9 ms·
Energy Jobs Have Increased in Nearly Every County in America
- kitanata 3y ago[flagged]
- gabereiser 3y agoA day ago, there were people in Montana up in arms over the supreme court in Montana siding with climate activists. "Leftist-liberal agenda being shoved down our throats" I remember reading. "We need an above-the-line energy policy, we're going the wrong direction, we need to reverse course". Yet, the energy sector is growing. Solar / Renewables, growing. Demand for it, growing. The US's ability to generate it, growing. As are many other nations around the world who are realizing their energy needs are beamed to them every day, if only they would capture it. I'm sensationalizing a non-trivial task at the macro level but this is good news. The more we move away from burning things for energy, the better. Those same people, 10 years from now, when they can breathe without Benadryl, will probably take the credit for it. "See what having a robust homeland energy policy does?" :/
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- thrwayaistartup 3y agoMontana has a massive amount of coal reserves, several productive oil fields, and a lot of refining capacity. If you close the oil refineries and leave coal in the ground, a lot of communities in Montana are going to become ghost towns. The lives of the children of people in those towns is going to suck -- poverty, drugs, and an early death if you can't get out. The fact that those jobs are offset by growth in solar and energy jobs doesn't help without a centralized wealth transfer, which ain't gonna happen. The problem with US political-economics right now is that the future of the country depends on making a series of "society wins, some regions win, some regions lose (win-win-lose)" decisions. Because the societal win is net, it could be made into a very attractive win-win-win situation. But everyone knows from the last half century of globalization that taking win-win-lose and turning it into win-win-win is a false promise that won't pan out.
- JTbane 3y agoIMHO coal should be banned as an energy source and efforts made to convert existing plants to nuclear.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoAgree with a lot of your points (most especially "a bullshit promise that won't pan out"), but recent legislation does attempt to mitigate the losses the communities you mention will face as coal is rapidly phased out. Folks in the industries we're transitioning from should not be left out in the economic cold. https://www.forbes.com/sites/energyinnovation/2022/08/24/inflation-reduction-act-benefits-billions-in-just-transition-funding-for-coal-communities/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/energyinnovation/2022/08/24/inf... (Inflation Reduction Act Benefits: Billions In Just Transition Funding For Coal Communities) https://www.ilo.org/global/topics/green-jobs/WCMS_824102/lang--en/index.htm#q_0 https://www.ilo.org/global/topics/green-jobs/WCMS_824102/lan...
- coding123 3y agoThis is hand-waving a real concern away. It's why people on the right are so mad right now. Did we hand-wave the homelessness issue away in CA? Seems like there's an awful lot of hand-waving we did in the past 15 years growing the tech sector that left a shit-ton of people behind. I know a bunch of people are going to hand-wave this comment away too. The downvotes generated on hacker news will not translate at the voting booth.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoIt's a real concern, but it is the best that is going to be provided. 2 million voters over the age of 55 die every year, 4 million voters turn 18. Conservatives can vote all they want, the electorate turnover and outcome is a combination of inertia (inflation reduction act has stoked an enormous amount of renewables manufacturing capacity coming online) and demographic destiny. Fossil fuels will die due to economics, it is just a matter of time horizon. I want to stress that I strongly support a just transition (policy should express compassion and empathy at scale), and if people can't be found other jobs, retiring them out early to bridge the gap to other social safety nets (medicare, social security, etc), but there is no path to success for conservative ideology on the issue of leaving fossil fuels behind (either through votes or economics). https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37052550 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37052550 (citations)
- Bostonian 3y agoCourts rather than legislatures making climate policy is indeed "an agenda being shoved down our throats". Legislators who face elections are more likely to consider tradeoffs.
- duxup 3y agoCourts act based on ... something. You can agree with the reasoning or not but it's not simply an arbitrary policy based on nothing. In the Montana situation it is based on the rights of younger people who will take the brunt of choices made today. Courts make decisions all the time about balancing different people's rights.
- lolinder 3y agoIt is widely accepted that one of the court's jobs is to determine whether the legislature's laws are in line with state and federal constitutions. This mechanism exists to make sure that the majority cannot infringe upon the rights of a minority simply because they control the legislature. The ruling in this case is weirdly hard to find, probably because it's not a supreme court case yet, but the reports say that all the judge did was strike down one provision of a law that the legislature passed, according to a pretty reasonable interpretation of this provision in the state constitution [0]. [0] https://leg.mt.gov/bills/mca/title_0000/article_0090/part_0010/section_0010/0000-0090-0010-0010.html https://leg.mt.gov/bills/mca/title_0000/article_0090/part_00...
