7 ms·
> The bottom line: If you have a .com domain name, or other at-risk domain names like .net, you are subject to US domestic laws and jurisdiction. I don't under
by skrebbel 15y ago
> The bottom line: If you have a .com domain name, or other at-risk domain names like .net, you are subject to US domestic laws and jurisdiction.
I don't understand this. If you buy an American product and use it for business, you're an American? Except without the benefits?
Isn't that like Taiwan (or, well, ROC) filing an extradition request when I use my Asus laptop to pirate Taiwanese movies??
Or like Miele dragging me before the German courts because I vacuum cleaned (loudly) on sunday?
What am I missing? Is US law really this fucked up, or is the article exaggerating?
- lawn 15y agoThat's exactly right. Do we still look down on third-world countries and their lack of democracy? Do we make fun of Chinese censuration? Sadly I've stopped doing that.
- radu_floricica 15y agoIt's not the US law that is at fault here, but the extradition treaties. It should be the same as being tried in a Pakistani court for being an atheist while you're born and lived your whole life in Holland: you shouldn't care. But because US is a de facto empire...
- tptacek 15y agoThat's not how extradition works. It depends on the treaty, but most of them stipulate that extraditable crimes must be recognized by both jurisdictions. You obviously can't be extradited to Pakistan for being an atheist. Because we hear so often about legal proceedings against piracy in the US, I think we have a cognitive bias that suggests piracy is more criminal here than in Europe. That's mostly not the case. For instance: the UK's criminal copyright infringement laws, which date back to the late '80s, are just as stringent as ours.
- nextparadigms 15y agoSo then why was the UK guy extradited if what he did wasn't even illegal in UK?
- tptacek 15y agoWhat he did was illegal in the UK, and has been since 1988.
- philjohn 15y agoThen they should be forced to pursue a private prosecution in the UK, where the crimes were committed instead of relying on a technicality that allows them to wrest "jurisdiction".
- tptacek 15y agoWhy? He has better due process protections in the US than he does in the UK. I think you just don't like the idea of people being prosecuted for crimes that involve file sharing.
- radu_floricica 15y agoTaking him in another country by force for what is essentially a civil matter is not ok. The process can take a long while, and all this time I assume he will be in custody - which most likely would not happen if he were to stand trial in his own country. Plus yeah, we really don't like that he's being prosecuted for that. In all the talk about whether it's illegal or not it's too seldom that it's said "the law is just wrong". It protects too much the copyright holders, and the evidence that this is actually for the common good is getting sketchier and sketchier.
- smsm42 15y agoYes, US law is really like that. Of course, "subject to US law" is a bit of an exaggeration - you subject-ness extends only as far as .com address is concerned, AFAIK. But if the US government thinks you violated US laws, it can seize your .com domain. Unfortunately, taking a domain is much easier than taking physical property, so US government (due to intensive lobbying by copyright mafia) instituted such laws and procedures as to allow it. Next time your local copyright mafia raises its head, remember what they are capable of.
- idonthack 15y ago>Of course, "subject to US law" is a bit of an exaggeration - you subject-ness extends only as far as .com address is concerned, AFAIK. No, as the article says, you can be extradited to the US to face trial. Another story: http://torrentfreak.com/pirating-uk-student-to-be-extradited-to-the-us-120313/ http://torrentfreak.com/pirating-uk-student-to-be-extradited...
- tptacek 15y agoUK law is like that too! People have attempted to have US citizens found civilly liable under the UK's (much stricter) libel laws in exactly the same jurisdictional razzle-dazzle as is being applied here.
- rmc 15y agoYou are not subjected to US law. However verisign have complete control over .com namespace, and they are subject to US law and US courts. Verisign will take your .com off you if the US counts tell them to.
- excuse-me 15y agoUnless one day in the future you have to change planes in the US and suddenly find yourself arrested for running a used DVD site. Or you can't fly inside Europe because the airlines share a no-fly list with the DHS and you are a US felon.
- rmc 15y agoYep. Things get 'troublesome'.
