3 ms·
Why does a university have the power to find somebody guilty of sexual assault, and not the actual courts? EDIT, I am rate limited so I can't reply: The speci
by _dain_ 3y ago
Why does a university have the power to find somebody guilty of sexual assault, and not the actual courts?
EDIT, I am rate limited so I can't reply:
The specific phrase was "found guilty" and the specific wrong being alleged is sexual assault, which is a criminal offense for which people can go to prison. University HR can fire him if they like, but they cannot find him guilty of a sexual assault any more than they can find him guilty of fraud or manslaughter.
People are innocent of all crimes until they are proved guilty in a fair trial, in a real court with a real judge and a real jury.
> Did the university send him to prison, or are you collapsing multiple different connotations of "guilty" into one?
Excuse me, am I collapsing multiple definitions here? It seems to me the parent commenter is pivoting on two different connotations of "sexual assault" and "guilty", so as to have it both ways: ostracize this person as one would an actual sex offender, without needing to go through the awkward formality convicting him of a sexual offense.
- JohnMakin 3y agoDo you think HR isn’t real or something? If you grab your coworker’s ass, do you think they’re not legally able to conclude this happened and then fire you?
- CraftingLinks 3y agoActually, not sure you can in Europe?
- Talanes 3y agoDid the university send him to prison, or are you collapsing multiple different connotations of "guilty" into one?
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoAre you asking why people and organizations have the power to decide whether to associate with or employ someone, while the government has the power of criminal justice? Are you mixing up those two things?
- Phiwise_ 3y agoAre you asking why "found guilty" means found guilty in a court of law and not some other private person or org asserting a perogative of association? Are you mixing up those two things?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]