10 ms·
US Housing Affordability Hits Worst Point in Nearly Four Decades
- supertrope 3y agoLegalize apartments.
- something168581 3y agoNo. More, cheaper houses and housing complexes instead. More apartments only makes lack of home ownership worse. You're always paying someone else for something you will never own. Rent payments go down a black hole. Mortgage payments at least result in an actual asset, and eventually end.
- robotburrito 3y agoYou can buy an apartment. Many do in cities.
- monkaiju 3y agoIsnt that what makes it a condo not an apartment?
- distances 3y agoI recently learned that it is, but that's not at all obvious for non-US people. In Europe an apartment is an apartment, and the ownership status is a separate matter. Condo is a not a word anyone uses or probably even understands over here.
- whimsicalism 3y agoi think the definition is a bit sketchy as some would say that if you can buy it, it is not an apartment.
- whimsicalism 3y agoAmerica doesn't need more urban sprawl and the stigma against renting is ridiculous. > Rent payments go down a black hole. Mortgage payments at least result in an actual asset, and eventually end. Generally making rent payments and investing the money you would have spent on the house in the stock market will get you further ahead in terms of ownership stake than just making payments on a mortgage. The only reason this is not true is due to massive, massive government subsidies of owners at the expense of renters (ie. Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac acting as lenders of last resort for nonsense mortgages that no private bank would have ever granted without this support).
- guestbest 3y agoIf preference against renting is cultural, what cultures celebrate renting over ownership?
- whimsicalism 3y agoMy personal culture that I adhere to. That said, I mentioned stigma, I didn't say anything about culture - and I'm not sure why it is at all relevant to my point.
- medvezhenok 3y agoRenting is much more common in Europe and renters have significantly more rights. This is because much more wealth in Europe is generational (although we are quickly moving in that direction in the U.S. as well). Some European countries have things like the imputed rent tax (basically taxing homeowners as if they were renting their own home). This goes a long way towards balancing the scales between homeowners & renters.
- HumblyTossed 3y ago> America doesn't need more urban sprawl and the stigma against renting is ridiculous. Not that there isn't a stigma against renting, but, does one really want to be renting during retirement when most people's income is fixed? And yes, there are ongoing costs to ownership, but you can possibly plan for those better. You can't really plan for your land lord to raise rent by 50% because the media tells him the market is hot and he can do that.
- returningfory2 3y agoThe question of whether renting or buying is more financially beneficial is highly complex, and certainly it is not always the case that buying is better. Additionally, there are non-financial reasons why some people prefer to rent. So IMO we shouldn't be designing housing policy around everyone becoming an owner.
- Analemma_ 3y agoI bought a condo in 2021 (at a fantastic interest rate), and am currently regretting it deeply because my life circumstances changed and I probably need to move to a different state, meaning I need to either sell the place at a considerable loss or become an out-of-state landlord, which I don't want to do and is unlikely to turn a profit for me. The flexibility of renting is a real and important phenomenon: people's lives change unexpectedly sometimes.
- yodsanklai 3y agoI regret not buying an apt in 2021 at a fantastic interest rate. Even though I moved since then, it would have been very easy to rent it, and inflation would have paid for it. Since then, interest rates have only increased, and in my location, real estate is at a record high. It's been increasing pretty much since the 90s without a break. I don't believe a bubble will break any time soon. Also, materials/energy is getting more expensive, there's a lack of labour, so even building/renovating places isn't an option.
- notaustinpowers 3y agoI support this, but it would require so many more city and county level law changes to implement. Many counties have zoning laws in place that require homes to be a certain square footage (my county is 1,500sqft), that also have to be built on-site, and must have 2 off-street parking spots, and must be 50 feet from the edges of the property line, etc. While making townhome-style housing impossible due to those same zoning regulations. While providing tax incentives to luxury apartment complexes. These zoning restrictions would need to be rewritten first, and incentives given to developers to create high-volume, inexpensive housing. With restrictions preventing them from selling to built-to-rent companies. But zoning restrictions are incredibly difficult to rewrite. A woman from a county in GA is having to sue the county to try to adjust their zoning restrictions and the counties constitution states that zoning can only be used to protect the health of the citizens. And their restrictions banning off-site built homes or small homes does nothing to protect health since they're built to the same standards as larger site-built homes.
