5 ms·
A recent Reason magazine article described Hawaii’s emergency suspension of zoning regulations as “YIMBY martial law” which is exactly what the entire country n
by jeffbee 3y ago
A recent Reason magazine article described Hawaii’s emergency suspension of zoning regulations as “YIMBY martial law” which is exactly what the entire country needs to crawl out from under its economy-choking housing crisis. A developer who proposes housing that meets basic health and safety criteria on a site within city limits that is already surrounded on three sides by other developed parcels should walk out of the permit office with over-the-counter approvals. They should not face five years of process and appeals. The only way to counteract the trends of this article is to build!
- slashdev 3y agoYep, exactly this. All the barriers to entry are decreasing the supply. The only way to fix it is get rid of them in a dramatically big way. Politicians like to point at foreign investment, empty houses, immigration, anything except acknowledge and fix the real problem.
- doublespanner 3y agoRate of population growth (migration) is the demand side of the "real problem". And a slower rate of growth seems to have more benefits than fast growth with reduced building restrictions.
- jeffbee 3y agoMigration is a very minor contributor overall. Longevity and birth rate are the main drivers of the housing crisis. Boomers squirted out the largest generation ever and then forgot to die.
- beckingz 3y agoIntercity/ interstate migration is a huge contributor to the pressure in major US cities. If NYC or SF were 1/4th the cost I would move there immediately, but the value would be marginal at this point.
- jeffbee 3y agoSF has only enjoyed positive net domestic migration for one single year in living memory. Domestic migration is absolutely not a driver of housing costs in San Francisco. Over the last 40 years San Francisco has consistently failed to build enough housing for its endogenous population growth due to longevity and births.
- farzinadil 3y agoArguably the housing supply shortage is a better problem to have than a population shortage problem ie Japan. The supply shortage can be amended with construction. The population shortage ... not so easy. There are many problems with a declining, aging, shrinking population. Particularly the distribution in the economy between the retirees that need to be taken care of and the workers in the economy that contribute to the economy. Many western countries would face similar problems if not for immigrations since birth rates are falling.
- doublespanner 3y agoI've heard this taking point often, but from the perspective of a resident in Japan (rather than an investor) is really not leading to observable negatives for the people... Housing and land prices are lowering, wages are increasing, and investment in working environments and labour savings technology is high... Maybe the worst is yet to come, but at the moment it looks like an overall benefit for the majority.
- slashdev 3y agoThat’s the ultimate nimby. Don’t even think of living or working in my city. May cities that pursue that strategy suffer the exodus of people, wealth, and jobs that they deserve.
- xnx 3y agoSounds good, but who gets to decide what's allowed? Is a 60 story building next to single family homes OK? No? What about 20 stories, or 5? I'm conflicted myself about this.
- dymk 3y agoCopy Japan's zoning wholesale and solve all those problems
- xnx 3y agoAwesome if you can get an area to agree to this. Is there anything close in the US? Houston maybe?
- jeffbee 3y ago> Awesome if you can get an area to agree to this Which part of "martial law" is unclear :-) The whole point is to abrogate local powers.
- farzinadil 3y agoOr someone/some company/government should look into building a new city somewhere in America. Avoid the NIMBYs entirely. Kind of like what Culdesac Tempe is doing but bigger. Maybe if Culdesac Tempe turns out to be successful someone may attempt this.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoBut no one wants to live in Houston because it’s city planning is a mess.
- xnx 3y agoHouston is second fastest-growing metro in U.S., census data shows, with post-COVID population surge https://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/houston-texas/article/houston-second-fastest-growing-metro-us-census-17888963.php https://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/houston-texas/article/...
- WillPostForFood 3y agoLet's see how it works out for Lahaina before we rush out and start more fires.
- jeffbee 3y agoWhy? Do you believe there is a way to replace housing in Lahaina without building any? Do you believe that the 14000 households destroyed in Butte County, CA by the Camp Fire five years ago, who are scattered to the wind because California refuses to permit any new construction, are not enough of a precedent?
- WillPostForFood 3y agoThe obvious way to replace housing in Lahaina is to rebuild what was there. Zoning regulations wouldn't need suspending. They definitely should suspend permitting to expedite the process, whichever way they choose to go. https://www.hawaiibusiness.com/hawaii-building-permit-delays-top-nation-uhero-study-real-estate-carl-bonham/ https://www.hawaiibusiness.com/hawaii-building-permit-delays...
- jeffbee 3y ago> Zoning regulations wouldn't need suspending. A common belief, but throughout America the zoning regulations prevent the construction of that which already exists.
- WillPostForFood 3y agoWe are getting lost in semantics. Your original comment was clear in its intent, YIMBY martial law and "housing that meets basic health and safety criteria on a site within city limits that is already surrounded on three sides by other developed parcels". I responded with a viable alternative: free instant permit to rebuild what was there before (regardless of current zoning). You are proposing something much more radical. I'm not opposed to doing something crazy in Lahaina like a building free for all. I'm saying don't declare it a success and start promoting it elsewhere before it is even started, let alone a proven success.