9 ms·
The flipside is the refusal of people to acknowledge the good news that we do have -- like solar and wind power. Perhaps because it's boring. Solar is basical
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
The flipside is the refusal of people to acknowledge the good news that we do have -- like solar and wind power.
Perhaps because it's boring. Solar is basically the same tech as it was in the 70s. The only major difference is that it is literally more than a million times cheaper.
It's cheaper to install and operate solar than it is just to operate a coal plant.
Sure there are challenges with wind and solar, but that's all they are: challenges, not showstoppers. When something has such a compelling cost advantage, there is lots of margin to throw at the challenges.
It'll be difficult to power a grid with 100% wind and solar so that's all you hear. But on the flip side, it'd be quite straightforward to power the grid using 90% renewables using the existing plants for the last hard 10%. It'd be both cheaper & cleaner! Why the heck aren't we celebrating that? Add short term storage and it'll be 99%.
And this isn't theoretical or anything. We are doing it. We're currently installing solar & wind at about 5% a year, and that 5% is increasing by about 50% annually.
There is way more good news than bad news about solar. But good news is boring and bad news gets clicks, so you only see the bad news.
- jackmott42 3y ago>It's cheaper to install and operate solar than it is just to operate a coal plant. When you say this you need to also talk about how much it costs to build enough energy storage for solar to become some given percentage of grid power. There is probably some % where it stops being cheaper than coal
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThank you for nicely illustrating my point.
- jacquesm 3y agoIt's interesting how you could hand a solution out on a platter and all that will happen is that people will run around yelling 'it isn't perfect'. As if any powersource has a 100% uptime guarantee.
- cratermoon 3y agoU.S. nuclear power plants typically refuel every 18 to 24 months. The average planned outage time is about a month. We never hear much about how nuclear power plants only have a ~95% planned uptime.
- concordDance 3y agoThe problem isn't the uptime, it's that the downtime strongly correlates across all instances of wind power and across all instances of solar power in a country: https://gridwatch.templar.co.uk/ https://gridwatch.templar.co.uk/
- jacquesm 3y agoSo what? It's not as if those baseline powerplants that we have today will all suddenly disappear. They will just have a lower utilization factor. And that's perfectly fine. Solar, hydro and wind when you have them, nuclear when you don't, gas when you don't have nuclear and coal when you don't have gas. It is really quite simple. And the best bit is that you can have your solar and wind installations up and running before the ink is even dry on the kind of permit and investment required for a nuclear plant and it is much cheaper to boot, as well as decentralized so far more resilient and friendlier to the grid (assuming the grid is well designed in the first place, which isn't always true). And 'in a country' is the wrong level to be thinking at. You should look at much larger areas than that, and across both longitude and latitude.
- lolinder 3y agoThey have a paragraph addressing that point, if you read on: > It'll be difficult to power a grid with 100% wind and solar so that's all you hear. But on the flip side, it'd be quite straightforward to power the grid using 90% renewables using the existing plants for the last hard 10%. It'd be both cheaper & cleaner! Why the heck aren't we celebrating that?
- asynchronous 3y agoAn article about fusion and HN manages to bring up solar and wind somehow. Never fails.
- HPsquared 3y agoThey are competing for the same market. Unless fusion can be much more economical than solar?
- dale_glass 3y agoIt's an article about how fusion is still far away. It's technically cool, yes, but we need electricity now, and tomorrow, not next century. I'm excited for fusion as a human accomplishment, as high tech research, maybe as a power source for future spaceships. But I think it's likely the time may never come when it's used to generate power for the electric grid, and expecting that to come soon is just naive. We don't even have a single fusion plant that produces power yet, let alone the hundreds of them that would be needed for the tech to have a real-world impact.
- oezi 3y agoIt is an article that nicely illustrates that it is at least 50 years away. We shouldn't pin any hopes to it or (for me at least) fund research on it any more than 10% of the funding we provide for solar research.
- joak 3y agoThe title says 'fusion' but the talk is actually about NIF and their inflated PR. Fusion energy companies like CFS (tokamak) or Helion (colliding FRCs with direct energy capture) might start producing electricity to the grid in less than 10 years.
