5 ms·
The tech job recession is over
- 88913527 3y agoInstead of looking at layoffs, should look at the net of hires and departures (both voluntary and involuntary) to see where things stand. In more than a few places, natural attrition often isn't rehired, which will tighten the labor market. Anecdotally, far fewer recruiter mail messages as well. It may not be 'recessionary', but it isn't a rapid hiring environment either.
- icedchai 3y agoSame. Plus many of the ones I get are for "hybrid" situations 100's of miles away. Did these recruiters even look at my profile?
- ineedtosleep 3y agoThe vast majority of the time the answer is no. I've even had recruiters contact me assuming I was with a company I left 2 years ago -- a company that no longer exists.
- Jare 3y agoA friend started his profile with a very visible "if you are a recruiter contacting me for a job I will mock your attempt in public". It was a bit cringey, but proved the point that many recruiters didn't look.
- Michelangelo11 3y agoRight. Yes, the mass layoffs are over, but nobody seems to be hiring en masse.
- ldehaan 3y ago[dead]
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoThe report this article is based on seems to say as much. From the article: > "The Tech Job Recession is Over," the Bernstein analysts declared in a recent email to clients. "Tech layoffs have slowed to a trickle. When will the hirings start to reaccelerate?"
- binarymax 3y ago"Anecdotally, far fewer recruiter mail messages as well" Anecdotally for me, I know several recruiters that were the first to be laid-off. So, even if tech jobs are back, there may be a case of nobody being left to run the recruiting.
- Tade0 3y agoI can tell you where all these jobs went - here - east of the 14th meridian east. At least that's where Amazon, Google and Netflix have been hiring for the past few months.
- twelve40 3y ago> Thank OpenAI and the generative AI boom for limiting the carnage here. AI startups have raised billions of dollars this year how can that "limit the layoff carnage"? Were "AI startups" the ones who were doing the layoffs? what a nonsensical piece of text
- pgeorgi 3y agoMaybe: "AI startups raised billions of dollars" => "The megacorps had to jump into that market, relatively unprepared, to avoid surprises down the road" => "The megacorps couldn't pull through with even more layoffs because they need the flexibility to redirect folks to wherever the AI boom leads while keeping their established business afloat"
- twelve40 3y agoHave you observed significant numbers of tech people redirected to wherever the AI boom leads? i haven't. And the article is certain not to give you any numbers for that, aside from hand-wavy, unsourced, non-quantified "newfound AI startups billions save people from layoffs"
- Michelangelo11 3y ago> OpenAI's careers website listed 60 open roles on Tuesday afternoon, for instance. Yeah, that's one company -- whose product is contributing to the layoffs. Not to mention, 60 engineers is a rounding error compared to the layoffs. > Meta shed 25% of its workforce in multiple rounds of cuts that ended in May. Now, dozens of those workers have been rehired, mostly since June, Insider reported recently. "Dozens" is a tiny fraction of that 25%. > Amazon laid off 25,000 employees in January. By February, AWS HR VP Ian Wilson was telling staff that the company was looking for ways to rehire some of the laid off workers. So they were "looking for ways to rehire" 6 months ago, and that's it? Come on. It's impossible to take this as a sign of the job market coming back. Anyway, it's really telling that these tiny little things are what the article presents as signs of some kind of tech job market recovery. FWIW, depressing as it is, my money is on the tech job market as we know it being a ZIRP. A huge chunk of the tech sector is dead in the water without infusions of VC cash, as we're now seeing, and I don't think things can go back to the way they were without interest rates dropping to near-zero again (and that seems impossible in the near future).
- epicureanideal 3y ago> Anyway, it's really telling that these tiny little things are what the article presents as signs of some kind of tech job market recovery. FWIW, depressing as it is, my money is on the tech job market as we know it being a ZIRP. A huge chunk of the tech sector is dead in the water without infusions of VC cash, as we're now seeing, and I don't think things can go back to the way they were without interest rates dropping to near-zero again (and that seems impossible in the near future). If antitrust were enforced against Google, Facebook, etc., and the companies split into 3-4 companies, there might be enough jobs created by that lack of consolidation to soak up all the extra labor. The profits for the shareholders might go down a little, but there could still be many profitable companies. It might also be good for the ecosystem as a whole because 3-4 Facebooks would likely purchase common services from a new, 5th company that sells certain services all "Facebooks" use, which could then ALSO be used by a startup trying to compete with Facebook.
- fidotron 3y ago
- epicureanideal 3y ago> Most big tech companies have also halted layoffs and some have even begun to rehire staff they let go only a few months ago. But have they tracked how many of the 300,000+ from this year and 150,000+ from last year have found jobs? The article just says "begun to rehire"... So the layoffs have stopped, but there are still almost half a million former tech company workers who need to be soaked up by the labor market. And that assumes there isn't an additional downturn in Q4 this year. Making the situation worse, venture capital investment has dramatically slowed down, so even if some of the laid off workers wanted to start companies, they either a) can't, if they require initial capital, or b) need to slowly, slowly bootstrap the companies, meaning they can't do fast hiring this year or probably next year or the year after.
