4 ms·
Mars?
by coldtea 3y ago
Mars?
- vore 3y agoHow would you get it there? Besides, if you were confident enough to not accidentally make a dirty bomb, you might as well just send it into the sun instead!
- arbitrandomuser 3y agoFun fact , it's surprisingly harder to shoot things at the Sun compared to other planets in the Solar system. It takes 55 times more energy to go to the Sun than to Mars https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/2018/its-surprisingly-hard-to-go-to-the-sun https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/2018/its-surprisingly-h...
- vore 3y agoThe more you know, thanks! Good thing I didn’t pick a career as a rocket scientist!
- nonethewiser 3y agoHow much could you even transport? Seems like it would be crazy expensive.
- tannhaeuser 3y agoThe standard argument against that is that the risk of contamination (of the athmosphere or basically anything) in case of a rocket accident is too high.
- dotnet00 3y agoAnd the standard response to that should be to how that too is kind of a load of FUD. The safety requirements for a rocket to carry nuclear material in the US are higher than those for carrying crew. The material would be flying on a rocket that has proven itself over many flights, with a rigorously tested design, with a safe abort mode for every point along the way to orbit and on top of that, stored in a vessel such that it wouldn't be released into the atmosphere if a failure still occurred. The proper answer is that it'd be absurdly expensive and completely pointless. After all, why bring it down to Mars? Just put it in an appropriate orbit around the Sun and you're basically guaranteed to never see it again unless you want to.
- tsimionescu 3y agoRockets are still by far the most dangerous mode of transportation developed. It's by no means safe to fly a rocket, even though it may be safer than it was before.
- dotnet00 3y agoThey're certainly safe enough that the primary risk is not of them exploding. Hell, the most current iteration of Falcon 9 has only ever had one failure, which was early in its lifetime before it was crew rated. In general, the vast majority of rocket explosions in the US ever since we got past the phase of having to build two of everything in-case one launch failed have been ones which were either still in active development or weren't anywhere near nuclear rated at the time anyway. The media loves to report on exploding rockets, but by and far that is not the norm and if you're flying on a rocket that is allowed to carry even nuclear material, you're essentially guaranteed to be safe (if not necessarily guaranteed to make it to orbit).
- bryanrasmussen 3y agoeven assuming the percentages have improved significantly since 2014 when this was written https://www.seattletimes.com/life/travel/if-planes-failed-like-space-shuttles-272-would-crash-daily/ https://www.seattletimes.com/life/travel/if-planes-failed-li... I would expect it is still probably high enough you wouldn't want it carrying nuclear waste.
- mcv 3y agoLets see if we can go a couple of decades without any rocket explosions at all before we risk burning up radioactive waste in the upper atmosphere. I don't want to trust this on mere claims of safety, I want to trust statistics on large, non-cherry-picked numbers of launches.
- dotnet00 3y agoHave we gone decades without plane crashes? What's with this insanity that seems to grip even supposedly educated science-minded people whenever something involves nuclear technology?
- dharmab 3y agoWhat happens if your rocket loaded with radioactive material explodes? Especially at high altitude?
- oceanplexian 3y agoThis is a solved problem, we already put nuclear fuel on rockets for stuff like RTGs, and they are shielded so well that even when they go wrong, it doesn't spread past the crash site. The other thing is that with re-usable rockets you could spread the waste over a large number of launches, and fire them off over the ocean. If something goes wrong with any single launch, the risk to people or property would be pretty small.
- antonvs 3y agoRTGs contain tiny amounts of nuclear material by comparison. It’s easy to shield such a small amount.
- sph 3y agoAh crap, there was a micro fracture in the solid fuel booster that caused it to fail just after launch, now we have 100 tons of spent nuclear fuel in the atmosphere. Sorry.
- londons_explore 3y agoJust make a tungsten shell to transport it in. Very expensive,but you can reuse the shell for many launches.
- senectus1 3y agothe sun.