2 ms·
Evergrande has been insolvent for a long time. The government kept patching it up, but anyone could tell just by looking at the data. So you know, if the numbe
by seanmcdirmid 3y ago
Evergrande has been insolvent for a long time. The government kept patching it up, but anyone could tell just by looking at the data.
So you know, if the numbers say your debt is waaaaaay over your asset (they’ve been leveraged since 2008 or so, most Chinese real estate companies, just that Evergrande was exceptionally so), but the government keeps you alive for 10 years anyways, is the trader wrong or you know, the government.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoAlso, the reason the HK court gave for its judgement is not that Andrew Left lied or was touting fake numbers or anything like that, but the literal judgement is that “He had the right data but didn’t understand how the Chinese market was different from the West.”
- hnfong 3y agoI'm reading the raw report - https://www.mmt.gov.hk/files/Evergrande_Report.pdf https://www.mmt.gov.hk/files/Evergrande_Report.pdf It looks like Left's concerns were largely legitimate, but he wasn't familiar enough with the standard accounting and industry practices that the authorities were able to nitpick details he got wrong, and he probably used a bit of hyperbolic tone to describe the real concerns about the Chinese property market. The problems with the Chinese property market isn't "accounting fraud" as alleged because everybody is doing it in the open, I guess. I think Left's main "fault" was that he shorted the stock, triggered a small panic, and profited from the deal. I mean, that's market manipulation unless the allegations are true, and it really is unfortunate that when it comes to truth, it's more like "what I said might be technically wrong, but I'm telling the truth!"
- futhey 3y agoHe profited from the panic, not the eventual failure of Evergrande. So the court ruled in accordance with the intent of the law. If they were legally insolvent back then and his information forced them to immediately declare bankruptcy, this short would have been above board.