5 ms·
Eh, nothingburger. As the original source of this data notes in their report, global IT systems energy demand has only slightly expanded in the past decade, bec
by jeffbee 3y ago
Eh, nothingburger. As the original source of this data notes in their report, global IT systems energy demand has only slightly expanded in the past decade, because the countervailing trend is that workloads are migrating from tragic-comic corporate datacenters with PUE of 2 or worse, into the cloud where the PUE is 1.1 or so. And in the cloud the power that is delivered to the CPU is better used due to oversubscription, multitenancy, and so forth. Finally, because large-scale operators often also build their own renewable energy facilities, their fraction of global CO2 is much less than their fraction of energy consumed.
Naturally you should design your systems for maximum efficiency, but since operating expenses are closely approximated by power consumption you are already correctly incentivized to do so.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoIT is also about ~10% of the global economy...
- theluketaylor 3y agoPlus data centers are low hanging fruit for decarbonization. Everything (apart from diesel backup generators) is already electric, so as the grid de-carbonizes so do data centers. As you mention, DC operators are already highly incentivized to reduce energy costs, so as wind and solar power continue to drop in costs DC operators will want to fund or buy green power as often as possible. Getting backup power to be carbon neutral will be a little more challenging in a DC, but it's a walk in the park compared to many sectors. Shelf-stable biofuel is already fairly accessible and using grid scale batteries can reduce the need to combust anything (plus open power arbitrage opportunities).
- pge 3y agoI’m not sure datacenters have a great incentive to reduce energy costs (a lesson I learned the hard way after investing in a DC energy optimization software company). People costs are much greater than energy costs. Electricity just doesn’t cost that much in the grand scheme of things. If additional energy spend is necessary to ensure uptime, the choice is an easy one.
- Spooky23 3y agoData centers are the cost. I worked for an entity that automated key operational workflows. They went from 15,000 employees in that division to 4,000. The energy cost of those buildings, overhead, etc far exceeded the datacenter, and the datacenter cost and use gets whittled down every year.
- toomuchtodo 3y ago> People costs are much greater than energy costs. Can you prove this assertion? The first page of Google results indicates energy is a greater cost than labor, with figures ranging from 60-70 percent of total operating costs. (i owned a small web hosting company in the early 00s, and am somewhat familiar with the per sq ft cost model of colos and datacenters in general, having had to contract for space and perform part of the buildout myself)
- closeparen 3y agoI think this is taking an expansive view of labor e.g. writing all datacenter applications as optimal code in low level languages. The general disinterest in performance/efficiency work even for large scale datacenters is a major theme of Dan Luu’s writing. I’m not sure how that applies to the rest of the industry but I can attest that my company’s performance engineering team has been zeroed in every round of layoffs we’ve ever had.
- peter422 3y agoThe larger your footprint in the cloud is, the larger incentive you have to make it more efficient though. I think it’s a somewhat self-correcting problem. The biggest players are running highly, highly efficient software.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- closeparen 3y agoDan Luu’s point is the big players are in fact leaving 7+ figure optimizations on the table all the time, and not really caring when they get found. We’re of course free to disbelieve him, but it tracks with my experience.
- hgomersall 3y agoFor the most parts your points are good, but the large scale facilities buying up renewable generation resource both hides the true energy cost whilst consuming that renewable resource. I suspect data centres are good candidates for such resource usage since they can be built optimally for generation capacity, but it's definitely possible the numbers could be skewed by the data providers' ability to hide energy consumption whilst having a net global impact.
- b112 3y agoAnd then some yahoo thought that a 3 line js "library", should pull in 4000 other malware laden, bloated js "libraries", and all out power savings were for naught. Just the power consumption in browsers... Thanks node.
- nitwit005 3y agoDon't forget people are still migrating from paper. Paper and printing are some of the most energy intensive industries.
- robertlagrant 3y agoIndeed. Also, Zoom calls replacing car journeys.
- shrubble 3y agoFrom 2005 to now, how much more computation and network transfer, can be done per kwh? No more T1s and T3s... it's all optical; and the efficiency of CPUs and amount of RAM per CPU, has increased greatly as well.
- Libcat99 3y agoAnd how much more computation is needed per transaction? Per person? Are we really making more efficient systems if they take 100x the compute to fulfill the same transaction.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ilyt 3y agoThe efficiency of hardware certainly grew but inefficiency of software grew with it. Why all sites don't load in 500ms or less ? Our compute power grew few magnitudes but sites still take few hundred ms (hell, second) to render on server side and then burn more CPU on client side
- shrubble 3y agohttps://learnbchs.org/ https://learnbchs.org/ is somewhat of a joke response; but there are plenty of other performance oriented ways to cut that down...
- Quindecillion 3y agoWhat I find interesting is that most of what you said is applicable to Bitcoin miners too.
- copperx 3y agoIsn't it interesting how the word "nothingburger" isn't politically neutral? I wonder how many words are like that.
- jeffbee 3y agoIn what way? I can determine no political alignment of the word after a brief search.