4 ms·
> This guy is a ... "doomer" ... Whatever your feelings about his pessimistic tone, regularly debunking the latest popular media baloney is a reasonable pastim
by bell-cot 3y ago
> This guy is a ... "doomer" ...
Whatever your feelings about his pessimistic tone, regularly debunking the latest popular media baloney is a reasonable pastime, which society could certainly use more of.
> Fusion is obviously monumentally hard ... steady march of gains toward higher ... There is no known fundamental physical reason why ...
True. And limestone can be mined by hand, on top of Mount Everest. The cost per kilogram would be enormously higher than any normal commercial limestone quarry, but if we just invested enough...
Meanwhile, "aim your solar cells roughly toward the sun" fusion energy is available at scale, now, and is orders of magnitude cheaper than there's any reason to believe possible for a commercial fusion reactor. And human society does not have infinite resources, to invest in sounds-cool stuff with massively negative ROI's.
- cubefox 3y agoSolar power is highly volatile and can't be stored in large quantities. It's not cheap when it is infinitely expensive at night. A better alternative to fusion would be fission. It works, is stable, and will likely remain far cheaper than fusion even when fusion becomes technically possible.
- api 3y ago> can't be stored in large quantities. "We don't have an energy problem. We have an energy storage problem."
- cubefox 3y agoWe don't even have much of a storage problem, fission works and doesn't need energy storage. Our problem is rather that coal power is cheaper than fission. Coal plants are responsible for the majority of anthropogenic CO2.
- api 3y agoCoal and fissile fuels are stored energy. My point is that if we can store energy at scale we can just grab the free energy that falls from the sky.
- cubefox 3y agoWe can't store the energy in coal. Only in batteries at high cost and low capacity.
- pfdietz 3y agoThe claim that we can only store energy in batteries is a lie. In fact, storing energy in "e-fuels" is likely to be essential for a 100% renewable economy, as they are much better suited to long duration storage use cases.