7 ms·
[It needs to be said that domestic consumers by and large are insulated from this price variance] Surge pricing has always left me feeling a bit cold. Laura In
by ggm 3y ago
[It needs to be said that domestic consumers by and large are insulated from this price variance]
Surge pricing has always left me feeling a bit cold. Laura Ingalls Wilder writes about her father surge pricing the food and fodder he held in the great storm. If you read around the topic, shopkeepers who did this were lynched.
In effect, its rationing. But unlike state rationing which makes everyone equally unhappy by doling out less than anyone wants (except of course the poor who often find under rationing their quality of life goes up: this happened in the UK in WW2) Surge pricing says "sucks to be poor"
I get it. I get that mechanistically its pure market. I get that some people like this. I just think its stupid and a-social.
I think we should work harder on how to manage the public utility function of power when there isn't enough to go around. '
Thats why sensible economies do in fact have "death panels" in health, because deciding to let the rich live and the poor die is worse. Of course once you call them that, its "game over" -And I have no doubt a power rationing function in the state would become weaponised to make the poor pay, more than the rich because rich people vote more. Surge pricing has the same outcome, but more simply. "it wasn't me, it was the _market_" is a great get-out clause.
You could (for instance) pay people not to use power. Thats a model being trialled in the UK and it was enormously popular. You get everyone with a TOU (time of use) smart meter and you tell them for every KWh they can demonstrate they stop using you will rebate them for that months bill. People RUSH to turn off devices, and sit in the dark with phones on battery to make some vig.
- changoplatanero 3y agoThe other element of surge pricing is that it encourages reallocation of resources to the places where they provide the most value. I'm not sure how you could achieve that benefit with rationing.
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoIt's just that the value allocation is weighted by wealth; there's apparently no value whatsoever in providing essential life-sustaining services to people who can't afford to pay for it.
- Eisenstein 3y agoIs that a value? If you kept that line of thought then only cities would have cell towers or postal delivery, etc.
- jonhohle 3y agoPostal delivery is a government service legally required to provide coverage for all citizens including areas private delivery services don’t operate due to the cost of delivering to those locations. Cell service is private and there are certainly places, even places near major cities, that don’t have cell coverage. The western US is full of areas with no coverage whatsoever, even on highways. There are plenty of utilities that aren’t universally available (water, sewer, phone, cable, Internet, etc.) and are, in fact, limited to populated areas.
- Eisenstein 3y agoMy question was not 'does this exist anywhere' but 'is this a value'...
- vel0city 3y ago> only cities would have cell towers You ever actually look at a cellular availability map? https://fcc.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=6c1b2e73d9d749cdb7bc88a0d1bdd25b https://fcc.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- yial 3y agoI think this map actually paints an optimistic coverage. I’m posting this from an area that shows coverage All around, but if I walk 1/2 mile down the road I won’t have reception for 20 minutes of drive time.
- ggm 3y agoWell in Leningrad during the siege (as it was at the time) they did that by sending more food rations to fighters. It sucked. So there's direct and literal command-economy ways to prioritise. There is a case to be made money is simpler. I'm not going to say I prefer sky faries to decide who gets AC and who doesn't. So, I suppose I'm just saying "value" here is a bit decoupled from "has money"
- hollerith 3y agoSo, basically you don't have an answer to grandparent's objection to rationing.
- jjoonathan 3y agoThe economic notion of value is wealth-weighted. It's true, rationing would struggle to maximize economic value by allocating to well-off hoarders and scalpers. But it also wouldn't properly incentivize consumption minimization, warehousing, and production, and that's the real rub. It's complicated. Just be careful about fudging "economic value = value," because this seemingly harmless approximation actually smuggles in an assumption on the scale of "free market can do no wrong."
- MichaelZuo 3y ago> The economic notion of value is wealth-weighted. No it isn't, nor was the parent necessarily restricting the scope to economics. Many animals such as beavers, bees, ants, dolphins, etc., have notions of value. Way before human society existed and likely will continue to have them long after.
