5 ms·
It'll cost several trillion dollars more to switch the US to nuclear electricity than it would to switch to renewable electricity. Those trillions of dollars
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
It'll cost several trillion dollars more to switch the US to nuclear electricity than it would to switch to renewable electricity. Those trillions of dollars could clean up a lot of waste if that is your primary concern.
- whimsicalism 3y agoWill we be able to replace current loads with renewable power? All I know is that France has effectively been GHG neutral for decades because they invested in this. I know renewables have gotten way cheaper, but if GHG neutral is so achievable with them why haven't we just done it?
- bryanlarsen 3y agoWe are doing it. We're doing it at a rate of about 5% per year, and that rate is increasing every year. Given how big our grid is, 5% per year is pretty massive.
- coding123 3y agoNuclear is at 20% of total US grid power. So 4 years ago it was 0%? This graph is showing nuclear as being pretty flat GW production last 10 years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_the_United_St...
- seadan83 3y agoFrance gets a large portion of electricity from Nuclear, though the data I could find does not say France is GHG neutral. The second largest source looks to be oil at around 35% [1] This source, [2], goes on to state: "In 2022, France's power sector carbon emissions nearly reached 40 million tons of carbon dioxide equivalent (MtCO2e), down from a century-peak of over 50 million tons recorded in 2005" [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_France#/media/File:Energy_mix_in_France.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_France#/media/File:E... [2] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1290541/power-sector-carbon-emissions-france/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1290541/power-sector-car...
- whimsicalism 3y agoEnergy != electricity That said, what I probably should have said is the capability to go GHG neutral. I believe that France has more domestic nuclear capacity than its domestic electrical conception.
- seadan83 3y agoThis is a good resource looking at the energy capacity of france: https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-profiles/countries-a-f/france.aspx https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-profil... This resource describes France's nuclear sector as aging: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=55259 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=55259. Between those two, it's not obvious to me that France could enable more nuclear capacity to account for the rest of their energy needs. I'm not sure I would even agree that GHG neutral is even a thing. Just because a person plants 1000 trees to account for emitting 10 tons of carbon today, the 10 tons of carbon were still emitted today while those trees need decades to even get close to break-even (and in the meantime they can burn, contribute to mono-cultures, possible not grow at all, be double sold as offsets, etc..) More concretely, I think it's like calling a Geothermal plant GHG neutral if it powers a facility that pulls down as much carbon as the thermal plant emits. As an aggregate, there is actually a true net zero there, but the thermal plant is still a positive contributor to emissions.* The first resource linked earlier states it pretty well: "As a result of the 1974 decision, France now claims a substantial level of energy independence and an extremely low level of carbon dioxide emissions per capita from electricity generation, since over 80% of its electricity is from nuclear or hydro." "an extremely low level of carbon dioxide emissions per capita" is AFAIK as good as it gets. I'm not sure why/where the energy vs electricity different really matters here. Perhaps you can help me out? Googling for some other numbers, it looks like France's total emissions are 270M tons, with an energy sector emitting 40M tons, even if that energy sector were zero'd out - France would still emit 230M tons of GHG. *Low carbon != zero carbon output. This resource shows nuclear as being a very low carbon source of electricity, akin to wind and solar (and even less than geothermal, all quite surprising to me): https://world-nuclear.org/nuclear-essentials/how-can-nuclear-combat-climate-change.aspx https://world-nuclear.org/nuclear-essentials/how-can-nuclear... I think I might be extra sensitive to the phrase "GHG neutral", I believe that phrase is very often 100% PR and 0% reality.
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago> why haven't we just done it because fossil fuel companies engage in grand fraud, for example they create astroturfing groups like 'citizens for responsible solar' which go around the country and file objection to every solar project that needs planning permission. They got on-shore wind turbines banned in Britain. They got construction of solar panels banned on all land except low-grade non-agricultural land, so like steep hills of Scotland where it is impractical. The underground power cable to France was blocked because it would 'ruin the landscape'.
