3 ms·
I'm building https://www.datasette.cloud/ https://www.datasette.cloud/ and https://datasette.io/ https://datasette.io/ almost entirely open source for a number
by simonw 3y ago
I'm building https://www.datasette.cloud/ https://www.datasette.cloud/ and https://datasette.io/ https://datasette.io/ almost entirely open source for a number of commercial reasons.
1. I want organizations (initially newsrooms that care about data journalism, but rapidly growing beyond that) to be able to trust the product. The default result of 95% of startups is to go out of business, and going all-in on a product that then blinks out of existence is bad! When I'm selecting a vendor this is a thing I always consider, so I'd like my customers to feel confident that they have the ultimate escape hatch - run it yourself - should they ever need it.
2. Newsrooms in particular have learned this lesson before, many times over - and not just for startups. Remember Google Fusion Tables? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Fusion_Tables https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Fusion_Tables That's just one relatively recent example.
3. Datasette is an ecosystem play. There are over 100 plugins already - https://datasette.io/plugins https://datasette.io/plugins - and I hope for there to be thousands more. Developers don't invest nearly as heavily in building and releasing plugins for closed-source platforms.
4. Open source is a way for me to punch _way_ above my weight. I can have a much larger impact on the world by participating in open source, compared to if everything I'd been building had been closed.
- MPlus88 3y agoHow are you going to monetize it? Your site has no mention of pricing.
- simonw 3y agoI'm going to charge organizations a monthly fee for using the hosted SaaS service. Implementing billing and setting pricing is next on my TODO list!
- codetrotter 3y agoWill the billing system itself also be an open source plug-in for datasette? :D
- simonw 3y agoSadly not, it's going to be a Stripe subscription management dashboard!
- TX81Z 3y agoSo now you have to manage both the core software and the hosted version. Whereas your competitor just needs to build a hosted version, use the core you provide for free, thereby having a fraction of the expense and the ability to undercut you on price. You have to realize going in that once you try to monetize your open source, some of your users become your competitors. They’ll tell you how great you are, while cashing checks off your hard work.
- debarshri 3y agoI agree with your perspective but let me try to formulate an argument against that. 1. Trust over a product or platform can be formed in many ways. Opensource is an irreversible way of doing that. I have often seen people equate opensource to free usage of the product, it is great for adoption but very bad when it comes to monetization. Even if your project is available as OSS if you don't have community around it, disappearance of the org is still a threat. 2. If there is no market, you don't any incentive to maintain it forever. Google fusion tables is probably that case. The market perhaps was not large enough. 3. I do buy into incentive to opensource for building an eco-system 4. I do buy into the larger impact argument but question is - will you keep maintaining it if there is no incentive for you in the process? I have seen lately, lot of VC backed orgs posting OSS as a differentiating factor than their competitors. I am not sure if I would buy into that argument.
- simonw 3y ago> will you keep maintaining it if there is no incentive for you in the process? Speaking personally, Datasette is the first project I've worked on in my entire career where I'm confident that I would be delighted if I was still working on it in 10-15 years time. The space it operates in - analyzing, exploring and publishing data about the world we live in - has completely limitless appeal to me. Every project I've ever cared about can be attached to it, especially given the plugin architecture which supports me trying out all kinds of weird and interesting applications for the core technology. If I can't make it work financially it can go back to being a side-project for me. I'm confident the financial side of it can work though.
- kapilvt 3y ago> Speaking personally, Datasette is the first project I've worked on in my entire career where I'm confident that I would be delighted if I was still working on it in 10-15 years time. I feel the same way about cloud custodian and starting stacklet, but I also put stuff into a foundation, so that it has proper survivability beyond the org, irrespective of the org's decisions (Ala hashicorp), and true survivability and impact on an oss project means getting past individual contributor bus factor.
- candiddevmike 3y agoI made an open source license that you may be interested in. It's basically the AGPL + copyleft for _services_ that are dependent on your service, as well as build tools. You can check it out here: https://github.com/candiddev/cpl https://github.com/candiddev/cpl.
- benatkin 3y agoThat's kind of like saying "I have a fork of bash that you may be interested in". It fails the familiarity test, and that's really important.
- candiddevmike 3y agoDoes that really matter in the context of a license though? The terms are the terms, if folks don't agree with the terms they can negotiate different ones or not use it.
- benatkin 3y agoThere isn't a lot of people thinking, gee, I want an unfamiliar license, so you're going out on a limb by showing someone a new one. Just like if you made a fork of bash with some new feature and were like, "here, use this".
- hiatus 3y agoIf you want your software to be used, yes it matters very much.
- bcx5k15 3y agomatters a lot, most orgs have a whitelist of permitted licences, and if some software you want to use isn't on it you have to jump through loads and loads of hoops, so much its usually not worth it.
- thrashh 3y agoWith all due respect, a project being open source means nothing for trust. There's a litany of open source projects that I have used that have been completely abandoned. Trust comes from building a healthy ecosystem of users, which ultimately comes from building a good product.
- indymike 3y ago>Trust comes from building a healthy ecosystem of users Trust comes from the publisher/author being truthful and honest with users, nothing else. By publishing source code, an open source software publisher is making a strong statement towards trust: you can see everything. Nothing is hidden (this is not true though when a company uses an open source client and closed source back end strategy). > There's a litany of open source projects that I have used that have been completely abandoned. There's also a litany of abandoned closed source commercial software and SaaS products. Keeping commercial software alive requires money. Keeping open source alive requires time. In the end, both are scarce and the author/publisher has to make a decision on what to invest in, and sometimes the software they sold to me last year doesn't get that investment. If it did, I'd still be using NBI Legacy to write documents, I'd be running OS/2, Microsoft Bob would be helping users make Windows work, and I could read news with Google Reader (aside Bob, all of these were at least good products. Bob was... ahead if it's time).
- thrashh 3y agoBeing truthful doesn’t mean much. Actions are worth much more than words. What trust is seeing how a product has evolved over 5-10 years. I think you’re missing my point. My point is focusing on whether a project is open source is relatively meaningless. It’s like using the price at a restaurant to judge the quality of food… it’s almost meaningless.
- trinsic2 3y agoIt means a lot to me. Thats the first thing I look for in a company/concept. releasing code to the public is an act of social responsibility. I means quite a bit to the public good. The public good still exists no matter what people in business think. It just takes awhile to effect your bottom line if you ignore it.
- anitil 3y agoI've been using and pitching datasette at my employer for a long time now. It's just so useful for so many ad-hoc tasks in my work.
- foob 3y agoDid you have the newsroom angle and monetization plan in mind when you started working on Datasette? Or did you start working on it first and then come to the monetization strategy after you realized that it resonated with people?
- simonw 3y agoIt's been inspired by newsrooms and data journalism since the start, see https://simonwillison.net/2018/Aug/19/instantly-publish-datasette/ https://simonwillison.net/2018/Aug/19/instantly-publish-data... for the story.
- TX81Z 3y agoI said almost exactly the same thing a decade ago with my own project. I learned a lot in that time. It’s closed source now.