4 ms·
The first map is quite remarkable: even in this record-setting year, there is still a big swath of the US that is cooler than the historical average, or only ve
by jfengel 3y ago
The first map is quite remarkable: even in this record-setting year, there is still a big swath of the US that is cooler than the historical average, or only very slightly warmer. This has been a pattern for a while.
It almost feels like a conspiracy: the part of the world that is ideologically predisposed to disbelieve in climate change is also the one that is (partly) avoiding it. And that part is the linchpin: other places are disinclined to do the hard work of fixing the climate while the US prominently denies that the problem even exists.
It's as if the earth wanted to keep warming.
Obviously not, of course, and I don't really know if it really figures into it one way or the other. But it still strikes me as weird. How different would the situation be if the US midwest and south were on the hotter side of the scale, rather than the cooler one?
- PraetorianGourd 3y agoI honestly do not think it would matter much. Most folks in the South and Midwest are already accustomed to hot, humid temperatures. As such, it would be a matter of "hmm the AC is running more than normal" and then back to their normal day-to-day. Places where AC and other hot-weather mitigation tools are not common are the places where a suddenly-warmer environment would be immediately noticed. Besides, getting folks to recognize the impacts of climate change is one thing, convincing them that the threat is such that any impactful fix would require fundamental and drastic changes to their comfortable lifestyle is a whole different conversation.
- oezi 3y agoIt isn't really clear that fundamental and drastic changes to lifestyle is needed. It just needs considerable investment in climate friendly energy technologies. On the order of 100-200 trillion USD. Which is roughly 100-200% of global yearly GDP. This investment will likely bring in a positive return on investment because it reduces the negative climate impacts.
- landemva 3y agoInstead the neocons running the White House spend our resources on yet another war and more munitions. The Dems will get serious about climate when they put RFKjr on the Presidential ticket. Until then, the warmongers are feeding happily at the government trough.
- trilbyglens 3y agoNo it makes a difference. I get up in TX and compared to then so many more people just leave the state in the summer. It used to be that in the evening temps would come down to the mid 80s and now they might hit mid 90s even at midnight. It's fucking miserable to be trapped indoors for months on end. So much worse than cold.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Gustomaximus 3y agoI'm assuming it will be more than run AC longer. E.g With more extreme weather events tornadoes will be potentially more frequent and destructive. Or rain more heavy and out of normal patterns which can create serious issues with farming, especially staples like wheat or rice. Or fires which we seem to already see more of. With recognising climate change, I feel the issue is many people, focus on the short term for what is a long term issue. In the way people say the climate change isn't happening, to them it's not. Individuals will see fairly limited change over a single lifespan, but what we do today will likely have a huge impact to people 100+ years from now. Often media/activists presents climate change as this imminent threat year after year, which isn't true as the climate is a slow ship, and while actions is absolutely needed for the future, I think many people see these endless imminent threat predictions not occuring, so to them this seems over dramatic and therefore untrue.
- Tamarini 3y agoNew Mexico and Arizona (Phoenix in particular) actually had a record-breaking heatwave this year, a full month of daily peak temperatures above 110 degrees Fahrenheit.
- moritzwarhier 3y agoGot your point, still a bit intrigued by OP's. I often have similar thoughts: if you expand the scope a bit and don't limit yourself to the metrics that are the topic du jour - this is not meant to diminish the severity of heatwaves, to the contrary - it seems like a natural law that the people who do the most damage to common goods (such as humane shelter and food, clean water, clean air, healthy environment, bearable noise pollution, bearable working conditions if you want to go there) - they are the people who profit and stand exactly on the other side, experiencing the absolute minimum of the damage they cause. This is a prisoners's dilemma or market failure that has infested all of our global society, to a point that we can't even start to imagine.
- SoftTalker 3y agoEvery species tries to maximize its use of available resources. Humans are the only ones that even think about the consequences (emphasis on think, actually doing something is more rare). I think we will continue to live as we do until we cannot. Then there will be a natural correction. It will probably be ugly for a while, then we will adapt. This is the history of the planet.
- moritzwarhier 3y ago> Every species tries to maximize its use of available resources Do you think humans use oil, soil etc as efficiently as ants do? Or do you mean "consumption" when you say "use"? The way you put it sounds like you mean use ~= utility Claiming that our "bad conscience" does any good (speaking and writing, to be precise), increasingly proves wrong. There are just so many speakers and writers and thinkers with their own side of the prisoner's dilemma in mind
- chasil 3y agoOf course the earth wants to keep warming; the current climate is rare. It doesn't fall to the personification of the earth enacting a conspiracy, but things can and will return to [planetary] normal at some point. "A 'greenhouse Earth' is a period during which no continental glaciers exist anywhere on the planet... Earth has been in a greenhouse state for about 85% of its history... Earth is now in an icehouse state, and ice sheets are present in both poles simultaneously." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenhouse_and_icehouse_Earth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenhouse_and_icehouse_Earth
- ajross 3y agoThat's a weird use of "normal". The current ecosystems are fundamentally ice age ecosystems. Whether they count as "normal" to you personally isn't really material. They are the only ecosystems we have. You don't warm the earth rapidly (which at this point we undeniably are) and then magically get back "normal" fern forests and dinosaurs or whatnot. What you get is a mass extinction.
