4 ms·
Or, just use the hydrogen as-is, in stationary power plants. Hydrogen can be burned in combustion turbines just like methane; why add the extra step? At $1/kg
by pfdietz 3y ago
Or, just use the hydrogen as-is, in stationary power plants. Hydrogen can be burned in combustion turbines just like methane; why add the extra step?
At $1/kg, the fuel cost of a combined cycle power plant will be $0.05/kWh. Hydrogen is quite storable underground (just like natural gas). At this fuel cost, new construction nuclear is hopelessly uncompetitive, even for base load generation. And unlike nuclear, the hydrogen burning CC plants can be economically dispatched, turned down/off when renewables or short term storage are directly powering the grid.
- rgmerk 3y agoSure, if you're only using it as storage in a largely electrified economy. The attraction of synthetic methane is that it is 1) transportable in existing pipelines, including to millions of homes and small businesses. 2) usable in literally millions of existing devices 3) relatively easy to ship. None of those things are true for hydrogen.
- chii 3y agoso the question becomes whether it's harder to improve CO2 capture, or to make transporting and using hydrogen (ala, build out new or improve existing pipes, machines etc). I would imagine that improving CO2 capture is "easier", because it requires fewer people to cooperate. Existing infrastructure replacement/improvements will need large numbers of people to agree on what, who and how. And you know how that goes...
- pfdietz 3y agoIt's more efficient to burn hydrogen (or methane) in a combined cycle plant and use that power to drive heat pumps in homes and businesses, than it would be to burn that fuel in furnaces there. As an added bonus, you can often drive those heat pumps directly from renewable sources without the conversion cost of electrolysis (and for methane, DAC and methane synthesis.) Methane also has the probably unavoidable problem of leaks in the distribution network. It's a strong greenhouse gas; even small leaks are very problematic.
- rgmerk 3y agoYes, I agree, and am of the view that the widespread distribution of piped gas (hydrogen, methane, or blends thereof) to homes and small business is going to be phased out for the reasons you describe. But you can see why some people are trying to make a drop-in, clean-ish (modulo fugitive emissions) replacement for fossil gas.
- angiosperm 3y agoIncidentally, leaked hydrogen is substantially worse, as a greenhouse gas, than methane.
- fomine3 3y agoIs it? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential#Values https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential#Value...
- morsch 3y agoIn the atmosphere? No. The GWP of methane is about twice as high as hydrogen, as far as we know. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential
- semi-extrinsic 3y agoNope, the GWP of methane is 2x larger than hydrogen, both on 20 and 100 year time scales. And that's on an equal-mass basis. If you consider an equal-energy basis (which is what we actually care about), methane is 5x worse than hydrogen. Finally, hydrogen has wider flammability limits than methane, so from a safety perspective you have to make hydrogen systems even more leak-proof than methane/natural gas systems.
- angiosperm 3y agoThe atmosphere has a limited capacity for turning H2 into H2O. As more H2 is released, each molecule takes longer to be neutralized.
- whimsicalism 3y agoSynthetic methane also would enable renewable, carbon-neutral plastics - I have a friend working on a startup that is using microorganisms to produce traditional petrochemical precursors and they have said a major barrier to this being green is that the methanol that the bacteria needs is typically produced from natgas now.
- Loic 3y agoWe are in the process of using current gas pipelines for pure hydrogen in Germany. It is also possible to mix a percentage of hydrogen in the normal feed of gas burners. For the moment only at the industrial scale. Home devices are not yet adapted. Industry is quick to adapt especially because of the incentives.
- b3orn 3y agoAre we? Do you have a source for that? Unless it has already been built with hydrogen in mind we'd need completely new infrastructure, pipepines, storage and turbines in power plants.
- ben_bai 3y agoWe aren't. It's all a pipe dream. We want to, but Hydrogen is much harder to contain than Methane. If anything we are closer to dismantling the gas pipelines then to use them for Hydrogen. All the attached "Appliances" must be converted from using Methan to Hydrogen, too. Not gonna happen.
- defrost 3y agoI suspect the plans in Germany are to import Hydrogen as Ammonia from overseas in addition to directly creating and locally storing hydrogen from wind and solar power .. all to feed local generators to baseload the German powergrid. https://www.wasserstoff-niedersachsen.de/en/wilhelmshaven-green-energy-hub/ https://www.wasserstoff-niedersachsen.de/en/wilhelmshaven-gr... https://www.ewe.com/en/media-center/press-releases/2022/11/tes-and-ewe-to-build-500mw-electrolyser-at-wilhelmshaven-green-energy-hub-ewe-ag https://www.ewe.com/en/media-center/press-releases/2022/11/t... https://www.reuters.com/business/sustainable-business/fortescue-germanys-tree-energy-partner-develop-green-hydrogen-facility-2022-10-04/ https://www.reuters.com/business/sustainable-business/fortes...