- 8note 3y agoDoes it though? The main element of surge pricing is that it's temporary, which means not-important-for-non-emergencies
- Etrnl_President 3y agoEveryone has an equal chance to prepare for disaster while supplies are still cheap. You either pay now and buy in bulk, or you pay later.
- mxkopy 3y agoConflating value with wealth is just dumb.
- rasz 3y agoSo in emergency like this Texas will use its non existent links to national Grid to "reallocate resources to the places where they provide the most value"?
- irrational 3y ago> People RUSH to turn off devices, and sit in the dark with phones on battery to make some vig. You mean poor people sit in the dark. The rich aren’t going to sit in the dark for a rebate.
- ggm 3y agoYes. And only some people, and in a context of power costs having gone up 6x normal. I'm using it as an example of another mechanism but its the corollary of rich people can pay: you can pay poor people not to use it, instead of just letting them have to not use it. And, you can profit less from the situation. Utility profits should tend to the longterm rate of return, not the surge pricing rates of return. Under surge pricing there are perverse models where it pays the utility not to generate to earn better revenue per cost of unit electricity made.
- atdrummond 3y agoYour last paragraph is basically saying that private utilities aren’t revenue or profit maximizing, which is a pretty extraordinary claim.
- ggm 3y agoIt's a regulated monopoly. Its not pure market, there are public utility oversight issues. Down here, the "gold plating" of the network allowed them to seek year on year 8% rate of return on capital investment. Caused a few problems. Regulator didn't do its job properly. I don't tend to like private power functions, or water, or sewage or gas. I tend to thinking public utility really should be public. Texas Power probably doesn't align with my bad economics. I am sure they seek any profit they can get away with. (and. I stress bad economics. I am pretty sure a lot of people think surge pricing is the least-worst choice. I just question how Texas wound up there)
- wmf 3y agoYou're not wrong in principle, but in this case these prices are not directly passed on to consumers. The downside of that is that consumers have little incentive to conserve. When we do have rolling blackouts it's not fair because houses that happen to be on the same substation as a hospital never get blacked out while others suffer for hours.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoYou'd think some retailers would create some incentives. If a consumer is consuming below expected at a time when the retailer is losing money on every watt, the retailer should split the savings with the consumer to incentivise the behaviour.
- jstarfish 3y agoThey do though...unless you're talking about something other than demand-response programs? SDG&E offers: > Receive a financial incentive if your business meets its goal to reduce energy use on days when conservation is needed. > Earn a bill credit if your business can reduce energy use during a statewide grid emergency. > Earn a monthly bill credit if your business can reduce energy use within 20 minutes of SDG&E calling for conservation.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoI thought right, then. wmf said there was little incentive. I assume they have these sort of incentives for consumers and not just businesses?
- jstarfish 3y agoI'm more familiar with commercial incentives but it does seem there is less incentive for residential customers: > Get a $50 financial incentive for registering your approved smart thermostat and enrolling in the Smart Thermostat program (STP). > Earn an annual bill credit for air cycled by an AC Saver device that SDG&E installs at no cost on your AC unit. > Earn a bill credit if your home can reduce energy use during a statewide grid emergency. They do have an option for some sort of third-party DR arrangement but I don't know anything about it: > Under Electric Rule 32, you have the option to participate in Demand Response programs offered by third-party Demand Response Providers. (https://www.sdge.com/residential/savings-center/energy-saving-programs/reduce-your-use/demand-response-residential-programs https://www.sdge.com/residential/savings-center/energy-savin...)
- x86_64Ubuntu 3y agoInstead of trying some solution from across the pond, TX could do what virtually everyone else does and that's connect to their grid to the rest of the US.
- Sakos 3y agoThe last time Texas had a power crisis, I vaguely remember other grids not having enough spare capacity to be able to help Texas even if they had been connected. Bing connected to the rest of the US isn't necessarily a solution for this problem.
- x86_64Ubuntu 3y agoI don't remember hearing that at all.
- anonporridge 3y agoI do. Oklahoma had the same issues and weren't saved by being part of the larger interconnect. It's just not politically expedient for news corps to elevate these stories. Hating on Texas gets clicks.
