4 ms·
The Campbells soup example shows precisely why inflation can't be based on a single product, and why the Bureau of Labor Statistics employs a bunch of professio
by ceejayoz 3y ago
The Campbells soup example shows precisely why inflation can't be based on a single product, and why the Bureau of Labor Statistics employs a bunch of professionals to figure this issue out. If you measured inflation by the cost of a 60" television, you'd see a very different (and equally useless) chart.
The new car price chart says in tiny text "not adjusted for inflation".
At that point, I figured the rest of the article was likely to include similarly glaring methodology problems.
- barbazoo 3y agoYou can't eat a 60" tv or a car though. When it comes to surviving, the price of food (among others obviously) is what matters so I'd say it's fair to focus on that for the purpose of a writeup like this. Not saying this isn't cherry picked though.
- ceejayoz 3y ago> You can't eat a 60" tv or a car though. That's not the point. (As I said, the 60" TV stat is equally useless for evaluating inflation.) Cherry-picking a single product like "Campbell's tomato soup" is not a valid methodology for measuring inflation. Not because it's edible or inedible, but because it's too small of a sample size. You can tell any story you like about inflation and the economy by carefully hand-picking a single item. If the price of an egg doubles, but the price of butter halves, what do we conclude about inflation? Nothing; we need more information.
- landoftheice 3y ago[dead]
- TheCoelacanth 3y agoFood spending as a percent of income[1] has trended down drastically since the 1890s, though. It would be reasonable to look at the price of food in general, but cherry-picking one specific brand of one specific food item is absurd. It has as much to do with Campbell's marketing strategy as it does with food prices in general. [1] https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/chart-gallery/gallery/chart-detail/?chartId=76967 https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/chart-gallery/gallery...
- barbazoo 3y agoDrastically down until 2000 and then drastically up since 2020.
- TheCoelacanth 3y agoDriven primarily by eating out rather than spending on food eaten at home. It's not the food that's more expensive; it's the waiter and the cook that are more expensive.
- trdtaylor1 3y agoThe point the article is making about the BLS statistics is they do not represent the ground truth of inflation, and indirectly how it impacts different economic classes, due to both difficulty in capturing real inflation AND there are ways to game it. There are reasons for BLS to come with reduced official inflation, same as other countries. The real inflation rate as experienced by the poor and middle class is normally higher then what BLS claims.
- ceejayoz 3y ago> The point the article is making about the BLS statistics is they do not represent the ground truth of inflation... Neither does the price of a can of a particular brand's tomato soup in isolation.
- oatmeal1 3y agoNo matter how many, or how qualified the professionals, inflation can't really be measured. The goods change over time, and it's very subjective as to whether those changes justify price increases.
- DonsDiscountGas 3y agoA messy and imperfect measure is the best we can do, which is definitely better than no measure at all. Though it also means we argue about inflation methodology calculations forever.
- oatmeal1 3y ago> A messy and imperfect measure is the best we can do, which is definitely better than no measure at all. Not sure I agree. I think it leads to fundamentally misunderstanding the economy and an excessive focus on financial measures of the economy where other measures are available.
- awithrow 3y agoLargely I see inflation measurements as a model that degrades with time. Inflation of one year vs the last couple of years? Not too bad of a measure, things are similar enough. Inflation of this year's dollars vs dollars 50 years ago, much less useful as the things being purchased are radically different. Inflation comparing today's dollars to dollars 100-200 years ago. Largely worthless too many goods are either completely different or don't exist
- jkaptur 3y agoThe price of Campbell's soup began its dramatic rise after Warhol's record-breaking sale of Campbell's Soup Cans in 1970. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campbell%27s_Soup_Cans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campbell%27s_Soup_Cans) Although back then you could buy Campbell's Soup Cans (the painting) for just $60,000. In 2022, a famous Warhol painting went for ~$195,000,000.
- mbg721 3y agoPete Rose didn't have the same good fortune...