- oezi 3y agoOnce they have a working prototype it is going to be 10 to 15 years for paperwork and building the first plant.
- oezi 3y agoI think it is obvious to anyone following the technology trajectory that solar is the dominant energy source of the future. No other energy source is on a similar path to become cheaper so quickly. We won't even focus on storing much of it but just build more and more.
- jacquesm 3y agoSolar + transport is good but still fragile, a cheap, durable and reliable means of storage would complete the picture.
- pydry 3y agoI think a lot of the skepticism around solar/wind/storage rests on an incorrect understanding of how easily variability can be dealt with. Which is understandable, because it's quite a complex problem to model. The story on that is surprisingly positive, but it's quite easy to FUD by parties with a vested interest (carbon lobby, nuclear lobby) because some people will hear: * "well, the sun doesn't shine at night. the wind doesn't always blow! check mate!" E.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37161473 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37161473 (posted after I wrote this) or, if it's aimed at a slightly higher intellectual level, things like: * "pumped storage is a nice idea but realistically there just isn't enough space for all the pumped storage we need". E.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37161790 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37161790 (posted after I wrote this) * "we need 1-2 weeks worth of storage to deal with the inherent instability of wind/solar" And they'll believe it because it all sounds plausible enough, even though it's wrong. And then they'll repeat it all over hacker news lol...
- jacquesm 3y agoIndeed. It's raining soup, all we need is more spoons. We are awash in energy but we're totally focused on making it in the most complicated, centralized and expensive way possible. It's fascinating in a way, how all of these tools are available and yet there are fairly powerful lobbies that keep pulling us away from the solution just so they can make a bit more money.
- concordDance 3y agoNo, the problem isn't some conspiracy it's the very real problem of "how do you store electricity when days are cloudy and still?". Look at these graphs: https://gridwatch.templar.co.uk/ https://gridwatch.templar.co.uk/ You need to either overbuild 10x or you need lots of storage. Even a 3x overbuild means you need weeks of storage if you want to avoid once a year brownouts. And electricity storage still costs 100-400$/kWh per 10 years. An extra £60 billion per year while ALSO building 3x more solar and wind than we will use during peak times is a lot of money for the government to spend.
- jacquesm 3y agoThis is really old hat by now. Everybody is aware of the fact that when it is cloudy and there is no wind that you will need other sources. But on balance for the planet as a whole there always is plenty of wind and there always is plenty of sun. We are just not capturing it and we are not transporting it effectively across longer distances. People used to say that you can't make baseline power with solar and wind. Slowly - and often grudgingly - they've come around and now realize that it isn't about 100% availability, that will always be a mix. The question is simply how much of that mix can be offset by renewables and the answer is 'much more than you originally thought'. And as the price of solar and wind drops further and further that fraction only increases. Every KWh that is produced by solar and wind does not need to be generated by fossil.
- concordDance 3y agoHow are you transporting that power from thousands of miles away through unstable countries containing people that love to take your power hostage?
- indymike 3y ago> The flipside is the refusal of people to acknowledge the good news that we do have -- like solar and wind power. No one is ignoring it. We're rapidly deploying both technologies all over the place. It's exciting that real money is flowing into the industry. Fusion has speculator money, and Fusion gets extra attention because it's sold as basically, the cure to all energy problems, forever and ever.
- pfdietz 3y agoWhen one considers that the world will spend somewhere around a quadrillion dollars on energy in the 21st century, fusion is actually getting very little money. The market is saying the chance of fusion grabbing this gargantuan market is rather small.
- dahfizz 3y agoHow do you power the grid with 90% solar when the sun only shines 40% of the day during the winter? Renewable optimists consistently under-estimate the storage problem by orders of magnitude. We don't have enough batteries on Earth to hold one single day's worth of electricity. And for us to actually rely on solar, we would need to store multiple months of electricity to survive the winter. Solar is cheap because you're comparing a generation source that works on occasion with a generation source that works 24/7. I'm not anti-solar at all. But I am realistic about what we can and can't do with it. The thing that will make a solar grid practical _today_ is focusing on variable loads. When the sun is shining, we should be cranking the AC of every home and office, smelting aluminum, filling dams, etc.
