7 ms·
Flipping the model presents a new way to treat sleep apnoea
- king_magic 3y agoOral appliances for sleep apnea are such a step forward. Have been using one for a few years now, never had to go the CPAP route. Plus stops me from grinding my teeth at night.
- taeric 3y agoThe number of people that are using a CPAP is honestly mind boggling to me. The number that have gotten one, and then refuse to wear it is even crazier. I remember when I first got one, I assumed it was some niche thing that was going to be unheard of from everyone I talked to. Turns out, not so much. I don't think it has been a miracle device, by any measure. But I'm curious what makes it so hard to stick to for so many.
- TheBlight 3y agoIs it really difficult to understand why people don't like sleeping with a mask that makes noise?
- JimtheCoder 3y agoIf you are asleep, can you hear it?
- awb 3y agoFalling asleep with noise might be difficult for some. Also, some people have parters in the room where they sleep and the noise might bother them as well.
- dryrun 3y agoYour partner hears it, you may hear it when it has moved a bit and the air is leaking, you hear it when you try to go to sleep and the overpressure safety valve is next to your pillow and making a wheezing sound, when you end your sleep cycle and could go to another one except that the mask moved a little and it's bothering enough to wake you up (and then you have to find sleep again), you worry about keeping it and yourself in just the right position that will allow you to go back to sleep, effectively preventing you from falling asleep because of the stress... And I have a few reasons more,if you really need.
- hindsightbias 3y agoMy swift pillow on a Resmed A10 is 0db. I can’t tell if it’s running sometimes. It’s not for everybody but people should expect to have to experiment for a few weeks.
- taeric 3y agoIt isn't that it is hard to believe it can happen. It is so many people, though, that it is hard for me to comprehend. And yes, the mask can make noise, but typically not as much as the person makes snoring for your partner. Modern ones, in particular, are fairly quiet and can be tucked under the night stand such that they make about as much noise as basic forced air venting systems do. Which is not much. The mask can be uncomfortable some nights. They do have a variety of masks to try, though. And if it isn't working, they have other options. That last point is actually refreshing for me in this story. So many bounce off a CPAP into nothing. Hopefully efforts like this story will help people find something that can work.
- gmiller123456 3y agoMine is a pretty high pressure, and a full face mask. The high pressure means the mask has to be strapped pretty tight. It also makes it tough to get into a regular breathing pattern, making just the act of breathing a major chore. You can't talk, or cough. You have to stay in certain positions to prevent the air from leaking out. The air echoes down the tube. I was a stomach sleeper before, which is impossible with the mask, so had to learn to sleep on my side. Every now and then, I do skip the mask occasionally, and it's words can't explain how much better it feels to sleep "normally". So I can see why a lot of people skip it.
- hindsightbias 3y agoNot as mind boggling as the obesity rate. I’m very aggressive towards friends about cpaps. I bother them until they do a sleep study. It is life changing for many of us.
- taeric 3y agoAgreed, and one does not preclude the other. :D
- wincy 3y agoWhen I wear it I wake up in the middle of the night and feel like I am suffocating. Like it’s smothering me in my sleep. Even the expensive biPAP makes me feel this way. I have no such issues when I sleep without one.
- MagicMoonlight 3y agoThat sounds like you’re not using it properly. Let me guess, a doctor set it up for you and set the pressure to 4cm or something ridiculously low. They love doing things like that.
- 01100011 3y agoI went through that phase a couple weeks after starting and it lasted for a few weeks. That was almost 5 years ago and now I love my CPAP.
- lcuff 3y agoI sweat where the mask contacts my face, so that's one issue. As others have said, it can be noisy. I find the noise highly variable based on how it sits on my face and if there are things (a pillow, a sheet, my hand) in front of the discharge vent. At times it feels claustrophobic. I feel vastly better in the morning if I've used the device for more than half the night, so I'm very motivated to make it work.
- taeric 3y agoThey make a stupid number of different masks, so it is worth trying the different types. Also worth pursuing the dental ideas linked in this story. Looks fairly promising.