- cvhashim04 3y agoThe job market is still kind of cold in terms of open roles and many orgs are going through a soft hiring freezes, and instead only hiring for critical roles. For example my company has no IC roles open currently and only listing some managerial roles on the career page. I think things will pick up early next year. Many orgs and teams have been running very lean this past year and I’m sure most of you have been feeling overworked.
- benreesman 3y agoPick your favorite mainstream news outlet (I checked Atlantic, Guardian, CNN, Axios, NYT, WSJ, and maybe one or two others) and you can find an article to the effect of “Why Do Americans Think the Economy is Terrible When It’s Actually Amazing?” Credit where credit is due to the administration, they seem to know better than to push that narrative just at the moment. Regarding tech jobs, inbound recruiter contacts at flat at nearly nothing, we’ll over 80% of the people I know who were laid off are still looking, and competition remains brutal for the openings that exist. Tough job markets happen, we get by. But it’s starting to really grind my gears that there is a full-court press to act like it’s been like this in the last decade or two. It was easier in 2005.
- MisterBastahrd 3y ago"The economy," at least as far as the big publications is concerned since the early 80s, has always been about stock performance and unemployment numbers regardless of who is in charge. Stock performance is great. Unemployment numbers are great. To them, inflationary periods are just a time when big businesses which are flush with cash get to buy up smaller, cash-strapped businesses at discount rates. And the average consumer is so stupid that they're using credit just to maintain their lifestyles.
- benreesman 3y agoI’m not exactly a Jane St. quant, but people piling into SPY at a time when 40+ PEs for mature businesses are the order of the day and bond yields are spiking via open-market operations doesn’t smell right.
- coding123 3y agoInflation is 25% over 2019 so the only people celebrating the economy got a 25% raise. The rest? Debt piling up, some teetering on the edge of homelessness. But that doesn't matter because the president in office can't have bad news. I think we can sum up Biden's presidency with "no comment"
- 3y ago
- 0xbadcafebee 3y agoStart your AI ventures now, people. There's only 2 or 3 more years left in the hype cycle, and after that people will realize language robots are pretty stupid and the gravy train will dry up. You gotta give it to the tech industry for constantly tricking investors into paying for junk and ignoring that they make no profit.
- alasdair_ 3y ago> You gotta give it to the tech industry for constantly tricking investors into paying for junk and ignoring that they make no profit. It probably has something to do with the fact that most of the biggest and most profitable companies on the planet are tech companies. Meta, Google, Amazon etc. all famously made no profit for a long time.
- karaterobot 3y agoStill, it would be a fallacy to conclude that because a company makes no money, it may be the next Amazon. You need some way to consistently distinguish between unprofitable companies. That is probably pretty hard, and sure enough investors have an embarrassing track record at doing it successfully.
- 93po 3y agoSam Altman has one of the best track records and he chose to go all in on OpenAI without even getting compensated for it, so that definitely says something.
- sharts 3y agoThe problem is that most tech companies and entrepreneurs seem to think they are going to be the next “big thing.” And so many tech folk seem to also think they’re Wozniak underneath their imposter syndrome.
- bettercallsalad 3y agoCan confirm. I am getting above average number of recruiter messages. However, this last cycle of layoffs have taught me something. It is 1) the whole chase to Total compensation isn’t worth it, it matters the stability of the organization and the overall value of the work that we produce. To that end, stock compensation is really not to be relied upon at its face value. My total compensation in 2022 was less than 2020 when I was working as a new hire 2) if a company starts hiring to the point where you are taking more and more interviews every week without any real explanation behind the hiring, it’s time to GTFO.
- dilyevsky 3y agoSo you would gtfo from 2001 google or 2013 uber? Scaleups are totally fine if you have revenue to support it (right now not at some unspecified future date). Many companies that scaled in 2020-21 just didn’t
- huijzer 3y agoCounterexample: Pets.com cost of goods sold would go quicker than their revenue. Similarly, many companies inflate their revenue in all kinds of ways including excessive marketing spending.
- dilyevsky 3y agoThis time we didn’t really have that. It was pretty meh revenue numbers across the board and a lot of spending
- majormajor 3y agoHow many people joined Uber in 2013 vs in 2017-18ish or such? What was the breakeven point for it to be worthwhile? It's easy to be late to the party these days if looking at gaudy Series B/C/D numbers and stock-based comp.