- delecti 3y agoThe comment didn't say "90% solar", it said "90% renewables". That includes hydro and wind, which don't stop at night or in the winter.
- tmikaeld 3y agoCurrent and near-future grid cannot handle such a balance of renewables, especially hydro takes a lot of beating when the water level goes up and down constantly.
- delecti 3y agoNobody is blind to the fact that the grid will need to be updated to be more flexible.
- ekianjo 3y agoThats a myth. You cannot have baseline power with renewables only throughout the year. Hydro only works in very specific places and the same for wind.
- dale_glass 3y agoWhy? Build more. Interconnect with HVDC.
- matkoniecz 3y ago> using 90% renewables using the existing plants for the last hard 10% Solar and wind cannot be used in this role and at this scale due to their massive variability
- mordae 3y agoSo make the factory, AC, etc... vary the load!
- matkoniecz 3y agoBrownouts and blackouts lasting for weeks during windless winter weeks are hardly solution.
- KSteffensen 3y agoCan't we fill the Sahara with solar panels? If transmission lines are problematic hydrogen or methane could be used to transfer the energy to where it needs to be used. This of course has a lot of political implications, but if we wanted to do it we could.
- pfdietz 3y agoAnd quite avoidable, even on a 100% renewable grid.
- matkoniecz 3y agoI was responding to " So make the factory, AC, etc... vary the load! " that proposed blackouts as solution.
- pfdietz 3y agoThat post did not propose blackouts as a solution.
- concordDance 3y ago
- djha-skin 3y agoSolar requires way more concrete and a bunch of mined rare earth minerals, nickel and cobalt, and is not green. Wind power requires an enormous amount of epoxy and the windmills wear out and then you have to throw an enormous amount of epoxy away and it is not green. Storing energy using batteries from the above sources requires an enormous amount of nickel and cobalt mind out of the Earth by third world countries and is not green. Fusion power requires mining lithium and is not green. Nuclear power requires changing people's minds and when it does fail it causes two-headed fish. While perhaps green, it is not politically feasible at this time. Here's an idea. Take public transit instead of using that Tesla that required a bunch of imported rare earth minerals from sweatshops in China and microchips from Taiwan -- which may or may not be available to us in the future in this geopolitical climate -- and lithium and cobalt from death trap mines down in Peru and Africa. Burn natural gas in your stove instead of electricity which is generally coal-fired, or if it isn't coal fired, it comes from so solar and wind and is therefore not green. My point is that the original paragraph stands. It's going to get worse before it gets better and no one wants to believe this.
- sandworm101 3y ago>> Fusion power requires mining lithium and is not green. Where can I buy this machine?
- klysm 3y agoI hate this term of 'green'. It's conflating so many different axes of environmental effects, which is sometimes what we care about but it removes any nuance immediately. I find usually it distracts from one of the primary issues: carbon dioxide going into the atmosphere.
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoI feel like you're worried a little too much about having to tolerate some waste here and there and not worried enough about global changes to biosphere function. Yeah, having mine next to your house sucks, we need to get better at managing that kind of thing. But it's a local suck. It's in a totally different category than having the climate shift into a mode that no longer supports our food crops, for instance.
- concordDance 3y ago> it'd be quite straightforward to power the grid using 90% renewables using the existing plants for the last hard 10%. Sadly incorrect. You can see the variation of wind and solar we get here in the UK at: https://gridwatch.templar.co.uk/ https://gridwatch.templar.co.uk/ As you can see, fossil fuels are about a 1/3rd of power and we expand renewables by maybe another 30% before we start getting excess power. After that point, you start to have excess power while no longer reducing CO2 by much as you still need the Nat gas for the cloudy and still days. In practice you might be able to get to 75% non-fossil fuels before you're firmly into the realm of diminishing returns without a big storage breakthrough or a doubling/tripling of electricity costs (its triple to go pure wind and current tech energy storage because you need up to weeks of storage to not have blackouts, but with a nuclear power expansion youd only need a doubling).
