5 ms·
This is clever thinking, but we've been running airlines for so long now, I can't help but wonder if this has already been tried, and if there were issues with
by crazygringo 3y ago
This is clever thinking, but we've been running airlines for so long now, I can't help but wonder if this has already been tried, and if there were issues with it. Potentical obstacles I can imagine off the top of my head:
- Will people even obey? What if half the people from the wrong side get up too? After a long tiring flight, will that anger people on the correct side and lead to fights? Having to show your ticket to prove you were in the right column to get off is not very customer-friendly
- What about families with children, couples, and groups in general? People want to stay together. It doesn't matter if this is rational or not, it's what people want to feel safe and not anxious
- Is it really even going to make much of a difference? In my experience, people are already mostly grabbing their bags quickly, simultaneously while the rows immediately ahead are starting to exit
And of course, while this can in theory save perhaps a couple minutes for domestic passengers with only a carry-on, even in theory it saves no time at all for anyone who still has to go through a crowded passport control or wait for checked baggage.
- londons_explore 3y agoGetting off the plane is already fairly quick. Everyone wants to get going, usually the plane is empty in 5 minutes or less. I think it would help with getting onto the plane. Filling the plane can easily take 20 minutes - which in a half hour turnaround is often the critical path. The challenge here is you need to get people to enter the plane door in a very precise order. Just 10% of people ignoring instructions probably eliminates most/all of the benefits. Groups who don't want to sit apart or board the plane apart have to go either first or last.
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoGetting people to board in a certain order isn't particularly difficult. Southwest does it already, even if they only use it to... make sitting in a grounded plane a perk of checking in early? I'm actually not sure why they do it.
- londons_explore 3y agoThing is, you need people to board in a super precise order. Just two people swapped around in the line means someone can't get to their seat, delaying the whole boarding process.
- ajmurmann 3y agoThat still would be much faster though than the current approach employed by most airlines which makes it more likely to create congestion in the aisle and minimizes how many people can load luggage and take their seat in parallel.
- 1-more 3y agoTo get overhead luggage space before it fills up, or does SW not allow for that?
- nradov 3y agoSouthwest offers free checked bags so there is somewhat less demand for overhead bin space.
- 1-more 3y agoLots of airlines will gate check your bag for free if the overheads are full, but the overheads are still in high demand because they give you one less errand leaving the destination airport.
- jcl 3y agoI thought Southwest uses “open” seating, where passengers aren’t assigned a seat, but instead just take any unoccupied seat? If so, a perk of being earlier in the boarding order would be that you have a better chance of getting a seat you want, if you have any particular preferences.
- inetknght 3y ago
- paulmd 3y ago> Filling the plane can easily take 20 minutes - which in a half hour turnaround is often the critical path can you really reduce it that much, given that the plane needs to be refueled, cargo unloaded and reloaded, etc? like it may be the case that while it's inconvenient for passengers, the airline doesn't really care because it takes them a half hour to turn the plane around on the tarmac side anyway, so there's no benefit from reducing the passenger loading time.
- londons_explore 3y agopassengers are frequently the critical path. fuel and luggage crews can be quick. I've seen a luggage crew unload and reload a plane inside 8 minutes, including loading 2 airfreight containers.
- ajmurmann 3y agoThere have been similar simulations for boarding airplanes. I wish I had never heard about them because now I get annoyed almost every time I fly. As with de-boarding most time is wasted/spent by people standing in the aisle and waiting for someone who is putting their luggage in. The optimal solution has as many passengers loading their luggage in the overhead compartment in parallel as possible. The ideal way to do this would be that we first have passengers with window seats board with one person for each row. We should only use every other row to ensure people can maneuver. So we'd first board seats NA, N-2A, N-4A, etc. down to row 1 with N being the last row. Then NF, N-2F, N-4F etc. And then N-1A, N-3A and so on. Then we work our way through the middle seats and then aisle seats. The current approach which commonly boards people starting from the front or back FORCES congestion and minimizes probability of two people reaching their seat at the same time and being able to put up their luggage in parallel. Even if the approach I describe is broken because groups board together, it becomes at worst a random boarding order which is still much more efficient than the current nonsense. The reason we cannot board more efficiently is because it's unintuitive, people don't like it and behave like wild animals in groups.
