8 ms·
Just 23% of Americans Know the US Has Failed to Pass an Internet-Era Privacy Law
- sharemywin 3y agoWould it just be something that benefitted big tech even if it did pass?
- tgma 3y agoTLDR Think tank spin job. Nothing to see here. This strikes me as a number porn trying to spin something by benchmarking against a distinct and unrelated question. Of course the answer to “Do you know Elon Musk runs Twitter? Yes/No/I don’t know” is going to be skewed towards Yes or No much more frequently than something that requires much deliberation: “do you think the US lacks a meaningful national law on privacy?” Even if I am I supposed to answer that question as a legal expert, it may require sophisticated analysis to know whether it is meaningful, and as a layman do I know something is passed on a national level or not. Just too many moving parts.
- svachalek 3y agoThe questions are the opposite of what you describe: DKQ1 As of April 2023, which of the following companies did Elon Musk run? - Tesla and Twitter {correct} - Uber and Snapchat - Twitter and Uber - Snapchat and Tesla - Not sure DKQ10 Does the United States have a national privacy law that sets common standards for what companies can do with all data their products and services collect? - Yes, it does - No, it does not {correct} \ - Not sure
- tgma 3y agoThanks for posting the exact questions. I apologize if it came across as what the quotes means quoting from their questions. I was making a point with an example, which stands, that the answer to the latter question requires much more knowledge and deliberation than knowing a simple fact.
- googlryas 3y agoI guess COPPA doesn't count.
- dragonwriter 3y agoThe question actually asked about privacy laws is one to which the answer is actually yes, not no: the US has (several) federal privacy laws that impact what companies can do with personal data they collect, they provide radically different coverage for different kinds of data and impose little to no restrictions on many kinds of datat that might be important, but the question doesn't ask about the adequacy of federal laws on data use, only whether at least one such federal law exists. (And “internet-era” isn’t part of the question, despite the headline, though several of the applicable laws were passed in the “internet era”, and even with the internet specifically in mind.) So a more accurate headline would be “vast majority of Americans aware that the US has some federal data privacy laws”, but that’s not as useful for the PR purpose this is put together for.
- svachalek 3y agoThe question is "Does the United States have a national privacy law that sets common standards for what companies can do with all data their products and services collect?" The key word, but tricky, is the word "all". I think this makes the "no" answer correct but is not a great form of the question. If the answers were "all, some, none, not sure" it would have been more illuminating.
- username135 3y agoThis is why I hated standardized tests. There's no room for outliers or edge cases that make the answer to a question not really 100%.
- hedora 3y agoThe word "all" doesn't appear in the version of the question in the story I see. It just says this: "The U.S. does not have a national privacy law addressing how companies can use the data they collect" Even still, "all" wouldn't falsify the statement. There are some laws enumerating illegal things you could use data for. Anything not prohibited by law is legal. That's how the US legal system works. "Common standards" also doesn't exist in the version of the question in the article. However, setting common standards would prevent states from pass stronger restrictions, with the effect of actually weakening privacy law. [edit: Flipping some negations around, I think your version of the question is logically equivalent to "In the US, state and local governments do not have the authority to pass any laws addressing how companies can use any of the data they collect."]
- cj 3y ago(Founder of B2B SaaS startup here) my perspective is GDPR, CCPA, and similar laws haven’t really done much to benefit consumers. They provide an illusion of protection, but I haven’t really seen concrete cases where the regulation has benefited broad swaths of people. GDPR definitely makes it harder for new companies and startups to sell to larger companies (GDPR creates a lot of paperwork required to sell to large companies, which results in lawyer fees and efforts to comply that are largely superficial) Meanwhile, Google/Facebook/etc are finding loopholes and ways to work around the regulation to “comply” (more of less) without meaningfully improving user privacy, IMO. I’m 100% supportive of privacy advocates, but I have a sinking feeling regulation in place today is more of a charade that makes people feel good, rather than something that is actually improving online privacy in any meaningful way. I personally don’t mind more regulation because our company can afford to comply with anything thrown at us (and we already treat and protect user data with extreme care), but I don’t think more regulation is guaranteed to have meaningful impact in practice. Many people already know this, but things like SOC 2, ISO 27001, CCPA, GDPR, and lots of other security + privacy compliance frameworks are largely just a matter of getting your paperwork and internal procedures in order. I’ve run into a lot of people who think SOC 2 (for example) means we’ll have to secure our servers better, but the reality is auditors aren’t looking at your servers, they look at your paperwork. Paperwork typically does very little to actually make data more secure.