- jnovek 3y agoSome of us are just unlucky and face a bunch of challenges with CPAP. I was first prescribed a full face mask. I didn’t tolerate it well. I swallowed air and woke up every morning feeling like I was going to vomit. I had to teach myself to breathe through my nose while sleeping (with no help from the sleep clinic, of course) and then switched to a nasal mask. This was extra challenging because I have a deviated septum and can only really breath through one nostril. I’m a side sleeper and it took me a long time to find a pillow and sleeping position that didn’t hurt or break the mask seal. Along with all that, I just find it uncomfortable to have a thing strapped to my face all night. I still really can’t fall asleep without some sort of sedative. It’s just hard for me.
- salzo 3y agoI'm muy experience with a Reamed one, on one hand, the noise. It took a lot of time for me to get used to it and fall asleep. I did some adjustments to the machine using the hidden medical menu to improve it (basically, disabled "Expiratory pressure relief (EPR)™" which "maintains regular airflow pressure while you inhale and reduces pressure to make it easier when exhaling") On the other hand, the masks. I started with moderate success with a nasal pillows one and at some point I started opening my mouth having the worst dry mouth experiences in life. Then I switch to a full face mask that covered my nose and it itched so hard at night that I woke up just to scratch. Then I switched to another full face one that left my nose out, but couldn't get it to not leak (I have a lot of facial hair). Then I got back to the nasal pillows one but I'm taping my mouth close. I've finally had moderate success with this. I took me like 3 years to get here.
- reilly3000 3y agoFor me, I have an unrelated sleep disorder that makes sleep extremely important, and sensory issues that made sleeping with CPAP difficult to impossible. I tried lots of kinds of masks at my expense, but got no material support from the providers involved. After many months of trying I found that I have far better sleep without it, and got sick less frequently as well. I cleaned it fastidious and fiddled with it regularly but couldn’t find a sustainable way forward with it. The mechanical sound of breathing, the mask getting stuck in my long hair, the intentions posture and breathing form… and dear mercy the pooling moisture on my face. I shaved a sick beard for it. I stopped sleeping with my partner. It was a saga that I had tried a decade earlier with the same outcome. Ultimately it turned out that simply staying hydrated and adding a little incline to my mattress is all it took. My O2 concentration has held steady and the snoring has stopped. I’ve taken my alcohol consumption down to near zero, and I have to imagine that helped as well. My weight and body fat have been pretty stable throughout. I’ve kept my gear in case I have an occasion to try it again. Also they wouldn’t take it back and have got legislation passed to ban CPAP resale. Maybe one day I’ll get around to hacking on an IoT smell-o-vision project and have a decent use for the thing.
- mfgs 3y agoHow are you measuring O2 levels? I’ve also been experimenting with a slightly elevated mattress recently, it seems to help quite a lot for my OSA.
- pkaye 3y agoI've gotten a full bed foam wedge in the past. I can't find the original one I bought before but I think the below is similar. Its much better than a short wedge pillow if you are a side sleeper. The only problem is initially you will slide down slowly but it gets better over time. I used it for a different reason because I used to get GERD issues in the past and elevation would help a lot. https://www.amazon.com/stores/page/20D27239-CBE7-4150-BEA7-A2E57EED1A20 https://www.amazon.com/stores/page/20D27239-CBE7-4150-BEA7-A...
- callalex 3y agoWear the gear every time you have had alcohol, and you will definitely feel much better the next morning. Bonus points if you can crank the humidifier to help keep you hydrated while sleeping.
- Llamamoe 3y agoCPAP causes a sense of suffocation, nasal congestion, face masks are weakly effective while nose masks often run into the issue of switching to mouth breathing during resistance. It also prevents total airway collapse but not increases in effort. Basically it's way less effective than people assume, while introducing its own sleep disruption
- xnx 3y agoReduction is sleep apnea seems like a likely second-order effect of GLP-1 drugs.