- mcphage 3y ago> But zoning restrictions are incredibly difficult to rewrite. I really want to know how they got written in the first place. It seems clear that somehow, zoning regulations is one of the biggest issues we've got. But everyone has these onerous zoning regulations that make life worse... where did they come from?!
- medvezhenok 3y agoI think most zoning regulations came as a backlash to the crime waves in the 60s/70s and were intended to keep "safe" neighborhoods "safe". This uses house prices as a tool to separate people into "desirables" and "undesirables" (roughly). China (and the former Soviet Union) did/does it more explicitly via the hukou system - if you don't have a hukou, you can't live in a given city nor attend the school/use the city's resources. The process in the Soviet Union might not have involved financial capital, but it involved human capital (i.e. if your profession was not "respectable", or if you were ever convicted of a criminal act, you might not receive permission to get an apartment (or even a room) in a top tier city like St. Petersburg or Moscow)
- timeagain 3y agoMore radical: legalize a path to ownership for renters. You rented with no issues for 5 years straight? Great that’s 20% down on your new mortgage, it’s yours. It isn’t that real estate can’t be an investment, but we should reward those who invest their human capital as well. Landlords and market investors might balk, but they are going to hell anyway.
- smeej 3y agoRent-to-own is already a thing if both parties consent. Forcibly taking something from somebody just because somebody else wants it is rather totalitarian.
- ComposedPattern 3y agoPlease take off the ideology goggles for a second. > Alice has to pay Bob one third of her income, or else he'll call on on armed men to throw her out of her home. "Not totalitarian" > Bob isn't allowed to do that anymore. "Totalitarian"
- za3faran 3y agoQuite the nonsensical argument. Alice pays Bob to rent his house, not her house. This is secondary to the nonsense situation we have at hand though, thanks to usury (aka interest) being normalized.
- pessimizer 3y agoA lot of people and funds bought up a lot of houses to flip or rent at a premium, so even though free money is gone, they can't lower their prices. The next step is to tax people hard who leave houses empty. Make owning unsalable and unrentable property a liability again!
- whimsicalism 3y agoI disagree that this is a major driver of housing costs. And why can't they lower their prices?
- jfghi 3y agoI’d say it’s because the pricing is algorithmic based off of demographic and personal data. Similar to hotels, it can be more profitable to keep some empty in order to reduce supply and price up the others.
- whimsicalism 3y ago> it can be more profitable to keep some empty in order to reduce supply and price up the others. You mean if you own a massive complex, which is the vast minority of housing - and also not what was mostly accused of being bought up by individuals or firms for speculation. If you're talking smaller units, landlords are effectively price takers and it is pretty much never profitable to keep empty and price up everything else unless you are anticipating immediate increase in prices. None of this is a major driver of housing prices either way.
- jfghi 3y agoI’d say based upon the overall profitability and scale of single family corporate landlords like American homes for rent that commercial interests have great influence over pricing. Smaller landlords are then able to price similarly. It makes little sense for them to have houses be empty and lose money, but this is often the case. However, the focal point is the drivers of pricing and I don’t see any evidence in your argument as to why I am wrong.
- whimsicalism 3y agoSeems sort of absurd to me that this article is entirely about mortgages and rates when likely the majority of new housing entrants are renters. This is exactly the intention of higher rates - cooling off the housing market.
- SaintSeiya84 3y agohousing should be a human right and people preying on this should pay for it. Own more square meters than reasonable? tax heavily or confiscate it for the greater good.
- smeej 3y agoYes, this is the solution. Send government goons with guns to tell people they have too much house. </s>
- supertrope 3y agoComrade SaintSeiya84! Your bourgeois decadence has come to an end. Your housing unit has been placed into receivership by the local revolutionary council. We will give the unit to a worthy family or distinguished hero. You are evicted effective at the end of the month.
- TulliusCicero 3y agoPolitician: "I'd do anything for lower housing prices!" Build more housing. Politician: "...but I won't do that."
- xnx 3y agos/politician/current homeowner/
- Justsignedup 3y agoThat's part of the problem. The other part is that common buyers are competing with investor funds + international investors who can pay over asking price and still make a major profit. Worse is how in New York a ton of stores are left empty to lower the tax burden on the owner of the building, or to drive up prices more. All that combined with automated landlord pricing tools that effectively make a nationwide collaboration between landlords who'd previously never talk to eachother.