- vel0city 3y agoTexas' power failures were largely due to failures in natural gas production. This drove down natural gas supplies across a huge chunk of the country. It had a lot of knock-on effects in neighboring states where they were pushed near their limits as well, especially neighboring areas. Even Minnesota was affected by Texas gas production shortfalls. https://apnews.com/article/why-texas-power-grid-failed-2eaa659d2ac29ff87eb9220875f23b34 https://apnews.com/article/why-texas-power-grid-failed-2eaa6... > This isn’t just happening in Texas, of course. Utilities from Minnesota to Mississippi have imposed rolling blackouts to ease the strain on electrical grids buckling under high demand during the past few days. The amount of energy deficit was like 30GW of power. Oklahoma's entire generation capacity is like 6.7GW. Arkansas has a little over 5GW. Both states were already massively straining to keep the lights on and had rolling blackouts. Even if you decided to redirect all the electricity from both states into Texas you'd still have a shortfall of an additional 20GW of power. So you'd need all the power of like six surrounding states to balance out that deficit. Moving power from even further out causes a lot of challenges, so even if there was a good bit of spare capacity in places like maybe Illinois or something a lot of it wouldn't have made it down there. There's a good chance even if Texas was connected, if gas failed the same way there would have still been massive outages. Now, would gas have failed if required to make the NERC's recommendations? That's another question. But just the basic idea of being on the other interconnection, it probably wouldn't have saved Texas from having massive outages.
- cameldrv 3y agoBack in the old regulated days, the power company would just plan to have enough power for hot days. They would keep around a few old inefficient plants and only run them a few days a year. They might get the TV news to ask people to turn up their thermostats, but that was it. If there wasn’t enough power, somebody would get fired.
- jcranmer 3y agoPower companies are still required to do that. However, there are few things that make electricity less reliable in Texas: 1. Texas refuses to interconnect to the big synchronous grids for silly political reasons. 2. I suspect that Texan "worst-case scenario" planning assumes situations less extreme than are actually happening.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y ago> for silly political reasons An interesting side-effect of this is that the texas power providers make out like bandits during these surge-price situations. Much more than they would if they were connected to the national grid and were able to draw on it to ease peak demand. The incentives all line up for them to remain disconnected and to keep power-generating supply minimal to reap the profits that come with surge pricing.
- vel0city 3y agoAnother interesting side-effect of this deregulation style is it splits up power producers from the actual utility providers managing the lines which (can) allow for more competition in generation. Those big spikes in prices are a signal there's money to be made building battery systems or more PV systems. Unlike places where there's a government-granted monopoly on generation construction, pretty much anyone can put solar panels in a field and start being a producer, you don't need to get the government's permission as long as you meet the requirements to hook up to the grid. Your idea is based around the concept that only a few orgs can participate in generation. Its just not true in the end, there's a pretty competitive market in generation. Its why Texas has added grid-sale solar and wind faster than the majority of other states; it doesn't take some entrenched interest to decide to build. Texas hasn't been experiencing these spikes because of some kind of captive industry pulling the strings and driving artificial shortages a la Enron. Its been having these spikes because we're consistently demanding more electricity than any state in the US has ever demanded at once, practically every day. Power demand and generation records pretty much keep getting smashed. Despite the fact its generally pretty easy to get new plants online compared to other places we're still having challenges building fast enough to meet demand.
- ars 3y agoIf you don't have surge pricing you have shortages. The only reason for the surge is supply doesn't meet demand. If you keep the price the same, people will buy until there's none left. And then you are in worse shape than if you had the surge pricing. With surge pricing people will switch on extra (expensive) supply because it's worth it, or they'll sit in the dark to avoid having to pay a high bill. You can do what you say: Encourage people to cut usage, and in fact Texas did that a while, and everyone with such an electricity contract enjoyed the cheaper prices, until there was a surge and they were shut off. People decided that that was worse and now such contracts in residencies are rare. All your suggestions have been tried and found to be worse at the end. Surge pricing is the best option available. Mostly because it leads to more supply, and that's the ultimate solution.
- Dylan16807 3y agoThat's the texas grid method. Many other grids directly pay for spare capacity all year long, instead of paying entirely via pricing spikes. You might still need some surge pricing under such a model, but it's a lot less intense.
