8 ms·
Screen Time at Age 1 Year and Communication, Problem-Solving Developmental Delay
- op00to 3y agoKids need interactive play to learn how to interact with the world. If kids are watching TV, they’re not exercising their problem solving skills. Good to see this proved out!
- recursive 3y agoScreen time and interactive play aren't mutually exclusive. My 7 year old is really into Minecraft redstone and command block builds lately.
- myhf 3y agoToo bad this study doesn't differentiate between interactive and passive "screen time".
- Terr_ 3y agoYeah, didn't people realize this back when comparing decades of traditional television to computer games? It's disappointing--and kinda fishy--when they still get lumped together.
- in_cahoots 3y agoWhat sort of interactive screen time do you think a 6-month old does?
- spondylosaurus 3y agoI'd be shocked if six-month-olds even recognize objects on a screen as anything more than abstract shapes/sounds tbh. A baby that age can recognize their mom, but would they recognize a picture or video of their mom?
- giblfiz 3y agoI appreciate that they corrected for a few other variables, but honestly this seems like a really really underpowered list. >Covariates > >We selected covariates that may affect the association between children’s screen time and developmental delay based on previous studies.7-18 Children’s sex was garnered from birth records. Information about maternal age at delivery and parity (nulliparous, or primiparous or multiparous) was gathered from medical records. We divided maternal age into 4 categories (<25, 25-29, 30-35, or >35 years). Information on annual household income (<¥4 000 000 [US <$28 400], ¥4 000 000-5 999 999 [US $28 400-$42 599], or ≥¥6 000 000 [US ≥$42 600]) was gathered from the midpregnancy questionnaire. Data on maternal educational attainment (high school graduate or less, junior college or vocational college graduate, university graduate or above, or other), child living with grandparents or other adults (yes or no), and maternal postpartum depression and maternal bonding disorder were gathered using the questionnaire at 1 year post partum. Maternal postpartum depression was assessed using the Japanese version of the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS).28-30 In Japan, an EPDS score of 9 or higher is widely used as the cutoff point for screening of postpartum depression, with previous studies reporting sensitivity of 75% and 82% and specificity of 93% and 95% at 1 month post partum.29,30 Maternal bonding disorder was assessed using the Japanese version of the Mother-to-Infant Bonding Scale31-33 (MIBS-J), and the cutoff point was set at 5. A previous study of Japanese mothers with 1-month-old infants showed that an MIBS-J cutoff point of 4 or 5 correctly classified approximately 90% of pathological maternal bonding disorders.33
- SkyPuncher 3y ago> In particular, more than 4 hours of screen time per day was associated with developmental delays in communication and problem-solving across ages 2 and 4 years. While the title is not incorrect, I believe it's incomplete without that line. Further, the "more than 4 hours" group was unbounded with little insight for how much more than 4 hours was median. I'd be very curious to see the home environment associated with this study. At some point, this seems to be less about screen time and more about lack of engagement and active involvement with your kids. If you have a full-time job, you may only have 4 hours of awake time with your kids. With 4+ hours of screen time, that could very well mean little to no involvement with your kids.
- nucleardog 3y agoAny study that doesn’t directly address this is pointless to me. My daughter has a fair bit of screen time. Very little of it is entirely passive. The closest she gets to passive is watching Frozen and Frozen II, her latest favorites. She’s constantly explaining the movie to us, singing, dancing, and otherwise more using it as a launching pad for activities than just passively consuming it. When she watches other things it usually involves myself or my wife discussing the show with her as it’s going. Asking questions, making observations, etc. She’s practicing and developing understanding and communication skills. When she’s playing on a tablet, it’s usually stuff like Duo ABC where she’s learning and then demonstrating understanding of letters and words or games where she’s playing with the sort of equivalent of a virtual interactive dollhouse and is exercising her imagination making up stories and social interactions and then relaying the stories to us. We don’t really pay attention to how _much_ screen time she gets as much as what she’s getting out of it. I definitely think she’s had more than her share of “4+ hours” days. But any study that doesn’t differentiate what we’re doing from a kid being left unattended and ignored with some YouTube recommendations all day seems to be… incomplete if I’m being polite. > At some point, this seems to be less about screen time and more about lack of engagement and active involvement with your kids. When we were told, as many parents are, “no screen time / limited screen time for kids” I didn’t accept it at face value but instead went digging for what the justification for this advice was. From what I found you hit the nail on the head. The damage comes from the lack of interaction. Small children are absolute sponges and need to be around and observing and interacting with older children or adults to have the opportunity to sponge up how to be a human and then practice those skills. Plopping them in front of a TV doesn’t accomplish that. Especially when they’re quite young they’re not even able to comprehend the TV as much more than colors and sounds and get nothing.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoThe people who should be reading this don’t care, and don’t see any downside. It’s a cheaper babysitter and it’s portable!