- sophacles 3y agoYes, but I think you're missing the point. The Montana constitution was adopted in 1972 in a constitutional convention. The people that were elected to that convention were not the legislature (because the previous constitution forbade someone from holding 2 elected offices at one time). The people elected were largely not even politicians, just regular people. Therefore it shouldn't matter at all - the parent post comes from a position of "the people must be ruled over" and the Montana constitution has a "will of the people" vibe.
- 3y ago
- irrational 3y agoBreathe without Benadryl? Isn’t Benadryl used for allergies? Allergies come mainly from plants and pollen. Hopefully those won’t be going away as we adopt solar more.
- slacka 3y agoI’m diagnosed as having pollution induced Asthma and allergies to wood smoke. While I need steroids or an N95 mask when the air quality is very poor, Benadryl indeed does help with the symptoms. What value does your comment add by nick picking his comment? The premise of his argument is correct. Fossil fuels kill far more people than renewables and nuclear. https://www.canarymedia.com/articles/fossil-fuels/which-power-sources-are-most-deadly-hint-not-solar-and-wind https://www.canarymedia.com/articles/fossil-fuels/which-powe...
- irrational 3y agoBecause even if we went 100% fossil free today, we’d still need Benadryl to breathe.
- sophacles 3y ago> Asthma and allergic diseases cases have risen in recent decades. Plant pollen is considered as the main aeroallergen causing allergic reactions. According to available data, urban residents experience more respiratory allergies than rural residents mainly due to the interaction between chemical air pollutants and pollen grains. From: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5941124/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5941124/ There's a lot of research linking the two - particulate matter in the air from burning coal is another allergen related to this.
- datavirtue 3y agoIt reduces inflammation in the respiratory track. Relax.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Aunche 3y agoEveryone is happy when the government throws free money at them. That's why even the most climate denying and self proclaimed "fiscally conservative" politicians will vote for subsidizing new solar jobs in their free state. What people get up and arms about are policies that destroy jobs or make things more expensive. This why all climate-change related legislation is about throwing free money at the problem rather than pricing in the externality in bad environmental practices. Even in the farthest left of politicians only make vague suggestions of a carbon tax because they know that they'd immediately get kicked out of office if they allowed gasoline prices to rise to what they are in Europe, let taxing all sources of greenhouse gases.
- jvanderbot 3y ago"destroy jobs" > Jobs up 95% "more expensive" > free money.
- Aunche 3y agoYou're acting as if I made a contraction, but I didn't. Montana is getting sued because they aren't destroying jobs, and neither is any other state. The government is granting free money to people who buy solar panels, EVs, etc which is why jobs are being created.
- nonethewiser 3y agoWhat are you trying to say?
- datavirtue 3y agoI see people up in arms about massive solar farm installations in Ohio. I'm not sure what the issues are as no one has ever quantified them other than to say "I moved here because of the fields" or "They are gobbling up good farm land for solar panels." You see signs everywhere: "Say NO to Solar!" As an Appalachian I recognize this as a miss. These people could have easily legislated (and still can!) a cut of the energy $$ to themselves. Instead they are trying to burn it all down and will be unsuccessful at it. Where is JD Vance or Mike DeWine on that one? Probably too busy ducking energy policy corruption charges.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoI like green energy as much as the next guy but I think it's hard to know if it's growing organically or growing because the government is spending trillions of dollars on it.
- mrguyorama 3y agoIt was growing even under Trump's admin, who was NOT spending trillions on it. China made renewables cheaper than coal.
- nomel 3y agoOne aspect is that storage is getting cheaper than peaker plants [1][2], in the "more profit with storage" sense. [1] https://www.ge.com/power/transform/article.transform.articles.2018.oct.storage-threat-to-peaker-plants https://www.ge.com/power/transform/article.transform.article... [2] https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/news-insights/latest-news-headlines/natural-gas-in-transition-grid-balancing-tactics-in-flux-as-battery-costs-fall-64822077#:~:text=According%20to%20a%20recent%20analysis,plant%20average%20at%20%24173%2FMWh https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/news-insights....