- michaelmrose 3y agoIf it's really better how come virtually nobody on the planet actually buys electricity that way on the consumer level and people who aren't Texans manage to keep the lights on?
- ars 3y agoNot sure where you are getting your data. A 2 second google search finds https://www.dsoelectric.com/interruptible-residential-rate https://www.dsoelectric.com/interruptible-residential-rate in Kansas. Google "Interruptible Residential Rate" and you'll see it's quite common. Sometimes done with 2 meters: An interruptible one for heat pumps and a regular one to everything else. I'm actually pretty sure it's available in basically all states - they often list it as "pay a cheaper rate, and let the utility control your thermostat in times of high demand". Go check - you might find it's available to you as well. And BTW, Texas has a better track record than California on keeping the lights on. They've had a single major power outage caused by high demand. California on the other hand..... The reason they have a reputation in your mind is the same reason people make fun of Florida: They are very open with their data, so you know more about it.
- gizmo686 3y agoFor the most part, we have solved this problem with electricity. The wholesale price of electricity varies contiually due to market/grid conditions. However, regular consumers do not purchase electricy wholesale. Instead, they buy electricity at a fixed rate from an energy provider, which then buys at the spot price [0]. The energy provider charges a premium (on average) for the service, and utilizes various financial instruments to mitigate their downside risk. Some markets allow energy providers to pass the spot price onto their constumers. This allows them to offer, on average, lower prices; but exposes the customers to the downside risk of high spot prices. Of course, those customers sign up for the low price, and do not purchase any of the financial instruments that make the fixed priced system viable. When spot prices get too high, they have a serious problem, that can infect the entire market if too many people are on such a plan and cannot pay. Texas ran into this problem a few years back. I would like to think they outlawed spot pricing for normal customers because of it, but I'm not sure. Regardless, I would assume that most people learned their lesson and are now on fixed priced contracts. Major electricity users also tend to be larger industrial or commercial entities, who can handle spot prices better than consumers. In addition to being able to purchase the same financial instruments energy provides do. These users are also in a position to significantly reduce electricity usage when given the proper market incentive, allowing both them and the grid the ability to realize the theoretical benefit of spot prices. [0] I am not familiar with every market. There may be somewhere where people buy directly from the utility, although the overall story is mostly the same.
- terom 3y agoIn the Finnish market the situation changed drastically during 2022-2023 as the energy market futures went through the roof and fixed-price contracts became crazy expensive (10-20× "normal" kWh prices). I'm not sure if there are any official public statistics, but a recent news article [1] puts eg. 30% of consumers on spot price contracts, and during the spring they were the vast majority (70%) of new contracts. The news media reporting is mostly about the people locked into two-year 30-60c/kWh contracts, and not the people paying the recent <3c/kWh spot price averages. Recently [2] a combination of several simultaneous planned/unplanned outages and low wind power generation have bumped the spot market prices back up again, so let's see. [1] https://www.aamulehti.fi/talous/art-2000009773460.html https://www.aamulehti.fi/talous/art-2000009773460.html [2] https://www.fingrid.fi/ajankohtaista/tiedotteet/2023/monet-yhtaaikaiset-tapahtumat-vaikuttavat-sahkon-hintaan/ https://www.fingrid.fi/ajankohtaista/tiedotteet/2023/monet-y...
- somenameforme 3y agoThis article's misleading. It's talking about spot price contracts. This is the price electric providers themselves pay and certain large businesses which opt into the potentially extreme volatility to achieve lower overall pricing. If there are any 'normal' consumers on spot-contracts, it's exceptionally rare. Just about everybody's on fixed price contracts, which have been trending downward in cost. The other extreme side of this coin that you will sometimes see is spot-prices going negative. Needless to say, customers don't receive a check in the mail as their bill during those times, anymore than they suddenly get a 5 figure bill in these sort of times.
- theolivenbaum 3y agoIsn't that the whole issue in Texas, that end customers can decide to pay the spot prices? Something similar happened last time they had issues: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/20/us/texas-storm-electric-bills.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/20/us/texas-storm-electric-b...