- TulliusCicero 3y agoInvesting in real estate this way only makes sense when supply is sufficiently constrained. An explosion of housing makes it a bad investment. But we've made it incredibly difficult in many, perhaps most areas to build substantial new housing, so we don't get housing explosions even in areas with incredible demand. You end up with just a trickle.
- whimsicalism 3y agoYou are diagnosing a symptom as the cause.
- em500 3y agoPolitician just respond to their constituents wishes. "We should build more houses" Proposals for for new development. "... not here."
- TulliusCicero 3y agoI don't deny it. People want more housing, just not right next to them. Move the decisionmaking authority for zoning to the metro or state level where this sort of local regulatory capture is harder. Get more new housing spread everywhere, rather than concentrated in the few spots that are okay with it (or are too politically weak to stop it). The current setup is kind of a prisoner's dilemma. Ideally everyone would approve housing next to them and that would be the impact almost everywhere would be small, since new construction would be spread out, and housing prices would go down a lot. But if you choose to opt out of new housing, well, then you get to deal with zero new construction, which for many people is an improvement. But then if everyone does that, hardly any new housing.
- soupbowl 3y agoThis problem is much worse in Canada with no end in sight.
- cyberax 3y agoNope. Nope. Nope. Housing in the US is freakingly cheap. You can buy a house that would be an envy of half of the people in Europe for $200k. The problem is, it won't be anywhere near "trendy" locations. And that's the _real_ problem. People are forced by market forces to move into ever denser cities. And increasing density ALWAYS results in cost increases. It's like the rocket equation: dense cities need infrastructure to support infrastructure to support infrastructure. And no, none of the inane solutions: "let's legalize SROs^W microapartments!" or "let's just force each homeowner to take a family to live with them!" will do anything with that. They'll just increase the overall misery.
- bugglebeetle 3y ago> You can buy a house that would be an envy of half of the people in Europe for $200k. The problem is, it won't be anywhere near "trendy" locations. It’s not been my experience that the lion share of Europeans envy Americans and certainly not Americans who live outside big cities. And I work with Europeans every day in my job.
- techsupporter 3y ago> The problem is, it won't be anywhere near "trendy" locations. You are being very reductive and writing out entire categories of reasons why housing is unsustainably expensive. In your next two sentences: > People are forced by market forces to move into ever denser cities. Lots of us already live in cities but our neighbors and elected leaders have let this get massively out of hand. I have lived in Seattle my entire life, as has my wife, and we raised kids here. One of them has had to move away because they can't afford housing here and the other has moved to Marysville just to be able to afford something. My wife and I are both getting older and didn't want to climb stairs to be able to get to our front door (Seattle, as you may recall, has a lot of hills). Even though we had nominal equity in our house, the red hot housing market here means that equity didn't go as far because we wanted to stay in the same region to be near family and friends we've had our entire life. Never mind that a lot of those "trendy" areas are where jobs and cultural activities are. Housing is "cheap" in the US if you follow the "just live in the middle of nowhere" model, which of course lots of people don't want or are unable to do.
- someguy7250 3y agoPeople don't really like each other enough to work for a positive future. And yet they all want to live in a populous city with amazing opportunities/infrastructure/environment/etc That's the problem. If technology is so advanced and if solar panels are getting cheaper, why aren't we building new cities in the desert? (Or, why aren't we bringing new techs to small towns that already exist?) If everyone is so tired of planned obsolescence and not owning their devices, why aren't we making new industries based on sustainable, repairable, open source phones? There could be whole new towns running an economy on producing sustainable hardwares and then selling the repair parts. It wouldn't be a lot of money. But if everything we use is repairable and sustainable, we wouldn't need a lot of money. Maybe I am just silly to hope for such a future?
- beedeebeedee 3y ago> There could be whole new towns running an economy on producing sustainable hardwares and then selling the repair parts. It wouldn't be a lot of money. But if everything we use is repairable and sustainable, we wouldn't need a lot of money. > Maybe I am just silly to hope for such a future? Not silly- that's the future we need
- whimsicalism 3y agoI think you are projecting your interests onto the population at large, planned obsolescence of phones is not really a major concern for most people. And if you are starting out by asking people to accept a poorer lifestyle because it will be sustainable and repairable, you are setting yourself up to lose. I don't even agree that these are choices we necessarily have to make - I think we are getting closer and closer to sustainable growth, not merely subsistence.
