3 ms·
ICANN warns UN may sideline tech community from future internet governance
- raxxorraxor 3y agoThe only real solution is to exclude politics from infrastructure. While I certainly have immediate negative impressions if I read their stated goals for several reasons, the current political situation would also never have allowed an open net to prosper. Politics here isn't about constructive solutions and instead about influence. If they would include technical voices here, they would include people from large tech companies that have their own ambitions. The tech community can only shape technical realities to curb most political influence. The old rules still apply, route around censorship, try to protect data and anonymous communication. I doubt any political influence would net a better net. On the contrary, it is often the source of the fractures we already see today.
- sybercecurity 3y agoI am guessing part of the push of politicians into "the Internet" is because they do see this effort of the tech community to minimize them. They see themselves as representatives of the people of their countries (especially democratic western countries) and so they should have a say about how the Internet works rather than unelected groups of technologists. I heard this repeated several times in meetings where Internet governance is discussed. You may agree with that or not, but that's their point of view. I don't know if tech could ever be completely separated: infrastructure needs physical locations, tech companies have employees who are citizens of somewhere, etc. The Internet grew because it wasn't seen as a threat at first, or the benefits outweighed the risks. Now, an instant, global communication network that is critical to the economy means it's seen as too important to leave up to a bunch of computer nerds.
- raxxorraxor 3y agoIdeally it would be the case that there is some democratic control instead of just random technocratic growth. I think that could only ever be legitimized if access stays universally free. There are also decent and most importantly honest political ambitions to improve the net. But there are the other kind too. Overall the most profound impact of politics is still content control and putting up barriers. Of course I am biased, but I am very glad that some computer nerds made manipulation and censorship as difficult as it is. If we talk about truly global efforts, the democratic legitimacy can also be disputed for that matter as there is no world government. Again, it became a topic about control and the strategy to create technological realities is maybe not a good defense, but the best one I could imagine.
- nvm0n2 3y agoHow the internet works is decided by their voters already, by the act of deciding what products to use.
- juanani 3y ago[dead]
- tjpnz 3y ago>outline shared principles for an open, free and secure digital future for all. Unless you're Taiwan.
- iinnPP 3y agoHello UN citizen, It's come to our attention that you run a website that is hosting misinformation. Ban user "tjpnz" for "suggesting Taiwan is real" in order to regain DNS control. You have 8 hours, UN Failure to comply is an offense punishable by netdeath.
- iinnPP 3y ago...and making the internet trustworthy "by introducing accountability criteria for discrimination and misleading content." The above is misleading. It impacts people differently based on mental health variations and is thus discriminatory. That's ok though as long as you are nice to those in power. Selective enforcement is only for those we don't like. Feel free to lie in the correct direction. Feel free to discriminate against white men. Discriminate based on appearance or wealth as much as you would like. Power.
- nvm0n2 3y agoDoes the UN matter at all? Their track record is quite poor, especially recently. They seem to have branches and offshoots that have opinions on absolutely everything, these opinions are invariably so predictable an AI could have written them, their impact is small and when they do have impact there's a long list of other people signing up to point out major holes in their work. Honestly, these sorts of international NGOs increasingly come across as legacy code that should just be deprecated for removal. They date from a time when people thought that if only you held enough international conferences and delegated to enough technocrats, eventually everything would be wonderful. That hasn't worked out because the enlightened technocrat wise enough to govern the entire world is essentially a myth, something found in Star Trek and 1930s utopian storybooks. The sort of people who are good at things generally don't want to work for talking shops like the UN (or the WHO, or the IMF, or the ...). And when it comes to the internet, none of them do. ICANN, ARIN and the rest are right: governance by mailing list has worked well so far and there's no reason to change, nor much chance of it happening short of a massive and coordinated global legislative "conspiracy".