- Maxious 3y agoWe've known since at least 2016 that GLP-1 drugs would have a massive impact https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4973216/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4973216/
- elric 3y ago"Massive"? The intervention group went from a mean AHI of 49 to a mean AHI of 37. While the control group went from 49 to 43. It's something, but it's still very much in the "severe" category, and I wouldn't call it "massive". Proper CPAP usage would reduce this group's AHI to <2 events/hour.
- stavros 3y agoThat's a fairly convoluted way of saying "GLP-1 agonists help you lose weight, and losing weight reduces your sleep apnea".
- elric 3y agoMaybe. I'm not convinced. There is some correlation between obesity and sleep apnea, but skinny people can develop sleep apnea just as easily as fat people. It is very difficult to lose weight (and very easy to gain weight) once you do develop sleep apnea for a variety of reasons, so the causal relationship might even be reversed. That being said, if you suffer from OSA and have a lot of fat on your chest and around your airway, losing some of that fat might help. Maybe GLP-1 drugs can do that in spite of OSA.
- 01100011 3y agoAgree, but many of us got sleep apnea while skinny. Definitely interesting to ponder the far reaching changes of GLP-1 drugs though.
- renewiltord 3y agoHas anyone used an oral appliance off the market? I googled and found this thing called snoreRx. Any recommendations or reviews? I would prefer to just go get something like this which I can pay for directly rather than have to navigate insurance etc. so if there's a DTC brand that has worked for someone that would be a great plus.
- robbiep 3y agoThere’s a reason why this sort of thing is managed through someone medically guiding you and that’s because it’s complex, and there is a lot that snoreRx is not suited for. Unless you feel like you have a firm physiological foundation on which to base your need for some sort of treatment, you’re really doing yourself a disservice. There’s also no harm in discussing this with your doctor either
- jrm4 3y agoAnd as someone who's dealt with the ins and outs of CPAP and sleep apnea, increasingly, I believe that reason has very little to do with safety or expertise. I'm not saying experts can't be valuable, but there's too much obvious bullshit in this space to take at face value what is supposed to be "best practices." The price fluctuations, the differing bits of information, the restrictions on who can and cannot get what without a prescruption, etc are often quite absurd (when, e.g. compared to the potential danger of MUCH other OTC stuff.) Example: that it's made condescendingly artificially difficult to adjust your own pressure in a CPAP. It's a damn fan with a release; if you're otherwise healthy, it strongly appears as if the worst possible dangers here are, your sleep will continue to suck and/or you'll fart more.
- DenisM 3y agoI tried it, and it seems to work. However, I was informed that lacking professional supervision this sort of thing can permanently damage your jaw after prolonged use. From which I deduced that using one occasionally, e.g. for travel, is acceptable. Still, see a doctor and don’t take safety advice from me. And be sure to shop around, prices for the professionally made device range from $1100 to $4000. If you can justify paying a couple thousand for a newer laptop then an oral appliance might be an even better investment for you.
- DrAwdeOccarim 3y agoTotally agree. My journey started with TMJ disorder. Turns out bruxism (teeth grinding) is common in sleep apnea patients; I assume because it forces the lower jaw forward. I started with a mandibular advancement device and it was amazing. It completely relived my debilitating TMJ jaw pain and fixed my sleep apnea. I couldn’t believe how amazing I fet every morning. Unfortunately, and which was clearly communicated to me by my sleep dentist, after about 8 years my lower jaw stopped resetting back to a normal bite during the day. So I switched to CPAP. I love my nasal pillows plus chin strap CPAP, the sleep quality is unbeatable and my light-sleeping partner would have left to sleep in another room permanently if not for it. Along the way I have tried many other ideas—a tongue suction pull forward thing, a rear tongue electro stimulation device, prone sleeping, wedge sleeping, just the chin strap, and I looked into the pace maker thing and participating in an oral small molecule trial but didn’t follow through with it (also, I’m already thin, just a weak jaw line). Nothing compares to CPAP at high humidity and medium temperature. What has made a major impact was seeing an ENT, and the discovery of sinus blockages, so I recently had major sinus surgery and it’s improved my sleep apnea about 75%! Turns out “negative pressure” is a major cause of airway collapse. So I’m going to try some of the non-CPAP stuff again to see if my partner is able to deal with at most some loud breathing. Sorry for the long post, but my advice to all is see an ENT if you need a CPAP and are already thin.