- vel0city 3y agoResidential customers can't really sign up for spot pricing plans anymore, and even back then those plans were extremely rare.
- somenameforme 3y agoYeah, the article seems to clarify this: --- 'Many of the people who have reported extremely high charges are customers of a small company that provides electricity at wholesale prices.. The model can be risky. Last week, foreseeing a huge jump in wholesale prices, the company encouraged all of its 29,000 customers to switch to another provider when the storm arrived. But many were unable to do so.' --- So a fraction of 29,000 people in a state of 30 million. Things like this are such a shame because being able to buy electric wholesale would be such a luxury. You could pay rock bottom prices 99% of the time, but of course it'd come with the responsibility that you need to be able to handle those 1% events without just relying entirely on your electric. And the natural/reactionary outcome of stuff like this is the government will simply completely prohibit people of insufficient means from being able to sign up for spot priced electric contracts, and the gap just gets even wider.
- remarkEon 3y ago>I think we should work harder on how to manage the public utility function of power when there isn't enough to go around. We should've built enough nuclear power plants to have basically infinite electricity so that we don't care about events like this, as far as their impact on electricity consumption. Alas, we didn't and now we're stuck dealing with the consequences of a "free" market that has limited, if any, means to price in tail events like this.
- Gigachad 3y agoSurge pricing seems like an effective way at getting end users to reduce their usage when needed. If you have a fixed pricing, even in times of extreme demand, I’m still going to crank my aircon to the max, run my gaming PC, start the washing machine, etc. I have no incentive to change my usage based on network load. Meanwhile if pricing is dynamic, I’ll time my appliances to run at peak renewables times when power is plentiful, I’ll chose to reduce my heating and cooling when it’s not. The alternatives are rolling blackouts, and those iot thermostats that block you from using your air con when the power companies say.
- hnben 3y agoI think dynamic prices in itself are a good thing for the reasons you mentioned. On the other hand: if the end-user prices rely solely on market-pricing, than utility-companies don't have any incentives to provide a stable energy generation (e.g. via utility-scale storage, or peaker plants). I think a good solution would be involve some dynamic pricing together with a capped upper and lower bounds.
- thebruce87m 3y ago> You could (for instance) pay people not to use power. Thats a model being trialled in the UK and it was enormously popular. You get everyone with a TOU (time of use) smart meter and you tell them for every KWh they can demonstrate they stop using you will rebate them for that months bill. People RUSH to turn off devices, and sit in the dark with phones on battery to make some vig. More sustainable than that is charging people less for off-peak use. My EV charges between 23.30 and 05.30 for a quarter of the KWh rate than normal. We can even schedule the dishwasher and washing machine to take advantage of the cheap rate.
- Fluorescence 3y ago> But unlike state rationing which makes everyone equally unhappy by doling out less than anyone wants So first up, upper class goods like champagne, caviar and dining out at restaurants was not rationed so saying everyone suffered equally is not true. > except of course the poor who often find under rationing their quality of life goes up: this happened in the UK in WW2) To describe rationing as a quality of life improvement that did not upset the poor is insulting frankly. It implies the poor obtained a benefit by losing food choice. It feels like the type of dehumanisation that has people saying that slave labourers benefit from the exercise. I am quite old, and I can tell you that the scarcity mindset of the war permanently scarred my grandparents and parent relationships with food and waste in ways that would be unrecognisable today. I wonder if you think rationing meant the poor were given a more equitable share but that is not the case. You still had to pay and food prices rose during the war. At best there is the argument that lowering meat and sugar improved people's diet but there are counter claims based on disease rates. It is a claim skewed by modern issues with obesity instead of contemporary health issues from being underweight. A suet pudding and steak and kidney pie would be like medicine for those at the sharp end. Not to mention, the shortages often hit the healthy things like fruit and veg. Having to queue with your ration book and come home empty handed was not a quality of life improvement. There were some health improvements from essentially the opposite of rationing e.g. government catering engineered with calorie targets for workers supporting the war effort.
- tomjen3 3y agoSurge pricing does make it so that factories are incentivized to stop producing temporarily. That will cut much more than shutting of a few lighbulbs.