5 ms·
On practice those were either proprietary or required beefy machines that the people writing C couldn't get. On the limited environment where C got created, it
by marcosdumay 3y ago
On practice those were either proprietary or required beefy machines that the people writing C couldn't get.
On the limited environment where C got created, it was the only option. And everybody suddenly adopted that limited environment, because it was cheap. And then it improved until you could use any of those other languages, but at that point everybody was using C already.
- grumpyprole 3y agoIIRC, Mac OS Classic was written in Pascal, as were other operating systems. C just won the popularity contest.
- marcosdumay 3y agoThat was about a decade after C had already won.
- grumpyprole 3y agoThe Xerox Alto was early 70's and that GUI OS was written in Pascal. I always thought Pascal was better designed and less bizarre than C. Null terminated strings were particularly a bad idea.
- marcosdumay 3y agoOh, by 73. Impressive. I didn't know that. Still, that was a much more powerful machine than the ones people wrote C for. And when the cheap segment of those "fridge computers" became powerful enough to run whatever you wanted to put on it, people started using small workstations. And when those workstations became powerful enough, we got PCs. It's only when the PCs got powerful enough that we could start to ignore the compiler demands and go with whatever language fit us better. (The later reductions all were based on cross-compiling, so they don't matter here.)
- pjmlp 3y agoGo check the capabilities of systems written in high level languages like ESPOL and NEWP in 1961. Let not say that a 1961 system is more powerful than a PDP-11.
- mcguire 3y ago"Why Pascal is Not My Favorite Programming Language", Brian W. Kernighan, April 2, 1981: https://www.cs.virginia.edu/~evans/cs655/readings/bwk-on-pascal.html https://www.cs.virginia.edu/~evans/cs655/readings/bwk-on-pas... One of the major problems, as I recall, was that Wirth's basic Pascal definition was very limited---the max 256 character strings, for example. So the makers of "production" Pascal compilers added extensions to do all of the things that you would want to do and unfortunately those extensions were all incompatible.
- pjmlp 3y agoA famous rant ignoring Pascal dialects, while C still lacked a standard and was a bunch of dialects all over the place.
- mcguire 3y agoI've never seen a C dialect, other than not supporting bit fields. The language was usually the same although the libraries were all over the place.
- pjmlp 3y agoThen you haven't used any C compilers during the CP/M, 8-bit and 16-bit days. Here are two, RatC, Small-C. Additionally what do you think GCC C is, in regards to K&R C and ANSI C?
- pjmlp 3y agoMesa not Pascal.
- grumpyprole 3y agoYes apologies, I misremembered. Mesa is definitely a decendant of Pascal though, more like Modula-2. Very ahead of its time.
- pjmlp 3y agoSorry for being a bit pedantic, it predates Modula-2, Niklaus Wirth got in contact with it during his first sabbatical at Xerox PARC, after returning to ETHZ Modula was born, and shortly thereafter Modula-2 and Lillth Workstation, with the OS written in Modula-2. Several years later, a similar encounter with Mesa's evolution, Mesa/Cedar, gave birth to Oberon. As for being ahead of its time, very much indeed. Many people relate to Smalltalk and Interlisp-D, and are unaware of strong typed systems programming at Xerox, with a tooling that only decades cater came to be. Mesa authors were quite adamant that in order to succeed, Mesa had to support comparable tooling to Smalltalk and Interlisp-D environments.
- StableAlkyne 3y agoFortran predates C by over a decade, and dozens of compilers existed for it by the mid-60s. Much of that legacy code is still in use to this day in scientific computing. One example: John Pople won his Nobel prize for work he did (and implemented in Fortran) in computational chemistry - the prize was delayed until '98 but he did the work in the 60s. The software he commercialized it into, Gaussian, still gets releases to this day and remains one of the most popular computational chemistry packages. It's really dependent on which field you're in. Not all scientific computing requires a beefy computer, but for a very long time it (and I guess LISP) dominated scientific computing. That said, I think it's a very good point to bring up the network effect of using C - if I need to hire a developer in 1985, it's probably easier to find someone with industry (not academic) experience who knows C than it is to find someone who knows Fortran. I do kinda prefer Fortran to C though, it's so much cleaner to do math in. Maybe somewhere there's an alternate universe where IBM invented C and Bell invented Fortran to win the popularity war.
- jacquesm 3y agoI tried to get access to FORTRAN and it was just way too expensive and required machines that I would not have been able to get close to. C ran on anything from Atari STs, IBM PCs, Amiga's and any other machine that an ordinary person could get their hands on. The other mainstream language at the time was BASIC, comparable to the way PHP is viewed today by many. And with the advent of the 32 bit x86 era GCC and djgpp as well as early Linux systems really unlocked a lot of power. Before then you'd have to have access to a VAX or a fancy workstation to get that kind of performance out of PC hardware. It's funny how long it took for the 386 to become fully operational, many years after it was launched you had to jump through all kinds of hoops to be able to use the system properly, whereas on a 68K based system costing a tiny fraction that was considered completely normal.
- StableAlkyne 3y agoMy perspective is a bit biased by scientific computing, I do more of that than enterprise stuff (and Python has been fine for personal use). It's cool to see the perspective of someone who was around for the early stages of it though. How did people see Fortran back then - nowadays it's seen as outdated but fast, but was it seen as interesting, and what drove you to seek it out? Other side question if it's okay, I keep seeing references to VAXen around historical documents and usenet posts from the 80s and 90s, what made them special compared to other hardware you had back then?