- DenisM 3y agoCan you elaborate on “oral small molecule”? Googles failed me.
- DrAwdeOccarim 3y agohttps://apnimed.com/ https://apnimed.com/ https://journals.lww.com/neurotodayonline/Fulltext/2022/04070/Sulthiame_Found_Safe_and_Tolerable_for_Obstructive.5.aspx https://journals.lww.com/neurotodayonline/Fulltext/2022/0407...
- DenisM 3y agoThanks. “AD109 targets two neurochemical pathways which control the upper airway musculature during sleep via a dual mechanism of action”
- ShrigmaMale 3y ago...i may be stupid but i could have sworn endotyping was already a thing. i talked to someone last week who brought it up. does anyone w more expertise know what the specific innovation is?
- webnrrd2k 3y agoI was curious about the term, too. I found this [1], although it focused on asthma. I found it interesting, and the money quote is ”The term asthma is now considered an umbrella diagnosis for several diseases with distinct mechanistic pathways (endotypes) and variable clinical presentations (phenotypes)." [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6411459/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6411459/
- Tarsul 3y agoFor myself I noticed reducing my own bodyweight helped a lot (so from 108kg to 100kg was already helping me a lot). Which also means that I know that I cannot allow myself to regain this weight again... ;)
- stavros 3y agoAgreed, I know when I've crossed the 98kg mark because I start snoring.
- Aurornis 3y agoNot every apnea sufferer is overweight, but it’s at the top of the list of causes by a very wide margin. Weight reduction is extremely effective for most (though not all, there is a small minority of non-responders) in this situation. The challenge is that patients hate to hear it from their doctors so many doctors won’t even bring it up. Doctors are increasingly dependent on patient ratings for their performance reviews so difficult topics are often avoided.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- MagicMoonlight 3y agoI think the solution is a stent inserted into the airway to prevent it collapsing during sleep. This would permanently treat the condition with no side-effects and no daily upkeep. Unfortunately I have no way of implementing this so I’ll never know for sure.
- elric 3y agoSuch stents exist, like the Nastent [1]. They're expensive, more or less single use, and shoving a tube down your nose sounds very unpleasant. CPAP seems a lot more attractive to me. Unless you mean a permanent stent, in which case I doubt it'll happen. You need the airway to be flexible (including for speech) in various places. It's hard to pinpoint which bits of airway are responsibe for an individual's apnea. And surgeries, especially in the throat/neck/airway area sound very risky. [1] https://www.breathewellmedical.com/product/nastent-classic/ https://www.breathewellmedical.com/product/nastent-classic/
- vvladymyrov 3y agoFacebook recently started to show me this nasal stent product https://alaxousa.com/how-it-works/ https://alaxousa.com/how-it-works/ Basically they sell expandable metal mesh tubes that are inserted though the nose and go down to throat when installed. And they are rather expensive - $395 and according to FAQ last up to 18 months. I’ll ask my ENT about these stents when I’ll visit them next time.