- sitkack 3y agoThen the device should have built in baby sitting. These kids will all be citizens.
- slily 3y agoIt's a bit shocking to see such denial on HN of all places. I imagine that evidence will keep mounting in the coming years, but by then the damage will already be done. Widespread autoimmune diseases and allergies, poor social and problem-solving skills, and poor attention span are already common among millenials, let alone younger generations. We're already seeing IQ trending down. The idea that having children watch YouTube for hours a day instead of exploring the world should be laughable, yet here we are.
- zanellato19 3y agoIt's because a bunch of people here are addicted to screens, like I am, but don't want to admit it. Also, it's so much easier to let your kid watch something on YouTube
- ghusto 3y agoI think he's more saying he's in agreement, but unfortunately the people who should take notice, won't.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoCorrect
- tspike 3y agoThis undifferentiated trend of “screen time” as a catch-all can’t die soon enough. There’s a massive qualitative difference between letting your kid tap on whatever the YouTube algorithm recommends for hours unsupervised and other, beneficial use cases. My son’s major motivation for learning to read came from watching us play Breath of the Wild and getting tired of not knowing what was going on. Lately we’ve been playing the remake of The Oregon Trail and using it as a springboard to discuss the history of westward expansion in the US. We are adamant that he not watch advertising or make heavy use of recommendation algorithms and have explained why and what they are and what the difference is, but he’s welcome to watch as many pre-downloaded Dr Binocs videos as he likes (for example). All that said, his daily chores include getting the eggs from the chicken coop, weeding the garden and the heavy “screen time” season is winter when our days are very short and wet.
- a_bonobo 3y ago>My son’s major motivation for learning to read came from watching us play Breath of the Wild and getting tired of not knowing what was going on. My son gets a few dozen minutes of Youtube kids as a treat if he has done well. The in-built timer asks you to solve a simple multiplication problem to add more time: he has gotten remarkably well at doing those even though he hasn't had multiplication at school yet. Now I am pretending that I am not seeing him solve those problems! If anybody here works at Youtube kids: please add division!
- bombcar 3y agoTo continue watching baby shark please: solve the Riemann hypothesis
- sitkack 3y agoAnd/or/xor/nand, popcount and maybe FMA. Division, bah!
- ido 3y agoI've added screen time restrictions to the ipad my kids use (5 and 7, but mostly the 7 year old - the younger one seems to not care much for TV of his own volition). I set it to 10 minutes per day per year of age (so 1h10m per day, as only the 7 year old seems prone to overuse). This is a maximum, but he reaches it most days and then after some grumbling accepts it and does something else. One advantage: when the iPad "decides" it's time out instead of me or my wife, he is somehow a lot more ready to accept it! With both our kids we only started allowing them to watch TV/use screens at around 2 years of age using roughly the above formula.
- balls187 3y agoMeh. Who cares about developmental delays at age 2 and 4, without putting it into context for how kids perform as adults. So what if kids can no longer do well in a government institution designed entirely to babysit and to train factory workers? Abortion is now illegal, and you don’t get access to any childcare until age ~5, and now you better not dare let kids watch TV or else you will be ridiculed by society. Good grief.
