perspective in the US. If you use the internet, or an app, you must protect yourself. I assume everyone is a capitalist, so wouldn't adding laws here somehow subsidize and therefore tarnish the market?
- mustafa_pasi 3y agoDoes it impinge on your personal freedom, if the government decides to put up special privacy protections for groups it deems too vulnerable?
- adasdasdas 3y agoThey're not special if they affect everyone
- master-lincoln 3y agoLiberals lied when they told you about it. There is no free market and the whole concept would only work if actors had equal powers which is not the case. Why do you think adding laws that forbid advertisements in certain configurations are a subsidy?
- JohnFen 3y ago> If you use the internet, or an app, you must protect yourself. That's easier said than done when it comes to the tracking that enables this sort of advertising. What method do you suggest? > I assume everyone is a capitalist I don't think that's a valid assumption. Also, there are many different kinds of capitalists. I'm a capitalist in the most basic sense, being an entrepreneur, but I see a lot of things asserted under the banner of "capitalism" that I disagree with. > so wouldn't adding laws here somehow subsidize and therefore tarnish the market? I honestly don't understand what you're getting at here.
- omginternets 3y agoMost people balance the ideal of a free market with other ideals, such as freedom from corporate predation.
- asu_thomas 3y agoSmall businesses use this kind of advertising as much or more, proportionally speaking, as corporations. And with a virtual guarantee of worse data security/privacy practices when applicable.
- pseudalopex 3y agoYour point is unclear. Small businesses are corporations. Advertising services are run by corporations. Tracking is predatory.
- JohnFen 3y agoNot to mention that Adam Smith himself made the point that there can be no free market in the absence of regulation.
- asu_thomas 3y ago> If you use the internet, or an app, you must protect yourself. As in "choose a strong password"? As in "never accept a terms of service agreement you disagree with"? As in "read all code before running it"? What thoughts were going through your head when you typed that?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bigbillheck 3y ago> I assume everyone is a capitalist, I assure you that I am not.
- Lammy 3y ago> What about this free market that everyone talks about? Never existed https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/article-1/#article-1-section-8-clause-3 https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/article-1/#ar...
- btbuildem 3y agoI really wish Canada would grow a pair, and stand up to the big social media platforms -- especially in the light of the latest shenanigans with the availability of / paying for news. Whichever side of that debate you fall on, you have to admit that meta et al are in a position to strong-arm a country and have an impact on its laws. That's a terrible precedent, already having played out in Australia. Anything that chokes off the flow of money via advertising to these companies is a two-tier win in my book.
- tomComb 3y agoI’m no fan of the power of big tech, well, except when it involves standing fast against the blatant political corruption of a government devising a bizarre and nonsensical law to funnel money to their corporate buddies (according to PBO analysis the most money goes to bell, rogers and Shaw). Yes, Canada should develop strong privacy and competition laws, but I’ve lost hope that they wouldn’t just be whatever serves the interests of our local oligopolies.
- goodpoint 3y agoBig companies are not standing against corruption. They are the ones pushing the biggest envelopes.
- nceqs3 3y ago>Anything that chokes off the flow of money via advertising to these companies is a two-tier win in my book. So you want paywalls for every service?
- asu_thomas 3y agoWhy would it? The EU is just protecting its own member states' IT industries and its own interest in undermining encrypted communications.
- OfSanguineFire 3y ago> The EU is just protecting its own partner states' IT industries Doesn’t the GDPR go back to a largely grassroots effort, including from members of the Pirate Party phenomenon that people initially scoffed at? I have no doubt that there has been local IT lobbying, but one cannot deny some level of true popular will.
- seydor 3y agoThe green party was a small german party with lots of access to powerful eu people I very much doubt this was anywhere near "grassroots" to the italians That is not even how eu politics work
- orwin 3y agoThe pirate party, not the green party, had a bit of support in Scandinavia, a lot less in Germany, and in France, in 2011, they could barely present 200 candidates in 50k areas, and i'm pretty sure their only access to 'powerful' people was the condescending sympathy of a single billionaire and maybe some secret service. And a single member in the French parliament (900+) ever listened to pro-liberty lobbies like lqdn, and fought for it. So yes, it's pretty grassroots.
- seydor 3y agothe gdpr was initiated by german greens
- orwin 3y agoLegislatively, yes. Politically, it's from ex-members of the 2011 pirate party (many of its members ended up in the greens). And I'm arguing against 'it's not grassroot'. My argument is that it's as grassroot as support for Snowden, wikilealks, whistle-blower protection. Because all of the was in the 2011 pirate party manifesto. It happened that only this legislation caught interest of other parties, but it's origin is grassroot. Have you heard of framasoft?