- someguy7250 3y agoTrue. I am not asking people to just accept anything though. If you want growth, have at it. When my phone completely breaks, I would love to get a better hardware with more features.
- itchyouch 3y ago
- benzible 3y agohttps://archive.li/V974r https://archive.li/V974r
- hbcondo714 3y agoI just did a Ask HN related to this: Did you purchase a house recently? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37204037 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37204037 If so, how? Did you use a real estate agent? Mortgage rates are the highest in more Than 20 Years[1]. Did you put more than 20% down? Or did you pay cash for a foreclosure, auction, fixer-upper or wholesale home? Are there any sites / apps / services you would recommend for finding a home? For context, California housing affordability is at its lowest level in nearly 16 years where a minimum annual income of $208,000 was needed to make monthly payments of $5,200[2] [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37171849 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37171849 [2] https://www.car.org/en/aboutus/mediacenter/newsreleases/2023-News-Releases/2qtr2023hai https://www.car.org/en/aboutus/mediacenter/newsreleases/2023...
- stillbourne 3y agoI feel like Colorado is creeping up there in terms of costs comparable to California. I'm disappointed rent control keeps failing to pass committee, they bumped my rent 12.5% this year. I didn't get a 12.5% pay increase, I can tell you that.
- ihsw 3y ago[dead]
- whimsicalism 3y agoRent control only makes housing less affordable in the long run, this is the consensus of economists [0], and ignoring this is the left-wing equivalent to pushing oil & gas and continuing to ignore the consensus opinion of climate scientists - beneficial to ones short-term interests but absolutely screwing the future. [0]: https://www.kentclarkcenter.org/surveys/rent-control/ https://www.kentclarkcenter.org/surveys/rent-control/
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Rent control only makes housing less affordable in the long run Rent control doesn’t exist to make housing affordable in general, or in the long run; it exists to prevent existing residents from being priced out of their existing residence, particularly against localized (in time and/or space) market movements. It is intended to (or, at lrast, it is not an unknown cost when it is adopted) to make housing more expensive for others (new market entrants, and, when rent control is targeted by age, income, or other conditions, those existing residents not eligible) to provide that benefit. Absent general new supply restrictions which are the actual problem, it is a redistributive that makes an area brcoming attractive to new and richer populations less destructive to existing and more econonically precarious communities. If there are problematic general new supply restrictions it magnifies the effect, but the solution is to deal with the new supply restrictions.
- swsdsailor 3y agoThis comes up so much it's like a pathological condition. If the voting population want's more houses the solution is not to tax people out of their homes - that just swaps house occupants - the solution is to build more houses. There is plenty of land and room to do this, but the GOVERNMENT - again the ~GOVERNMENT~ implements restrictions on the building process. The restrictions are so onerous in CA that new properties are expensive. You want more houses, scale back the government control over building and building costs. Easy.
- whimsicalism 3y agoTaxing people out of their homes would help resolve the problem because homes in prime areas for development are often held for an extremely long time, especially in California, due to distortionary tax incentives. This is politically impossible to say because it usually amounts to pricing out old people from places that could use an apartment building. The main thing requires zoning reform, agreed - but higher land taxes would absolutely help.
- doug_durham 3y agoIn all of these conversations no one is mentioning income inequality. I see housing unaffordability to be symptom of this. The transfer of wealth to the highest income Americans has been constant for the last several decades. We are now seeing the impact of this. The significant number of Americans don't have meaningful savings. How can they be expected to afford a house?
- friend_and_foe 3y agoThe transfer of wealth to the highest income people has been a thing for all of time. High income == transfer of wealth. They're literally two different ways to say the exact same thing. How can they be expected to afford a house? The same way they were in the past. A house is a plot of land with some sticks bundled up to create a shelter, with some added amenities like a toilet and an air conditioner. There's no reason that something like that should cost what it does. There's also no reason that a bunch of wood exposed to moisture and termites should appreciate in value over time or be viewed as an asset. Yet here we are.
- tb_technical 3y agoCourtesy of Blackrock, Vanguard, and State Street.