3 ms·
The funding isn't evenly distributed. One special ed student might consume $100k/year, funding for kids without special needs will subsidize that cost (assuming
by seanmcdirmid 3y ago
The funding isn't evenly distributed. One special ed student might consume $100k/year, funding for kids without special needs will subsidize that cost (assuming this is per pupil across the board). Teachers in Seattle went on strike for that last fall, with no way of funding more special education spending beyond taking it away from other students.
Equity might demand that funds are diverted to less well funded districts; Washington state for example will siphon property tax money away from richer western districts to subsidize poorer districts on the eastern side of the state (because of state supreme court ruling).
Then of course, there is administration costs (which are the first to get cut in funding shortages), training costs (which are often legit), etc...
- aydyn 3y agoSorry, why does one special ed student require 100K / year? That is insane, it's literally twice the median income of an adult in the U.S.
- dessimus 3y agoThat student might require a full-time 1-on-1 aide whose sole responsibility is working with that student, plus additional interventionists who only work with a handful of students. Those labor/benefit costs would be the majority of the $100K. Then, start to tack on additional learning materials that may be needed for that student that may not be necessary for the rest of the students.
- devoutsalsa 3y agoIt also includes transportation. I couldn’t find the video, but I remember reading how one special needs student in a rural area would get a flight to school every day, as there was no special education program in their local area.
- badlucklottery 3y agoEqual access to education (a consequence of the 14th Amendment) means that the school district more or less has to do whatever it takes to educate each kid regardless of disability. A modern, functional district will have a small army of Speech Language Pathologist (SLPs), Occupational Therapists (OTs), etc. jumping between schools and/or special ed classrooms to work with kids. The more severe the needs of a kid, the more therapists and therapy sessions they'll need. This adds up quickly. I suspect a lot of this is covered by universal health coverage in other western nations.
- K0balt 3y agoI hate to be that guy, but we need to be making these choices based on overall benefit vs cost to society. What is the benefit to society of providing the best possible education to a person who will never hold any kind of position of responsibility in society? A person who will spend their entire life under some kind of supervised care? Often trying to cram an education down these kids throats is more traumatic than useful. And society is going to pay 1.2 million for the satisfaction of torturing this unfortunate child for a decade? What is the point of that? Wouldn’t money be better spent paying a part time aide for the child at home with the goal of maximising quality of life, working directly with their primary caregiver? That could cost around 25k and have a much better outcome. We should be investing heavily in our brightest students, investing in practical applied knowledge for the majority, and focusing on critical thinking and independent learning skills for everyone. The unfortunate few that will not be able to meaningfully participate and will require support and supervision lifelong should be prepared in such a way to maximise their prospects for comfort and happiness, not trying to give them skills they can’t absorb and will not use in a misguided feel-good “see, they can do it!” effort that costs every other child in the school a better education so that we can pat ourselves on the back for giving it the best try. Fighting evolution is a losing battle every time. Better to swim with the stream and amplify the beneficial effects while minimising the downsides as possible. Civilisation is ultimately an engineering problem. Social engineering, governance and finance engineering, civil engineering, sadly now geoengineering. If we did any other kind of engineering on an equal outcome basis we’d be trying to launch carts into space with oxen. We need to focus on doing things that produce useful outcomes, not pretending that we can somehow fix the inherent injustice of unsolvable disadvantage- and certainly not cutting everyone else off at the knees to keep anyone from getting too far ahead. Well implemented gifted and talented programs and advanced academic tracks produce value for society, raise families out of poverty, and change lives. Special needs education below a certain minimum level is a sunk cost fallacy in action.
- strawhatguy 3y agoThat's the problem with equity; which tries to force equal outcomes. That's a goal that can never be reached, and so ever greater shares of wealth are consumed in pursuit of it. Eventually it will consume too much, and we'll have very hard choices we'd have to make. My vote: get government out of running education. I'm sure without all the permitting and licensing and restrictions on who can run a school, more and more varied ones would be made. $100k/year for a student is 2x the average salary, as someone noted, so people will be interested in providing the service. Competitors would fill that gap, and often better, for less. Also, the number of administrators for education has increased dramatically too, so I'm not sure where 'cuts' even happened. My sister (a teacher) says there are more 'life coaches' and other bogus roles these days, that just wonder the halls talking to students and making suggestions that essentially make more work for the teachers. It's absurd the level of waste. Not to mention you can go to several neighborhoods, even in 'richer' areas, and the newest nicest buildings are for schools (and sometimes just an admin building for a school district), while the neighborhood around that building has many homes that seem to be run down or old. It's ridiculous. I really haven't seen actual cuts in schooling anywhere. Hopefully that'll change, it needs to. Education is such a bubble.