6 ms·
> Turns out the state required you to “wear” this license plate after your third DUI or something. This doesn't make much sense because the license plate is at
by ryandrake 3y ago
> Turns out the state required you to “wear” this license plate after your third DUI or something.
This doesn't make much sense because the license plate is attached to the car, not the driver. Couldn't the manager just drive his wife's or friend's car or something? What purpose does the plate serve? "Warning everyone! A serial drink driver might be in this car, but might not be, and if he's in it he might be driving, or might not!" Totally useless. As someone else mentioned, wouldn't it make more sense to permanently revoke someone's license after 3 DUIs?
- mptest 3y agoYou're right! We should make them wear a star or something to indicate their specialness! Joking aside I imagine taking licenses away are a big part of it, but that doesn't stop them from driving, at least the license plate warns the rest of us not to drive too close to the guy.
- some_random 3y agoPeople usually drive their own car, and taking away someone's license can be life destroying in most parts of the country.
- ComputerGuru 3y agoDriving drunk can be life destroying in most parts of the country.
- oakesm9 3y agoWait, is it not possible to get banned from driving in the USA? For comparison the drink driving penalties are here: https://www.gov.uk/drink-driving-penalties https://www.gov.uk/drink-driving-penalties
- Scoundreller 3y agoBut you have to get caught first. USA is bigger on pulling vehicles over for ??? reasons than most other places. I’m figuring in UK if you get a DUI, it’s because you were driving allll over the place or got into a 3am collision.
- msm_ 3y agoI don't get your point. Are you defending people driving drunk in the USA because they are more likely to be caught? In my country it's also common to get caught after being stopped for speeding or car malfunction (like missing headlight), after a minor crash, by driving in a suspicious way, or just during a random check (that police is allowed to do). In total, around 450 drivers out of 1000 are tested for drunk-driving every year. It's one of the higher numbers in EU, so drunk drivers here are also (hopefully) likely to be caught. And the US DUI limit is insane - 0.08% BAC. In my country it's 0.02% BAC and if you get caught you lose a driving license for at least 6 months (with progressively more severe consequences for higher violations, up to a prison sentence, lifetime driving ban and losing your car permanently).
- Scoundreller 3y agoGenerally, the more likely you are to get away with an offence, the steeper the penalty. I can't speak for all EU countries, but I get the feeling that traffic enforcement is a lower priority by EU police than US/Canada. Several hypothesized factors for this in EU: more competency-based licensing, more regular technical inspections of vehicles (so fewer missing headlights), more automated enforcement (so fewer in-person controls), less focus on revenue generation by police (again, fewer in-person speed/mechanical controls), and most collisions just being a matter of submitting paperwork to insurance without police involvement. In Ontario Canada, police interaction is mandatory if any injury, >$2k damage or public property damage, so 99% of collisions, which is far different than France at least. So unless you have mobile alcohol checkpoints, even if drink-driving happens at the same rate as elsewhere, you're less likely to be caught in EU. And those that are caught probably did something more significant at the same time to warrant police attention. But sounds like your country, testing 45% of drivers per year, makes up for those several factors I brought up. Doesn't seem to be the norm in my EU experience - I do ~25% of my driving there. 20 year old EU data on this on p. 21 here: https://road-safety.transport.ec.europa.eu/system/files/2021-07/02-alcohol_en.pdf https://road-safety.transport.ec.europa.eu/system/files/2021...
- woodruffw 3y agoThis sounds like a good reason to pursue policies that make taking away a license not life destroying, rather than pursuing policies that allow people to destroy lives by continuing to drink-drive.
- Moomoomoo309 3y agoEasier said than done, unfortunately. In suburbs, that'd require completely changing zoning, adding public transit, and waiting for new stores to be built in or near neighborhoods. In rural areas...I don't even think you can fix it, there's no infrastructure by design. (in cities, this usually isn't insurmountable, so there it'd just be incremental improvements) The biggest roadblocks are the zoning and the public transit, because NIMBYs will come out of the woodwork to prevent any work being done. What it comes down to is that the people who can make laws affecting DUIs and the people who can lessen car dependency in an area aren't really the same people, so it's much more difficult to get done.
- coldpie 3y agoThe theory is they'll just drive anyway without a license. Plus in many/most parts of the US, a car is effectively required to live, so removing one's ability to drive is a seriously major punishment. The whiskey plate indicates to other drivers that the car could be more dangerous than expected, and yes, I think the shame is supposed to be a component as well. It's harm reduction, not a perfect solution. I don't know if the theory works in practice.
- gambiting 3y ago>>so removing one's ability to drive is a seriously major punishment. Being caught drunk driving 3(!!!) times is a seriously major crime. I'm a strong advocate for a complete driving ban after a single drunk driving episode, 3 is just crazy to me. I get the argument that in US that basically makes it impossible to get anywhere without a car but I don't know - get a bicycle or something, literally anything is preferable to letting these people on the road again.