- drusenko 15y agoThe exact same thing happened to Arrington in the UK with regards to a frivolous libel suit he chose not to defend. He couldn't visit the UK or risk being arrested. National laws differ. We each make our own. If you are found guilty of a US law, either (a) don't do that, or (b) don't come to the US. This is no different than any other country on the planet, the US is just bigger, so their laws may impact you more than Iran's, but no-one is forcing you to visit or do business in the US or Iran.
- okamiueru 15y agoExcept that they have extradited people on multiple occasions.
- phatbyte 15y agoYes, the american dream, the land of the free and the home of the brave.
- lwat 15y ago.. and fuck the rest of the world!
- drusenko 15y agoThe concept of jurisdiction is complicated, but often comes down to "do you have the authority to make me care". Any country in the world can make laws about whatever they'd like with regards to things they have control over. In fact, they can make laws about things they don't have control over, but in practice, you can safely ignore getting sued in Iran unless you plan on visiting Iran. In this case, things are pretty simple: .com, .net, .org, etc are US domain names, administered by a US company, and the US has the authority to subject you to their jurisdiction (because so much of it happens in the US). If you would like to use a US domain name, you are subject to US law. If you live outside the US and would not like to be subject to US law, then don't use a US domain name or a US web host. The United States isn't doing anything special here that every other country in the world isn't also doing. If I buy and use a .fr domain name and host servers in France, I am subject to French and EU jurisdiction.
- excuse-me 15y agoThis doesn't apply only to servers hosted in the US. The US is claiming that because .com domains must ultimately be registered by a US registrar (since they have ultimate control of the DNS) then even if you have no servers in the US, no customers in the US and no links with the US - you are under US jurisdiction. It's like France having jurisdiction if you use a French word in your product.
- drusenko 15y agoNo, it's exactly like if I registered a .fr domain name. France has jurisdiction over that domain name, and can shut it down if they'd like. The US has jurisdiction over the .com domain. If you have no US customers, no servers in the US and no other links to the US -- you may have your domain shutdown, but that's it. I very much doubt you would be extradited to the US in that situation as it does not involve the US at all. But the US having extradition abilities with other countries' foreign nationals that it finds to be criminals is a separate issue entirely from their jurisdiction over .com, .net, .org etc. [edited for clarity]
- 15y ago
- sp332 15y agoVerisign is the registrar for .com, and they are based in the USA. So the registration of a .com domain is (currently) under US jurisdiction.
- rorrr 15y agoIt's because that statement is not legally correct. Yes, they can take the domain away, but they can't extradite you and prosecute you, unless you're in one of the countries with mutual extradition treaties. It's not the US that fucked up, it's your country that caved to the US pressure.
- tptacek 15y agoWith very few exceptions (basically, China, Ukraine and Russia), the countries that don't have mutual extradition with the US are underdeveloped, poor, repressive, unstable, theocratic (the Vatican!), or all of the above. I'm not sure what kind of pressure you think has to be brought to bear to get two countries to agree to extradite. Extradition treaties are the norm, not the exception. Extradition is not a product of American imperialism.
- WildUtah 15y agoWith very few exceptions (basically, China, Ukraine and Russia), the countries that don't have mutual extradition with the US are underdeveloped, poor, repressive, unstable, theocratic -Russia is plenty repressive. -China is poor and repressive. -What about Morocco? Andorra? Slovenia? -Maybe also Namibia, Botswana, Mongolia, Croatia? There are some nice exceptions, but not a lot. You're mostly subject to full US jurisdiction everywhere in the world. And if the USA police want to sieze your assets, including your domain names, in New Zealand they're going to do so without any trouble. For now you can smoke in Amsterdam without going to jail in the USA, but only because the US government doesn't care yet.
- tptacek 15y agoI guess I agree about Russia and China but I think you're making my point for me.
- spindritf 15y agoThere's extradition, and then there's extradition of own nationals/citizens. The latter happens but is not the norm and many fairly civilized countries, France or Germany† for example, generally don't do it. † some exceptions related to the European Arrest Warrant apply