6 ms·
I don't know how common it is, but the AI War developers posted recently about their new game & said Steam recommended they drop their Linux port, saying that j
by jauntywundrkind 3y ago
I don't know how common it is, but the AI War developers posted recently about their new game & said Steam recommended they drop their Linux port, saying that just relying on Proton would be better performing & a better use of time.
I'm very curious how widespread this advice is. It's a little sad & ironic to me if Proton is now entrenching Windows as the only target platform. I'm hoping this wasn't blanket advice Valve is handing out but really something specific to the team.
- mcpackieh 3y agoIf the devs test with Proton, then I don't see a problem. Proton is open source, so the future of games that run well with Proton seems secure.
- ShamelessC 3y agoDo you want more games to be played on Linux or not? Because we've been trying the whole "please target native Linux" thing for awhile now and it simply isn't appealing enough to ever work. Evangelism is useless in the face of results.
- memefrog 3y ago>Do you want more games to be played on Linux or not? This is meaningless if you change the definition of "on Linux" to mean "on Windows".
- ShamelessC 3y ago“on Windows” is no longer a worthwhile phrase when it simply means “targeting a Linux/Windows shared compatibility ABI”. There are more functioning games on Linux than I ever would have thought possible because of this (very difficult and certainly open source) work that’s been done by Wine, Proton, Valve and many many more. But of course, someone has to find a way to discourage all of that because it isn’t pure enough or whatever.
- COGlory 3y agoProton almost always runs better than Linux native. Windows is the only stable ABI on Linux, now.
- gjsman-1000 3y agoArguably, WINE has always been the most stable ABI on Linux. Good luck just getting a 5-year-old binary of any desktop file manager running on a modern Linux installation. I’m dead serious. Grab a copy of Nautilus or GNOME Files from Ubuntu 16.04; try running it on Ubuntu 22.04. It isn’t easy. Now imagine a game.
- crickey 3y agoThis is only because of the nature of dynamic linking. Have a statically linked executable and you should be fine. Not that it should be an issue to get old software to run you simply need to download the dependent lib versions. Anyone who sais this i feel hasnt worked very much with software, not that you should need to thats up to the one distributing the executable
- gjsman-1000 3y agoUnless you statically linked GTK, possibly Xorg, and more into a ludicrous bundle size, you’d still be screwed. As for “just get the libs,” that’s hilariously easier said than done. Try my example - it’s enough to make an engineer cry.
- crickey 3y agohttps://www.x.org/wiki/Releases/ https://www.x.org/wiki/Releases/ https://www.gtk.org/docs/installations/linux/ https://www.gtk.org/docs/installations/linux/ I mean it will probably not be painless and other applications u run might break* but xorg is relativly stable. Liba are out there are free to get. Usually people are arguing that the conveniences isnt there not that its not possible. * if u dont sandbox this a bit with custom lib paths
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>Steam recommended they drop their Linux port, saying that just relying on Proton would be better performing & a better use of time. I'm very curious how widespread this advice is. It's a little sad & ironic to me if Proton is now entrenching Windows as the only target platform. Very. Win32 ABI is the most stable and rock solid compared to the messy moving target of the Linux world, so recommending it is not entrenching Windows, just very good advice to save time and resources to target a platform that's alredy known and stable, and since the target is fixed and well known, it makes it also very easy to emulate on their end for Linux. As much as FOSS-Linux evangelists hate it, Win32 emulated on Linux is better for everyone, than tryin to port games natively on Linux, and makes the most business sense of you want the same games on Linux.
- mistrial9 3y agodo you have first-hand knowledge of the structure of the code base that ports to both Linux and Windows for this particular game?
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoValve and others have explained it already why in general terms that apply to all games on the native vs emulated situation, no need to go into the pedantic details of one specific game.
- mistrial9 3y agoas a framework author and C++ coder, the code base structure is not "excessively concerned with minor details and rules or with displaying academic learning." -- certainly not for you in any case, by your own statement
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoNo need to be snarky and flash your coding street cred to make yourself big and make me look dumb. I'm not the smartest tool in the shed, but I was not trying to be snarky and undermine your superiority or downplay your question, I was just saying it doesn't matter as the end goal is to get Windows games playable on Linux, and for that Proton emulation is the way that makes sense financially and practically for both developers and gamers, so no need to dive into the codebases and compare them, just to prove a point that's moot from the get-go.
- baq 3y agoSad? A bit. Wrong? Not in the slightest. WinAPI is the stable Linux ABI now, that’s simply the status quo.
- memefrog 3y agoRepeating this FUD meme over and over again does not make it true. Yes we get it. You read an upvoted HN comment once that said "Windows API is the stable Linux ABI now" and know you can get upvoted if you just repeat it. But it is simply false.
- baq 3y agoMy steam deck doesn’t need opinions to work. It just does.
- ndjdjfjfj 3y ago> relying on Proton would be better performing I tried Overwatch 2 with Proton and performance was abysmal. My computer seemed to be melting and FPS was jumping all over the place. It does 144fps on Windows 11 without sweating (same PC).
- hackyhacky 3y agoGP isn't saying that Linux is faster than Windows; they are saying that a Windows app running under Proton under Linux is faster than a native Linux app running under Linux.
- netbioserror 3y agoI highly recommend tweaking things like Proton versions (try GloriousEggroll for example). I've been playing OW and OW2 on Linux for years, had very few issues since the beginning and excellent framerates.
- smoldesu 3y agoYep. It also really depends on your hardware. In my experience, I had no problem playing Overwatch 1 at 144fps through Proton on my 1050ti.
- acomjean 3y agoI have a notebook (Nvidia 10xx something gpu), 8th gen intel I think. It gets plenty warm playing games, but the games play fine on PopOS. The fact that they run is pretty great. But I think of the steam deck which is basically a Linux PC. Its lowerer spec, low power, but it seems to run pretty well without terrible battery life.
- vinyl7 3y agoGame developers have stated that the support requests they get for Linux outweighs the revenue they get from supporting it. There are so many distros with different packages/dependencies, drivers, package managers etc. that it's very time consuming to keep up and not worth it.
- johnny22 3y agoSteam has provided their own container runtime for quite some time, so the packaging and dpendendies are a lot of a problem if you only distribute on steam. I still prefer they go with the proton approach though.
- taeric 3y agoI recall seeing similar with major caveats, though. The general "make linux support and they will come" crowd is clearly too big to be meaningful. That said, there was a story of someone that had a bug cut from a linux user that commented how it was one of their best support cases ever. User was engaged and willing/able to work with them in ways that few support cases are. As such, this is a mixed bag. Actual users that cut support issues from random machines will be worth trying to engage with. General cries that you should support it with no payment in play should likely be ignored, though.
- olliej 3y agoI mean that's what Apple has done with "Game Porting Kit" - valve has pushed "windows is the platform" to such an extent that no one even tries to write portable code for games and just targets directx.
- stonogo 3y agoSeems a pretty obvious way to preserve value-add in the face of competing game services. GOG and so forth don't have Proton, so the simplest moat to build is to curtail native Linux development and protect Proton's status as the "default" approach to getting games running there.
- joveian 3y agoUnfortunately, GOG seems to have mostly given up on Linux and often doesn't provide available Linux builds (I think there may have been one main employee who pushed for better Linux support who left years ago). There is at least one "Proton without Steam" build that I haven't tried: https://github.com/GloriousEggroll/wine-ge-custom https://github.com/GloriousEggroll/wine-ge-custom Personally, I've been using Windows fully offline with GOG games, although I'd like to some day try putting together a Linux based offline game console (or maybe NetBSD based if Wine is sufficient).