- londons_explore 3y ago> Even if the approach I describe is broken because groups board together, it becomes at worst a random boarding order which is still much more efficient than the current nonsense. I think it can quickly become worse than random. Imagine you have the perfect sequence for max parallelism, but right in the middle is one 6 person family group who are going to take 10 minutes to get seated while they arrange toys and stuff for each child, blocking the aisle the whole time. With the perfect sequence, this halts all boarding for those 10 mins, since people need to pass the blockage for the scheme to work. Whereas with random boarding, there will actually be many people who manage to get seated during those 10 mins, because there will be a bunch of people who, by chance, are seated between the door and the blockage and can get to their seats.
- ajmurmann 3y agoUnless the method is reactive, that family would always lead to the entire aisle being filled within seconds with waiting passengers who need to pass them unless the family is very far back in the plane.
- avidiax 3y ago> The challenge here is you need to get people to enter the plane door in a very precise order. Small amounts of money are often very motivating. You could, for example, say that anyone can enter or leave the plane in any order they like. However, if they do so before their turn in the system, they don't get a $10 refund on their ticket. If they don't present their ticket, they are assumed to have gone early. The question then, is whether the benefit would remain with proportional instead of total compliance, and whether the benefit outweighs the costs of enforcement.
- mattnewton 3y agoMy first thought is that there no way the boarding time is worth $10 per passenger to the airline, and no way they increase the cost $10 and don’t lose tickets to other people just using aggregate services like google flights and picking cheap options
- andrewflnr 3y agoEvery plane I've been on in the last decade already sorts people by "boarding groups" which are relatively fine-grained. They won't let you onto the boarding ramp unless you're in the correct group, which they check by scanning your boarding pass. All they would have to do is make those boarding groups be based on your seating position instead of how much extra money you paid.
- Accujack 3y agoExactly. This proposal entirely ignores human nature, and the author has obviously not done any research into the problem beyond being annoyed while waiting to exit an aircraft. There's this 2015 article on doing essentially what he/she is suggesting: https://www.vox.com/2014/7/8/5877863/it-takes-forever-to-get-off-an-airplane-there-might-be-a-better-way https://www.vox.com/2014/7/8/5877863/it-takes-forever-to-get... There's a paper on solving the problem by assigning passengers to seats so that their luggage is evenly spread throughout the overhead bins: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0969699713001166 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S096969971... There's a paper here on other methods tried, including creating "pre boarding" areas for passengers: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269466040_Speeding_up_the_airplane_boarding_process_by_using_pre-boarding_areas https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269466040_Speeding_... The first step in any scientific endeavor should always be a literature search.. see what's been tried, and what worked and what didn't.
- yellowapple 3y ago> Will people even obey? One solution might be to have lights that light up when it's time for your column to deplane. A more evil solution would be to use physical barriers that only open when it's a given column's turn. Maybe replace the seatbelts with rollercoaster-style restraints for extra fun. > What about families with children, couples, and groups in general? Have them deplane either first or last. The page seems to suggest that waiting for the next "wave" ain't a huge deal, so having groups wait until their last column is ready to go (or worst case, until all individuals have deplaned) could probably work. > Is it really even going to make much of a difference? Maybe not in isolation, but maybe the aggregate effects (e.g. more flights per day) would justify it?
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoYeah, I read analyses like this article and just think "this person doesn't realize that they don't think/act like most people". Most people flying are not traveling alone. It's not just the oft quoted "families with small children". What about couples/friends/colleagues. People traveling together largely sit in the same rows, not the same columns, and they want to exit together. These kind of analyses (especially the "if everyone saved 13 seconds we'd size the equivalent of 20 lives!" part) always make me a bit said because, in a lot of cases, it's clear the author understands math but not humans.
- very_good_man 3y agoI've considered the "group" issue at length and do not consider it a major issue. People like us are obligated to improve the world for the less enlightened.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoIn a world where we can’t convince people to wash their hands (among other more controversial public health asks that shall remain nameless to prevent ideological thread derailment) I don’t think we can convince people to not descend into chaos when asked to do something like this. It’s a great idea for efficient pipelining, but humans view the emptying of each row in order as more fair and common sense. It doesn’t require coordination beyond the people within rows and is resilient to people bucking the protocol. I wonder how rapidly this column wise deplaning breaks down in the face of random compliance and confusion.
- acherion 3y agoI guess families with young kids that would have to leave the kid in the window aisle, distressed and upset while the only people they know are leaving them in a vessel with people they don't know, are just not "enlightened" enough. I implore you to consider the group issue in more detail, and perhaps with a touch of human empathy this time.
- very_good_man 3y ago