- elric 3y agoThe only reason why CPAP has such abysmal failure rates, is because followup is an absolute joke. Patients are titrated in a sleep centre, typically for one night, and are then sent home with a machine, probably the shittiest mask the sleep centre had on hand, and a kick out the door. With some luck, patients have to come in once a year, usually to prove that their therapy is compliant with whatever harebrained scheme their insurance has set up. If they're really lucky, the physician will actually look at the machine's data, and if they really strike gold, they might even adjust therapy as needed. One initial visit, then once a year. For something you have to wear every night for the rest of your life. It's a joke. Everything else, you'll have to figure out on your own. Is it any wonder people give up? They're likely on the wrong pressure, using the least comfortable mask, and have no idea how to make things better. It's a good thing there are resources like Apneaboard [1], Lanky Lefty's youtube channel [2], and software like Oscar [3] to help people out. If these didn't exist, failure rates would be even higher. And if the medical industrial complex would get their heads out of their arses and actually tried to help patients, compliance would be through the roof. [1] https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&q=apneaboard&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&q=apneaboard&ia=web [2] https://www.youtube.com/@Freecpapadvice/videos https://www.youtube.com/@Freecpapadvice/videos [3] https://www.sleepfiles.com/OSCAR/ https://www.sleepfiles.com/OSCAR/
- Aurornis 3y agoI know some medical professionals in this domain who would disagree with your assessment. The hardest part is convincing patients to come back for followups and to comply with treatment. Even my primary care doctor said he has abysmal compliance rates with apnea treatment because so many people decide that wearing any device every night is too much to ask. I half suspect that apnea is being diagnosed so aggressively that people with even mild apnea are getting treatment. This would explain why patients are willingly giving up a treatment that is life changing for the better in patients who are suffering severe symptoms.
- elric 3y agoThat's a catch-22, and it's exactly why followup is important. And why physicians should talk to patients, instead of just sending them on their merry way with a cheap CPAP and a shitty mask. "Here's a shitty mask and some random pressure, good luck, and remember to use it for 4+ hours each night and byebye." If you're unfortunate enough to require a stoma, they don't just randomly attach a bag and send you home. You're sent to a stoma nurse. You're educated on the life changing effects of having to use a stoma. Your nurse will help you find a type of bag that's right for you and can help you deal with complications. But with OSA, we slap a mask on people and don't even tell them that there are dozens of kinds. Now, I'm sure this all depends heavily on where you are, how shitty the healthcare system is over there, and even who you see at which sleep centre. But in general, CPAP would be very well tolerated if we could help people to optimize their therapy.
- thomasqbrady 3y agoWhen you see a paper like this, what, if any, path is there to seeking this kind of treatment? I know someone who would likely be interested in this, but I know from prior experience of my own that just trying to reach out to the researchers listed is a long process that can be fruitless. Is there an intended/better way? I know about clinicaltrials.gov, but that’s only helpful if there’s an ongoing study of the thing you’re interested (which is less likely if you’re reading about findings).
- 01100011 3y agoIf you're in the US, then you have to be the primary driver of your health care. In this case, research oral appliances on your own, buy one and try it. You can use something like a wrist mounted pulse oximeter to gauge its effectiveness. If it works, great. I'm not familiar with the article's 'phase 2' options like oxygen therapy. There again though, you are able to purchase a home oxygen concentrator on your own and try it out.
- hijinks 3y agohas anyone used an oral device and love it? The ones I've tried I always take them out while sleeping without knowing. Been trying for years to find one that I'll keep in. I know you need to keep trying but its never in my mouth when I wake up
- UncleOxidant 3y agoWhen I was first diagnosed with sleep apnea I asked my doc about alternatives to CPAP because I didn't think I'd be able to sleep with that thing on my face. He sent me to a dentist who specialized in making those oral appliances for Oral Appliance Therapy. I did the adjustments for a couple of months (you move a screw just a bit further every few days which pulls your lower jaw forward in the device). After a couple of months he had me do another sleep test - it was actually worse than it was before without the device. Soon after I got a CPAP and after a 2 or 3 week adjustment period I was sleeping just fine with it.
- Klonoar 3y agoI’ve done the oral appliance route and it fixed it for me, so it might be a YMMV thing. I really recommend everyone get tested for it tho, good sleep is the biggest game changer.
- UncleOxidant 3y agoThis was about 15 years ago and I got the distinct impression that the oral device they gave me was still pretty experimental. I remember making a few suggestions to the dentist for ways it might work better and he thanked me for my feedback. Maybe they're better now?