- JohnFen 3y ago> stock compensation is really not to be relied upon at its face value. This is a fantastic realization to have. Getting stock as compensation is a bit like getting lottery tickets as compensation. This is triply true if they're options rather than actual stock. I learned decades ago to ignore the stock component of compensation packages when evaluating an offer. I'll never turn stock or options down, but they will also never be something that will "tip the scales" for me.
- photonbeam 3y agoMy linkedin has really picked up the last few weeks, lots of contacts
- CoastalCoder 3y agoSame here. A sudden up-tick in the amount of recruiter contacts in the past few weeks. I'm not clear what that says about the number of attractive positions, but it's at least encouraging.
- readonthegoapp 3y agoi've been out for almost a year now. i'll decide when it's over. but thank you, business lobby, for confirming the tech recession is still in full swing.
- Zetice 3y agoMaybe one reason you're struggling to find a job is that you can't understand that just because something is effecting you doesn't mean it's a larger problem for many people...
- temp10298385 3y agoThis is just hateful. The same point could have been made without kicking someone who is down.
- menacingly 3y agoI also love smugly insulting people who are having a hard time with a poorly-considered take
- CoastalCoder 3y agoI'm sorry, that sucks. I've been out for nearly 5 months now, and I'm starting to feel anxious about my domain-specific knowledge fading / getting stale. I'm hoping to stave that off via interview prep and practicing coding problems. But I'm wondering how long it is before hiring managers start to assume my knowledge / skills have atrophied. I'm starting to appreciate the old saying, "It's easier to get a job when you have a job."
- tschellenbach 3y agoMost companies can stretch their runway a little and have done so. We are still 12 months away from many startups who don't have solid economics collapsing.
- Zetice 3y ago...if literally nothing changes. But that's never been true at any point in human history, so we can rely on change of some kind taking place.
- qbasic_forever 3y agoYeah hiring in January is the real tell of what's going on. The layoffs winding down now were all planned and executed early at the start of the year. If next year rolls around and companies are still doing rounds of layoffs then everything is very far from being over.
- deltarholamda 3y agoThis is only meaningful if all "tech jobs" are interchangeable. If you are a COBOL programmer and you get laid off, you aren't just a priori qualified to start working at OpenAI or whatever. There was no mention of H1B workers in the article either. Are any of the hirings H1Bs?
- CoastalCoder 3y agoI agree. Although to be fair, there's always going to be some limit to the precision of these statistics.
- comfysocks 3y agoSo will the tech giants go back to hiring everyone and parking them to create a talent mote against startups that might disrupt them? The business press never seems to mention that.
- bequanna 3y agoInterest rates create cheap money which makes the talent parking you describe more possible. It seems like rates may be at this level for some time.
- candiodari 3y agoRates at this level means governments must either pay back debt (good luck with that) or cut spending ~5% per year, every year, and borrowing more for new projects will be very hard to justify. Next year is an election year. Also in many European countries.
- peruvian 3y agoWhen I got laid off in January 2023 and then created a LinkedIn, I was spammed by recruiters such that I had interviews set up within a week and a job offer by late February. I don't have an impressive resume on paper either. The only thing I did different than others was I didn't chase a high TC upgrade - I just wanted a solid job.
- JohnFen 3y agoYeah, I've been trying to reconcile the reports I read here about how rough the job market is with the fact that everyone I personally know has had no problems getting a good job in the industry. The only things I can think of to explain it is that people are looking at a very narrow slice of the industry (the FAANGs) where things are rough right now, or people are asking for more compensation than the market will support. But I don't know. There does seem to be a disconnect somewhere, though.
- peruvian 3y agoI have one friend that got laid off Twitter in November due to Musk. He just got a job this week. I don't want to speak ill of him but he's the kind of TC/resume-maxxing type — has to work at top 10 company on "impressive" technology (ML, now AI). He did well on interviews and had offers but kept rejecting or stalling because it wasn't impressive enough. He was living at home so he could afford to do this. I just took the first job I found that paid slightly more and I liked. I can interview again in a year if I don't like it.
- epicureanideal 3y agoCan you share more information? Industry, location, any special skills, any personal attributes that might make this more likely to have happened for you than others?
- hankchinaski 3y agoUK contracting market is pretty much dead. Full-time/Perm hiring pretty much still very quiet as well. They might have stopped layoff but we have a lot to catch up to be back at the bonanza days of 1-2 years ago, the market is now flooded with ex-faang people working for pennies on the dollar. The ride is still bumpy ahead
- r4vik 3y agoAfter months of not seeing any outside ir35 contracts I've seen about 3 today
- tareqak 3y agoJune, July, August is the summer. People might be spacing their vacations apart to have coverage in on-call rotations and the like. I would wait for the next Federal Reserve meeting in September before calling it over and done with, but that is just me.
- Der_Einzige 3y agoGenerative AI is the gift that keeps on giving.