- TonyTrapp 3y agoI think the amount of crap and dark patterns that is missing from Windows 10 / 11 for European users compared to US users speaks otherwise.
- ultrarunner 3y agoI don't use windows; can you give some examples? (I ask out of curiosity)
- TonyTrapp 3y agoI don't have concrete examples but almost everytime there was an outcry about some new experiment Microsoft was subjecting Windows 11 users to (I think one of them might have been ads in Windows Explorer?), that misfeature was not to be found in European Windows 11 installations. I have also recently seen a video (I think it was on Twitter but I might be wrong) where the setup dialog for some Microsoft service had a dark pattern where it would change an option from opt-in to out-out in real-time depending on which country you selected from a dropdown box. For countries where the GDPR applied, the option changed to opt-in, and it immediately reverted to opt-out if you chose another country with less strong consumer and data protection laws. I'll try to find the video again but no promises. Edit: This is not a video but I think it's the same dialog that I saw in that video. https://twitter.com/AdamSmithKipnis/status/1121221430056603648 https://twitter.com/AdamSmithKipnis/status/11212214300566036...
- hotnfresh 3y agoAny polls or surveys of voters’ level of information about policy and function of government is disheartening. And usually really, really easy to manipulate with how you ask the question. Check out surveys of how many US voters understand how marginal income tax rates work, if you want to be sad. I’m aware of at least one fucking tax accountant who doesn’t get it. Confusion on this pretty simple point that most people deal with in some fashion is widespread, let alone less-directly-encountered stuff like in TFA. Reading much of this kind of research will make you wonder how democracy’s not even worse than it is.
- orangepurple 3y agoIf you leave America and do business you are also subject to GILTI and FATCA. Guess how many people know about those.
- akira2501 3y agoWhat this, and the article leaves out, is the US is a collection of 50 states. With 50 separate legislatures and 50 separate law enforcement mechanisms. That's why our republic isn't "worse than it is," we're not bound by waiting for the federal government to solve problems, and probably shouldn't examine the situation through that lens either. Furthermore, I'm not sad because they don't understand, I'm sad because they weren't _taught_ these subjects in school. If the purpose of public education is to produce public citizens, then we've failed miserably. Meandering articles castigating unfounded notions of "corruption" are looking in entirely the wrong direction.
- amelius 3y agoHow to change US internet privacy laws: 1. start a Chinese company 2. buy data from US-based data brokers 3. confront US senators with the fact that your Chinese company now has personal info about US citizens
- kube-system 3y ago4. ~~Senator~~ (lobbyist) writes a law specifically targeting foreign entities and continues to allow big data broker to collect data.
- falcolas 3y agoAnd isn't it funny how the lobbyist is also the big data broker.
- tacticalturtle 3y agoI think information about “average” US citizens wouldn’t be enough. You would need to confront them with evidence this company has information on the Senators or government officials themselves. It worked for Blockbuster VHS rental data: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Video_Privacy_Protection_Act https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Video_Privacy_Protection_Act
- Zetice 3y agoHold on; the US government should not prevent me from willingly giving my data away in exchange for goods or services. Maybe make it clearer that’s what is happening, but if you truly believe my data is mine, then you don’t get to tell me what I’m allowed to do with it, including giving that data to China in exchange for some dancing videos, if that’s what I want to do (god help me).
- bilbo0s 3y agoThe government wouldn't tell you that you couldn't do what you please with your data. It is far more effective to make a law that would tell companies that they couldn't use the data you gave them for any commercial purposes. With draconian fines for any violation. (Which fines to be meted out per violation rather than per user.)
- Zetice 3y agoBut that’s paternalistic; you are disallowing me from doing what I want with my data. I should be allowed to sell it to corporations in return for services, knowing full well they intend to sell my data to others. That’s what makes my data worth the services I receive in return!
