3 ms·
Absolutely not. People bond because they like being around each other or because they share some goal. Making that goal a negative of "destroy X" or "protect ag
by marcosdumay 3y ago
Absolutely not. People bond because they like being around each other or because they share some goal. Making that goal a negative of "destroy X" or "protect against X" is a very clear sign that the group isn't healthy.
EDIT: Where X here means an specific group of people.
- jl6 3y ago“Protect against X” is a bit of a Rorschach test… depending on the X, the healthy attitude can be found either on the offensive or defensive side.
- marcosdumay 3y agoI meant X on both of those as a group of people. I recon that it could have been clearer. And yeah, there are a few exceptional cases when protecting against some other group is a very important goal. The group gathered around that goal can be even right, but I've never seen a case where it was healthy, and one should be always wary of those groups evolving into something exclusively destructive.
- tetris11 3y agoOkay I'll bite. Emacs and Org-Mode, these are groups that require you to do a public good with the idea that you're protecting against many X's. To do this, one can contribute in any meaningful way, big or small. For a cult, it seems to only do good, despite one of its unspoken tenets being to keep corporate interests at bay. Is that bad?
- _thisdot 3y agoTake example of politics. The left "hates" right and vice-versa. The bond within them is tight and has been going for a long time. Whereas the moderates/centrists party will never have a future because they don't have a common enemy to hate.
- Nevermark 3y agoRadical moderates would get vilified by both sides as insidious milquetoast charlatans! What a sad but funny thought.