- PM_me_your_math 3y agoWe were promised cheaper energy. Nothing is cheaper about renewables, and the costs grow ~3% per year. To say nothing of the raw materials demand, requirement of fossil fuels to develop and use 'renewables' and the cost to replace such equipment. For example, battery replacement for EV are outside of affordability for the mass market. And of course, there is the inescapable long term problem of 250MM electric vehicles requiring charge when we're already telling people that they can't charge their EV due to grid constraints. The inconvenient truth is this; there isn't enough raw material on earth to electrify all transportation, upgrade the entire national grid (every line, every transformer, every substation) to meet the demand that an total EV conversion demands, not for 30 years and definitely not by 2030. Saying otherwise is simple wishful thinking. My apologies in advance for offending the perpetual victims in the church of climatology.
- hexhexhexagon 3y ago“the more we move away from burning things for energy, the better” is not self evident. We’ve been burning things for energy since the invention of fire 1 or 2 million years ago. It is a major major factor for how we have built this global civilization that we all benefit from. That said, we moved away from burning fire, not because we ran out of wood, but because we found something more efficient. Currently, hydrocarbons are the single best method of generating and delivering cheap, reliable energy. Only nuclear comes close, but for some stupid reason it is demonized. Solar and wind serve a purpose, but they’re nowhere near ready to replace hydrocarbons. We should only transition away from hydrocarbons at the point that by doing so, humans flourish more, and not less. This means either we develop a newer, better technology (nuclear nuclear nuclear), or we begin to run out of fossil fuels, which won’t be for a very long time.
- Timon3 3y ago> Solar and wind serve a purpose, but they’re nowhere near ready to replace hydrocarbons. We should only transition away from hydrocarbons at the point that by doing so, humans flourish more, and not less. This means either we develop a newer, better technology (nuclear nuclear nuclear), or we begin to run out of fossil fuels, which won’t be for a very long time. You are ignoring the main reason we have to move away from burning things for energy: it is making our future selves flourish less. People aren't suggesting to move towards renewables because they look better or because it just feels so nice to use solar energy. The negative externalities from our energy usage today are literally negatively affecting, partially even destroying, our future. If you only look at the present you're ignoring all the problems our current consumption of fossil fuels is introducing. Imagine your grandma is cold. Sure, you can warm her up by setting her house on fire, but it will only help for a short time.
- hexhexhexagon 3y agoTechnologies like solar and wind are actually very ugly! No one is suggesting moving to them flippantly, and certainly not because of an aesthetic. To the extent that we can make the planet more survivable, fossil fuels is our number one energy source for making that happen, and nothing comes close. I’m a fan of solar and wind, as much as I am of hydroelectric, but they simply can’t handle the demand at their current output. Not to mention, they require energy from the burning of fossil fuels to build their own infrastructure, and then even more to provide the on-demand backups whenever the sun doesn’t shine and the wind doesn’t blow enough. The energy we derive from fossil fuels is precisely why we have thriving civilization and flourishing humans today. Nowhere where fossil fuels are absent do we see such flourishing. That doesn’t mean we should put our heads down and burn burn burn until the planet runs dry. It means we should acknowledge the good and the bad, and work towards a more sustainable future. In my opinion, until we come up with a better way to harness solar energy (which is what hydrocarbons actually are), we can’t lock ourselves into solar panels and batteries. There has to be something more efficient and cheaper than hydrocarbons. It’s nuclear. Nuclear is the answer. The faster we can get people, countries and continents to adopt nuclear, the faster we can move toward a future where our energy concerns effectively disappear.
- nomel 3y ago> A day ago, there were people > ... I remember reading Any references?
- pkdpic 3y ago> Data is reported for five energy sectors: Electric Power Generation; Transmission, Distribution, and Storage; Fuels; Energy Efficiency; and Motor Vehicles and Component Parts No real mention of what these jobs actually are? I'm guessing the software development needs in this sector are comparatively pretty minimal...
- thrwayaistartup 3y agoThere are a ton of software development jobs in those sectors! Especially if you include all the "software" jobs that are less like the sort of programming at a typical software shop and more like "Math/CS/Eng PhDs writing MATLAB code". I think we will see that transition throughout the economy, actually: software will continue to be very important, but the marginal value add of someone writing software will depend on their having deep domain expertise.
- throwawayai2 3y agoI'm interested in moving into this sector. Do you have any resources/companies/etc to share?