- ToucanLoucan 3y ago> So what if kids can no longer do well in a government institution designed entirely to babysit and to train factory workers? Well for better or worse, basically our entire society for everyone who doesn't have a trust fund relies on one's ability to both complete that government institution's trainings, along with a subsequent, quite similarly structured public or private institution's trainings directly after, after which we will enter a contract with another entity that in turn is structured similarly in order to earn the right to live. And we can discuss at length why this is a bad and limiting system that fails to recognize the diversity of the student body that passes through it, however failing to reform the institutions first and shrugging your shoulders like "well that sucks anyway what do we care what it thinks" is akin to telling people in a burning building to make for a rusted out derelict fire escape on the grounds that the last time the place was on fire, it held okay even though that was 20 years ago and several steps have fallen out since then.
- balls187 3y agoI can appreciate not letting perfect be the enemy of the good, and to use another analogy like yours: worrying about the impact of screen time is akin to not seeing the Forrest from the Trees. I also appreciate the researchers were not focused on identifying every problem children face, and that understanding causal relationships between behavior and outcomes is also important. However, specific to the issue of screen time, it's my opinion that it is completely overblown, mirroring the issue of my day "violence in media and it's impact on children." Having two children myself who were developmentally delayed (who did not get any screen time at young ages) what helped was access to early intervention. Research like this just feeds into negativity and judgement parents face from society.
- thelock85 3y agoI don’t think screen time is beneficial, but it really depends on level of selection, supervision and coordination when it comes to whether it’s harmful IMHO. I’ve seen my toddler completely zone out on a show and on the same day, transfer both scientific and socio-emotional concepts from the show to the real world. It really is mind-blowing as a parent. Now being more aware (and having an M.Ed) I can easily design everyday learning activities based on the handful of shows I’ve (since) vetted. At the same time, I have great empathy for parents who don’t have the privilege of being present due to work, multiple kids mental health, or otherwise. And I don’t want to judge those parents, understanding that I could be in a similar position with a few different outcomes.
- memefrog 3y ago>transfer both scientific and socio-emotional concepts from the show to the real world. It really is mind-blowing as a parent. The last place I would want my children to get socio-emotionql concepts is YouTube...
- thelock85 3y agoFair enough. I'd never let my child roam on YouTube but my reality is that there are hundreds of millions of indexed videos and it doesn't take that much effort (compared to other parenting efforts) to find shows that match my value around socio-emotional development.
- sandGorgon 3y ago>I can easily design everyday learning activities based on the handful of shows I’ve (since) vetted what have you vetted? am a new parent, so trying to learn.
- elif 3y agoi am not an expert in the field but i really hate the oversimplification of "screen time" the conflation of "watching cocomelon" with "performing a task or even a simple game" seems too broad to be characterized as one metric.
- in_cahoots 3y agoI see a lot of comments here saying that there are different types or qualities of screen time, but not one addressing the fact that this is a study of babies. Babies don’t play video games, solve puzzles, or interact with videos. Especially not for 4+ hours a day; even a 12-month old is only awake for 10-12 hours a day. It’s like people feel the need to defend their own beliefs instead of engaging with the article itself.
- barbazoo 3y agoSounds like many didn't read the article at all. > It’s like people feel the need to defend their own beliefs I think so, and not only their beliefs but also their own addictions to screens. It's like every time something comes up about alcohol use. Same thing.
- ghusto 3y agoI'm heartened to read a few comments like yours. This sort of sentiment was being downvoted to oblivion not six months ago. "Oh, am I in that group that's deemed bad? To the rationalisation-mobile!"
- lern_too_spel 3y agoI have seen 1 and 2 year olds learn to read playing video games. I see no reason why a properly designed game wouldn't be able to help develop social skills as well. The study itself acknowledged this, saying, "a meta-analysis showed that greater screen use was associated with decreased language skills, whereas screen time spent on educational programs was associated with increased language skills," and, "A limitation is that the information we collected did not allow us to separate educational screen time from other types of screen time." You're right that babies won't be able to engage with games or puzzles for 4+ hours per day, but that is not what others in this thread are suggesting. The criticism I'm seeing is that a parent interested in educating their children shouldn't throw out all screen time just because most other parents use screen time poorly.
