4 ms·
The super wealthy have their own exclusive versions of Amazon, Tinder, Instagram
- matt3210 3y ago1000$ a month is not a lot and doesn’t make someone rich.
- defrost 3y agoNot in itself, no - but for context that's just the subscription fee for a single app ... anyone that's idlely boasting about their lifestyle across several apps and burning N x $12K a year to do so is either rich enough to think nothing of the cost or running a long con.
- xg15 3y agoIf you spend $12.000/year purely for personal entertainment then you either have deeply problematic spending habits, are involved in something shady or really are filthy rich.
- jychang 3y agoPlenty of people spend over $12k a year for things that make them feel better (that they don’t need). It’s called a luxury car. Anyone who bought a new Porsche (and isn’t a professional racing driver using it for work) is probably spending over $12k a year on something for fun.
- broast 3y agoI assume anyone who buys a new Porsche is indeed rich
- hungryforcodes 3y ago[flagged]
- junon 3y ago... What? Spending 250 a week on a less interesting version of Instagram access is wild if you aren't "filthy rich". I'd argue it's wild either way but I'm not your parent. Criticizing that is normal, your comment is very much not. Are you filthy rich and don't realize it?
- hungryforcodes 3y agoBut the original post was "personal entertainment". Between eating out and having a couple of beers (both of which are unneeded), it's easy to spend at least $35 a day ($250 a week).
- xg15 3y agoYeah. Would you browse HN if it cost you $36 a day?
- prepend 3y agoIf it was worth it, sure. If has the same content now, definitely not. This app sounds stupid and I can’t imagine it has better content than Instagram or TikTok. Country Clubs aren’t worth it just because they are only full of rich people. It collects golf, dining, space, etc. Few people would pay $50k to join a “virtual country club” that solely exists to filter rich people. I mean salespeople and scammers would, but what’s the value to rich people.
- dillydogg 3y agoThis highlights how out of touch HN people are. 37% of Americans can't afford a one time $400 expense. And $12k a year is just nothing, apparently. https://www.federalreserve.gov/consumerscommunities/shed.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/consumerscommunities/shed.htm
- raincole 3y ago$12k is not nothing, but the title is "super wealthy". If you make $1.2m a year, spending $12k on entertainment seems very reasonable. But making $1.2m/y alone doesn't make someone "super wealthy".
- shusaku 3y agoA lot of people on HN have Silicon Valley jobs which leads to a distortion field around prices.
- jandrewrogers 3y agoThat number is almost exactly the median amount of money Americans have left over for spending for "personal entertainment" after all ordinary expenses, per the US government. Americans have anomalously high income generally, not just tech workers. You don't need to be rich to spend this much on something wasteful, though you may need to be American.
- xg15 3y agoeven then, would that half of americans spend the majority of their "personal entertainment" budget on one app?
- jandrewrogers 3y agoI'd hope and expect not but Americans do lots of inadvisable things at scale, so it would not surprise me if there is a small sub-population that would. A "small sub-population" can be a lot of people.
- janalsncm 3y agoIf you have an extra $1000 per month laying around that you don’t mind parting with maybe I can send you my PayPal address.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- postalrat 3y agoUnless your $1000 a month account is a few years old you will just be ignored.
- klntsky 3y ago> In 2015, Luxy kicked out 40,000 members for being “too poor, too ugly or both.” Interesting, it goes against my stereotype: the more wealthy are less likely to discriminate by look (which is associated with low social intelligence). Maybe the trend reverses when it comes to super-rich? Or maybe it does not even exist?
- BrickStoneWall 3y agoI think that in general, richer people tend to have better education, therefore also being less likely to discriminate, but if you are super rich (born into a 100-milionare or billionaire) family, you don't need any education and therefore discriminate more.
- strikelaserclaw 3y agoI don't think education has anything to do with discrimination when it comes to partners, a lot of these rich people have an image to maintain so they probably look for partners who can help maintain this image, this is especially true for the rich people who didn't earn their wealth.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y agoExactly, a good-looking bf/gf is a status marker.
- massysett 3y agoMaybe this is semantic…but I can’t imagine the super wealthy scrolling through James Edition the same way we search on Amazon and then scroll through a bunch of flea market crap and intentionally off-base ads to find what we want. Instead, wouldn’t a super-rich person tell her assistant, “I want a yacht,” and then the assistant would sift through the crap and contact other assistants as a result. And as a result the assistant might tell his boss “well, looks like a good yacht costs $xx million,” and the boss says “oh that’s more than I thought, and then I have to take care of a stupid yacht, forget it, hey book me a luxury cruise, my friend had a good one.”
- dtgriscom 3y agoWhen I'm a billionaire, I'll still have fun sniffing around Amazon for things I'd like to buy. The only difference is I'll have the money to buy them.
- oceanplexian 3y agoI’m no billionaire, but the more money I make, the less I’m actually interested in buying consumer goods. Like, I’ll spend a good chunk of money for a nice vacation or a high end restaurant. I like buying Real Estate or spending on investments. Perhaps I’ll get a boat or a really nice car in a couple years. But then what? You’ve kinda run out of stuff to spend on.
- stavros 3y agoI haven't seen anyone else express this, but you're right. All my money is sitting in the bank or investments, and whenever I go to shops or browse online, I keep thinking "eh, one more thing to take up space". I barely buy anything these days, and ask people to give me cheap, thoughtful gifts instead of spending money I either don't need or think is not worth its money. I wish I could afford to buy a nice house, though. The prices on those are crazy.
- taskforcegemini 3y agothat sounds very confident, how come?
- LUmBULtERA 3y agoI was thinking the exclusive version of Amazon was going to be like Amazon but where you don't need to worry about being sent something counterfeit or wade through a ton of crap! James Edition is much less interesting.
- selcuka 3y agoYeah, it's more like Facebook Marketplace, but with yachts instead of fishing boats.
- poulpy123 3y agoI don't know for the first one that look legitimate, but the 2 others scream of scamming new riches
- prepend 3y ago> For $1,000 a month on Rich Kids, you’re guaranteed to only see photos from other wealthy patrons. Similar to the check marks that denote verified Facebook and Twitter accounts, the app’s prohibitive monthly fee ensures that everyone who uses it is certifiably wealthy. This is such poor people logic. “Spend money on a cheap thing to prove you’re rich. Btw, that’s my business model.” I think it’s way more likely that it will be people paying a few grand on their credit card to pretend to be rich and/or golddig.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y agoThere is a still a threshold. To even be able to spend 'a few grand' on such things means you have at least that much disposable income, which many many people do not. So you may not necessarily be 'rich', but you are most certainly not 'poor'.
- prepend 3y agoI disagree. There’s a lot of consumer debt. People go into debt to rent houses and cars just to post instagram photos. Id say this proves you have at least credit to charge $1,000 or $12,000 for a year. If I was rich, I would not value such a service that has such a bullshit filter. Especially one they is so easy to scam. I expect there are real services that have ways to vet members for actual wealth. I also expect they have PR firms working to stay out of articles like this. But if you want fake rich or people who want to look rich, then you want this kind of PR.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y agoSounds like you wouldn't use this service regardless of whether you were rich or just had good credit (and neither would I) but that's not the point I was making. It's that having $12k a year (either debit or credit, it doesn't matter) that you don't need to spend on things like food and rent is still a luxury for a great many people. People who would never be able to use this app no matter how much they wanted to. This fee is therefore an effective barrier to entry for a considerable segment of the population as intended.