- tuckerpo 3y agoAnecdote: I'm at a 0% hit rate over ~60 applications the last month. I'm not really actively looking so I'm not hand-tailoring each app, just moreso looking to interview to keep those skills sharp. This is down from a ~75% hit rate on cold applications, also not hand-tailored, pre-pandemic. It's still rough out there.
- Ancalagon 3y agoAlso seeing this. Thats with 7 solid years of experience (granted, non-FAANG). Whats really deceiving is I am actually getting tons of inmail. I respond to most with my contact info, times to talk, and my resume, and almost none progress beyond a initial phone call with the recruiter, if even that.
- neilv 3y agoRecruiters need to be recruiting, even if they don't currently have job openings, or even clients. Your resume is the product. Right now, if an initial contact is from a recruiter, rather than management at the company, I'm probably not going to take it very seriously.
- dutchCourage 3y agoSimilar experience here. I thought with about 10 years of experience working on the web, and 5 of those working on large React projects, I could finally be more picky with my next role. I was wrong, I'm struggling more now than as a junior.
- neilv 3y agoI wish the frequent advice to interview even when not actively looking, to keep interviewing/Leetcoding skills sharp... would stop. It's bad for the people at the company. And it's bad for the people who are genuinely job-hunting. And it's bad for people who do it, because they'll surely end up spending commensurate time in purgatory. If we all apply only to places where we're genuinely interested, that's good for everyone.
- 3y ago
- karaterobot 3y ago> Meta shed about 25% of its workforce in multiple rounds of cuts that ended in May. Now, dozens of those workers have returned to Meta, mostly since June, Insider reported. So they laid off tens of thousands of people, and rehired dozens. The article speculates that because layoffs have slowed, everybody who was laid off will be rehired. I don't see evidence for that yet, and I'm not sure how you'd come to that conclusion at this point. I mean, I hope they do, but.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoI'm currently interviewing with Meta, but the process is amazingly slow: - early June: a Meta employee submits my referral - mid June: talk to Meta recruiter - late July: screening interview with hiring manager - mid August: still scheduling an interview-planning meeting with the hand-off recruiter. I'm guessing that on their side, either the recruiters are super busy, or there's no sense of urgency. Maybe a blessing in disguise, since it gives me more time to work on their coding-practice problems. Which are great, btw.
- chrisabrams 3y agoIt's possible that candidates are getting shuffled around, as some of the Meta recruiters themselves have been laid off. I know multiple people that were/are in the Meta process that this happened to. Takes a few weeks for the new recruiter to go through their double/triple work load of candidates and schedule.
- sharts 3y agoAnd therein lay the ridiculousness. Just because the rate of something has slowed does not mean a reversal. It’s like when people report on inflation going down. No, it’s not going down. The _rate_ is going down and you need it to go negative if you expect things to “return” to normal.
- Zaheer 3y ago# of layoffs being down doesn't necessarily indicate the job recession is over. The total # of job postings is still much much lower than late 2021: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/IHLIDXUSTPSOFTDEVE# https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/IHLIDXUSTPSOFTDEVE#
- rexreed 3y agoHow does this jibe with all the news / media hype about Startups facing impending doom and the big squeeze to focus on profits vs growth (which means cutting staff): [0] https://news.crunchbase.com/venture/monthly-vc-funding-recap-seed-downturn-july-2023/= https://news.crunchbase.com/venture/monthly-vc-funding-recap... [1]https://news.crunchbase.com/startups/tech-venture-survival-profitability-itay-sagie/ https://news.crunchbase.com/startups/tech-venture-survival-p... [2] https://news.crunchbase.com/startups/unicorn-sector-investors-winners-losers/ https://news.crunchbase.com/startups/unicorn-sector-investor... I can go on and on. Maybe for the MAFANG's life is going .. ok, but it seems in startup land, the sky is still falling? Or is this all a head fake?
- disgruntledphd2 3y agoIt's both. Profitable companies mostly did performative layoffs (they sacrificed some of their employees to appease the gods of wall street), whereas for lots of money losing startups, they should never have hired as many people in the first place. Unless the startup has incredible PMF (and sometimes even then), they won't be hiring at least till mid next year, as lots of them need time to grow into their valuations. Also, the ridiculous AI stock price boom of this year has left the profitable companies (MAGMA) with no need to reduce headcount to juice their income statements.
- rexreed 3y agoSo in sum, the Big Tech job recession (might be) over, but the Startup tech recession stays on. There have been a lot of AI startup failures over the same period as the credited GenAI boom. GenAI is favoring large, entrenched companies, and startups (and the hype-following VCs and investors) might want to look elsewhere for big opportunities.
- disgruntledphd2 3y agoYeah, basically.
- archo 3y agohttps://archive.is/hc8lQ https://archive.is/hc8lQ