- bryanlarsen 3y ago90% is easier in North America where I'm based due to our large grids. But you've already implemented part of the solution to get to 90% -- bidirectional HVDC grids with Norway. Sell cheap wind power when you can and buy hydro when you can't. But even if you can't easily get to 90% why not celebrate the fact that 75% is easy. Sure the last 25% is hard, but 75% good news and 25% bad news is not what I see in the news articles.
- Projectiboga 3y agoIsn't nuclear nearly 20% of the USA power mix? I've never liked fission but it's there and lots of effort to design a next generation of it which would be able to use nuclear waste and maybe make that less hazardous.
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoThe problem with breeder reactors isn't, and never has been, an engineering one. It's a relatively simple process, so far as nuclear physics is concerned. The problem is that the anti-nuclear cowards don't want to make plutonium easily available. Nevermind the fact that we already have one of the largest nuclear arsenals (maybe the biggest, given Russia's gross mismanagement as of late), and pose no real proliferation risk, since we already have all the plutonium our hearts desire.
- sydbarrett74 3y agoSadly, it's the old 'if it bleeds, it leads' meme. People are attracted to extremes (good or bad) and if something is boring and middle-of-the-road, they ignore it. SLow, iterative, steady progress is boring to most people. They want dramatic breakthroughs. Most of the public can't grasp the mathematics of compounding change.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoThere's many reasons to believe that the future is going to be as unrecognizably (mostly) better to us as someone who was born in the 1940s to today. In the 1940s - cities smelled like sh!t, were so polluted you almost never wanted to go outside, healthcare was still largely snake oil, the average person was still working 10 hours a day 6 days week, human rights outside of straight white christian men were questionable, AND we were in our second world war in 20 years - at the advent of the nuclear bomb. Look at where we are now. If you don't see progress, and if you can't see how people back then thought the world was surely coming to an end, and you think it's worse now, I'm honestly amazed. At no point in time, was progress a up and to the right with no impediments. Every advance we've had, people have worked HARD for. So thank your lucky stars so many people get up every day and keep working for it. Because it isn't easy. But it's what we do. Always have. Always will. Eventually, we will reach the physical limits of how good technology can get. But we are laughably far away from that point in so many major aspects of life, that we've got a long way to go before the 10 & 20 year future might not be better.
- ifyoubuildit 3y agoThat's all well and good, but even if progress continues as you say, you have to worry about powerful people directing that progress ineptly. As we get more advanced, room for mistakes shrinks and we get closer to a great filter situation.
- jchonphoenix 3y agoSF still smells
- geodel 3y agoYou can't really compare past nasty smell with premium high tech NextGen® smelly shit of today.
- tarsinge 3y agoThe catch is it’s not really progress if it’s not sustainable. It’s like living on debt, it ends up in bankruptcy. Are we really correctly investing the ecological debt for a sustainable better future, or are we just burning through it for short term "progress" and leaving a ruined earth after? > But it's what we do. Always have. Always will. You can’t extrapolate from the past because never before in history we had the capacity to have impacts at that scale (e.g. atomic bomb). We are in uncharted territories.
- ianburrell 3y agoAlso, 100% renewables isn’t the only option. We can build more capacity than we need. Research shows that 300% mix of solar and wind will cover all but the worst days. It also gives lots of extra capacity on most days to produce fuel and capture carbon. The fuel provides long-term storage for bad days.
- AlbertCory 3y agoHe posted about fusion, and you replied about solar. Not all technology follows the same cost curve.
- fho 3y agoFun thing: (in Germany) some of the peope that are strictly against nuclear power now start to argue against wind too ... Because they don't like the look of the turbines and does nobody thing about the nature and ... Some can't be reasoned with.
- Gibbon1 3y agoAlso that utility storage batteries suddenly got cheap enough to compete with peekers. California now can shift a couple of GW of power from mornings and mid day to the early evening. It's maybe 10% but that capacity was all added in the last 4 years. Also population growth has declined more rapidly than predicted and in places where it wasn't expected. Which brings it's own issues most of which have to do with finance and sustainability of rentier capitalism, but not being able to feed and house people. Partly due to policy makers fuckups around the 2008 financial crisis birth rates in US dropped. Which means today's 14 years olds are going to enter the best job market in three generations.