- Qwertious 3y ago>but if GHG neutral is so achievable with them why haven't we just done it? Because France's energy system is/was largely publicly run, and I expect the US coal lobby would have objected pretty strongly to direct competition against coal plants being paid for and subsidized by government money.
- kevincox 3y agoThe fact that a few coal billionaires have any notable influence on public policy is a failing of democracy. They are literally poisoning the air we breathe and killing many thousands of people a year but our government is bribed to do what they want.
- edgyquant 3y agoCan you provide a citation explaining why this a definite fact? Sounds very untrue considering we still have problems to solve to go 100% renewable which requires R&D
- XorNot 3y agoDo you have any research which supports those numbers? Because I haven't seen a single analysis of renewable energy which manages to come up with a plausible figure for solving the energy storage problem with realistic assumptions about overbuild (i.e. a pumped hydro storage system which only holds 1 day of energy isn't robust if you have a grid which doesn't have fossil fuel fallbacks).
- bryanlarsen 3y agohttps://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262545044/electrify/ https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262545044/electrify/
- crote 3y agoThe overnight cost of building nuclear is about $7000 / kW. Wind and solar are closer to $1500 / kW before taking storage into account. That's plenty of margin for a wide variety of storage solutions - including simply building a huge overcapacity and letting it idle, or doing carbon capture on a peaker gas plant.
- XorNot 3y agoBut there isn't, is the thing. Nuclear might cost $7000/kW but it has a capacity factor of 80%[1]. Solar has a capacity factor of 25%. So while nuclear is closer to $8750/kW after capacity factor, solar is $6000/kW after capacity factor...before storage. And storage doesn't have a simple analysis: you can only charge pumped hydro at a certain rate, so on any given day if you don't have excess solar, you might not fully recharge at all (and that's before the problems of storing exactly 1 day's worth of excess energy when you don't have a large, dispatchable fossil fuel grid to fall back on). And how much is pumped hydro per kW, naively? Varies - an optimistic assessment is $1500 per kW, potentially as high as $5,505 per kW (in capex)[2]. [1] https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2205429119 https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2205429119 [2] https://www.hydroreview.com/business-finance/business/nrel-includes-pumped-storage-in-2022-electricity-technology-baseline-report/ https://www.hydroreview.com/business-finance/business/nrel-i...
- 3y ago
- rayiner 3y agoExcept we could have avoided enormous amounts of emissions if every first world country had followed France’s lead back in the 1970s. By the time renewables technology advances sufficiently (grid-scale storage is still a necessary but unsolved piece of the puzzle) we will have wasted a 50+ year hard start we could’ve had with nuclear.
- crote 3y agoUnfortunately most countries didn't follow France, and unless you have a time machine that is going to be quite difficult to change. When it comes to climate change, the most important goal is to reduce emissions as quickly as possible. This means switching from 100 units gas to 90 units renewable 10 units gas in 5 years is way better than switching to 100 units nuclear in 15 years. If you figure out a solution to the remaining 10 units of gas somewhere within 100 years, you end up ahead!
- hackerlight 3y ago> When it comes to climate change, the most important goal is to reduce emissions as quickly as possible. This means switching from 100 units gas to 90 units renewable 10 units gas in 5 years is way better than switching to 100 units nuclear in 15 years. If you figure out a solution to the remaining 10 units of gas somewhere within 100 years, you end up ahead! This is an important refutation of "we need grid-scale storage before we can build out renewables". The total area under the curve is all that matters. 90% renewables + 10% gas can mean less overall emissions than 100% nuclear if it occurs sufficiently faster.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoYes, in 1980 or 2000 or 2010 or even maybe 2015 it would have been a fabulous idea to start a whole bunch more nuclear plants. But in 2023 we have better options.
- evilos 3y agoWe've been saying this for decades. It's still not true because we haven't figured out massively scalable grid scale energy storage. The only thing that gets close is PHES and we don't have enough of it.