5 ms·
'No-water' hydropower turns England's hills into green and pleasant batteries
- gardenfelder 3y agoBest to open in a private window since they do not let you control cookies. See also [1] Short Vimeo video [2] [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26062698 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26062698 [2] https://vimeo.com/495158864 https://vimeo.com/495158864
- Sayrus 3y agoThey do actually open a pop-up to allow selected cookies, although you need two clicks to say No and only one to say Yes to all. The Vimeo video is not rated which requires login. I'm very curious about the longevity of such a fluid, wouldn't there be issues with evaporation and particles falling to the bottom of the downstream station?
- djmips 3y agoDidn't work for me
- isoprophlex 3y agoIf only TFA mentioned what is actually in the working fluid...
- cinntaile 3y agoI found the following quote: > RheEnergise said it invented the new high-density fluid, known as R-19. Chief executive Stephen Crosher told Professional Engineering that the liquid is a fine-milled suspended solid in water, with low viscosity and low abrasion characteristics. The base material is used in oral medication applications, in a similar way that chalk is used as a bulking agent for pills and tablets. He said the raw materials are common and available, including in the UK, and the fluid could either be manufactured on-site or at a depot. [0] Maybe someone knowledgeable about oral medication applications has any idea. [0] https://www.imeche.org/news/news-article/high-density-pumped-hydro-could-be-installed-on-thousands-of-small-hills https://www.imeche.org/news/news-article/high-density-pumped...
- gadders 3y agoI wonder if it's kaolin?
- isoprophlex 3y agoInteresting! I wonder how the economics work out wrt aging of the liquid, abrasion (low abrasion != no abrasion)... and of course how environmentally friendly it is to dispose of. It seems hardly worth it to use a specialized fluid for "only" a 2.5x density multiplier, on first glance.
- Hextinium 3y agoAfter looking up mining slurry densities limestone is 2.7x the density of water. Calcium carbonate (limestone) is also used for filler in some medications. I'm pretty sure its just limestone slurry.
- 3y ago
- pyrolistical 3y agoSo something worse than water? It’s not clear what this liquid really is
- dwheeler 3y agoMuch depends on the fluid. Is it toxic? What happens when (not if) it leaks?
- ajb 3y agoGiven they only need to specify two properties of the material (density, and ability to be suspended in water), they should be spoilt for choice; and would be pretty stupid if they didn't pick something inert. This is not like semiconductor manufacturing or something where they need to find a material with obscure properties. My guess is the main reason for not specifying the material is that they will pick whatever is cheapest locally to each development.
- pfdietz 3y agoThe surfactant might be a problem, but the mineral particles are almost certainly something very cheap and common, like clay.
- raverbashing 3y agoQuestion is how abrasive it is and how does that affect the turbines and pumps
- pfdietz 3y agoThe particles would have to be extremely small to not fall out of suspension, so I don't think they'd be very abrasive. The thickness of the viscous part of the boundary layer in water is maybe 0.1 microns (if the water is moving at 10 m/s). Particles smaller than this would be slowed before striking the surface. If the particles are making the liquid more viscous the viscous part of the boundary layer will be proportionally thicker.
- coolspot 3y agoFrom their patent [1]: > the working fluid is a slurry comprising a suspension of mineral particles and a surfactant in water [1] - https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/c5/20/54/60053718c6e1b9/GB2600262B.pdf https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/c5/20/54/6005371...
- fasterik 3y agoSo the article is wrong in multiple ways. Not only is "no-water hydropower" a contradiction in terms, but when you look into it, it is in fact using water. This is the status quo for science journalism, unfortunately.
- psunavy03 3y agoIt's the status quo for any kind of journalism. Read anything you either do for a living or have life knowledge or education about, and the credulous BS just leaps off the page. Pick any controversial issue, do some research on it, and you'll realize how much "common knowledge" is misinformation due to crap media coverage.
- fasterik 3y agoI think good journalism still exists, you just need to pay for it. I don't see the Economist getting basic facts wrong, even in topics I'm familiar with. The main problem is that there is far more money in ad-driven content than high quality subscriber content.
- KennyBlanken 3y agoThere's discussion of something to stir both reservoirs to keep the mineral particles from settling. Which seems rather energy-intensive and wasteful. There's no specification for what kind of minerals or surfactant, or what kind of properties they'd need to have. No discussion of how to pump an abrasive mixture without lots of expensive maintenance. It, frankly, sounds like they're saying "sand!" What happens if the surfactant leaks or there's a dam break? The scale of disaster from something like this is pretty insane; they're proposing what amounts to a ready-made mudslide behind a dam. There's also discussion of using the water to cool the generators, like that's somehow novel...and for some strange reason, heat pumps and geothermal heatsinking? This feels like patent trolling. It reminds me of crazy-board-of-string-and-photos meme guy. "OK, so we have a hydropower plant! BUT, BUT, we put SAND in the water! And and we need some things to stir the water to keep the sand in suspension. We can tack on this geothermal well! And cool the pumps with the water!"
- jjk166 3y agoI have to imagine building 2.5 swimming pools worth of water storage is cheaper than filling a single swimming pool with a heavy liquid. They typically go for $100-$1000/kg, with the non-toxic ones of course being the more expensive. No idea what the article is talking about wrt being able to utilize lower heights, as the amount of power you can get from a certain drop is independent of density. Higher density decreases the size of the pipes and turbines, so there is a potential economic benefit, but it doesn't change what locations are viable.
