4 ms·
Except we could have avoided enormous amounts of emissions if every first world country had followed France’s lead back in the 1970s. By the time renewables tec
by rayiner 3y ago
Except we could have avoided enormous amounts of emissions if every first world country had followed France’s lead back in the 1970s. By the time renewables technology advances sufficiently (grid-scale storage is still a necessary but unsolved piece of the puzzle) we will have wasted a 50+ year hard start we could’ve had with nuclear.
- crote 3y agoUnfortunately most countries didn't follow France, and unless you have a time machine that is going to be quite difficult to change. When it comes to climate change, the most important goal is to reduce emissions as quickly as possible. This means switching from 100 units gas to 90 units renewable 10 units gas in 5 years is way better than switching to 100 units nuclear in 15 years. If you figure out a solution to the remaining 10 units of gas somewhere within 100 years, you end up ahead!
- hackerlight 3y ago> When it comes to climate change, the most important goal is to reduce emissions as quickly as possible. This means switching from 100 units gas to 90 units renewable 10 units gas in 5 years is way better than switching to 100 units nuclear in 15 years. If you figure out a solution to the remaining 10 units of gas somewhere within 100 years, you end up ahead! This is an important refutation of "we need grid-scale storage before we can build out renewables". The total area under the curve is all that matters. 90% renewables + 10% gas can mean less overall emissions than 100% nuclear if it occurs sufficiently faster.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoYes, in 1980 or 2000 or 2010 or even maybe 2015 it would have been a fabulous idea to start a whole bunch more nuclear plants. But in 2023 we have better options.
- evilos 3y agoWe've been saying this for decades. It's still not true because we haven't figured out massively scalable grid scale energy storage. The only thing that gets close is PHES and we don't have enough of it.
- hackerlight 3y ago> Except we could have avoided enormous amounts of emissions if every first world country had followed France’s lead back in the 1970s. We should have, but we didn't, and we can't change the past, so it's irrelevant. Not only can't we change the past, but it's an apples to oranges comparison to compare what we ought to have done in the past to what we ought to do today, given how drastically renewables have decreased in cost between the 1970s and the year 2023. > By the time renewables technology advances sufficiently (grid-scale storage is still a necessary but unsolved piece of the puzzle) we will have wasted a 50+ year hard start we could’ve had with nuclear. There is no need to wait for grid-scale storage. That piece of the puzzle can be added later to replace last mile gas peaker plants. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37219148 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37219148