6 ms·
Are they actually underwater or do they just have higher loan payments than rental income? If it's the latter, let them sell some properties or transfer them to
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
Are they actually underwater or do they just have higher loan payments than rental income? If it's the latter, let them sell some properties or transfer them to the bank in lieu of loan payments.
- HWR_14 3y agoUnderwater. Totally underwater.
- Zetobal 3y agoThe problem they have is that nobody buys their properties...
- jldugger 3y agoOnly in the sense that the problem with pyramid schemes is that people stop buying in.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoHard to rationalize with land rights that expire. You are just playing with government land for a while.
- lmm 3y agoWho says those properties are worth their book value? This is how a crash happens these days - distressed asset holders forced into fire sales of the assets themselves, lowering asset values and putting more of the holders into distress.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThey don't have to be worth book value to be worth more than the outstanding loan principal. This is also why it can make sense to pay the bank in real estate. The bank doesn't need to sell it immediately because they don't need to pay a mortgage so they can just sit on it and collect rental income until they can find a buyer. Another alternative is for the real estate trust to sell new shares into the market and use the money to pay the bank, or pay the bank in new shares. That dilutes the existing shareholders but doesn't force a fire sale of the properties.
- worrycue 3y agoEvergrande has more debt than assets - including property - I believe. They can sell everything at book value and they will still owe money.
- bartvk 3y agoDoes this actually happen? A bank that owns real estate and collects rental income on it?
- nradov 3y agoThat happens all the time in the US and other countries. Banks typically try to sell off those repossessed real estate assets fairly quickly because they aren't really in the landlord business, but when there's a supply glut they may have to hold for several years.
- slv77 3y agoUS regulators also require banks to move non-performing loans and assets off the balance sheet. Allowing banks to hold them makes the balance sheet murky and hard to determine if the bank is solvent. In the 2008 financial crisis banks sold houses off in blocks of 1,000 at a time to hedge funds.
- the-dude 3y agoThis happens all the time, they pony up the money and you pay interest on the loan. In Dutch, interest is actually called 'rente'.
- tacker2000 3y agoOf course. Some banks have their own real estate arms that sell/rent/manage these types of assets
- thechao 3y agoUntil people demand their RMB, and all the bank has is piles of building materials…
- RugnirViking 3y agothere is deflation in china right now. Why would you buy a house today if the money you have today would buy a bigger house tomorrow? As a result, nobody can sell. The only way to move any inventory is to dramatically slash the price. Everyone is doing this, so you gotta do it even more than the next guy (or just hold on to the property but what if you need the money/can't maintain the property?). I've heard of 2mn rmby apartments in beijing going for 100k
- misja111 3y agoTypically real estate companies use properties as collateral for loans. So they can't sell those properties unless they pay back the rest of the loan at the same time, which they probably can't. They might have some properties that are not collateral, but even selling those imposes a problem: in the current market, most likely they will be sold well below book value. This automatically devaluates the value of any other property which they would like to use in the future for collateral and it will make existing lenders very nervous as well.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoThey are massively underwater. They have hundreds of thousands of unfinished apartments, and no money to finish them. And even if they could, no one wants to buy the unsold apartments. The average person in China owns more housing than the average person in the US or the EU. This, with house prices being roughly equal but incomes being 1/6th on average, and there being about ~2.5B unfinished sqft of space (~2 sqft per person), and a rapidly shrinking population. You do the math. Houses have been in a massive bubble in China for a long time, on nearly the same level as the Japanese bubble. Who knows if it's finally going to pop. But the writing definitely seems on the wall now.
- jacquesm 3y agoThey are so far under water that there simply are no buyers, at all, and there likely never will be buyers. A lot of this construction was just to keep the wheels spinning. There are entire cities that are empty.