- angst_ridden 3y agoYes, but after mass extinction, stuff won't just stop. Eventually, things will evolve to forests or the equivalent. You'll be unlikely to have the same kinds of dinosaurs as before, but as the old saying goes, nature like carcination. There will probably be new variants of crabs.
- ajross 3y agoNo, but the stuff that is here now won't be there anymore. Traditional conservative (small-c) ethics generally says things like "don't throw stuff out or destroy things if we don't know what we'll get instead". You seem to be saying the equivalent of e.g. "It's OK to kill all the elephants because in a few million years something else will have filled the niche". That seems ridiculous to me. Does your logic extend to all species? All ecosystems? Our species?
- 3y ago
- boveus 3y ago> How different would the situation be if the US midwest and south were on the hotter side of the scale, rather than the cooler one? If the effect of global warming were felt equally in the US and that somehow caused the US to halt 100% of their emissions it would reduce global emissions by about 11% [1]. 1: https://www.cnbc.com/2021/05/06/chinas-greenhouse-gas-emissions-exceed-us-developed-world-report.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/05/06/chinas-greenhouse-gas-emissi...
- Daishiman 3y agoFor the US to halt emissions there would be policy in place to make sure emissions made somewhere else get appropriately priced, hence the effects of emissions reductions in the developed world impact everywhere else.
- boveus 3y agoThe main problem with global emissions is with developing countries who are increasing their emissions while at the same time taking up a greater share of global emissions than developed countries. See: https://www.cgdev.org/media/developing-countries-are-responsible-63-percent-current-carbon-emissions https://www.cgdev.org/media/developing-countries-are-respons...
- landemva 3y agoYes, environmental parity tariffs.
- lm28469 3y agoI don't understand how people make that point in 2023 still China is the world's factory, 20% of the US imports come from there, of course your own country doesn't pollute much when you gutted half of your industries and relocated them in foreign countries. edit: don't forget per capita greenhouse emissions too, in that case Americans emit twice as much as Chinese https://www.worldometers.info/co2-emissions/co2-emissions-per-capita/ https://www.worldometers.info/co2-emissions/co2-emissions-pe...
- 3y ago
- akira2501 3y ago> the part of the world that is ideologically predisposed to disbelieve in climate change There is more nonsense in this statement than in the headline. Parts of the world don't have ideology and these highly judgmental and superficial analysis certainly don't help. > other places are disinclined to do the hard work of fixing the climate while the US prominently denies that the problem even exists. So, China's inability to manage pollution is somehow down to the imputed attitudes of a few areas of the US? > It's as if the earth wanted to keep warming. It's as if human beings exist and continue to multiply. It's as if third world countries don't care about our ideology if it means they never get a chance to develop themselves the way every other country had an opportunity to. It's as if a few rich people half way around the world expect the difference to be made up elsewhere. > But it still strikes me as weird. It's purely anecdotal. > How different would the situation be if the US midwest and south were on the hotter side of the scale, rather than the cooler one? Texas had the hottest summer in recent history. California had one of the mildest. Minnesota had one of the hottest and they're getting Canadian wildfire smoke. Perhaps we shouldn't view this through the lens of "how miserable do we have to make people to get change to happen" and instead through the lens of "how incompetent are our politicians that they can't find an honest solution to this problem?" This _desire_ for self-inflicted austerity is what is _weird_.
- zztop44 3y agoWhat does an honest solution positions could come up with that would be accepted by a large majority of the voting public look like? In your opinion what should they be doing? Edit: because another way to view the lens you dismiss is “how miserable do people need to get before they accept that something real is happening here?”
- landemva 3y ago> In your opinion what should they be doing? The largest voting block could stop war emissions by replacing Biden with RFKjr or even Trump. Huge carbon savings there.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoMeh, Texas is famous for being super conservative and has also been hotter than fuck this summer, and we're very used to hot AF summers.
- tzs 3y agoKeep in mind that climate change also means more extremes in many places. Quite a few of those US places that have only gotten a little average warming have been getting getting more extremes and longer heat and cold waves. I'd guess that for most people in the US they are more likely to notice that than to notice a change in average temperature. Consider someone in a place that normally gets cold enough to require heat for much of the winter and hot enough to require air conditioning for most of the summer. Someone could easily not notice a 3℃ increase in average temperature that manifests as winter being a little less cold, summer being a little warmer, and winter being a little shorter, and summer a little longer because their HVAC system keeps their would at a fixed temperature all year around. Their energy bill would go up, but they might think that is just due to inflation. But if they start getting afternoon brownouts because of everyone's AC dealing with extreme summer heat, and that happens more and more each year, that is something they might notice