3 ms·
There's been a couple of stories about people (usually fairly young couples) that brought houses, on the specific guarantee from their local "broadband" monopol
by ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago
There's been a couple of stories about people (usually fairly young couples) that brought houses, on the specific guarantee from their local "broadband" monopoly, that they would have the service, and found out only after moving in, that they did not, in fact, have the service, and would need to pay many thousands of dollars, to get substandard service.
The companies that made the guarantees were allowed to say "oops, we goofed. Our bad.", without having to pay a dime, or even say sorry.
- barbazoo 3y agoHow would one get such a guarantee, surely it's not just the availability check by address because I wouldn't expect that to be binding.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoI am quite sure that there was never anything binding.
- spamizbad 3y agoWell, story time. Because I went through this process. I purchased a condo in a building that Comcast (A cable internet ISP) claimed to service. I even called ahead before putting an offer on the unit to verify I'd have them as an option, since they were the only high speed internet option available besides slow DSL or 4G. Sure enough, Comcast told me they service that address. Fast forward to near the move-in date, I call Comcast to transfer my service to this location. They tell me sorry, we can't do that, we don't service this address. I tell them this is impossible, because not only am I on your coverage map, but I called a month ago and you told me you service it. They said sorry, nothing they could do, and that I should try Comcast business or pay something like $4000 for a build-out. Well, I was desperate and called Comcast business to see if I could get a business line in my very residential condo. Weirdly, they allowed it. But I had to pay $200 for a setup fee and then roughly $100/month for what was basically 50mbps internet, locked in a 2 year contract. I had no choice, so I ate the cost - which looked much better than the $4000 option. But then Comcast said "Hey, we want to install a distribution box in your building, can we do that?" and I had to wrangle with the condo board to get that thing installed. About 3 months later I finally had Comcast internet, locked into an expensive contract. But because Comcast had installed a distribution box in the building, at least my neighbors could now actually get the service Comcast claimed they offered on the map (even for regular home internet). After 2 years my contract was up and I was able to switch to residential internet at a lower rate. I suspect if this was a SFH rather than a single unit in a 28-unit condo building I'd be screwed and have to shell out the $4K.
- em-bee 3y agoprobably not easy to achieve, but i think the contract needs to be made with the property owners, that is, if their property doesn't have the required internet service, they need to pay to fix it or allow you to cancel the contract.
- michaelt 3y agoA legally binding guarantee? I doubt anyone will give you one. But if you're buying a home you have other options - for example, you can just buy a house that already has a working broadband connection. The homeowner will give you the wifi password to run a speed test if you ask nicely. If the property doesn't have broadband already, there are other signs you can sometimes spot - cables going into other people's properties, street cabinets and handholes with the company's branding, nearby wifi networks with supplier names in the SSID, and suchlike.
- Analemma_ 3y agoYou can't. Several people have shared stories about trying to get it in writing from Comcast (and it is always Comcast) that service is available at a particular address before they move there, specifically to avoid this issue, and the CSRs will not do it. They're very careful not to make a paper trail with discoverable evidence.
- foobarian 3y ago> the specific guarantee Ah, so it was in writing and backed up by an escrow account? :-D
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoVery doubtful. Probably a Web site, and, in one that I read, actual verbal assurance, by sales person.
- tw04 3y agoThis literally happened to me. Looked at a house, Comcast said they serviced the address. First I checked online, then I called in on top of that just to make absolutely sure. Bought the house, ordered my Comcast, tech shows up on the day of install and says: "Sorry, we don't actually service this address, not sure what happened". I call in and they basically said tough shit, there's no way we're ever running service to that neighborhood.
- zlg_codes 3y agoWow, the gall of those people. It should be punishable for a business to lie to you like this. You made a financial decision based on information that the business should have on file.
- jmholla 3y ago> It should be punishable for a business to lie to you like this. Agreed. Are there routes to sue these corporations? I think there are laws against financial decisions dependent on information provided by others.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoApparently, the reason they do it, is that it qualifies them for some kinds of favors/kickbacks, if they are listed as serving an area, and it also may prevent rivals from serving that area. They tend to have a lot of local politicians in their pocket. Ars Technica tends to cover this crap. They were not fans of Ajit Pai.
- tguvot 3y agoBefore I bought house I opened access panel on a side of the house to make sure that there is coax/etc going into the house and asked neighbors about availability of the service