- onewheeltom 3y agoI had both obstructive and central apnea and have been totally fine with the CPAP from day 1. Sounds like I’m an outlier. As for the other options, they may not have worked for me.
- e40 3y agoWorked fine for me, too. I was in bad shape with sleep and it was very much impacting my health. The CPAP was literally a life saver to me. That was in 1/2021 and been using it ever since. I even took it on vacation recently.
- WoahNoun 3y agoI use a nose mask and my CPAP is great. No snoring anymore, the mask doesn't bother me, and I wake feeling much, much better than before.
- sheepscreek 3y agoCan anyone with access to the actual paper share the treatment regime they are suggesting, preferably with the names of actual devices they used? The summary and conclusion was unfortunately light on details. Please, and thank you!
- themadturk 3y agoI started using a CPAP with a nose facemask almost two years ago. My doctor ended up also prescribing a low dose of Ambien because wearing the mask triggered a claustrophobia reaction in me. It was enough to get me to sleep with the mask on most nights, but I almost always pulled the mask off after 3-4 hours (or less) without even waking up. I haven't worn the CPAP for about six months because I have allergies that keep me just congested enough that I can't breathe through my nose with the mask on anymore. The thought of a full face mask terrifies me. After all that, my sleep seems fine (it never seemed bad at all to me) and I have some amount of dependence on Ambien which I have no idea how to kick.
- sxg 3y agoIt's not about fixing poor sleep. Chronic sleep apnea causes other downstream effects like pulmonary hypertension and right-sided heart failure, which are the main things we're trying to avoid by using CPAP machines.
- cocoa19 3y ago> It was enough to get me to sleep with the mask on most nights, but I almost always pulled the mask off after 3-4 hours (or less) without even waking up. That's pretty common, but you get used to wearing the mask longer and longer, it may take multiple weeks. Me and a lot of users on /r/CPAP will give you similar feedback. As for allergy congestion, have you tried Claritin, Flonase, others? May need to check with the doctor.
- medicalreasons1 3y agoI am completely shocked that this discussion does more or less not include the issue of noise. I was diagnosed with 100 AHI last year and from day one it was impossible for me to sleep with the noise the mask makes.... The first night in sleep centre with CPAP was hell for me. I couldn't fall asleep even though it was 4 a.m. and I had only slept 4 hours the day before. At home I can only fall asleep with hearing protection, because of which my ears are permanently inflamed. The doctor, referring to the high AHI, did not even consider trying other forms of therapy. > You can sleep with hearing protection, right? Then everything is good. To me, CPAP doesn't feel like a solution. Rather, it is a bad temporary solution with which a lot of money can be made through rental fees.
- teucris 3y agoThat’s an astonishingly loud machine - I can barely hear mine. I sometimes lay and try to listen to it, but quickly I find the sound of my breathing makes up the majority of noise in the room.
- medicalreasons1 3y agoIt is not the machine at all. I have a ResMed AirSense 10 AutoSet. Bystanders tell me that they hear next to nothing. It is the sound that is made in the mask (ResMed AirFit F30i) when I inhale that drives me crazy. Every time I breathe in, it sounds like Darth Vader.
- callalex 3y agoIf sounds on your face and in your head are that noticeably loud, you may have obstructions in your ear canal, such as impacted earwax. Does your humming sound louder when you plug your ears, or does it stay the same?
- medicalreasons1 3y agoIt sounds louder. I figured, since hearing protection solves the problem, it's not a problem inside the head. Well it might be after all as I am apparently super sound sensitive.
- euroderf 3y agoI tried a CPAP and could not sleep with it. So the therapist went for plan B, which was a dental appliance. Just enough to make my lower jaw jut out a bit. Problem solved.
- j-kent 3y ago1000 times, yes. I also couldn’t sleep with CPAP. I tried about 3 different mouth pieces (and tongue extensions that looked like pacifiers) until settling on one that also had a strip that held my tongue down - which was a total game changer.