- isoprophlex 3y agoI'm imagining two connected olympic swimming pools, at the base and on top of a mountain, filled with liquid mercury...
- theragra 3y agohttps://www.bing.com/images/create/two-connected-olympic-swimming-pools2c-at-the-base-/64e109e8c05c4c7a8429d3b5fdbde0e0?id=ovsqMVH7cSSzhz3A36w9hg%3d%3d&view=detailv2&idpp=genimg&FORM=GCRIDP&mode=overlay https://www.bing.com/images/create/two-connected-olympic-swi...
- ragebol 3y agoThe equation for potential energy is U = m ⋅ g ⋅ h, so higher density factors into higher mass (per unit volume) so directly into higher energy storage capacity.
- 3y ago
- Reason077 3y ago> "100MW in storage capacity" Sigh. A MW is not a measure of storage capacity, it's a measure of momentary power. Do they mean it can store 100 MWh of energy? Or do they mean it can generate up to 100 MW of power? Journalists always seem to get confused by this[1], but it's surprising to see "Recharge News", of all people, making such a mistake! [1] The Times once famously published an entire headline anti-EV article that claimed the UK would need to build dozens of new nuclear power plants to power them. But it quickly turned out they had just gotten GW and GWh confused!
- nurettin 3y agoI think it is talking about power capacity, not the discharge rate.
- kwk1 3y agoA watt has dimensions of energy over time. It cannot be used to express a measure of energy unless you multiply it by time, as in a watt-hour.
- ishtanbul 3y agoI work in energy storage. This is not totally wrong, its just omitting the duration. 100MW only describes the rate at which the battery can discharge. The duration would be expressed in MWhours (mwh) so a 100MW/200MWh system would be able to discharge its full tank in 2 hours. You need to know the MWh to know how physically large the system is.
- danjc 3y agoCame here to say the same
- psunavy03 3y agoEither way, "building dozens of nuclear power plants" is something that should have been done decades ago. Yes, waste handling is a concern for the local environment of a specific area and needs to be taken seriously. But given that climate change is a GLOBAL concern, how much better off would we as a planet have been doing prudent risk management and pressing forward with nuclear power as opposed to listening to the hysterical FUD of people who call themselves "environmentalists?"
- _joel 3y agoThe state of the UK's waterways is atrocious. I'm not really keen on them filling the hills with "fluid", personally.
- lostlogin 3y agoIf the dense fluid is sewage sludge, they may be into something.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI'm super sceptical of these types of approaches, to the point that I often question some of the weird financial incentives that can cause money to be put into stuff like this in the first place. Simple physics says that gravity is actually a pretty poor energy storage mechanism (see other fanciful ideas about stacking heavy blocks). Pumped water storage is about the only form that actually makes sense from a cost/energy storage perspective because (a) in nearly all those cases the reservoirs already exist, and (b) you're pumping a lot more than a couple Olympic-swimming pools worth of water. And even then the costs can be giant - LA was looking into a $3 billion project to use pumped storage behind the Hoover Dam a few years ago, not sure what happened with that. There is just so much "green washing" going on these days, I think it's more important to focus on things we know will work, or improvements to ideas that already work.
- audunw 3y agoPeople don’t understand the grid energy storage market. Some think it’s only about storing as much energy as possible over as much time as possible. That’s not the full picture. Response time and ability to handle several cycles a day is also very important for many grid energy storage applications. The stacking of heavy blocks you mention is actually a very decent idea. No, it’s not going to compete with pumped hydro for seasonal storage. But that was never the point. It’s about shifting load a few hours a couple of times every day. Perhaps with some spare capacity to help with a day or two with less power. We need both solutions. Pumped hydro is not that great for cycling often and rapid response and it’s much harder to find good sites to build it. Big water reservoirs are extremely damaging to the environment. They obviously destroy all land based life on the land they claim, and the constant cycling up and down of the water lever means the conditions for life in the water is atrocious as well. A fun fact is that for hydro power plants it’s becoming viable to install battery energy storage on site. Wouldn’t think that makes sense would you? By putting some of the power regulation loads on the battery they can run the hydro power plant production more evenly, reducing pressure variations that causes more wear and tear, which increases long term maintenance costs. Don’t watch those YouTube “debunkers” for insight into these kinds of topic. They rarely do more than 10 min of research. (I know one of them did a video on Energy Vault that always gets shared in these conversations, despite the fact that there’s not a single valid point in the video)
- prisoner3986 3y ago[flagged]
- prisoner3986 3y ago[flagged]
- waynecochran 3y agoEssentially pumping a denser-than-water fluid up hill underground. OK. Here in the PNW that is what all these ugly windmills should be doing in the Columbia Gorge.
- adrianmonk 3y agoMore direct / detailed info here: https://www.rheenergise.com/how-it-works https://www.rheenergise.com/how-it-works https://www.rheenergise.com/faq https://www.rheenergise.com/faq They have their own denser-than-water fluid called R-19. The formula isn't public. They say it's "environmentally benign" and the ingredients are "common and available". The viscosity is comparable to milk. They believe they can make mechanical parts (pumps, turbines, etc.) that can handle the denser fluid. They say the cost is "broadly similar" to regular pumped hydro.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sinuhe69 3y agoI wonder why the dense liquid? Only to save the storage tank or will it able to generate higher power? Probably both because the potential is proportional to the specific weight of the medium. Pumped-storage hydroelectricity is certainly no novelty.