- 7thaccount 3y agoSure. National Labs (NREL, Argonne, Sandia...etc) EPRI is a big one that sits between industry and academia and hires plenty of both to act as an R&D hub for industry. The large RTO/ISOs (CAISO, ERCOT, SPP, MISO, PJM, ISO-NE, NYISO) run large regions of the grid and work to maintain the reliable operation of the grid, optimize the use of hundreds of generators every 5 minutes in automatic competitive auctions, and plan certain upgrades like transmission. Consulting firms (too many to count) like EPE typically run simulations for anyone who needs it done Software Vendors (GE, Siemens, Hitachi, Energy Exemplar...etc) Utilities that are members of the RTO/ISOs (or independent as in the South east) Renewables developers (Nextera, EDF, ENEL...etc) that try to get renewables built and then participate in the RTO/ISO markets. This is just a section of the power industry as well. Good paying jobs, but a fair amount of red tape too depending on where you go. From a software perspective there's a lot of IT Enterprise work, a lot of programming that engineers do typically involves calling the APIs of commercial software and trying to analyze the resulting data. R&D work typically involves building prototypes. Enterprise software is typically Java, SQL, C#, JavaScript, or C++ depending on what it is. The engineer stuff is mostly in Python. R&D work is typically Python or Matlab. Can you be more specific as to your background and skills?
- justrealist 3y agoCoupling energy production success to job creation is a mistake, and the DOE is taking political wins at the cost of long-term energy abundance. Labor inherently puts a floor on the price of energy, no matter how cheap or clean the technology is! "Cheap, clean energy" IS the consumer benefit, not the bureaucracy and make-work. We should aim for a world where near-infinite energy production is produced by one guy in DC with a button that says "PRODUCE MORE".
- Bostonian 3y agoExactly -- producing the same amount of energy with more people is a bad thing.
- burkaman 3y agoWe're producing more energy, not the same amount: https://www.eia.gov/totalenergy/data/browser/#/?f=A&start=1949&end=2022&charted=4-6-7-14 https://www.eia.gov/totalenergy/data/browser/#/?f=A&start=19...
- gertlex 3y agoYou're misinterpreting the comment, almost certainly. The claim is more specifically: "Per given amount of energy generation, renewables are requiring employing more people, likely causing higher energy costs than other methods might" I'm just observing here. Obviously, there's tradeoffs to consider. I don't personally have a stance that this is a problem or that there's currently a better way to make our energy production green.
- jopsen 3y ago> Per given amount of energy generation, renewables are requiring employing more people, I don't really see that claimed backed by sources. But short-term, yes probably, it'll take a lot of work install renewable energy sources everywhere. But once installed, maintenance will probably require fewer human hours. And certainly fewer human hours spent extracting raw materials (oil, gas, coal).
- 23B1 3y ago"Bidenomics is working, and the clean energy transformation is creating good jobs in every pocket of America" This is propaganda, not news.
- comte7092 3y agoIt’s literally a press release from the Biden administration, not a news outlet. I’m not sure what you are mad about.
- micromacrofoot 3y agoIt's a press release from the government based on a recent analysis, I don't think it was trying to be news...
- datavirtue 3y agoIt is definitely propaganda.
- twoodfin 3y agoA reminder as always that the ideal number of jobs (i.e. labor cost) needed to produce adequate energy to meet consumption demand is 0. Yeah, yeah, this is startup cost in many cases. But jobs are not (or shouldn't be) the goal of an energy policy.
- CyberDildonics 3y ago> But jobs are not (or shouldn't be) the goal of an energy policy. No one is saying that. There is a transition to wind and solar, this is an indication of that. "Solar jobs increased in the largest number of counties of any electric power generation technology, growing in 74% of U.S. counties."
- asynchronous 3y agoCan’t wait to have ten billion windmills breaking down every year that we need millions of windmill techs for, rather than just a handful of nuclear reactors that require extensive maintenance every 30 years.
- stetrain 3y agoIf the solar panels and windmills and their technicians are cheaper to build and operate (safely) than the nuclear reactors, externalities included, then it seems like the market is making the right decision.
- kragen 3y agoi wonder why they include 'motor vehicles and component parts' jobs as 'energy jobs' but not, for example, carpentry jobs or cooking jobs a dude selling car parts isn't producing or reselling energy, and i'm pretty sure a cook with a gas burner applies more energy in their work if we cast the net wide enough to include auto parts stores then 100% of jobs are energy jobs maybe they're trying to choose only the categories of jobs where employment is going up instead of down
- dangrossman 3y agoProbably because it aligns with this administration's push to create clean energy jobs, in large part, by (quite successfully) pushing for EV and EV battery manufacturing in the US.