- spondylosaurus 3y ago
- foxfired 3y agoHere is a quick summary of the results by chatgpt: The study involving 7,097 children examined the relationship between the amount of screen time exposure and developmental outcomes in children at the ages of 2 and 4 years. Here's a breakdown of the key findings: # Demographics of the Study Participants: There were 7,097 children in the study. 3,674 (51.8%) were boys and 3,423 (48.2%) were girls. # Screen Time Exposure: The study looked at the amount of screen time exposure per day for the children. * 4,340 children (48.5%) had less than 1 hour of screen time per day. * 2,095 children (29.5%) had 1 to less than 2 hours of screen time per day. * 1,272 children (17.9%) had 2 to less than 4 hours of screen time per day. * 290 children (4.1%) had 4 or more hours of screen time per day. # Developmental Outcomes at Age 2: The study found that children's screen time was associated with a higher risk of developmental delay in various domains at the age of 2 years. * Communication: The odds of developmental delay increased as screen time increased. For example, compared to children with less than 1 hour of screen time, children with 1 to less than 2 hours had an odds ratio of 1.61 for developmental delay. * Fine Motor: Children with 4 or more hours of screen time had an odds ratio of 1.74 for developmental delay compared to those with less than 1 hour. * Problem-Solving: Similar trends were observed; longer screen time was associated with higher odds of developmental delay. * Personal and Social Skills: Children with 4 or more hours of screen time had an odds ratio of 2.10 for developmental delay. Developmental Outcomes at Age 4: The study also looked at developmental outcomes at age 4. * Communication: Children with 2 to less than 4 hours of screen time had an odds ratio of 1.64 for developmental delay compared to those with less than 1 hour. Children with 4 or more hours had an odds ratio of 2.68. * Problem-Solving: Children with 4 or more hours of screen time had an odds ratio of 1.91 for developmental delay. In summary, the study suggests that increased screen time in children is associated with a higher risk of developmental delays in various domains such as communication, fine motor skills, problem-solving, and personal and social skills. These findings indicate a potential link between excessive screen time and developmental outcomes in young children.
- collsni 3y agoIf a kid is spending 4 hours focus on a screen per day, that's 4 less hours in the real world using real communication skills.
- j2kun 3y agoAm I reading it correctly that the maximum delay observed is ~5% across all the groups?
- almost_usual 3y ago> In particular, more than 4 hours of screen time per day was associated with developmental delays in communication and problem-solving across ages 2 and 4 years. 4 hours is A LOT of screen time
- Neil44 3y agoGreater screen time at that age is indicative of parents without the time or interest or skills to do anything else with the kid which probably knocks on to all other aspects of said kids life.
- DoingIsLearning 3y ago"Mothers of children with high levels of screen time were characterized as being younger, having never given birth, and having a lower household income, lower maternal education level, and having postpartum depression." They found association with >4 hours screen time and development delays and then claim this is a dose response. But arguably it just seems that if kids are spending more than 4 hours away from humans then they actually just have a lot more issues going on in their household.
- ghusto 3y ago"Mothers ... having never given birth"?! What am I missing here?
- I_Am_Nous 3y agoAdoption or surrogacy are on the table, but I can imagine a case where a mother doesn't want to go through the pain or body changes bearing children brings about, so they just go with a surrogate, and that lowers the amount of bonding between mother and child in a way.
- ghusto 3y agoMan, I didn't think of _any_ of those obvious examples :P
- mo_42 3y agoWhile reading it, I was always thinking about confounding factors. This study is from Japan, but I'm pretty sure there are others too. For the USA or EU, I can imagine many confounding factors. Let's pick one example: income. Wealthy families can hire a nanny. Even if the nanny lets the child watch something on screen for the same amount of time as an unattended child, it's different as the nanny can choose more appropriate videos or explain some context.
- onetokeoverthe 3y ago[dead]