- moate 3y agoThe government is paternalistic by nature, so just say "I don't want government" instead of some weird statement that most people would likely feel is fundamentally opposite of how privacy should work (Most private by default, opt OUT). Do you believe that most consumers fit your description? That most people fully comprehend what selling their data represents? If so, how do you reconcile that belief with the date presenting by the polling? Is the polling bad, and if so why not attack their methodology? Is there an alternative conclusion you're able to come to?
- Xcelerate 3y ago> most people would likely feel is fundamentally opposite of how privacy should work I don’t know. I agree with Zetice. I would prefer least private by default and opt-in to more privacy. Most private by default is how we ended up with those annoying “accept all cookies” nag screens everywhere, and it will only get worse with most private as default. The internet isn’t the physical world, and I don’t think a reasonable expectation of physical privacy equates to the same thing as digital privacy.
- juujian 3y agoI can only imagine how this survey went. At least half the respondents wouldn't even quite now what a privacy law for the internet is or does.
- jncfhnb 3y agoDoesn’t the last question contradict the headline question?
- waterheater 3y agoI have performed significant academic and practical work in the privacy space. The US has a fundamentally different (and, frankly, better) approach to privacy compared to the EU. The US tends to view privacy, in general, as freedom from unwelcome perception, often construed as "the right to be let alone", following Warren and Brandeis. The EU tend to define privacy as a specific type of control, as "control over how your personal information is collected and used." More recently, the terms "information privacy" or "data privacy" is used to reflect the European approach [1]. I personally detest calling the European approach "privacy" in any manner; it's just data control, plain and simple. Freedom and control are both related to the expression of free will, yet their outcomes are quite different. These two approaches to "privacy" are fundamentally divergent from each other. That being said, a freedom-loving nation must use government to exercise some forms of control. This tension between freedom and control is behind so many conflicts in the world, though I believe it is most pronounced with the issue of privacy, perhaps moreso than even with security. The US government, serving a nation historically oriented toward the maximization of personal liberty, decided that providing strict, well-defined controls on certain types of information is better than not. As a result, three primary FEDERAL data control laws have been enacted: FERPA (educational data), HIPAA (health data), and COPPA (children's Internet data). In addition, some states have passed data control laws, such as California's CCPA. However, the US Constitution provides extremely robust "privacy protections" which do not explicitly refer to privacy, most directly so with the 3rd, 4th, and 5th Amendments, while the 1st, 9th, and 10th are more indirect. The EU, on the other hand, appears to place control as a value of higher importance. As such, they passed the GDPR, though EU-US agreements like Safe Harbor and Privacy Shield attempted to accomplish similar goals in more modest terms. The GDPR is massively complex. I know at least one privacy scholar who believes that machine learning may no longer be viable in the EU because of the GDPR's data reuse provisions. If a data controller needs to get permission from the data producer every time that information is used as part of a machine learning process, ML research may become too burdensome. Now, some European governments state that their citizens "have a right to privacy." This situation highlights the difference between a positive and negative right, which I argue is a meaningful distinction (though not all agree). For example, the US Constitution generally provides rights to citizens in the negative form, such as, "Congress shall make no law...abridging the freedom of speech". A positive form of that same right is Article 35 of the PRC Constitution, which is: "Citizens of the People's Republic of China enjoy freedom of speech, of the press, of assembly, of association, of procession and of demonstration" [2]. In the former case, the nation ultimately defines what "freedom of speech" means; in the latter case, the government ultimately defines the meaning of "freedom of speech." Granted, not everyone agrees with this interpretation, but I believe history generally shows this to be true. So, the question is, is a European, positive-right formulation of privacy better for the nation or the government? I argue the government. For these reasons, I cannot stress enough the importance of grasping the difference between the US and EU approaches to "privacy". [1] https://iapp.org/about/what-is-privacy/ https://iapp.org/about/what-is-privacy/ [2] https://constituteproject.org/constitution/China_2018 https://constituteproject.org/constitution/China_2018
- plandis 3y ago> 32 percent have a basic understanding of how “AI” (LLMs) function. This is surprising and I really doubt this is true.
- codeTired 3y agoThis might be more realistic statistic among programmers, no way it applies to all Americans.
