8 ms·
Owner of hydrogen-powered Hyundai quoted $175,000 to replace fuel cell
- ada1981 3y agoFile under “play stupid games, win stupid prizes.”
- 0ct4via 3y ago[flagged]
- mynameisvlad 3y agoHow is expecting your purchase from a major car manufacturer to work “playing stupid games”?
- ada1981 3y agoSounds like it was out of warranty and the replacement fuel cell cost on an experimental limited production vehicle wasn’t something the buyer considered? Sounds like it’s working exactly as planned.
- simonh 3y agoHe was actually quoted 104,000 Euros in Germany. The article is on an Australian web site so the amount in the headline is in Aussie Dollars.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoIt makes me not really understand why people do conversions in articles, especially not for more volatile things like cryptocurrencies. "$100K in bitcoin stolen" hits differently depending on whether the article was written in 2011 or 2021. Just say "100 BTC stolen", MAYBE include a widget that will offer a conversion to your currency of choice, with options to have it translated to current values, values at the time of writing, and values adjusted for inflation.
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoThis is just bad journalism. WHat is so expensive? Cost of labour? Cost of the part? If you literally have to take apart most of the car, than can end with hundreds of human-hours of labour and depending on the price per hour, can get very very expensive. On the other hand, I agree that parts costs should be regulated, where a sum of all parts should not exceed eg. 3x the cost of a new car (some overhead is of course needed in selling separate parts). But we don't know that either.
- yorwba 3y agoThe referenced Auto Bild article https://www.autobild.de/artikel/hyundai-ix35-fcev-mit-defekter-brennstoffzelle-22903177.html https://www.autobild.de/artikel/hyundai-ix35-fcev-mit-defekt... has an image showing how the quoted price was calculated, including 1009.05 euros labor costs, 86187.73 euros parts (of which 3.03 euros for a gasket) and 16567.39 euros taxes.
- moeris 3y ago> This is just bad journalism. It's possible you just have poor taste. Personally, I think the reasons for the repair cost aren't relevant, same is pretty obvious. It's an unconventional car that had limited production. I'm sure they're adding in the cost of parts (they'll likely have to buy another insurance of this car to rip the parts out of, or they'll have to fabricate it themselves. Which could require hiring an engineer to make sure they don't get sued if the car bursts into flames) and labor that comes with learning how to repair a complete unknown for them, plus a good helping of uncertainty. The most relevant part of this story is that there's a guy who bought into a new tech, and who is being unreasonable when it didn't work for as long as he had hoped. And that comes through fine in the article.
- bowsamic 3y ago> If you literally have to take apart most of the car, than can end with hundreds of human-hours of labour and depending on the price per hour, can get very very expensive. FYI, many repairs require taking apart most of the car. For example, replacing gaskets requires taking apart the entire engine. And yet, garages aren't charging 100,000 euros to do so. More like 500 to 1000
- prepend 3y agoThis seems expensive but it an out of production vehicle with a unique fuel source and not really supported. He bought the car in 2015 so he’s lucky to get 8 years. Especially since Hyundai only provided a 5-year warranty. That seems pretty crazy to spend US$100k on a vehicle with a new technology. When the Prius first came out they offered an 8 year warranty (or maybe 12) on the hybrid system. And that’s more familiar to mechanics than this fuel cell tech. Tl:dr; don’t do stuff like this unless you’re ready to lose all your money. The owner got 8 years of utility out of the vehicle.
- ourmandave 3y agoAssuming the replacement lasts another 8 years, that's $14,206 / year. But I'm sure they'd throw in free oil changes.
- jve 3y ago> He bought the car in 2015 so he’s lucky to get 8 years Well now I understand why manufacturers say transmission has lifetime oil in there... because some people think that 8 years old car is... an old car that could as well be done? I could afford buying new car and paying xxx/€ per month, but I choose to buy ~10 year old car and if I'm lucky it has <200k km on odometer. But then I'm debt free. If I'd be paying xxx/€ per month and having a broken vehicle after 8 years, I'd be very disappointed to say the least.
- no-reply 3y agoAdditionally, 1. Your car is easier to repair 2. It is easier to find mechanics for repair 3. You get the treasure trove of pre-existing repair videos/guides in case something goes awry and you want to DIY.