- Loic 3y agoI can tell you that the industry, that is, the biggest are setting up the infrastructure at the moment to have H2 transit between the "North" and the Ruhr region. So, yes, we do it now. Source: I work in oil & gas.
- tastyfreeze 3y agoI agree on methane being the ideal energy storage medium. It can be synthesisize but it is more efficient to use an anaerobic digester to turn organic waste to methane.
- pfdietz 3y agoMethane is not ideal. Liquid hydrocarbons would be much easier to store. They might be harder to make than methane, but then methane is harder to make than hydrogen (from non-biomass renewables), so by that metric methane isn't ideal either.
- tastyfreeze 3y agoIf we have the energy available for longer hydrocarbons, sure, do it. Methane is the feedstock. We would do well to produce as much methane as possible as local as possible. Everybody wants natural gas and we spend a lot of energy transporting it around the world.
- pfdietz 3y agoLonger chain hydrocarbons are more valuable as feedstocks than methane, too. Methane is used to make ammonia because it's so cheap.
- tastyfreeze 3y agoI'm not referring to the Haber-Bosch process. Fischer-Tropsch process also uses syngas mosty derived by steam reforming methane. FT is used to make a variety of hydrocarbons. If we are breaking hydrocarbons down to build them back from scratch might as well use the cheapest feedstock. That is currently methane. The nice thing about methane is we can get it almost for free, anywhere, using biology. That means we can continue our high energy lifestyle relying less on moving energy around.
- hef19898 3y agoHydrogen is also ised in a variety of industries, including steel. Today, that hydrogen is a by-product of oil refining. Having a green hydrogen source that is cost competitive is a great thing. No idea if the 1 USD per kg is realistic so.
- thinkcontext 3y agoHydrogen is consumed during oil refining, it is not generally a big byproduct.
- pfdietz 3y agoMost hydrogen is produced deliberately by steam methane reforming (SMR). Some 6% of world natural gas demand is making hydrogen. The primary use is for synthesis of ammonia (with hydrodesulfurization of petroleum also important.)
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago> 1) transportable in existing pipelines, including to millions of homes and small businesses. Thats not an advantage if hydrogen does not need to be transported at all - you burn it in a powerplant and send out electrons.
- jqpabc123 3y agoOr, just use the hydrogen as-is Or, just use the solar electricity as-is. I understand the energy storage aspect here but it comes at a high cost. One battery breakthrough will obsolete this entire process. Lots of time and money is being devoted to new battery technology --- very little to this. This effectively looks like a long shot effort to salvage the internal combustion engine.
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago> One battery breakthrough will obsolete this entire process Certainly, in year 2060 when it's too late. I can't help thinking that peolle who believe in Rapture have a similar thought process - if you are holding out for a miracle, it doesn't make sence to put in effort now
- jqpabc123 3y agoCertainly, in year 2060 when it's too late So when will this hydrogen thingy will be ready and economically viable? Don't look now but you might have just as big (if not bigger) case of religion.
- qwytw 3y agoSo investing it both would be the beast approach (using a ratio based cost effectiveness, viability etc. estimate)?
- jqpabc123 3y agousing a ratio based cost effectiveness, viability etc. estimate Isn't this sorta how the "free market" works? People/corporations invest money based on their judgement of viability, effectiveness, etc.. Right now, the majority of the collective mind trust is betting on new battery technology. But feel free to convince them otherwise.
- pfdietz 3y ago
- Gasp0de 3y agoThat's highly inefficient though, and therefore negates all the cost savings in the process before. How much efficiency can you get out of burning stuff, 40% of the stored energy?
- pfdietz 3y agoCombined cycle powerplants are > 60% efficient (LHV). The LHV of hydrogen is 33.3 kWh (of heat) per kilogram. Yes, it would be inefficient overall. And it's still cheaper than nuclear. Throw in a large fraction of energy not going through hydrogen (direct to grid, or through batteries) and the cost would be even lower.
- specialist 3y agoYes and: Startups like ETFuels are decarbonizing other industries, like transportation and fertilizers. We'll need all the solutions. Not either-or, but yes-to-all-and-more-of-it-please.
- pfdietz 3y agoThe space of solutions includes ideas that are ludicrous. We don't need all the solutions, we need some of the solutions that make sense. And you can't presuppose for any solution that it will fall in the sensible-and-not-ludicrous part; you have to argue why that would be. For new construction nuclear, for example, it's not at all clear building any more will make sense.
- rocqua 3y agoThe storage, transport, and existing infrastructure and machinery that already uses natural gas makes it much more attractive as a fuel. It sure isn't efficient. But with energy sources that are intermittent and have no ability to scale up for demand, we will have a lot of intermittently very cheap energy. Anything that can use this intermittent power is valuable, because we will need overcapacity to handle the low-wind, low-sun moments