- kragen 3y agodoes that mean a guy who sells replacement shock absorbers for diesel trucks has an 'energy job' tho
- hexhexhexagon 3y ago[flagged]
- hexhexhexagon 3y agofeels similar to the logic behind what goes into the CPI and what doesn’t
- Nifty3929 3y agoCreating jobs is easy: Spend a lot of money and/or make it more effortful to produce things. In either case, workers will be doing more of one thing and less of another. In this case, more workers are spending more time in "Energy," but this comes at the cost of all the other things those workers might be doing instead. This may or may not be a net-win, but unless we account for the reduced production in other areas, we will delude ourselves about the benefits of these energy jobs. We will be motivated to keep "creating jobs" simply by shifting workers from one task to another, and then another, regardless of whether those new tasks are actually more valuable to society than the ones they had been doing. We will put in place rules that make production more effortful, because this creates jobs in that field, despite the fact that we will have less overall stuff.
- whats_a_quasar 3y agoI don't think that's how labor markets function in the U.S. at the moment, and I think it's an odd critique to make of green energy projects in particular. Not all labor creates the same amount of wealth, and there isn't a fixed demand for skilled labor. Lots of energy construction projects increases the demand for skilled labor, which pulls people out of unskilled labor or service jobs. Greater labor demand in general means everyone wins - companies have projects that they're getting built, workers have negotiating power and wage growth, and wealth is being created in the form of energy infrastructure.
- Nifty3929 3y agoI did not intend to critique energy jobs or projects in particular - I meant to highlight that shuffling people from one task to another is not (necessarily) productive overall, but it's easy to delude ourselves. We see the increased productivity concentrated in one area/industry, but don't see the decreased productivity diffused throughout the rest of the economy. This may still be a net win, but you have to consider both sides. As far as moving people from less-skilled to more-skilled jobs - the real question is which one is more valuable for society. There might be plenty of low-skill jobs that are valuable, and high-skill ones that aren't. Also, we have to be careful about what we consider "skill." Would you say waiting tables is low-skill? A waiter may beg to differ... What are these "low-skill" jobs that people are giving up in order to move into which "high-skill" jobs in energy? Or is it just about whether someone has to wear a blouse or button-up shirt and slacks and go to an office? The important thing is that people should move from lower-value jobs to higher-value ones. But people do not get a direct signal of value, only of pay. So we can pay people more to do a job, and they will do it. But that does not mean it is more valuable overall.
- bhewes 3y agoI am part of a two new energy companies in OKC Larkspur Minerals and Operating -https://www.larkspurminerals.com/ https://www.larkspurminerals.com/. We take over old fields and increase production (marginal wells) we also work with renewable energy either through helping companies acquire land and or operating. Given our size the deals sizes are about the same though from a cash flowing prospective Oil and Gas is still king. A fun stat is Oklahoma renewable electric production is at 47% in 2022 up from 10% in 2011. Now 90% of that is wind power, but we are expanding into utility scale solar. And the country folk are self installing solar panels with cost $.50-$.75 per watt.
- gwbas1c 3y ago> These findings illustrate how Bidenomics is working, and President Biden’s Investing in America agenda is ensuring all communities have access to affordable, reliable, clean electricity, helping deliver on the President's ambitious clean energy and climate goals Gosh, I wish press releases like this weren't blatantly playing politics. When we keep politics out of press releases like this, it helps bring people onboard who otherwise may get stuck because the person in an elected office isn't the person they voted for.
- jfengel 3y agoPeople don't often come onboard for the people they voted against. The people who issued that press release are well aware that they're not going to convince anybody who opposes the incumbent. It's about the opposite: reassuring his constituency that they are getting something. They need something that sits in their mind when they ask the question "What has this guy done for me lately?" It would be great if they could do it in a less blunt fashion; this is rather on-the-nose. But even a better press release isn't going to suddenly convince the President's opponents that they were wrong about him all along. The best he can hope for is to nudge them towards having higher priorities on election day than voting. It would also be great if I didn't have to talk about politics in this abstract fashion. But in the end a politician cannot accomplish the goals that they believe to be important if they don't win. I'd love it if the voters simply looked at their own priorities and chose the candidate who fit them, but rhetoric has been understood to be more important than policy since before Aristotle.