- haswell 3y agoDepending on location, a bicycle is not a viable alternative. Driving is a condition of living if food is 30 minutes of driving into town. I’m am not advocating for lax DUI laws, but a driving ban is the equivalent of house arrest or forced relocation for some people/locations unless they have people who can help them with transportation. Moving to a city with public transit would provide the most autonomy, but would also mean uprooting one’s life, leaving family behind, etc. The total impact is indeed very harsh, even if it is necessary for the safety of others.
- gambiting 3y ago>>Depending on location, a bicycle is not a viable alternative. I understand. That doesn't change my stance on the matter.
- haswell 3y ago> get a bicycle or something So the suggestion was untenable from the start. Driving drunk should be penalized, even harshly. But people should have a chance at rehabilitation. In a car dependent society/region, a permanent ban without an opportunity for reform is cruel and unusual punishment. If self driving cars were 100% here right now, or if we had better public transportation, I think it’d be a different story.
- WkndTriathlete 3y agoIn Minnesota drivers recovering from DUI revocation are required to use the "whiskey" plates. (Incidentally the license plate database is incomplete because it does not include the Minnesota "whiskey" plate.) While "whiskey" plates are on the vehicle police officers can legally stop the driver of the vehicle for a impairment check without cause (e.g. without any indications that the driver is under the influence or any traffic violations.) The idea is that the extra enforcement is incentive for the recovering DUI driver to continue to drive safely and re-develop that habit.
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y ago> While "whiskey" plates are on the vehicle police officers can legally stop the driver of the vehicle Not any more. They changed this part of the law a few years ago. Probably around the same time that they (MN) began to implement breathalyzer interlocks where you can't start or drive the car if you're above a certain threshold. However, I think that if you're pulled over and you have an active DUI but are not driving a car with whiskey plates, then it's an immediate loss of license.
- sokoloff 3y agoBeing unable to rent a car or borrow a car while having a license seems like a weird combination of outcomes, so I looked it up. > What happens if I drive a car without whiskey plates? > It is a misdemeanor to drive a car that should have whiskey plates but doesn't. If you illegally remove whiskey plates from your car and are caught, you will go to jail. > When you register for whiskey plates, you'll need to disclose all cars that you own or plan to drive and get whiskey plates for each of them. So, it seems like you could incidentally drive a random car that you didn’t have a reasonable expectation to drive that specific car at a time of being forced to get whiskey plates. https://www.ssdpa.com/articles/plate-impoundment-understanding-whiskey-plates-in-minnesota https://www.ssdpa.com/articles/plate-impoundment-understandi...
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y agoWell, you can do anything as long as you're not caught but the only exception that I'm aware of is if you must drive a vehicle as a part of your job, then it can have regular plates.
- ojosilva 3y agoThe median is 1.8 cars per household in the US, so I'd say, from intuition and experience, that in these states the targeted vehicle will be +95% of the time driven by the DUI offender. But it doesn't matter, because "whiskey plates" are just plain wrong – they are a tongue-in-cheek, populist lawmaker's kool-aid. As a deterrent whiskey plates work best for conscious, god-fearing folk who rarely go over the limit. Besides these types of public shaming schemes can also have just the opposite effect, ie a university bro that looks cool with that whiskey plate or by creating enduring self or public confirmation that you are now that person the plate says you are. Adequate punishment would be to combine fines that are proportional to one's income, use tech like ignition interlock devices and invest on the individual's rehabilitation as a responsible driver, including participating in social services and education programs, among other ordinary measures. Furthermore, permanently revoking a drivers license is a serious punishment in a country where transportation/commute is primarily done by car. Also not all DUI's are the same and there's a principle of proportionality that always applies when sentencing offenders. So strike-3-and-you're-done would be very harsh for the great majority of DUI/DWI cases in the US.
- gnopgnip 3y agoTypically part of the sentence is to require an ignition interlock for multiple years. Driving a car without an ignition interlock is a lifetime driving ban, plus up to two additional years in prison. The details vary by state The plate is there to shame the driver primarily and dissuade them from DUI, secondarily so the police pay more attention to them.
- radlad 3y agoIf an unlicensed driver drives a car in Michigan, they remove its plate: > Unless the vehicle was stolen or used with the permission of a person who did not knowingly permit an unlicensed driver to operate the vehicle, the registration plates of the vehicle shall be canceled by the secretary of state on notification by a peace officer.[1] Similarly, this follows the car rather than the driver. [1] https://www.legislature.mi.gov/(S(s5t1ajhoq2c543ccg5zeslmb))/mileg.aspx?page=GetObject&objectname=mcl-257-904 https://www.legislature.mi.gov/(S(s5t1ajhoq2c543ccg5zeslmb))...
- HWR_14 3y agoI think the state requires all the cars you are likely to drive to get whiskey plates. So it's possible the managers wife was the drunk driver.