- ufjfjjfjfj 3y agoThey passed plenty of anti-privacy laws... I don't care that much about what didn't pass
- pradn 3y agoIt's hard for someone engaged in public policy to understand that most people just live their lives and have a basic and vague understanding of most policy issues. If you ask people about marine fishing limits, they'll say there are probably some national and some international rules to prevent overfishing. But they're not going to know the specifics, and aren't going to know the problem of overfishing by fleets from certain countries. The same thing is going to apply to every other sphere of policy. We on HN believe that tech privacy is important and follow the developments on this website, but it's a stretch to expect regular people to know this stuff. And it's not a knock on regular people! They're experts in their domains, everyone is - from car mechanics to baristas to hobbyist knitters. People are too busy resting from work, taking care of their families, and pursuing their interests. So where do you go from there? If you're engaged in the policy world, it helps to create institutions regular people can delegate policy expertise to, like the EFF or the Humane Society. Intense lobbying by small groups gets results (in both good and bad ways). And having a large "laity" of people that support the institution and expect it to do the nitty-gritty is ok.
- bitcharmer 3y agoI think protecting privacy to prevent the government from becoming oppressive tyrant seems like it applies to more people and in more indirect way than fishing limits. But maybe my priorities just aren't right.
- __blockcipher__ 3y agoIt seems that way to you because you're mired in it. But to someone who isn't, such policy doesn't have a tangible impact on their life, or more accurately it doesn't seem to. In much the same way that the impact of overfishing doesn't feel like it impacts you.
- troutwine 3y agoI think what the OP is getting at is that not knowing about something in great detail doesn't mean it's not important. Folks'll hew to what they find immediately pressing or have an inclination toward. Which is to say, the world is monstrously complicated and we are small and there's only so much an individual can focus on in their life. The collapse of fish populations due to overfishing will cause starvation, a lot of it. The erosion of personal privacy will abet a certain kind of tyranny. I don't think these are different scales of important but they are different problems that require detailed knowledge to comprehend to a good degree, which implies time and interest.
- hedora 3y agoSo, they're claiming this statement is true: > The U.S. does not have a national privacy law addressing how companies can use the data they collect when it is clearly false. I only need one counter-example, so here's one: HIPPA exists, and addresses how [some] companies can use [some of] the data they collect. Also, when overturning Roe v. Wade, the supreme court ruled that there is no federal right to privacy in the US, which impacted a wide range of privacy related federal laws in the US.
- jpalawaga 3y agoHIPPA protects medical records, which isn't so much as 'collected' as much as they are generated (and held) on behalf of the patient. So, I'd say this is a pretty disingenuous reading. They're clearly talking about something more akin to GDPR. Conflating HIPPA (or, say, top secret document classification) is not a productive vector of discussion.
- sidewndr46 3y agoWhere do you live that you aren't asked your medical history on your first office visit? That is definitely collection.
- philwelch 3y agoIf a doctor takes my blood pressure or asks about symptoms I’ve experienced, he is collecting data from me and putting it into medical records.
- hedora 3y agoOK, what about COPPA, the FCRA, the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, the Privacy Shield Framework, or any of the other stuff this branch of the FTC works on: https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/privacy-security https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/privacy-security We definitely have federal privacy laws. They are inadequate, but that the survey asked if they exist, not if they are sufficient. It doesn't matter what they are talking about in the article, since this is an article about how people responded to the survey question, not about how they responded to the article (before it was even written).
- sidewndr46 3y agoCall me when credit bureaus are on the chopping block. Till then I'm fine with little to no regulation in the US.
- hgsgm 3y agoOver 50% said "not sure", and the question was worded in a complicated way: "Does the United States have a national privacy law that sets common standards for what companies can do with all data their products and services collect?' The "wrong" answers to all the questions were <25% and had similar rates.
- seeknotfind 3y agoThis is such a biased title. "Failed"? The diagram this website pulled from pew doesn't have this term. It says "the US does not have...".
- dmatech 3y agoA lot of people don't realize that this sort of privacy right (ownership of data about you) is in direct conflict with free speech rights (which are far more protected than in Europe). We don't have a clear definition of what constitutes "the press" either. Basically, anything that requires the general public to delete data at someone else's request is problematic.