- jjfoooo4 3y agoThe point isnt that 8 years is a reasonable lifespan for a generic car, rather that getting 8 years out of a car with early stage, novel tech is not so bad
- 3y ago
- kitanata 3y ago[flagged]
- mlok 3y agoQuoted 104,000 Euros = $AU 175,000 = US$ 113,650
- Aachen 3y agoJournalism these days is in comment threads it seems
- mynameisvlad 3y agoHow is currency conversion (half of which is just from the article itself) “journalism”?
- Aachen 3y agoThat it's not 175k$ but 113k. But now that I see this comment again, I notice that it's 175 in Australian currency which is conveniently also called dollars apparently so that's actually my bad
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 0ct4via 3y agoA new fuel cell costs €84,875 net ($92,642 USD) on its own. Total repair/replacement estimate: €103,764.17 ($113,262 USD) Archive (in German): https://archive.is/w0Dq5 https://archive.is/w0Dq5 Original article (in German): https://www.autobild.de/artikel/hyundai-ix35-fcev-mit-defekter-brennstoffzelle-22903177.html https://www.autobild.de/artikel/hyundai-ix35-fcev-mit-defekt...
- andai 3y agoFascinating! Does this thing take a special fuel (if so, where can it be obtained?) or does it do its own electrolysis?
- gambiting 3y agoIt takes hydrogen that can only be refilled from a specialized hydrogen station. It's in the article.
- soggybread 3y agoIt likely uses liquid hydrogen for fuel which can be difficult to come by as there aren't a lot of fuel stations that have that available. I found this video interesting and informative and it goes over some of the pros and cons of owning a hydrogen powered car - https://youtu.be/rtZQLUtckS4 https://youtu.be/rtZQLUtckS4
- sbradford26 3y agoSo fuel cell cars other than one exception that I am aware of only use compressed hydrogen not liquid. Dealing with compressed hydrogen is difficult but manageable, dealing with liquid hydrogen is extremely difficult.
- mminer237 3y agoYou fill it at a hydrogen station: https://i.auto-bild.de/ir_img/3/2/6/3/8/7/1/4088383456-2a1d2b206d1edbe8.jpg https://i.auto-bild.de/ir_img/3/2/6/3/8/7/1/4088383456-2a1d2...
- jmacd 3y agoI had a Hybrid Audi Q5 and one day it just stopped working. The dealership quoted me $25,000 for a new battery, plus labour, plus they said I had to manage the recycling of the old battery. They estimated that at $6,000. My head was spinning. Eventually through a few Facebook groups I was able to find a battery technician. He happily opened up the battery, checked the cells, found the failed cells, repaired them and then had to do some work on the vehicle diagnostics to get it to forget there was ever a problem. Voila, it was working just fine. Took him 90 minutes.
- arielweisberg 3y agoChris Fix has a video showing how to replace all the cells on a Prius battery. It's not the hardest DIY thing I have seen by a large margin. I recall seeing a single cell replacement video a while back as well, but don't remember where. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oAHaYXBFnJo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oAHaYXBFnJo We need more right to repair and requirement to make things repairable regulations. The balance is in the wrong spot right now.
- 0ct4via 3y agoAgreed - unfortunately so much is going into proprietary systems and DRMing control units (and even spare parts), which really needs to change. There is some progress being made, like https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-64206913 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-64206913 - but absolutely, legislating RtR is the way to go.
- peterleiser 3y agoImagine a post-apocalyptic world with fully functional technology that surviving humans are hopelessly locked out from using. The Master-Blaster rulers will be the ones who are, or who control, the hackers.
- 1-6 3y agoRight to repair is already possible on Prii's. The question is, is it possible on Teslas.
- hkt 3y agoI'm ready for my down votes for this but here I go: Electric bikes are cheap, efficient, fast enough, safe, good for your health, and good for the environment. Live somewhere that isn't bike friendly? Do the right thing instead of the easy one and campaign for better infrastructure.
