3 ms·
Meanwhile, US data brokers still collect and sell all their data, and happily to state actors such as the CCP if they open their huge wallet. The only reasonab
by amelius 3y ago
Meanwhile, US data brokers still collect and sell all their data, and happily to state actors such as the CCP if they open their huge wallet.
The only reasonable solution is to ban all user tracking now.
- hangonhn 3y ago100% this. Respecting user privacy makes any sort of malicious propaganda campaigns that much harder -- be it CCP, Russia, US, or private entities. Otherwise we end up just playing whack-a-mole and usually after the fact.
- leotravis10 3y agoYes 1000% this! Also, TikTok and many other companies can still get user data from data brokers and credit agencies which are so unregulated that we need laws globally to ban surveillence alltogether.
- olyjohn 3y agoThis whole TikTok thing is such a waste of everybody's time and energy. And gives everybody this false impression that US social media is totally safe to use.
- hedora 3y agoDoes it give anyone that impression? It gives everyone that I’ve talked to the impression that the US government is transparently bought off by Facebook and friends.
- Zetice 3y agoEh, my understanding was the TikTok app collected more and different data than say, Facebook or Twitter.
- hedora 3y agoI doubt they get more info than Facebook. The last time I logged in to Facebook, it was to lock down the teacking settings. I found out that GM had sold our onstar info to them without my knowledge or consent. Facebook definitely builds shadow profiles, so they have such info on you regardless of whether you have an account.
- Zetice 3y agoAm I misremembering this? I thought a malware researcher reverse engineered the iOS app and said it was uniquely bad, or something to that effect. I can’t find the link, maybe I’m crazy…
- hot_gril 3y agoIt was uniquely bad in that it didn't encrypt video in transit. It'd just send stuff over plain HTTP, making it very easy for snoopers to tell what you're watching or maybe mitm. More of a security thing than a privacy thing. Vaguely remember this: https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/security-researchers-take-advantage-of-insecure-http-to-display-fake-videos-on-tiktok.2231502/ https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/security-researchers-ta...
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> Eh, my understanding was the TikTok app collected more and different data than say, Facebook or Twitter. Whatever data you think is being collected by TikTok/FB/Twit is actually being harvested for data brokers and being sold to anyone+everyone who wants to pay. Why could the CCCP do some complicated dance with social media companies to get spotty personal data, when they can easily buy comprehensive personal data on the unregulated market?
- Zetice 3y agoIf you're the CCCP, I think you do both, especially if Americans will just install the malware for you, doubly especially if they'll actively fight their own government when it tries to warn them about the risks.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoThat doesn't seem to be nearly the risk as what we have now - US data brokers providing unfettered access to personal data.
- Zetice 3y agoIt's not really personal data if you consent to providing it, is it?
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoNo, it is not. Public data are the details I post in a public forum. Everything else is best considered private and ought only to be distributed upon my clear, intentionally informed consent.
- yellow_postit 3y agoSure would be nice for the US to have a comprehensive data privacy law instead of the emerging patchwork state by state solution or whac-a-mole bans like this.
- edgyquant 3y agoThat’s how the US works. The states implement policies which act as a series of test cases for federal legislation once a majority of states support the law.
- wizofaus 3y agoWhich always struck me as a nice idea in theory but of limited use if people can just avoid state-based laws by moving interstate or even registering businesses interstate. In this case however it makes perfect sense to trial it at a state level. Though I'd assume federal government agencies, especially those that deal with particularly sensitive data, would already have strong restrictions on what can be installed on government devices anyway.
- localplume 3y ago[dead]
- sib 3y ago>> Which always struck me as a nice idea in theory but of limited use if people can just avoid state-based laws by moving interstate That (Federalism) is seen by many (reasonable) people as a benefit, not a drawback...
- tick_tock_tick 3y ago> The only reasonable solution is to ban all user tracking now. And that would impact tiktok how? The whole reason their is extra focus on them is because we can't regulate them effective so your solution would amount to nothing.
- amelius 3y ago> And that would impact tiktok how? Well, as it stands they would fall under user tracking, and thus either would be banned or they would have to change their business model and open up to regulators. And remember, a law does not have to be perfect to serve as a deterrent for bad behavior. > your solution would amount to nothing. TikTok is only the tip of the iceberg, so a broader law that bans all user-tracking (including tiktok) can certainly do a lot more than just banning tiktok.
- b112 3y agoIt would mean that apps discovered tracking users illegally, would be banned and fined locally. And that means any money leaving the US, or money entering the US, would be eaily seized to pay fines. Everything from money paid by app stores, from ads, to renting commercial real eatate in the valley, funds being transferred in country to pay employees, all of it can be seized. And the apps can be banned from all apps stores, and even eventually a court order to prevent any version from being preloaded. Anyone providing binaries could be fined per count, IP addresses of servers banned, DNS blacklisted, on and on. Plenty can, and will be done, because that's where all this is headed. And I might add, the above is "being a nice guy", compared to what China does in these circumstances.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> And that would impact tiktok how? At this point it isn't relevant. What tiktok banners fear tiktok is doing - is actually being done by data brokers. Doesn't it make sense to deal with the actual threat before banning the imagined one?
- rchaud 3y agoConsidering how often TT badgers you to enable access to your contacts or location, I think they would be somewhat chagrined by such a development.
- benreesman 3y agoCan Big Tech / Credit Agencies / Lexus Nexus / etc. sell to the PRC? I’m not disputing you I honestly don’t know, but that would be, surprising to say the least.
- hot_gril 3y agoI won't even pretend to care about the tracking or see it as a national security threat, I just want a big China-based internet company to get banned from outside markets. "Stones in glass houses" when they complain about it.