- slashdev 3y agoYou can have my downvote. People need transport now, not in some hypothetical ideal future world. Bikes are dangerous, even in places with good infrastructure. Bikes are no good for carrying your shopping, or your kids, or taking your partner to dinner, or when the weather is inclement, or if your physical condition doesn’t permit it. At best they’re an auxiliary option for when circumstances permit. In economics terms they’re not a substitute good for cars. I love cycling and wish my city had better infrastructure. But let’s keep it real.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 3y ago>Bikes are no good for carrying your shopping, or your kids, or taking your partner to dinner, or when the weather is inclement, or if your physical condition doesn’t permit it. I've been biking for everything for over about 15 years (we don't have a car). With two bags on the back, enough to shop. With kids. Taking my partners for dinner. For works, vacation, errands, everything. When there's rain and when there's snow. My physical condition improved thanks to biking. Idem for my finances. Do you even ride a bike?!
- slashdev 3y agoI wouldn’t do any of those things you listed on a bike, except a small shop, not a Costco shop. And I cycle in the rain sometimes, but not by choice. I love cycling, but I use a car when it’s the tool for the job.
- lostmsu 3y ago> Taking my partnerS for dinner. Am I reading too much subtle failure here?
- whartung 3y agoKind of surprised they sold the car today him in the first place. In the US, as I understand it, the Toyota Hydrogen program, all of the vehicles are leased, perhaps to prevent just this thing but also to actually protect the consumer from having a worthless used car. Perhaps the original vehicles were subsidized by Hyundai, but this part is “actual price “ with the expectation that we’re it ever to be used, it would be under warranty. Could just be on the wrong side of accounting gimmicks that companies use, especially on experimental development vehicles.
- sbradford26 3y agoI believe you can purchase a Toyota Mirai but it doesn't make much sense to. On lease you get $15000 in free hydrogen to be used in 3 years. If you purchase it outright you get the same 15k but you get 6 years to use that. But your resale value after that is going to be terrible since the next owner will actually have to pay for hydrogen(And it isn't cheap), so you are better off just leasing.
- barney54 3y agoI a few years ago I talked to people from Honda about their fuel cell plans. They laid out how many fuel cell vehicles they were planning on selling and it wasn’t that many. What was left unsaid is that they lost money on every vehicle and therefore weren’t going to sell that many, at least until that get costs down. It’s likely in this Hyundai story that Hyundai doesn’t want to lose additional money on this fuel cell vehicle and that’s why they quoted the astronomically high price.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoI'm very much worried that this will happen with electric cars as well, that their batteries will just run out and will need to be replaced wholesale, but that it won't be economically viable. I mean there's a project out there that monitors the battery capacity and lifetime of electric cars, tracking those of Tesla's Model S from over ten years ago now; those seem to be holding up all right. But it will cause more trash. 100 year old cars can still run today because the parts can be replaced, or worst case, engine components can be machined. That said, maybe over time there will be new generations of battery tech that will make it viable to replace and even upgrade old electric vehicle batteries. It's not likely in the near future though. And I think it'll be suppressed by existing battery manufacturers, Tesla being foremost - I'm not convinced cars are Tesla's long term goal, it'll be battery tech and charging infrastructure.
- bryanlarsen 3y ago"Dead" batteries from Leafs and Teslas are still quite useful for energy storage and thus quite valuable and unlikely to end in landfill. The recycling rate on lead acid batteries is over 99%. Li ion batteries will likely end up with a similar number.
- WorldMaker 3y ago> That said, maybe over time there will be new generations of battery tech that will make it viable to replace and even upgrade old electric vehicle batteries. That exists in limited capacity today. There are shops that have replaced older Leaf model batteries with upgraded batteries. That's a big deal for some of the earliest Leaf models because they had tiny batteries by today's standards (or Tesla's) and get double or triple range compared to when they were new. There aren't going to be as many models today that will benefit in quite the same way as those early Leafs, but it will probably still be a niche thing once we figure out what the average lifecycle of a car battery is. (As you mention, it is certainly greater than ten years we're seeing from Tesla batteries and others. Based on current data, it seems like it may be close to 20 years or possibly more that batteries last in their "first use" in cars.) Also, there's a bunch of companies working on electrifying old ICE cars today, which uses similar skills. I think it's fun to watch decades old cars with very new life as EVs. Some of those cars drive better than they ever did before.
- simonblack 3y agoThree little words: "Economies of Scale" EVs are still 'unusual' technology. (That includes all varieties of EVs) When they become as ubiquitous as petroleum-powered internal-combustion vehicles, that might change. Prices might fall.